Quantcast
Channel: Aidnography
Viewing all 750 articles
Browse latest View live

Combat charities and the mediatization of extreme humanitarian volunteering

$
0
0
I recently shared an article by Milli Lake and Sarah E. Parkinson on political scientists ‘out-dangering’ one another in their field research in fragile states. The ‘exotic’ site of the past has turned into a ‘volatile’ one where presumably a lot of publishable and communicable ‘action’ will happen. The authors warn us academics to take the practical and ethical components of (fieldwork) planning and implementation more seriously’.

Only this week did I learn about ‘combat charities’ thanks to a short CNN video that apparently shows the Free Burma Army fighting in Mosul and an article in the Washington Post on the family behind one of its leaders who had moved to Mosul
(
It was just an average day for the Eubanks, who describe their work as a calling from God). 

In some ways, the two stories are connected and I wonder whether some radical humanitarians
out-danger one another and the international development and humanitarian community paying the price for more blurred boundaries.Pavol Kosnáč’ recentBrookings working paper,Combat charities, or when humanitarians go to war, provided some interesting background reading:
Some could regard the term “combat charity” as a perversion of the very essence of a humanitarian mission’, Kosnáč points out, but for the purpose of my post I agree that the term captures the actual self-perception of these groups’.

While much of the critique of combat charities rightly focuses on policy, governance and (the lack of) regulatory frameworks I strongly believe that there is an important media and communication aspect that also deserves our attention.

Kosnáč mentions that
‘beyond this narrow component of public relations, broader media training is an important part of the services offered by HDA, Humanitarian Defense Abroad, one of the two organizations he analyzes in his paper, and an important reminder that visual engagement and representation are deeply embedded in todays battlefields.

As a kick-starter for more discussions, my post will focus on three aspects: the (American) hero narrative, the responsibility of media organizations to engage with content from such combat organizations and implications for volunteering/voluntourism and the humanitarian project.

The North American humanitarian hero narrative
I do not think it is a coincidence that the Eubank family in Mosul is American. North American, especially U.S., culture, media and society love a good hero narrative whenever one person’s heroic struggle can become an excuse for not looking too closely at systemic inequalities. As we already know from missionary endeavors, missions
guided by God’ are often convenient excuses for unprofessional or unethical approaches (oh hello, dancing missionaries of Uganda!). Depoliticized charity sells. I wrote about the ‘CNN Hero of Year’ event in 2015 and Oprah’s treatment of Kony 2012’s Jason Russell in 2012, for example.

Combat charities bring out the worst of such efforts, a missionary zeal combined with an outdated ‘friend-foe’ dichotomy and volunteering for the military-industrial complex with the aim to
save people. America’s love for heroes’ and clean-cut military action as a solution for political problems meets the web 2.0.

Mediatzation between YouTube video, computer game aesthetics and micro celebrity
One of the many challenges with these organizations is that despite their size, actual impact and relevance for humanitarian debates they are ticking all the right boxes for viral media attention. It is no surprise that global mainstream media such as CNN or Washington Post feature their content as it breaks the conflict and war reporting routines and presumable generates clicks. Whether these clicks are generated by critical academics or ‘patriotic’ Americans these articles polarize and that is always good for business. Combat actions, captured on video by the organization itself do not ‘speak for themselves’ and just because it may fit the usual media narrative that something is new, ‘growing’ or ‘the latest trend’, it means that mainstream journalists need to carefully evaluate motives and actions. Any organization on a ‘radical fringe’ first receives mainstream media attention and then book deals, speaking tours and movies often follow.
Is there a good way of how not to feed the value chain of ‘controversial’ figures and their organizations?

Zealous volunteers with guns only blur ethical boundaries further
It starts with the term ‘combat charity’ and it ends with a man in army fatigues rescuing a child: the current wars and conflicts in Afghanistan, Syria and Iraq really become a testing ground for how we define humanitarianism in the 21st century. From MSF hospital bombings to the debate around the White Helmets and now a new form of private-military engagement, the limits of humanitarian action are tested at the moment.
Engaging with, closely monitoring, and eventually establishing legal and policy guidelines for the operations of combat charities promises a better way to manage combat charities, Kosnáč recommends in his paper. I very much doubt that this will be enough to stop more unaccountable volunteering heroes with questionable, but ultimately very selfish motivations, to show up on the door step of war and conflict.
I am also aware that these endeavors fuel the global media machinery with engaging content-ideally free of charge for the media brands, so careful strategies, including less space in mainstream outlets, should be discussed.

All I can do is stress the importance of evaluating local contexts, engaging with complicated narratives and trying to generate political will.
No matter how many times they try or who bankrolls their efforts, an American guy shooting at people in a far-away land will not be the solution to end war and conflict…

Links & Contents I Liked 238

$
0
0
Hi all,

Happy midsommar from Sweden! Enjoy reading this weekend!

Development news: Combat charities in Mosul; one year after the World Humanitarian Summit; does Daily Mail’s criticism of aid matter? NGO-government relationships in Kenya; the WHO DG reflects on her tenure; Africa is far away from being a digital knowledge economy; a refugee city in Uganda; the rhetoric of partnerships lives on; Rwanda’s dictatorship; famine as weapon.

Publications:
Reviewing ‘Stay & Deliver’; global humanitarian assistance report; women & world employment trends; social media tools in Kenya; do age-of-marriage laws work? (Spoiler: No!); do certification schemes help farmers? (Spoiler: Not really!).

Our digital lives:
Philanthropy and the program officer; the rich give little; Silicon Valley’s flawed theory of history.

Academia: Reviewing MOOCs; higher ed institutions demand public scholarship-but don’t little to protect staff from backlash; open access in international organizations.

Enjoy!


New from aidnography

Combat charities and the mediatization of extreme humanitarian volunteering

As a kick-starter for more discussions, my post will focus on three aspects: the (American) hero narrative, the responsibility of media organizations to engage with content from such combat organizations and implications for volunteering/voluntourism and the humanitarian project.
(...)
No matter how many times they try or who bankrolls their efforts, an American guy shooting at people in a far-away land will not be the solution to end war and conflict…
Development news

One year on, World Humanitarian Summit scorecards are due
The coming days will see a flurry of publications and announcements as the humanitarian community takes stock of commitments made at the World Humanitarian Summit last May and assesses reforms. The diary includes a formal UN consultation and a blizzard of panels, launches, and side events in Geneva.
Ben Parker for IRIN. A lot of interesting discussions took place on Twitter (see above) and this post provides a good opportunity to catch up with events, reports and more!

Does the Daily Mail's criticism of aid matter?

Rather, the key conclusion is that newspaper headlines are not an accurate reflection of what people think about aid. Nor do they appear to have an immediate, direct and mass effect on public perceptions. If government officials do interpret public attitudes towards aid through media headlines, they are wrong to do so.
Martin Scott for The Guardian reviews survey data and concludes that the Daily Mail's agenda-driven terrible journalism does not seem to reflect general sentiments on international development and has limited power to influence 'the people'.Kenyans will vote in August. Why are NGO-government relations an issue?
Finally, evidence tells us that NGOs work where they have more freedoms. The more that Kenya moves away from democracy, the less likely NGOs are to concentrate their efforts there — be it for education, health care or providing humanitarian assistance in war-torn neighboring countries, like Somalia and Sudan. Nairobi could lose its appeal as a hub for NGOs throughout East Africa, which would also mean a loss of jobs and income for Kenyans involved in these services, in the NGO sector, and for global organizations based in Kenya.
Jennifer N. Brass for Washington Post's Monkey Cage with research-based insights into Kenyan politics-just in time for the forthcoming elections.

My decade leading the WHO: dirty fights and steps toward universal coverage

Going forward, I would like to see the WHO do more to address financing issues, both for its own budget and the health budgets of low- and middle-income countries. Member states keep asking the WHO to do more with the same budget, while resisting proposals to “sunset” some areas of work that fit the mandates of other UN agencies. Such a full-menu approach impairs strategic leadership. Overall, the tendency in international public health is to move away from official development assistance towards greater reliance on domestic resources. I worry about this. In large parts of the developing world, especially in Africa, small-holder farmers in the informal sector remain the backbone of the economy, severely limiting domestic resources derived from taxes.
Margaret Chan for Stat reflects on her tenure as WHO Director General.

Africa risks fading from digital knowledge economy

Going further than this, towards a transformation into knowledge economies, will need far more concentrated effort than simply increasing internet connectivity. One barrier highlighted by our findings is the short supply of locally produced knowledge.
Without investing to shift the trends shown in our research, Sub-Saharan Africa is facing a worryingly diminishing role in the world’s digital knowledge economy.
Sanna Ojanperä and Mark Graham for SciDevNet with a reminder that Africa's transformation into knowledge economies are more difficult than just getting people online.

A Bold Experiment in Uganda

This is what Zuckerman has been up to in Uganda. He’s evangelizing community-owned and community-sustained spaces within the settlements. And he sees this kind of open, bottom-up approach as a template for building not just the future of refugee settlements, but also the future of cities worldwide.
Kathi Vian for the Institute for the Future. The idea of treating refugee settlements as 'cities of the future' seems to be getting some momentum-but I am a bit more skeptical that this will be the 'future of migration' in an era of substantial control and skepticism about the 'refugee crisis'.

Refuge: Transforming a Broken Refugee System – by Alexander Betts and Paul Collier

Indeed, the main flaw I found in the book lies, somewhat perversely, in its underlying optimism. The persistent critique of humanitarian actors neglects an acknowledgement that humanitarians are more often than not acting in spite of a wider political and legislative environment on immigration that is largely designed to discourage (im)migration entirely.
(...)
The authors state towards the conclusion, in reference to these policies, that ‘few people want to feel they are a mean bastard’, whilst neglecting to mention that acting like a ‘mean bastard’ is implicit in the British government’s hostile environment around immigration. Indeed, the current British administration is likely to welcome the recommendations of the book, emphasising as they do solutions not much further beyond the borders of the country of origin.
Gayle Munro for LSE EUROPP reviews Alexander Betts and Paul Collier's latest book.

Partnerships: Handle with Care

It is disillusioning for all of us, and particularly for our ‘partners’ in the developing world, to have business as usual re-badged as partnership.
(...)
How many of us are working in partnerships where the more powerful partners genuinely make themselves accountable for the quality of their partnership practice, to their less powerful partners? Do we build in time to explain our organisations, drivers, incentives, risks, to each other, or are we too busy for that? Do we conduct regular relationship management health checks alongside our project management assessments? Do we plan standard processes like annual plans, reports, monitoring and evaluation, communication, to reinforce partnership principles, or do we run these processes the way we have always run them? Do we cherish the diversity which draws us to a partnership in the first place, or crush it by applying standardised monitoring and reporting requirements?
Yeshe Smith for the Australian Council for International Development with a great reminder about the gap between partnership rhetoric and reality!

The perenial dictator

So the statistics about Rwanda’s economic growth published by the World Bank, and then by most media outlets, are based largely on a single source: the Rwandan government. Few Rwandan journalists, economists or analysts dare to question the government. This is how the government’s statistics become the truth, in Rwanda and abroad. Such statistics are supported by images of Chinese-made buildings in Kigali, and Transparency International surveys of Rwandans who say that their president and government are not corrupt.
Anjan Sundaram for Africa is a Country with a reminder of how the 'international community' often wants to believe in narratives of progress from countries that may not support open and liberal discussions let alone allow critique...by the way: I reviewed Anjan's great book on journalism in Rwanda!

The Nazis Used It, We Use It

Drawing on a long Anglo-American tradition of economic warfare and blockade, the counter-humanitarian trend in London and Washington is both morally distasteful and practically stupid. When international aid fails to feed the hungry and treat the sick, extremist projects flourish. If security strategists and xenophobes think that humanitarian crises will burn themselves out at a safe distance they are mistaken: the biggest demographic outcome of famine has always been migration – the Gulf countries are learning this lesson, as millions of Yemenis cross their borders. The threat to the values of the humanitarians coincides with dramatic demands on their knowledge and skills. Their best strategy is to take the initiative and propose that starvation be added to the list of crimes against humanity.
Alex de Waal for the London Review of Books with a fascinating, historical long-read on famine and humanitarianism.

Hot off the digital press

Presence and Proximity - To Stay and Deliver, Five Years On

The report shows that humanitarian community continues to grapple with the problem of its ability to stay and deliver effectively and responsibly in highly insecure environments. Progress has been made in a number of areas. Humanitarian leaders consistently talk of their commitment to staying and delivering where at all feasible, and we have seen notable instances where UN agencies, NGOs, and others have stayed and delivered at great risk. Yet despite these improvements, this study also broadly finds that not enough has changed, particularly at the field level, since the publication of To Stay and Deliver in 2011.
New report by the Norwegian Refugee Council in collaboration with UN OCHA.

Global Humanitarian Assistance Report 2017

In addition to our annual analysis, the 2017 report introduces salient topics to support the reform of crisis-related financing. This includes analysis on the links between poverty and crisis, risks and resources and across several of the Grand Bargain commitment areas such as transparency, localisation, earmarking, cash and multi-year funding.
Development Initiatives just published their annual report with lots of food for thought, data and visualizations!









World Employment and Social Outlook: Trends for women 2017

However, the report finds that there are significant socio-economic and gender norm constraints influencing a woman’s decision to participate. Accordingly, the report introduces a comprehensive framework to address the drivers of these gender gaps and outlines a series of policy recommendations to improve the labour market outcomes of women.
The ILO also published an interesting new report recently.

Using Digital and Social Media to Monitor and Reduce Violence in Kenya’s Elections

3) social media monitoring of violence should be undertaken in conjunction with other reporting systems that seek to overcome inequalities in digital access and use
Caitriona Dowd for IDS with a handy overview about social media's role in the forthcoming elections in Kenya.

Do Age-of-Marriage Laws Work? Evidence from a Large Sample of Developing Countries

By this measure, most countries are not enforcing the laws on their books and enforcement is not getting better over time.
(...)
We conclude by arguing that better laws must be accompanied by better enforcement and monitoring in to delay marriage and protect the rights of women and girls.
Matt Collin and Theodore Talbot for CGDev. I think 'better enforcement and monitoring' was one of those lessons I first learned in my undergrad development studies classes more than 15 years ago...

Effects of certification schemes for agricultural production on socio-economic outcomes in low- and middle-income countries: A systematic review

There is limited evidence on their effects on a range of intermediate and final socioeconomic outcomes for agricultural producers and wage workers. There are positive effects on prices. But workers’ wages do not seem to benefit from the schemes. Income from the sale of produce is higher for certified farmers, but overall household income is not. Context matters substantially for the causal chain between CS interventions and well-being.
Carlos Oya, Florian Schaefer, Dafni Skalidou, Catherine McCosker and Laurenz Langer for 3ie. In global value chains, those at the bottom get ripped-off...

Our digital lives

Through the Eyes of the Program Officer

But when looking outside of their direct grantees, the perspective of program officers changes. Only about half of program officers who responded to our survey believe that nonprofit organizations, in general, are well run. Even fewer think that nonprofit organizations are well equipped to assess their performance. Just 39 percent believe that nonprofit organizations have the knowledge necessary to assess the results of their work, and fewer than 10 percent believe that nonprofit organizations have the resources necessary to conduct such assessments.
Jennifer Glickman introduces a new survey on foundation program officers for the Center for Effective Philanthropy.

Hold the Toasts to Generosity. In Fact, the Rich Give Away Very Little of Their Wealth

Even as a growing number of wealthy donors step up to give, many are holding back and the far upper class as a whole is only parting with a tiny sliver of its wealth. Some of the very richest Americans—like Jeff Bezos and the Mars family—give barely anything all.
Why don’t the rich give more? There are various reasons, including that giving away money wisely is harder than it looks. It takes time, focus and energy—which can be in short supply for busy people still involved in their careers. Also, many wealthy people may simply care more about preserving and growing their family's assets than about helping out others.
David Callahan for Inside Philanthropy with a reminder about the scope of current philanthropy-don't wait for donations, make sure the rich pay proper taxes :)

The Poverty of Entrepreneurship: The Silicon Valley Theory of History

But their universal fascination with charismatic leadership shows that behind the tech economy’s democratic façade beats a deeply authoritarian heart. For Horowitz, while the “culture” of a company or a nation is embodied by its employees and citizens, it can always be channeled by a wise leader to specific ends. The enslaved people of Haiti could never shape their own culture—only L’Ouverture, CEO of the Haitian Revolution, could.
John Patrick Leary for The New Inquiry takes on venture capitalist Ben Horowitz and his narrow interpretation of the history of innovation which is indicative of the mindset of a lot of Silicon Valley movers and shakers...

Academia

MOOCs Moving On, Moving Up
With some exceptions noted previously, MOOCs are mainly a technology business, focused on providing a return on investment (even for nonprofits like edX) by targeting the large nondegree professional development and technology training market. Though the MOOC experiment over the past five years has resulted in many positives, this era also reminds us that when it comes to degree attainment, there really is no magic bullet. The hard, in-the-trenches work of helping the students of today get and remain focused, learn, and stick it out to degree completion remains the province of mainstream higher education -- MOOCs or no MOOCs.
Cathy Sandeen for Inside Higher Ed reflects on her predictions about MOOCs she made a couple of years ago. Spoiler alert: MOOCs have not made colleges/universities obsolete and not 'everybody' studies at MIT at the moment...

Everything But The Burden: Publics, Public Scholarship, And Institutions

The point is, institutions have been calling for public scholarship for the obvious reasons. Attention can be equated with a type of prestige. And prestige is a way to shore up institutions when political and cultural attitudes are attacking colleges and universities at every turn. And, faculty are vulnerable to calls for them to engage. We’re all sensitive to claims that we’re out of touch and behind on neoliberal careerism. And some of us actually care about engaging publics (shocking, I know). But the prestige chase on one hand and eager faculty on the other means we haven’t asked what institutions owe its constituent members for public engagement.
Tressie McMillan Cottom with an important reminder that 'public engagement' (espcially at US universities) is a bit more than 'leaving the ivory tower and give a talk'-and in the digital age it can come with backlashes that many institutions are not well equipped to handle.

Open Access Policy In International Organisations

The question of open access is “much broader and more complex” than just access to research, Beauchamp said. The shared objective of open access is, according to Beauchamp, encouraging users to take the content and share it without any technical or licence barrier.
Elise De Geyter for Intellectual Property Watch with an good overview over debates inside international organization on how to make data and other information open access; it's a bit more complicated than simply putting an open access license on each product...

Links & Contents I Liked 239

$
0
0
Hi all,

I'm at a workshop about communication for development in the context of Germany today hosted by the University of Leipzig. There should be plenty of material for a blog post next week!

In the meantime, enjoy your weekly link digest with plenty of interesting readings for the weekend!

Development news: New challenges for UN peacekeeping; Louise Linton marries; key trends in humanitarian funding; British Red Cross received a lot of useless 'stuff'; Colombia's gold rush revisited; tax avoidance & illicit flows; UN struggles with open data-one pdf at the time; even the Guardian falls into white savior trap; Helen Clark hit the glass ceiling; the limits (and opportunities) of 'small is beautiful'; a long read on Bridge academies; spatial analysis in Madagascar; the impact of edutainment; the geography of humanitarian knowledge; the future of evaluation; photographing Afghanistan; remembering a priest from Nicaragua.

Our digital lives: Reuters Institute Digital News report; being without a phone in South Africa; the rise of the thought leader; looking after yourself; practicing intentionality.

Publications: A review of digital initiatives to support refugees in Berlin & Germany.

Academia: A tweet storm about social media & academic communication; a long-read on the origins of today's extremely profitable academic journal industry.

Development news

Congo peacekeepers to leave CAR amid sex abuse allegations
The UN said the review of the Congo-Brazzaville deployment found "the nature and extent of existing allegations of sexual exploitation and abuse, in their totality, point to systemic problems in command and control".
"These problems have also been compounded by issues related to the preparedness, overall discipline, maintenance of contingent-owned equipment, and logistical capacity of these troops," it added.
BBC News with a sad example of what happens when you cut corners in UN peacekeeping...

A “white savior” memoirist widely mocked in Africa has married Trump’s treasury secretary
Linton’s memoir about her surprisingly harrowing gap year in peaceful Zambia, “In Congo’s Shadow: One girl’s perilous journey to the heart of Africa,” was ridiculed by Zambians and the literary world for relying on untruths and cliches, with some comparing her to the satirical Instagram creation White Savior Barbie. The self-published book has since been withdrawn from Amazon. Yet, the hashtag #LintonLies hasn’t affected Linton’s career—unsurprising in the current White House.
Lynsey Chutel for Quartz with a lighter contribution to this week's review-and a reminder that Linton's book on 'development'will forever be linked to her name...

Humanitarian funding: What were 2016’s key trends?

While humanitarian grants do play a vital and principled role, they are not the right tool to tackle the underlying risks, causes and long-term consequences of crisis that these ‘left behind’ populations face. This demands a much fuller toolkit, which we begin to map out in the GHA report – one which contains everything from insurance to contingency funding and long-term concessional loans. Understanding these and other instruments, and tracking how much is going where and how, is crucial for effective, context-specific responses. So, as the minutiae of Grand Bargain commitments are negotiated, those who care about saving and improving lives also need to become adept at watching this bigger picture.
Sophia Swithern for Development Initiatives. Last week I included a link to the report and this is a good narrative summary.

British Red Cross to sell excess clothes donated after Grenfell Tower fire

The charity says it has 40,000 excess boxes of donations, some of which will be available for Grenfell families, some of which will be sold through its shops and some of which will be sold for recycling
Rebecca Cooney for Third Sector with a reminder that generosity in times of crisis is a great idea-and that donating/sending 'stuff' rarely is a good way to support charitable efforts...

Rwanda, Tanzania and Uganda face US sanction after used clothes ban

The move follows a decision by the six-nation East African Community – Kenya, Uganda, Rwanda, Burundi, Tanzania and South Sudan – to fully ban imported second-hand clothes and shoes by 2019, arguing it would help member countries boost domestic clothes manufacturing.
Africa News with a coincidentally related story, because a lot of donated, used clothes will end up in 'Africa'...

After the Gold Rush: Colombian Town Counts Cost of Illegal Mining Boom

Buriticá has had a taste of gold, and how the riches it provides carry their own price to be paid. But there is no going back, not when the secret is out. One of the richest gold deposits on the continent lurks just beneath the surface. And if the Buritiqueños do not exploit it, then the outsiders, whether in the form of a multinational company, mafia mining magnates or young miners with little regard for even their own futures, will.
James Bargent for Insight Crime reports from Colombia with a an updated story of a mining town and the lure of gold that is much, much older.

Corporations secretly lobbying UN to allow tax avoidance in its anti-poverty agenda

Now, say advocates of transparency and global tax reforms, it appears that many large corporations, with the backing of the International Monetary Fund, are pushing the U.N. to alter its definition of “illicit flows” to only limit illegal activities and ignore legal means corporations avoid paying taxes.
Tom Murphy for the Humanosphere with another reminder that corporations talk the talk about 'development', but try to avoid walking the walk when it comes to issues that really matter and go beyond CSR and high-level window-dressing.

Two cheers for UN transparency

PDF files are readable to the naked eye, but stripping the formatting and layout to get to the words and numbers on the page often results in messy data. Aidan McGuire, of SensibleCode, which runs an online service to convert large PDF tables, says that for open data, PDF is “not an ideal format and should be avoided”. (IRIN has used the service on this and other PDF documents).
PDFs may attract scorn from open data advocates – they’re known sometimes as “data graveyards”, but choosing a format and type of report depends on who the audience is. The ASR report may be trying to be too many things to too many people, according to Simons. National government officials in aid-recipient countries may be well-served with narrative reports in PDF format, but NGO and civil society users often want the ability to sift and analyse data, he explained. UNOPS confirmed the report had a “wide audience with different needs and demands”.
Another loophole is that vendors can be anonymised at the discretion of the UN agency – more than $1.7 billion of contracts have an “unspecified” vendor. Tens of millions also have the vendor withheld for security reasons – a legitimate practice in high-risk countries.
UN managers may not relish opening their books so that civil society and journalists can pick holes in their spending.
Ben Parker for IRIN with an important reminder that 'open data' is often easier said than done and that organizations, even if they have the best intentions, may end up producing yet another 'pdf graveyard'; making data open and accessible requires effort, time-and resources, especially when the data is supposed to serve different audiences with different needs.

In a Guardian Story About an Environmental Conflict in Kenya, the White Saviour Rides Again

Isn't it interesting that there are wonderful empty places in this beautiful Kenya waiting for someone to fall in love with them? That you can land in a place you have never been, where “falling in love” gets you 88,000 acres of prime ranch land? The casual erasure of the colonial violence that made Gallman's acquisition possible, and the human and social cost of it, is striking.
(...)
This is not to say that the conflict in Laikipia is not complex, or that there are easy answers. Climate change is leading to more frequent and more punishing droughts. Add the mix of demographic pressures and politics is an explosive one. But we have to tell the story right. Framing the conflict as between a noble conservation queen and a savage mob of impoverished locals is not only irresponsible and cruel. It is also simply not the truth.
Christine Mungai for Global Voices with a reminder that global media, including the Guardian, need to listen to more 'global voices' in their reporting...

What is really going on within ‘shrinking civil society space’ and how should international actors respond?

Behind all this there was an underlying anxiety that framing all this as the ‘global civil society crackdown’ could be somehow overly Western. I have yet to see a comprehensive ‘Voices of the Poor’ type piece of research that asks different forms of civil society (including CSOs but also grassroots organizations, sports club supporters, cultural groups, faith organizations) how they see the current threats and opportunities, but one participant described the feedback his organization received as ‘you frame this too negatively – there are huge opportunities in disruption as well as negatives’.
As for how to respond:
Big focus on the limitations of global narratives. Problems and solutions are deeply local, with INGOs and other outsiders having only a limited role (and having to be careful about their actions making matters worse – eg by highlighting the aid dependence of their local partners). Outsiders need to make it a priority to canvass the opinions of and be led by local civil society organizations, and be cautious about launching into generic global campaigns.
Duncan Green for From Poverty to Power highlights one of the challenges that most 'global reports' face that feel the pressure to present key 'take away points', yet analyze a vastly complex phenomenon that is as much local as it it global.

Can a Tech Start-Up Successfully Educate Children in the Developing World?

All the teachers I spoke to appreciated the regular paycheck. But they chafed at how they were managed, often by unseen bosses communicating with them via text or robocall. Some Bridge staff members described what they saw as a stark contrast between their hopes for Bridge and a grittier reality. One school administrator, an academy manager, described how the pressure to ensure that parents made their payments on time was disheartening. ‘‘I didn’t realize how hard it would be to talk to parents,’’ he said. ‘‘They’re ill, they’re out of work, they had a fire. No one is in the house who’s making any money. How can they pay when they have no money for food?’’ And working at Bridge, teachers said, can disrupt a career: Instructors are required to sign an employment agreement that includes a noncompete clause that prevents them from working at other nearby schools for a year after they leave.
Peg Tyre for the New York Times with a long-read that takes a nuanced look at Bridge academies in Liberia and Kenya. I don't think it's sufficient to answer the question in the title with 'it's complicated' or 'it's too early to tell with certainty'. The bigger question is whether 'more education', a mantra many organizations follow, can really lead to more employment, a brighter future and social transformation in an uncertain labor market on the verge of the 'digital revolution'.

Helen Clark: I hit my first glass ceiling at the UN

“I won the public vote, I won the social media scene, I won the staff votes – all of that, but it didn’t matter at all,” says Clark pragmatically, without bitterness. “Clearly, the security council wasn’t looking for someone like me, from a small, independent-minded country, having been an independent-minded leader, who looks at the evidence and makes decisions accordingly.
“That’s fine. That’s the outcome.” Clark’s experience of the process is the subject of a documentary, My Year with Helen, that screened last weekend as part of the Sydney film festival.
Elle Hunt's interview with Helen Clark for The Guardian somehow escaped my initial attention, but it's well worth the read now, of course!

Small is beautiful. Small is also, er, small.

Were the civil rights, feminist or LGBT movements seeded by small grants? What about democracy or human rights movements overseas? Can small grants really make a big difference? I’d like to see more evidence. That said, putting money and power into the hands of poor people and communities makes more sense than the old-school, top-down approaches. The bottom-up style of grant-making has also influenced others in philanthropy to become better listeners, so that today’s clean-water or cookstove projects are more likely to succeed than past efforts. Supporting grass-roots groups also strikes me as more likely to be effective than starting yet another NGO or “social enterprise.”
Marc Gunther for reviews 'Smart Risks' for Nonprofit Chronicles.

Please Use Spatial Analysis And Stop Asking People to Walk All Day

CRS Madagascar contacted the spatial analysis company ESRI, to estimate walking times for project constituents to figure out where they could better place food distribution. ESRI estimated walking times based on steepness, streams, and walking speed in different conditions.
This process created a distance map that told CRS where were the best sites to place food distribution. New locations were based on an optimal walking distance that was no more than 5 kilometers for most participants. Once CRS moved the distribution location based on walk times (not proximity to roads as most of us do), they recorded a 30 percent increase in participation.
Kathryn Clifton for ICTworks on using digital tools for real impact.

Ten concepts everyone in ICT4D should know

These particular concepts have helped me not only to frame problems in a particular lens, but to also guide the process for how to move forward. Or just fun conversation.
Gabriel Krieshok with an excellent overview over 10 ICT4D core themes-definitely bookmarked for my teaching next semester!

The rise of edutainment: taking stock of the evidence

Victor Orozco, a World Bank economist deeply involved with a multi-partner evaluation of MTV Shuga, has come to praise edutainment as one of the most cost-effective ways of getting people to do things differently. Conducted in Nigeria with 5,000 young people, the evaluation found that those who had watched the show in community screenings were twice as likely to go for an HIV test half a year later. Viewers were 43% more likely to think that HIV is a punishment for having multiple partners. Among women, chlamydia infections dropped by 58%.
However, the study also highlighted that viewers felt sympathy for a character who committed domestic violence. This finding demonstrates the importance of media development organisations systematically checking audience responses to their programmes.
Sonia Whitehead for BBC Media Action on the impact of edutainment programs.

Conversations: the Future of Development Evaluation

In development banks, the appraisal of projects should include a comparison of the proposed solution with alternative options. Only: in practice that hardly ever happens. And, I do believe that an update to the evaluation criteria could incentivize the evaluation practice to address issues of importance to decision-makers. For instance, an evaluation that would evolve from an assessment of project relevance in its policy context to one that produces evidence whether the most impactful development challenge was addressed – as suggested in our blog series – would be a step towards answering questions in a more complex and uncertain world.
The World Bank's Caroline Heider and OECD's Hans Lundgren talk about the future of evaluation.

In the Light of the Conflict: Photographer Andrew Quilty’s experience in Afghanistan

I do not think of myself as a huge risk taker. A lot of planning goes into travel outside Kabul: we do not just jump in a taxi and head for the hills. I was inexperienced and a bit ignorant in Badakhshan, and probably pushed my luck more than I would these days. Now, working with colleagues, I’m often the one who questions going here or there and often I’ll be the one telling journalists to wrap up their interviews because it feels like we have been in one place too long; but at the same time, I think I have a better sense of what is reasonable risk than someone sitting behind the desk in New York, or London, or even Kabul. It is something you can only learn from experience, and I trust my instincts and those of most of my colleagues on that.
(...)
Then Zahra and her mother kneeled by the grave, it was probably more confronting, for me, than when I took the picture of their dead father and husband on the operating table in the ruins of the hospital. Photographing children in pain, I find, is the hardest thing to see. And it’s so intrusive to be that close in moments like this. I suppose I try to diminish myself – make myself small and quiet, take the minimum number of photographs necessary.
Jelena Bjelica portraits Andrew Quilty for the Afghanistan Analysts Network.

The Geography of Knowledge in Humanitarian Action

For example, know-why is essential to humanitarian action as it tries to understand the causality of things like why people are hungry or sick, why violence is taking certain forms and why people are displaced. Know-who is important if humanitarians are to understand who is affected, who is responsible, who is vulnerable and who is capable. Know-that in humanitarian action is the base knowledge of certain facts, particular humanitarian disciplines and the laws and rights that govern armed conflict and displacement. Know-how represents the art of practice in humanitarian action – the skills, practices and expertise which help to protect, assist and respect the human being in extremis. All these different types of knowledge come together to form humanitarian knowledge – a body of knowledge that is the opposite of ignorance in humanitarian action.
Hugo Slim's short Keynote Address at the Launch of the CERAH Encyclopaedia of Humanitarian Action.

A Hero and a Priest
But many remember him as a principled advocate for downtrodden nations throughout the world, unafraid to seize the floor of aloof international bodies to advance local struggles. This readiness to repurpose imperial institutions in the service of anticolonial objectives was on full display in 1986, when he had faced down the United States in international court — and won.
Jonah Walters for Jacobin with a reminder about how differently 'development' was discussed in the 1980s-and how modern day 'celebrities' have replaced bottom-up revolutionaries...

Our digital lives


Interviews with Brilliant Women: Mary Ann Clements

Add the fact that in INGOs and NGOs there are usually more women employed in the first place – although, despite all the proclamations and commitments to women’s rights – often there are still more senior men – and you begin to see a pattern where our change making sectors are actually reliant on woman working over-hard and not thinking too much about their own needs. There is irony here of course as many of our organisations also work on women’s rights but working on these things at a distance without really thinking about the radical things we could do internally to make these commitments a reality is an example of the values disconnect I was talking about. Where our values are not being fully lived and that again contributes to burnout and a sense of frustration for us, for staff, in not-for-profit organisations.
Mary Ann Clements for Hermosas Chispas on looking after you as an aid worker and human being.

Me, My Phone and I? - guest post by Shari Thanjan

My time in the field and comparison with my own phone really made me realize, that even though statistic screams that South Africa has 100% mobile penetration, it is not even so. South Africa is a majority poor country. Yet, although there are many mobile interventions deriving from policy, pushed into South African programmes, it seems that end user was not considered, basically, the people of South Africa. In almost every interview I did, or people I met throughout fieldwork could not afford the phones imagined for the mobile interventions.Going back to my drama, my fieldwork really showed me that a phone is not everything, and one can actually live a happy content life without it.
Shari Thanjan for Media Africa on how losing a phone can lead to a winning auto-ethnographic reflections ;)!

The Rise of the Thought Leader

The idea of “disruptive innovation” caught fire in Silicon Valley, Drezner argues, because it “conformed to a plutocratic worldview in which success favors the bold, risk-taking entrepreneur.” Atop this enthusiasm, Christensen built a lucrative brand, producing eight books and founding the Forum for Growth and Innovation at Harvard, his own consulting company, and a boutique investment firm.In 2014, however, nearly two decades after Christensen debuted disruptive innovation in the Harvard Business Review, historian Jill Lepore eviscerated the theory in a widely read essay in The New Yorker. Lepore found that Christensen’s case studies were ambiguous and overblown:
(...)
What intellectuals need is the same as what everyone else needs: a society that prioritizes human flourishing over private profit, and strong political networks that guard public goods against the prophets of an atomized, high-tech future.
David Sessions reviews Dan Drezner's book for New Republic

“It’s Not Magic; It’s Intentionality”: Janis Reischmann Talks About Her Reflective Practices with Mark Sedway
Why do you think reflective practice is important to philanthropy practitioners generally?
JR: It helps us gain insight into what we’re doing and what we need to pay attention to. It’s not magic. It’s intentionality. When we were planning the reflective practice workshop, I took the concept to my book club of women who have worked with funders. From their experiences working with funders, they were really excited about it for organizations, not just individuals. How do you move philanthropic organizations to a state of reflection? We can be so full of ourselves and oblivious. It’s the failing of our field. How do we listen better, reflect on what’s working and what’s not, get out of our protective place, and recognize that our voice isn’t the only one in the room?
Mark Sedway talk to Janis Reischmann for Philanthrophy's Reflective Practices-excellent food for thought for impatient academics, too ;)!
Hot off the digital press
Digital Routes to Integration

Scores of innovative digital projects were created to coordinate this engagement and support the process of refugee integration. Two years one we asked – what has happened to these projects? And what potential do digital approaches have for refugee integration? This report is a product of our research, comprising 78 interviews with digital projects, refugees and volunteers.
New report by Ben Mason, Lavinia Schwedersky and Akram Alfawakheeri for Better Place Lab.
The biggest question for me after skimming through the report is how dependent all of this, albeit excellent work, is on Berlin as a city and 'space'. How can innovations (on a similar scale) happen outside the few urban hubs in Germany and Europe? There's also a RCT study waiting to happen, comparing migrants in Berlin who did/ did not receive support with other groups outside that hub. To put it a bit more provocatively: What kind (if any) of 'filter bubble' is Berlin and how does it affect innovation-and will it lead to social transformation in a city that is notorious for its shortage of jobs in certain segments of the labor market?

Academia


This is a great conversation from Twitter: 



Is the staggeringly profitable business of scientific publishing bad for science?
But history shows that betting against science publishers is a risky move. After all, back in 1988, Maxwell predicted that in the future there would only be a handful of immensely powerful publishing companies left, and that they would ply their trade in an electronic age with no printing costs, leading to almost “pure profit”. That sounds a lot like the world we live in now.
Stephen Buranyi for The Guardian with his long read. He is re-visiting the debate on high scientific journal publisher profits and how their paywalls limit access to scientific knowledge; his historical excursion is quite interesting, linking the foundations of today's model to the rise of a publishing mogul during the Thatcher years of economic transformation.

Radio Okapi Kindu (book review)

$
0
0
Jennifer Bakody’s memoir Radio Okapi Kindu-The Station That Helped Bring Peace to the Congo on her time as a UN communications officer and local radio station manager in Kindu, DRC in the early 2000s is definitely a great addition to your development-related summer reading list!

After reading and reviewing quite a few memoirs of aid work(ers), Radio Okapi Kindu adds some interesting new nuances to the genre and managed to entertain me right from the beginning through Bakody’s gentle and unhurried style which allows her story to unfold and ‘breathe’ with a lot of nuances, details and space for her protagonists.

Stories from and about journalists-not expat aid work in ‘Africa’

Unlike some aid worker memoirs, Jennifer Bakody manages right from the start to frame her story around the team of Congolese journalists, thereby avoiding the stereotypical pitfalls of a young Western woman going to ‘find herself’ in a remote place in the deepest and darkest and most dangerous part of Africa that all too often provides the backdrop for these books.
Her story is essentially about good journalism and good radio in a remote place-and that remote location happens to be in DRC in 2002.
The reader is quickly introduced to Mamadou, Mamy, Matthieu, Rigobert, Sadala, Tumba, Ulli and the rest of the team, which leaves refreshingly little space for any ‘expat hero’ narrative to unfold. Jennifer pushes for professional journalism, provides feedback and offers an outsider’s perspective, but there is no ‘us’ and ‘them’.
The governments backing Radio Okapi (…) were using the rich world’s tax dollars to buy high editorial standards in a country flooded with mediocre private and community-based radio stations, all trying to pick up the slack for the dud that had become the state broadcaster (…). A national radio in the locals’ indigenous languages (pp.51-52).
At the end of the (broadcasting) day the work of the station comes down to the same principles that make local journalism work almost everywhere:
“I mean…How do you know what’s going on every day?”
“We live here,” said Rigobert, his voice taking on a higher-pitched lilt of confusion.
“People in the community talk and we pay attention,” said Tumba (…) (p.63).
Treating people and their stories with respect
I described Bakody’s writing style as ‘gentle’ before and I am still not sure whether this is the best way to capture her approach.
Her outline of a typical broadcasting day comes with quasi-ethnographic observational details, but there is also a vivid collection of vignettes, visits and personal anecdotes that should keep you entertained throughout the book.
Bakody’s personal story, from arrival to Malaria hospitalization, a botched story about a development project and her subsequent departure to other duty stations in the country is always more of a  background. She is always treating local stories (families reunited after a long war; new local council legislation regarding fencing properties) and her own immersions with dignity and respect which should be the norm in reflections on aid work, but often is not.
She also makes few attempts to explain the ‘bigger picture’ or ‘Congo’ to her readers which may make her book not the first choice for new aid work(er) readers, but certainly worthwhile for those who already have an idea about the industry.

‘Cruel, unforeseen events that had a way of making our everyday problems seem at once luxurious and trite’
Still, no one could tell me for one iota of a second that out lives in Kindu were any less real than any other. Come 9 or 10 PM, the journalists and I would pick ourselves up and slump out the door, same as anyone else after a long day’s work (…). Mamy had managed to pick up typhoid fever. Matthieu fell sick with malaria. I knew Rigobert was midway through dusty cement piles of home renovations (…). So we had real-world problems. And not just real-world gripes, like never having enough paper for the printer or always having to rely on UN dispatch to get anywhere. Because in the Congo, in Maniema, the real world was also full of cruel, unforeseen events that had a way of making our everyday problems seem at once luxurious and trite.
(…)
“That was a friend on the phone. Just now,” said Gabriel. “He says they’ve found two Rwandans. And a mob is stoning them. They’re killing them.” (pp.190-191).
From my research and teaching perspective, these are important traits of a book that I can discuss with students in the classroom: Making everyday professional or personal worlds visible and connecting the regular and mundane with some of the broader ‘development’ challenges! And from a communication for development perspective, experiencing Bakody’s story through radio programming and communication work around a general election is an added bonus!

Aid work and tragedies in Congo, Haiti or Yemen
Yet another strength of Bakody’s narrative is that she focuses on her time in Congo from 2002 to 2006. That frees her from other typical aid worker memoir plot lines of the uprooted expat aid worker who follows the crisis caravan to the next emergency. Bakody settles in Europe, but before that she manages to hint at the dangers that local journalists face; most of them are not as fortunate as the Radio Okapi journalists to be affiliated to a national brand with international support.
Rigobert is abducted and beaten by one of the armed groups over a minor disagreement:
In an eyeblink – that fast – three soldiers gripped him steady as a vice while another took out a long wooden baton. They stripped him down and started lashing. The strikes where rhythmic. They struck the spine in the small of his back where there was bone and stinging skin. They hit is buttocks and keep on coming, one after another (p. 266).
And the senior female journalist Mamy also spends some time in jail before public pressure leads to her release.
Once out, Mamy shook her head and laughed. It hadn’t been so bad, she said. The best part of it was that she’d left with a ton of stories. She first quipped to her father, then later to Rigobert: “They really hadn’t been thinking, putting a journalist on the inside like that!” (p.338).
Other colleagues die on mission in other humanitarian emergencies or from HIV/AIDS and as sad as these stories are they nonetheless provide a sense of ‘wholeness’, of beginnings and endings and the extraordinary work of a group of regular, professional journalists:
One final word on Radio Oakpi: when recognizing the network with its Free Media Pioneer Award, the International Press Institute lauded it professionalism and success in drawing in a full third of the country every day, calling it a shining example not only for media in other conflict or post-conflict areas but for radio stations around the world (p. 342).
Radio Okapi Kindu is definitely among my favorite aid worker memoirs now and a great addition to this emerging genre that continuous to surprise me with fresh voices and approaches to communicating development in engaging and different ways!

Bakody, Jennifer: Radio Oakpi Kindu. ISBN 978-1-92795-897-1, 345pp, 16.95 USD, Vancouver, BC: Figure 1, 2017.

Links & Contents I Liked 240

$
0
0
Hi all,

It's Friday-and you know what that means: New #globaldev stuff and more from Aidnography!

Development news: Immersing with a family in Kenya; aid reforms; refugees & DAC-spending; the inflexible humanitarian architecture in Syria; Australia wants to outlaw orphanage tourism; towards a more equitable study abroad experience; donors & their urge to professionalize grassroots movements in Nepal; are there enough decent jobs in Kenya? Humanosphere's hibernation & the future of humanitarian reporting; aid worker mid-life crisis; what's the big deal about evidence?

Our digital lives:
The difficulties of female journalists in the Middle East; over-hyped Fintech; Twitter's glass ceiling for women and minorities; a CEO sleep-over; Tumblr is difficult to monetize.

Publications: The People in the Pictures; public attitudes towards migrants; women know stuff.

Academia: Better networking; morality & open access.

Enjoy!

New from aidnography
Radio Okapi Kindu (book review)

Unlike some aid worker memoirs, Jennifer Bakody manages right from the start to frame her story around the team of Congolese journalists, thereby avoiding the stereotypical pitfalls of a young Western woman going to ‘find herself’ in a remote place in the deepest and darkest and most dangerous part of Africa that all too often provides the backdrop for these books.
Her story is essentially about good journalism and good radio in a remote place-and that remote location happens to be in DRC in 2002.
(...)
Radio Okapi Kindu is definitely among my favorite aid worker memoirs now and a great addition to this emerging genre that continuous to surprise me with fresh voices and approaches to communicating development in engaging and different ways!
Development news
Truly left behind…

Last week I spent 24 hours with with Susan and her 5 kids in her homestead in Kuria, Migori County. This was a chance to immerse myself in the life of someone living well below the poverty line and reflect on what it means for my own efforts to tackle poverty. Despite the potential shallowness of a privileged expat like me dropping into a poor person’s life for 24 hours in the full knowledge of returning to my nice house and comfortable life, it was an incredible experience, raising more questions than answers.
(...)
How do we approach development through the eyes of people like Susan? When we talk of development, we often focus on helping the government deliver services to poor people, making sure there are health services, schools, and water. But people like Susan can’t even get to them, even if they are physically close. What more can we do more from the individual upwards rather than the service down. We’d see the deep socio-cultural barriers more clearly — like the practice of Nyumba Mboke — and how it holds families like Susan’s back even if there are reasonable services available.
David Vowles, the Head of DfID in Kenya, reflects on his immersion with a local family; IDS did a project with Action Aid on immersions for senior aid managers in the early 2000s and their publications still provide excellent food for thought.

Aid reform: Cash, World Bank stand out as localisation stalls

Analysts say the growing role of cash-based aid and the juggernaut of the World Bank moving into the humanitarian space are the two most visible areas of change. In other parts of the ecosystem, disputes and inefficiencies continue: The humanitarian community has not yet shown it can put “egos and logos aside” to forge other fundamental changes, one senior analyst summarised.
Ben Parker for IRIN summarizes key debates from recent high-level meetings in Geneva.

Debating the rules: What in-house refugee costs count as aid?

The working group is currently unpacking the meaning of the term “refugees” — and whether it should cover, for example, asylum seekers, refugees distributed under the European Union’s agreed quota system, migrants or some combination. It is considering the period within which sustenance costs are eligible and whether the timeframe should be changed from the current 12 months.
The DAC is also examining the methodology used for assessing costs and whether it can be based on estimates per refugee — as is currently done by some donors, Harcourt says — or whether it must be based on real individual costs attached to individual people.
Abby Young-Powell for DevEx with an update from OECD-DAC discussions on how domestic spending on refugee can be included as aid spending-and what the limitations are.

Lessons from humanitarian operations in Syria. Inflexible architecture?

My experience is that too many INGO’s are not confident of their status in regard to modern conflict. They rely too much on external guidance, encouragement or pressure from major donors, peer agencies, affected community representatives or perceived public pressure reflected in the media. Syria’s war has shone a powerful spotlight on the importance of organisational skill sets: the experience of operating in insecure, low-intensity or post-conflict environments are not qualifications to operate effectively in a hot conflict. Nor do they equip organisations with the ability to negotiate the delivery of aid across asymmetric battlefields. In Syria, where the civil war has spawned multiple combatant armies and militias, domestic and international, with overlapping and shifting objectives, even defining the conflict is difficult. The complexity of Syria’s asymmetric war has provided lessons that must be recognised and understood by humanitarian organisations.
(...)
I would also argue that the inflexible cooperation architecture currently favoured by UNOCHA and other agencies has no place when responding to the humanitarian needs of civilians trapped in asymmetric conflict. Coordination systems that distract from the business of delivering vital assistance and do nothing to enhance the impact of humanitarian response will inevitably cost lives.
Rae McGrath for Cable on delivering humanitarian aid in Syria and broader systemic challenges based on his experience as Mercy Corps director.


Child exploitation fears drive push to outlaw 'orphanage tourism'
Senator Reynolds also argues orphanage tourism should be a category of modern slavery because around three-quarters of the children are not orphans — they have at least one living parent.
"Some of these orphanages are well intentioned but most of them are for profit and some of them are run by organised crime because ultimately children in these facilities are a commodity," she said.
Sinet Chan, who grew up in a Cambodian orphanage, has pleaded with Australians not to donate to or volunteer at orphanages.
"The support of orphanages has created a thriving industry in which children are separated from their families and subjected to terrible abuse and neglect, as I was — being used as a commodity to generate funding," she said in a submission to a federal parliamentary committee investigating if Australia should have a law against modern slavery.
Louise Yaxley for ABC Australia. As much as I agree with the notion that orphanage voluntourism is a bad idea, of course, I am not sure I would subscribe to the notion of 'modern slavery'-but maybe that's more of a legal than a practical argument.

Against the romance of study abroad

We cannot expect that US institutions will embrace a more radical project of reciprocity without pressure. If UW and other institutions of higher education really want to build more equitable global partnerships, we suggest treating our partners as co-faculty with appropriate titles and compensation; supporting reciprocal exchanges and opportunities for students from host countries to participate alongside our US students in their home countries; and finally, situating reciprocal study abroad squarely in university efforts to address diversity and equity. This final step would not only address issues of access for US-based students, but begin to engage with the neo-colonial power relations that continue to benefit US institutions of higher education, often at the expense of our “global partners.”
Ben Gardner and Ron Krabill for Africa is a Country on reframing traditional discourses of study abroad and 'service learning' in the context of US academia.

Why grassroots activists should resist being ‘professionalised’ into an NGO

And so genuine activists get frustrated and seek escape. They seek ways to block out the disempowerment process. They refuse to participate while the senior manager is doing a staff performance appraisal and are indifferent to organisational rituals like one-to-ones, meeting the press or quarterly reviews with the donors. The movement-turned-NGO rebels by not sending reports to the donor within the stipulated time and saying “the computer crashed”, even if that means the donor giving you a red mark and threatening discontinuation of funding.
A good leader is sensitive to the disempowering ecosystem created by a large, process-driven NGO/donor. That leader provides the emotion that donor-pleasing NGOs are incapable of having. They have the power to bring joy to the team, discuss their issues, vent their frustrations and encourage their ideas. More importantly, a leader protects the interest of the movement, not because that is the expected “professional” leadership process, but because they are an empowered human being and knows why they are a leader.
Sunil Babu Pant for The Guardian on the disempowering engagement of many donors in Nepal and elsewhere.

How Kenya is Failing to Create Decent Jobs
The analysis reveals important information about job creation and wage trends. It demonstrates that the number of middle-income earners, who are likely to comprise a substantial proportion of a middle class, is small and not expanding any faster than gross domestic product (GDP) growth. This has important implications for Kenya’s economic and social development.
Kwame Owino, Noah Wamalwa and Ivory Ndekei for Africa Research Institute with an assessment of the 'growing middle class' narrative in Kenya.

A reader responds: Why Humanosphere’s hibernation matters

In short, Humanosphere’s hiatus is important because it represents a further narrowing of the already limited range of sources of information about humanitarian issues – just at a time when it is needed most.
(...)
News about humanitarian and development issues is generally ‘not commercially viable’ because it is both expensive to produce and rarely attracts mass audiences or significant advertising revenue. As a result, donor funding is one of the few – and often the only – substantial source of funding available.
Despite its importance, though, there are ‘significant limits’ to a donor-funding model – as Humanosphere’s experience illustrates.
Martin Scott for Humanosphere on the current state on uncertain future of humanitarian journalism.

Secret aid worker: mid-life crises hit earlier in the humanitarian world

I’ve also been through enough mission-born-but-eventual-long-distance relationships that have failed because of my ‘passion’ to continue helping the world’s children (read: spending hours in a sweltering office staring blankly at excel spreadsheets to fulfil student loan obligations) that I can’t help but laugh at the naivete of my lustful 24-year-old colleagues. But at the same time, I can’t picture myself in my forties or fifties in a small village with bucket-showers and movement restrictions that force me to take a car for the 100 metres between my house and office so I can have lunch.
The Guardian's Secret Aid Worker on getting older and wiser in the industry...

What’s the big deal about evidence?

Evidence is an important part of the decision-making picture, but it is only one element. As evidence advocates, we need to be conscious that even where there is reliable, relevant evidence, and demonstrable change – it’s not necessarily evidence that brings about change
Tari Turner for the Australian Council for International Development. My short answer to her initial question is that 'the big deal' is that people in power often seem to expect that evidence can 'do stuff' on its own. Evidence does neither replace action-nor does it neatly confirm your policies and approaches in many areas-especially if they are driven by political imperatives and not on the ground realities!

Our digital lives

The “double-edged sword” faced by local and foreign female journalists in the Middle East
A new paper by Yeganeh Rezaian, Joan Shorenstein Fellow (fall 2016) and Iranian journalist, shines a light on the difficulties women reporters face while working in Muslim countries, as well as the importance of the stories they tell.
Rezaian, who formerly worked for Bloomberg News and The National, was imprisoned in Tehran along with her husband Jason Rezaian of The Washington Post. She shares her own stories of being silenced and harassed, as well as those of other women reporters. In addition to imprisonment, women journalists in Muslim countries can experience online harassment and blackmail, defamation of character, unwanted advances in exchange for access, and the expectation to ask softball questions of officials, among other problems. Rezaian writes that such tactics not only oppress journalists, but are also part of a “larger goal of silencing women and defusing grassroots attempts at gender equality.”
Yeganeh Rezaian for Harvard's Shorenstein Center introduces a new report on female journalism safety in the Middle East.

Seven signs of over-hyped Fintech

A great many people in finance have now reached the point where they would like a way to identify Fintech technologies which are unlikely to solve real problems, work any better than existing technologies, are generally impractical or simply need a lot more explanation.
Martin Walker for LSE Business Review; his reflections also apply to many other digital field, including ICT4D...

Twitter’s Glass Ceiling Revealed for Women and Minority Races

That’s interesting work that reveals the clear existence of glass ceiling effects on Twitter. “We show that the Twitter glass ceiling effect, typically applied to females, also occurs in Twitter for males, if they are Black or Asians,” say the researchers.
This has significant implications for the way inequality can be tackled. A first step is always understanding the nature of disparities, and this work goes some way to achieving this.
But the next stage of working out how to level the playing field is a much more difficult task.
MIT Technology Review presents a new (open access) research paper on gender variances in Twitter activity.

The CEO Pikeout: How The Rich & Powerful Do Charity

Ten of the 70 CEOs who committed to sleeping out call it quits before McDonald’s breakfast is served at 5am – although one does return at 4:50am in a fresh new suit ready for the day ahead.
One by one, cabs come to collect the dignitaries and by the official 6am finishing time only half a dozen CEOs are left.
Virtues have been signalled. Connections have been made. Money has been raised, and, of course, people will be helped.
Sure, $5 million could have been $6 million if those CEOs who signed up but didn’t fundraise had of followed through. And $6 million could have been $10 million if the rest of the actually participating CEOs had hit their targets.
And perhaps a bigger impact could have been made if the media, the homeless and the general public were allowed to cross paths with the decision makers in any real and meaningful way.
The Underground Observer on a CEO Sleepout event in Australia to raise funds and awareness for homeless people.

Tumblr’s Unclear Future Shows That There’s No Money in Internet Culture

But the truth is that running a platform for culture creation is, increasingly, a charity operation undertaken by larger companies. Servers are expensive, and advertisers would rather just throw money at Facebook than take a chance on your weird, problematic network. Generating and incubating internet culture has little market value in and of itself.
Which means Tumblr has to hope for patience and kindness from Verizon while it seeks a way to make money. It’s not an impossible task (though Verizon’s hope that Yahoo will be the content arm of a major advertising operation is not promising for the company). There are signs that the internet-culture machines are finding ways to make themselves sustainable: YouTube is not shutting down anytime soon, but pre-roll ads weren’t doing the job, and now it has a premium subscription service in order to collect revenue directly from users. The next hubs of internet culture will learn from the mistakes of the past decade, hopefully by doing one of two things: developing a way to collect revenue directly from its audience, like Twitch or Patreon allow now, or by eschewing the notion of a sustainable business at all. It can be easy, in the era of just a handful of megaplatforms, to forget that the internet used to be a much more decentralized place, where things went viral across disparate platforms and websites and forum threads, rather than within a single one.
Brian Feldman for NY Mag on Tumblr, making platforms sustainable and the rather encouraging insight that maybe not everything can be commercialized, datafied, disrupted and sold :)!


Hot off the digital press
The People in the Pictures

We commissioned research in the UK, Jordan, Bangladesh and Niger, to listen to and learn from those who contribute their images and stories, as well as members of their communities. The research explored:
what motivated people to agree to Save the Children filming or photographing them or their children
how people experienced and perceived the image-making process
how people felt about their portrayal in the resulting Save the Children communications.
Latest report from Save The Children.

Understanding public attitudes towards refugees and migrants

This working paper is intended as a primer – outlining current global polling data on public attitudes, and analysing what the literature has to say about the drivers influencing these attitudes.
Helen Dempster and Karen Hargrave for ODI with a new paper.

Dude, Women Know Stuff

“In every instance in which you can make a difference, take personal responsibility to be inclusive and fight back against implicit gender bias,” the authors conclude. “Remember, women also know stuff. You should ask them about it.”
Colleen Flaherty for Inside Higher Ed introduces the new report from the political scientists of Women Also Know Stuff.

Academia
Banish the Smarm

In the slimy version of networking, one connects with others in order to gain opportunities to publish or otherwise disseminate one’s scholarship. A model based on sincerity, depth, and generosity, however, inverts that logic. Networking doesn’t enable scholarly achievement; instead, scholarship itself is the most important form of academic conversation — i.e., networking. The second act of generosity that every scholar can engage in is service. As academics, we perform a tremendous amount of unpaid labor. We serve on the boards of scholarly organizations and journals, review manuscripts and grants, work on committees. We do this labor because our profession would collapse without it. But we also do it to contribute meaningfully to our scholarly communities.
Robin Bernstein for ChronicleVitae disentangles academic networking.

The moral economy of open access
The analysis disentangles the ontological and moral side of these claims, showing how OA changes the meaning of knowledge from a good in the economic, to good in the moral sense. This means OA can be theorized as the moral economy of digital knowledge production. Ultimately, using Boltanski and Thévenot’s work on justification, the article reflects on how this moral economy frames the political subjectivity of actors and institutions involved in academic knowledge production.
Jana Bacevic and Chris Muellerleile with a new open access article in the European Journal of Social Theory.

Can we transform the repetition of virtual development debates into something bigger? And do we have to?

$
0
0
Maybe it was purely coincidental. Or maybe it was because I have more time to engage with digital content during my summer teaching break, but there seems to be an increased number of well-known discussions popping up that leave me a bit puzzled.

The Fifty Shades of Aid facebook group discussed expat salaries and various expat-local gaps again, Duncan Green revived the discussion on whether and how academics should influence policy-making, the Guardian wrote on volunteer stress and burn-out and on Africa is a Country there was a reminder that overseas volunteering needs a reflective framework.
Add to these debates the fact that a Western journalist apparently wrote a terrible book on his time in ‘Africa’ and mainstream celebrities got excited about clean water in Burundi (Beyonce) and hospital wings in Malawi named after their children (Madonna) this pretty much sounds like any other week.
Some policy debates, e.g. how much spending on refugees at home should count as ODA? have also been around for a while now and if that was not enough, someone can always organize an event on the ‘localization of aid’ or ‘cash transfers’.

Don’t get me wrong: I don’t want to rant per se and I do appreciate that a lot of people and organizations have many of these discussions with the honest aim to improve how they think, plan and work -but what happens when the short-lived digital attention span moves on until people donate SWEDOW during the next emergency and discover that the impact of a small participatory project is complicated to assess?

Revisiting learning, behavior change and knowledge management in 2017
To some extent, I stand by my first research article on development blogging published in 2013 that stressed the potential of digital engagement as a tool for personal learning and organizational- or self-reflection. This provides me as a teacher with plenty of case studies and teachable examples and it has certainly helped me to develop better engagement with different stakeholders.
But how do we move beyond this level?
Will I read in five years from now how much of an eye-opener an immersion with poor people can be? Or that Kathmandu is a great place for your first expat aid experience? And while MSF will hopefully continue to be a critical voice in the humanitarian industry will other organizations follow or post the starving child/give a goat/volunteer in Ghana campaign because ‘this is what people respond to’?
And why would an outlet like the Daily Mail change its journalism-simulation on development? The model sells well and it may not have a large impact on those who care about the topic anyway.

So my first question from the headline remains frustratingly unanswered: Can we transform the repetition of virtual development debates into something bigger? I have yet to find evidence. Yes, a new theme like ‘cash transfers’ is gaining momentum in the community-but then it quickly moves into a discussion of ‘Uber-
something-development and perhaps uncritically following tech solutionism despite evidence that INGOs will not quickly disappear and Silicon Valley approaches will not ‘solve’ poverty.

A global water-cooler where people meet, vent and go back to make things work somehow

At the same time, I do appreciate many of those virtual debates-which brings me back to my second question: Do we have to transform them into something bigger?

As diverse as ‘our’ community may be and as much as we suffer collectively through the one or two annual populist essays of ‘but does aid really work? You know, corrupt African dictators and all…!?!’, the digital, virtual water cooler may be just that: A relatively safe space for venting frustrations, finding support and maintain a community of like-minded people (which is not simply the same as a ‘filter bubble’…).

Maybe this seems too modest and unambitious for a project aimed at social justice, equality and transformation-or maybe these discussions are an extension of that bigger project.
With all the other mediatized anger in this world I am always impressed how respectful the vast majorities of debates around global development are-which is an important goal itself: Reminding ourselves of basic courtesies, respect and emotional well-being.
So what if someone else is already organizing a get-together of aid workers in Amman next month? And if re-posting reflections on volutourism get one new college student to think about her/his engagement abroad, that’s already a win! And eventually that one NGO that keeps insisting on ‘white savior’ images to promote its projects will have to change their communications in light of a changing donor basis (I am still young enough to dream…).
Be generous, be the anti-troll you want to see online and be gentle with those who reach out and make an effort to better understand the complexities of development.

Just writing my short reflective post to wrap up this week has already calmed me down from my ranting mindset I had when I started typing.
I also revisited an old post from 2015
for additional food for thought:

At the end of the day, when all ‘white Land Cruiser’ jokes are told, all ‘white elephant’ projects are evaluated and all voluntouristic photos by white people are uploaded to Instagram, development in general and development communication in particular will continue to have an important role as witness to injustice and marginalization, as an amplifier of dissent and as a connector between cultures, stories and those who need a virtual or physical hand that reminds them of humanity
I am grateful for all the critical discussions and engagements I can enjoy through our digital community and the latest link review I am finishing now is one regular proof that a lot of good, albeit not always new, stuff is happening all around us!

Links & Contents I Liked 241

$
0
0
Hi all,

Despite the lack of sun in Sweden, this post still counts as a ‘summer post’… 

Development news: The war in South Sudan; failing to learn from Biafra in Nigeria; Aga Khan’s 60 year of slow development; Rwanda really wants to ban second-hand clothing; a closer look at peacekeeping cuts in DRC; Liberia after Ebola; Cash transfers in Kenya; Madonna in Malawi; Beyonce and Burundi, Ashton Kutcher and US gender quality-the special celebrity section! World Bank & ILO whitewash in Uzbekistan; Philip Morris lobbies in India to undermine global governance; coming to a Bollywood theatre near you: Toilet: A Love Story.
Disaster of the week: Brookings Think Tanker runs aground off Crimea… 


Our digital lives:Use facebook groups! Check out an archive of 700 Oxfam campaign posters! Start a revolution!

Publications:
Women of color and gendered harassment in science; are women paying a higher price for UN careers? Your advisor’s gender can determine academic success; refugees & voting; Google News & filter bubbles


Academia:Lessons from being a PI; social media, open access & book chapters.

Enjoy!

New from aidnography

Can we transform the repetition of virtual development debates into something bigger? And do we have to?

So my first question from the headline remains frustratingly unanswered: Can we transform the repetition of virtual development debates into something bigger? I have yet to find evidence.
(...)
Be generous, be the anti-troll you want to see online and be gentle with those who reach out and make an effort to better understand the complexities of development.
(...)
I am grateful for all the critical discussions and engagements I can enjoy through our digital community and the latest link review I am finishing now is one regular proof that a lot of good, albeit not always new, stuff is happening all around us!
Development news
The war in Equatoria

When South Sudan’s civil war broke out in 2013, much of Equatoria – the country’s breadbasket ­– managed to stay out of the conflict. But that respite was short lived. As the government army began purging the region of perceived opponents last year, it triggered the world’s fastest-growing refugee crisis, with the United Nations warning of a potential genocide.
Jason Patinkin and Simona Foltyn for IRIN with a sad, great piece of contemporary multi-media conflict reporting from South Sudan and Uganda.

Fifty years later, Nigeria has failed to learn from its horrific civil war

Nigerian authorities have mastered the habit of ignoring the cries of marginalized groups or subtly fueling the maltreatment of their members, giving rise to public sympathy for demagogues who ultimately resort to violence to gain optimum attention for their grievances.
Eromo Egbejule for the Washington Post with a reminder of how the past matters for Nigeria's future and beyond.

Aga Khan 60th Anniversary Jubilee Puts Spotlight on Long-View for Development
Longer-term programming enables community-driven development to take place in practice, not simply in theory.
“What I find appealing about the Aga Khan Foundation is we are working farther upstream and we are working towards root causes of poverty and social tension and try to do something about it before something happens – whether it is the provision of health services or education,” Kocher said. “Many of these problems are not simple issues and are not able to be fixed in the course of a short-term grant cycle.”
The work may be secular, but the religious roots of AKDN provide a kind of organizational stability that enables AKDN to invest using time horizons that are rare in international development.
Tom Murphy for Dawns Digest with a portrait of one of the biggest 'anti-philanthrocapitalists' perhaps who has been 'doing development differently' for 60 years?

Rwanda will proceed with the ban on used clothes despite threats by the United States
Rwanda’s President Paul Kagame has insisted that Rwanda will proceed with its plan to phase-out importation of second-hand clothes despite threats from the U.S. that the move could lead to a review of his country’s eligibility for duty-free access to the American market. President Kagame recently made the remarks while addressing a news conference moments after submitting his nomination papers to the National Electoral Commission (NEC).
Kenya, Uganda, Rwanda, Burundi, Tanzania and South Sudan decided to fully ban imported second-hand clothes and shoes by 2019, arguing it would help member countries boost domestic clothes manufacturing.
Kylie Kiunguyu for This is Africa with an update on the used closing ban some African countries are considering.

The Dynamics of Peacekeeping Budget Cuts: The Case of MONUSCO

The DRC’s precarious political and security situation is not solely or even primarily due to UN failures, but it does not reflect well on MONUSCO or its predecessor mission, MONUC, which have cost UN member states almost $18 billion since 1999.
(...)
The challenge in financing negotiations is to find a balance between national political priorities and the operational imperatives in peacekeeping missions, given the mandates set by the Security Council and the strategic realities facing the missions. For MONUSCO, at least, this year’s negotiations tipped perilously toward cost-cutting as an end in itself, rather than reflecting a clear vision for a more effective mission, or a more peaceful DRC.
Katharina P. Coleman for the IPI Global Observatory with a detailed assessment of budget cuts for peacekeeping in DRC.

Liberia after Ebola: 'The human suffering changed me'

Now in Philadelphia, Sumo is still grappling with the psychological impact of the time she spent working with the burial team. Zio says that he'll often find her alone on the couch, curled up into a ball and crying. But Sumo isn't an American citizen, and he hasn't been able to find affordable insurance for her to see a specialist.
She says that her worst moments come when she thinks about the orphaned children she saw, crying alone in the homes where their parents lay dead, with neighbours too afraid to take them in or bring them food.
(...)
At one point, while interviewing Foday Gallah, he made a comment that resonated deeply with my own experience. "It felt like my identity couldn't be anything other than a survivor. I was just a survivor," he said. In some ways the attention the illness brought me was more overwhelming than the disease itself, something I try to remember every time I've interviewed someone since then.
Ashoka Mukpo for Al-Jazeera with plenty of local and personal reflections on life as a Ebola survivor in Liberia.

A heartwarming story in Kenya that will challenge your ideas on aid with a new experiment that hands out out cold hard cash – and what the villagers do with it, is up to them.
Madonna in Malawi to open children's hospital ward
Four of Madonna's six children have been adopted from Malawi. The hospital ward is named after her 11-year-old adopted daughter, Mercy James.
She described her legal battles to adopt Mercy, comparing them to her fortitude in pushing for the hospital to be built.
"I fought for Mercy and I won. So I am here to say, 'never give up on your dream.' Love conquers. If you do things with love in your heart, you will conquer."
Deutsche Welle on Madonna's latest trip to Malawi that, strangely enough, seems to be as much about her struggles and her children as it is about helping Malawi...

Beyoncé Has A Plan To Help Burundi, But Key Details Are Fuzzy

And though Beyonce herself has not indicated that she's visited Burundi, her representatives have. Ivy McGregor, director of philanthropy and corporate relations at Parkwood, was part of a Parkwood team that traveled to Burundi in April to plan for the new initiative.
"We traveled throughout the provinces to uncover the need. We asked one question: How can we help?" McGregor told a crowd at the Global Citizen Festival in Hamburg, Germany on Thursday, in a video posted on YouTube. "And there was always one resounding answer — safe, clean water."
Courtney Columbus for NPR Goats & Soda. This is a really interesting article for several reasons. First, it raises the question why Beyonce couldn't just be a 'normal' celebrity ambassador and let UNICEF worry about funding, implementation etc. Why does her charity need to get involved in this project? Second, it already raises questions about transparency and accountability-these issues tend to get worse, not better once T-Shirts are sold, money changes institutions and projects are implemented. Third, it raises interesting questions about Parkwood Entertainment, the PR firm behind Beyonce's activities; they actually went to Burundi for a 'needs assessment' and I would be very curious to read that report and learn more about how they select projects for celebrity clients and engage with organizations like UNICEF...

Ashton Kutcher plans to host an open dialogue on gender equality

Kutcher hosted the conversation on Facebook on Monday, in which he immediately pointed to the fact that many people on the internet berated him for the questions he originally posted.
Megan Rose Dickey for Tech Crunch. Since it is only fair to include a male celebrity in the review here's Ashton for you-but perhaps there is hope as he is already acknowledging some of the challenges.

World Bank and ILO Whitewash One of the World’s Most Brutal Regimes

On this flawed basis, the report’s conclusion is what the World Bank wanted to hear: the districts receiving funds for World Bank projects are, according to ILO, not affected by forced labor. The remainder of the country remains at risk of forced labor, yet not a single specific case could be identified.
The ILO monitoring report gives succor to one of the most oppressive regimes in the globe today, and buttresses the façade essential to continued labor abuses and corruption in Uzbekistan’s cotton industry, which occurs sadly with international complicity.
Kristian Lasslett for The Diplomat with a reminder that large international organizations often struggle to work with autocratic regimes-especially when the nature of their partnership is deemed technical and non-political...

Inside Philip Morris’ campaign to subvert the global anti-smoking treaty

The anonymity and distance helped Philip Morris approach delegates covertly. On the second day of the conference, a white Toyota van pulled away from the front of the Hyatt Regency hotel – where Philip Morris had its operations room – and headed for the FCTC treaty venue.
(...)
The Delhi conference ended as it began, with treaty Secretariat officials not knowing where Philip Morris had been or what it had done. The company had flown in a team of executives, used a squad of identical vans to ferry officials in New Delhi, and then left town without a trace.
Aditya Kalra, Paritosh Bansal, Duff Wilson and Tom Lasseter for Reuters. Make no mistake: Multi-national companies will always undermine global governance efforts and will try everything in their power to continue with their business models no matter how detrimental to public health they are. Cudos to Reuters for keeping an investigative eye on developments in the global South!

"Toilet: A Love Story": Bollywood spotlights India's sanitation crisis in new film

Their fight for a toilet inside their home - which is considered unclean according to social norms - quickly becomes a struggle for social change as they campaign for functioning toilets for the local community.
The film's promoters said the movie in particular spotlights women's safety, basic dignity and privacy.
"The film is the true story of millions of women in rural India who ... walk a few kilometres away from their homes just to be able to relieve themselves," said the statement.
"At break of dawn or fall of dusk, these women face the risk of rape and/or kidnapping – an inconceivable threat for most of us when routinely going to the toilet," it added.
Nita Bhalla for Thomson Reuters Foundation on how Bollywood is working on large-scale social norm change.

Millions Of Policy Proposals Spill Into Sea As Brookings Institution Think Tanker Runs Aground Off Crimea Coast

“We’re doing our very best to limit the exposure of marine habitats to the analyses of sub-Saharan energy infrastructure, universal basic income, and automation in the labor market, but it could be months before we know the full extent of the damage.”
The Onion :)

Our digital lives
Why Aren’t You Using Facebook Groups for Greater Engagement?

When I asked the 40+ Philippine farmers how many of them were using Facebook Groups to improve their farming techniques, every hand went up. I asked them how they used the group, and all the normal uses came up: reading others’ posts, sharing pictures of their own progress, and following links to outside sources.
When I asked about impact, all the farmers reported learning something useful on a regular basis from their farming group, and many of them were actively finding new business partners through Facebook Groups as well.
Wayan Vota for ICT Works on facebook groups and agriculture in the Philippines.
700 posters from the archive. Gold for students of charity history/changing use of images (both good and bad).
Duncan Green for FP2P. The Bodleian library was offline at the time of finalizing my review and I will probably repost the link next week!

The Fall of Working-Class New York

Electoral participation is a requirement for any serious socialist project. The Left, however, faces a set of strategic dilemmas that do not apply to parties and movements aligned with the current system. In the midst of the global crisis of the 1970s, Ralph Miliband identified the dual mandate of socialist movements in bourgeois democracies: they must be both “parties of government” and “parties of struggle.”
(...)
a compelling account of the rise of right-wing politics in the US, one that concentrates its fire on the leading culprits: business elites and their political functionaries. Together, they remind us that power under capitalism is ultimately located outside the electoral arena, and must be defeated at its source.
Chris Maisano for Jacobin with a great essay that reminds us that social change is rarely successful as a 'bottom-up' project within the straigh-jacket of existing institutions and power relations...

Hot off the digital press

Double jeopardy in astronomy and planetary science: Women of color face greater risks of gendered and racial harassment

In this sample, in nearly every significant finding, women of color experienced the highest rates of negative workplace experiences, including harassment and assault. Further, women of color reported feeling unsafe in the workplace as a result of their gender or sex 40% of the time, and as a result of their race 28% of the time. Finally, 18% of women of color, and 12% of white women, skipped professional events because they did not feel safe attending, identifying a significant loss of career opportunities due to a hostile climate. Our results suggest that certain community members may be at additional risk of hostile workplace experiences due to their gender, race, or both.
Kathryn B. H. Clancy, Katharine M. N. Lee, Erica M. Rodgers and Christina Richey with an important open-access article in the Journal of Geophysical Research.

Are women paying a higher price for a UN career?

The survey shows that women and men are equally well prepared when entering the UN, but there was a drastic discrepancy in career progression among men and women. In fact, it was found that women who left the UN progressed further in their career paths than those who stayed.
Henrik Ryden for Impactpool. Do read this study with a couple of pinches of salt: The results are based on 172 respondents which, unlike the author claims, is not 'a large data set with high statistical significance'. I am also not entirely sure whether the gender aspect is really the most important finding, or whether highlighting this finding is driven by Impactpools work on gender diversity. So do be careful with too many generalizations from the study!

An Advisor Like Me? Advisor Gender and Post-Graduate Careers in Science

We investigate whether having an advisor of the same gender is correlated with the productivity of PhD science students and their propensity to stay in academic science.
Our analysis is based on an original dataset covering nearly 20,000 PhD graduates and their advisors from U.S. chemistry departments. We find that students with an advisor of the same gender tend to be more productive during the PhD and more likely to become
professors themselves. We suggest that the under-representation of women in science and engineering faculty positions may perpetuate itself through the lower availability of same-gender advisors for female students.
Patrick Gaule and Mario Piacentini for the IZA Institute of Labor Economics with a new working paper on gender and academic careers.

Burst of the Filter Bubble?: Effects of personalization on the diversity of Google News
In offering personalized content geared toward users’ individual interests, recommender systems are assumed to reduce news diversity and thus lead to partial information blindness (i.e., filter bubbles). We conducted two exploratory studies to test the effect of both implicit and explicit personalization on the content and source diversity of Google News. Except for small effects of implicit personalization on content diversity, we found no support for the filter-bubble hypothesis. We did, however, find a general bias in that Google News over-represents certain news outlets and under-represents other, highly frequented, news outlets. The results add to a growing body of evidence, which suggests that concerns about algorithmic filter bubbles in the context of online news might be exaggerated.
Mario Haim, Andreas Graefe and Hans-Bernd Brosius with a new article from Digital Journalism.

Academia

Lessons learned from being a Principal Investigator and Co-Investigator

What does it mean to be a project lead – a principal or co-investigator?
What must you know before you take on such a role?
What problems or issues should you anticipate in applying for and running or co-running a project – problems that are not akin to anything you would have experienced in doing smaller or independent work (e.g., your PhD)?
How do you successfully navigate these problems?
How does project leadership abroad differ from project leadership done in one’s own home country/region?
Sara Perry with a great post on academic project management and how to navigate the university (not just if you are the PI of a large research project...). Excellent read!

Using social media and open access can radically improve the academic visibility of chapters in edited books

None of this is to deny that if you have strong primary research to report it is better to push it out in journals wherever feasible. But book chapters can have valuable exploratory, discursive, synoptic and review roles. And they can carry new findings too, especially in start-up fields and with good editors and editing. The old problems from the early digital phase, when for a while chapter texts became literally unfindable, and authors passively left things to publishers to promote their work, no longer apply with much of their previous force. However conservative your editors and publishers may be, you can get your chapter noticed, read and cited in the communities that matter to you.
Patrick Dunleavy for Writing for Research. As reasonable as his strategies are, I am not entirely convinced that book chapters are the medium of the academic future. They don't get read and cited-and if they are available open access they may get read a bit more often and still will not be cited; in most disciplines they will be 'write only' contributions to academia. But Dunleavy has a point that you always should try to make your publications as openly available as possible to maximize whatever little impact they may have...

Links & Contents I Liked 242

$
0
0
Hi all,

Did I mention that 'summer' has so far passed by the South of Sweden and I am finishing this review on a November-like gloomy afternoon...anyway, there is lots to discover this week-regardless of whether you are going to read on a beach, in the office or in front of a cozy fireplace ;)!


Development news:Orphanages and exploitation in Haiti; Somali piracy reloaded; African academics and their wish list for the WHO director; The G20 and the limitations of its Compact With Africa; inside the dysfunctional UN in Myanmar; remittances, rice & real estate in Nepal; Kathmandu’s wood carvers; reviewing emergency shelters; lunch meetings are a terrible idea; Americans want to help homeless people, but…; social justice orthodoxies; South African poets on writing & changing minds.

Our digital lives:Reclaiming social entrepreneurship; the trouble with Bridge academies; a 4,000 USD Renault for India; why study journalism these days? 

Publications:Manufacturing humanitarian martyrdom; blockchain & #globaldev; Twitter, facebook & the general public. 

Academia:Bureaucratization of utopia; impact of long-term development research; Sara Ahmed, feminist killjoy.

Enjoy!

Development news

Charities and voluntourism fuelling 'orphanage crisis' in Haiti, says NGO
Networks of traffickers are suspected of recruiting and deceiving children into orphanages to gain money from abroad, the Haitian state research authority (IBESR) believes. Indeed, Lumos found evidence of parents believing their children would receive a better education in orphanages, orphanage directors paid “child finders” to recruit children to the orphanages, and in some cases families were paid $75 to give their child away.
“Many parents are deceived into giving up their children, purely so that unscrupulous individuals can make a profit,” said Lumos’ CEO, Georgette Mulheir.
Naomi Larsson for the Guardian with another story about the global orphanage industry; interesting side note in terms of celebrity engagement that JK Rowling support the organization that carried out the research that supports the piece.

The Somali pirates are back (SPOILER ALERT: they never really left)

"They … challenged the local mafia by presenting real arguments against the benefits of being recruited as a pirate. They are the pirate conflict’s unsung heroes. Unlike many Western-led awareness campaigns, they were both matter-of-fact and unpretentious," Yusuf says.
The director himself says he showed illiterate young men in the coastal cities videos of how pirate ships were blown up and statistics proving how few pirates actually struck it rich.
(...)
Puntland's smuggling gangs collaborate not only with pirates and terrorists, but also with some of the region's politicians. These politicians are dependent on shady arms deals because the UN has had an arms embargo placed on Somalia since 1992.
Magnus Boding Hansen for IRIN with a detailed report from Puntland and the shifting frontiers of 'piracy' and its new complex re-configurations in an unstable region.

African academics set out what Dr Tedros needs in his toolbox to tackle health ills

A leader like this is needed at the helm of the WHO. Dr Tedros will understand that Africans can be included in partnerships rather than dominated in the quest to find solutions to the unique challenges that the continent faces.
Andrew Githeko, Bob Mash, Karen Daniels and Thumbi Mwangi for The Conversation share their views on what the new Somali director of the WHO could focus on.

G20 summit: Africa’s loss

Its macroeconomic framework – fiscal policy discipline, privatisation and deregulation – smacks of the neoliberal ‘Washington Consensus’ that was thought to be a thing of the past. The CWA has no room for nuanced recommendations that take Africa’s particularities into consideration. It does not distinguish between emerging economies and conflict-ridden poorhouses; countries that export and import raw materials; coastal states or landlocked countries; states in West and East Africa; or nations that are heavily indebted and those that are not.
The CWA is heavily influenced by the Anglo-Saxon financial model, which is based on stocks and bonds. In contrast to that, East Asia and Continental Europe financed their successful development models through retained corporate profits, commercial bank corporate credits, and taxes and mandatory levies for public sector investment.
Robert Kappel and Helmut Reisen for International Politics & Society review the G20 Summit's newly established Compact With Africa.

Inside the ‘glaringly dysfunctional’ UN mission in Myanmar

In recent years, friction and antipathy within the UN team have been something of an open secret in Myanmar. Humanitarians, who see rights abuses at the root of crises that involve displacement, hunger, violence, and statelessness want to raise the alarm, according to several insider sources. They voice resentment about development people who keep quiet for the sake of relationships with the government, which they have to work with to improve people’s lives. Each thinks the other is morally bankrupt, naive, or both.
Poppy McPherson for IRIN with a story from Myanmar and the eternal quest of the aid industry to find a balance between supporting 'development' and/or supporting social justice...as an emerging new hotbed of catch-up capitalism it would be great to see power issues and social justice addressed more clearly by the aid community...

Remittance, rice and real estate

“Most of the urbanisation was in the last three years, now more than 70% of paddy fields are gone, and even the remaining land has been bought up by real estate developers,” says Ward Committee Chair Kamal Bahadur Thapa, who blames the lack of local government for the unplanned growth.
The irrigated fields of Pokhara and Lekhnath used to be famous for their rice diversity, with famous varieties like Jetho Budo, Jhinua, Ramani and Sili, but many of them are now on the verge of extinction.
“Even on the remaining fields, most of the rice is of the hybrid or imported varieties, our own rice is being lost,” says farmer Sabitri Bhandari, 54, whose father sold all the family's land to property developers.
Yuvaraj Shrestha for the Nepali Times with a story that definitely deserves some research attention: How is the money from remittances changing geography and exporting Western/Northern notions of a 'real estate market'?

In post-quake rebuilding, Kathmandu's carvers reclaim a fading heritage

Today in the workshop, Pushpa Raj Shilpakar, one of the project’s most gifted carvers, is bent over a statue of a two-toned goddess: half old, half new. She has gone stub-nosed, details having blurred through the centuries. Flicking away woodchips, Pushpa Raj carves her new hand into a plain block, shaping fingers, and with his finest chisel, her minuscule nails.
Asked if he had worked on similar designs before the earthquake, he gave a wistful smile. “Nothing like this,” he says. “These designs – it’s like they were made by a god. I still can’t understand how they did it.”
(...)
Many Shilpakars feel indentured to the trade, unable to pursue better-paid jobs because of their truncated schooling, Surya Bahadur says. He would rather his children not join their ranks. Several of the craftsmen’s younger relatives, seeing the precarious finances they would inherit, have shunned the grueling apprenticeship to qualify as a carver, a rite that can take upwards of a year. This trend could spell the end of traditional woodcarving.
Tirtha Ram is buoyed only by the significance of temple restoration, which he frames as his “actual” work, as opposed to his “commercial” work.
Atul Bhattarai for the Christian Science Monitor with a very different story from Nepal...well, maybe it isn't such a different story after all, but a follows the common theme of how heritage and tradition fit into a growing capitalistic model of state building.

Emergency Shelter: Housing for the Age of Mass Displacement

Perhaps an alternative way to view this issue is not to consider architects as designers of individual living units but instead as professionals able to provide expertise at various timescales of temporality, carefully considering the economic suitability of proposed design solutions while helping to steer global funds more locally. Looking towards the future, to really address the issue of mass displacement, we must prepare for the next generation of ‘global cities’ and leave behind the idea of developing out of town camps—by definition unable to sustain themselves long-term—and instead look at how we might revise low-cost and collective living in our existing urban centers.
Hannah Wood for Archinect with a great review of current issues around migration, displacement and shelter from an architectural perspective!

Why you need pull-based community meetings

One variant of these meetings is the dreaded "lunch and learn" - one of my pet hates. There are many reasons why I dislike "lunch and learn";
- they assume that community meetings can't take place in "real working hours" and need to be held at lunchtime (thus perpetuating the idea that "KM is not Real Work";
- they assume you can eat and listen - that you don't need to pay full attention;
- they assume you don't need to take any notes (with your hands full of sandwiches);
- they assume that the people who turn up will be passive listeners and not active contributors. After all, how much can you contribute with your mouth full of food?
This is the worst way to transfer knowledge - a one-way presentation to a bunch of people who are busy doing something else.
Nick Milton on how to engage with a community like you mean it...

Americans want to help the homeless — as long as they don’t get too close. This explains why.
As we expected, people who are more easily disgusted are more likely to support bans on public sleeping and panhandling than those who are less easily disgusted. But they are just as likely to support policies providing aid or housing to homeless people. We also found no evidence that disgust sensitivity predicts more negative attitudes toward homeless people in general.
(...)
These findings suggest that when media coverage mentions concerns about cleanliness it amplifies the effects of disgust on exclusionary attitudes. Policymakers who want to combat homelessness should bear in mind that much of the public supports their efforts — but only from a distance.
Scott Clifford and Spencer Piston for Washington Post's Monkey Cage blog present interesting research that raises equally interesting questions for advocacy and fundraising in the aid industry.

Kin Aesthetics // Excommunicate Me from the Church of Social Justice

Don’t shut them out because their politics are outdated or they don’t wield the same language. If we are interested in building mass movements to destroy mass oppression, our movements must include people not like us, people with whom we will never fully agree, and people with whom we have conflict. That’s a much higher calling than railing at people from a distance and labeling them as wrong. Ultimately, according to Garza, building a movement is about restoring humanity to all of us, even to those of us who have been inhumane. Movements are where people are called to be transformed in service of liberation of themselves and others.
Frances Lee for Catalyst shares his reflections on social justice orthodoxies.

Writing Between Resistance and Celebration Two Black South African Poets On Writing, Urgency, And Changing Minds
First, there’s this expectation that the writing must be universal, it must fit everybody in. At the same time, you need to be Black and feminist and all the other labels, and perform those identities in a way that makes you digestible too. Also, on top of that, you can’t alienate white audiences too much. I’m very aware of this, while also trying to write outside of these expectations and be truthful and honest. Which is difficult, because there are too many people watching you, and once you speak, they won’t allow you to change your mind about some of the things you’ve said. I want to be allowed to change my mind.
(...)
I guess in my dream world, the work is sitting with people who have influence and power to shift things. They are people who make decisions that impact the rest of us. But more than that, the work is in the hands of people who think or believe that they don’t have the right to access imagination. I want those people to have the space to dream, sit, read, and indulge in joy and pleasure. In my dream world, the work is shifting something. And not in an airy sort of way, but in a tangible way, which goes back to my answer.
Maneo Mahale for Bitch Media interviews artists Koleka Putuma and Vuyelwa Maluleke and you definitely want to read this beautiful piece!

Our digital lives


But, as she explains, "we don't need more social businesses, we need more social change" and that requires more than just starting new businesses. It requires system change leadership. Daniela explores the difference between being a social business founder and a system change leader and then unpicks how we talk about, fund, and educate for social entrepreneurship, as well as what needs to change in our education and funding systems to fuel more system change leaders.
No Education Crisis Wasted: Billionaires Seek to Make Education in Africa Profitable
And the data that May earlier described as “robust?” They are up for sale. At least, that’s what a leaked Bridge presentation, meant for investors, from 2016 suggests. In this presentation, Bridge outlined new profit-making opportunities, including the sale of customer information to lenders and insurance companies, and increased profit margins on school lunches and student uniforms.
What has happened to May and Kimmelman’s dream? Opposition from governments, non-governmental organizations and trade unions seems to have slowed down Bridge’s growth considerably. It also looks like the company is not going to reach its planned target of two million pupils by 2018. The company wrote me that it currently has just over 100,000 pupils.
Not all of Bridge’s innovations are bad, of course. Absenteeism among teachers appears to be lower at Bridge schools than at state schools. Juul says that other schools could also take Bridge’s electronic payment methods as an example as a way to tackle corruption.
Maria Hengeveld on Alternet takes a closer look at Bridge academies in Liberia and Kenya - beyond Nick Kristof's assessment and the recent New York Times coverage.

Why This $4,000 Renault Is as Disruptive as the Tesla Model 3

In India, a Tesla is literally from the future. An Indian future that’s coming, but one built upon a universe of customers that need to own a moped first, then a Kwid, then something else while they wait for infrastructure to catch up.
Indian driving culture may take a lot longer.
The Indian and American markets may be half a world and many decades apart, but human nature is fundamentally the same. Understand it, and Tesla’s appeal here is obvious. So is that of the Kwid over there, where for $4000 you can also buy a piece of the future. It won’t have the Model 3’s bells and whistles, but it will have a lot of things you haven’t seen before, at a price you can afford.
And there’s nothing more disruptive than that.
Alex Roy for The Drive. In some ways, this may be bit of an outlier for my link review, but in other ways the story of Renault in India is a very interesting (and also scary from an environmental and consumerist aspect) story about 'development', disruption and how global brands are re-shaping local markets.

The Paradox of a Journalism Student With No Faith in Journalism

How does a journalism student that doesn’t have faith in American journalism, answer what they’ll do with their journalism degree? You could have an hour long debate about the merits of journalism and journalistic systems, the viability of journalism outside of economic and political influences and devoid of ulterior motive, and your solutions to the current media system…. check, check and check.
Yet with this comes the startling but expected realization that I have no solution. How does one remove the deep ties to political influence and market viability? Can you exist outside of the media system and still become as successful as those working within it? How do you reconcile your increasing nihilism about American systems and societal systems in general with your idealised view that someone needs to fix it?
Triggering Thought asks some important questions that we as teachers or researchers have a difficult time answering ourselves...

Hot off the digital press

Dying for humanitarian ideas: Using images and statistics to manufacture humanitarian martyrdom

Although we would all prefer to die a hero rather than a victim, the heroising of aid workers raises
at least two problems.
The first is that it produces a being set apart from the rest of the human race – better, more worthy.
The second –and the most problematic for the professional sector we are concerned with here – is that treating aid workers like heroes can also lead us to believe that death is an integral part of the system, an occupational hazard. It seems to us that this is where the real danger lies: setting sacrifice up as a virtue within a sector that has made “humanity” one of its cardinal principles.
Michaël Neuman for MSF-CRASH with a new report that I need to read in detail; but some of his reflections remind me of my recent post on Combat charities and the mediatization of extreme humanitarian volunteering.
By the way: The MSF-CRASH website could do with a little bit of TLC...


Blockchain and Economic Development: Hype vs. Reality

We argue that, while blockchain-based solutions have the potential to increase efficiency and improve outcomes dramatically in some use cases and more marginally in others, the key constraints to addressing these challenges often fall outside the scope of technology—and that these constraints need to be resolved before blockchain technology can meet its full potential in this space.
Michael Pisa and Matt Juden for the Center for Global Development with a new paper.

Twitter and Facebook are not representative of the general population: Political attitudes and demographics of British social media users
We find that Twitter and Facebook users differ substantially from the general population on many politically relevant dimensions including vote choice, turnout, age, gender, and education. On average social media users are younger and better educated than non-users, and they are more liberal and pay more attention to politics. Despite paying more attention to politics, social media users are less likely to vote than non-users, but they are more likely to support the left leaning Labour Party when they do vote. However, we show that these apparent differences mostly arise due to the demographic composition of social media users.
Jonathan Mellon and Christopher Prosser with a new open-access paper in Research & Politics; on the one hand, the findings are not *that* surprising-on the other hand the question remains about the general importance of social media for election campaigning-and more complicated questions around 'propaganda' and 'manipulation'...

Academia
The Bureaucratization of Utopia – A Report

Through the various ethnographic cases they explored, participants were able to highlight the tensions, contradictions and paradoxes that bureaucrats encounter when seeking to implement ‘good governance’ principles (such as ‘transparency’, ‘accountability’, ‘participation’). Their contributions also underlined the ubiquitous presence of audit and other measurement techniques in the global governance of the world, forcing the various actors interacting in this field to develop administrative skills in order to preserve their audibility and remain relevant. What these trends seem to highlight is the increasing reliance on ‘techno-legal devices’, to use Ballestero’s notion, (reports, indicators etc) to solve big world issues and to ‘neutralise’ politics. But shouldn’t we rather conceive these dynamics as another expression of politics, the mere ‘gloss of harmony’ (Müller 2013) covering inherently political – and therefore controversial – issues?
Julie Billaud for Allegra Lab with a neat summary/overview of their latest conference.

Timing is everything... or not?

Lastly, not only direct relevance to policy is important, one should also keep in mind that influencing practice can in turn be relevant for policy makers. Without denying that policy does have an impact on practice, it has long been recognised that the policy cycle does not work in a linear way, or is even starting with policy. Hilhorst: ‘In reality, practice is shaped by many factors outside of policy. Practice has a life of its own, and it is often the case that the policy cycle happens in a reverse way. Interesting work on innovation shows that innovation usually starts in practice, and it is therefore equally - if not more - important to target research uptake at communities of practice.’
The Dutch science research council NWO features research findings from Thea Hilhorst's long-term research project.

Sara Ahmed: Notes from a Feminist Killjoy

I think there are many ways we are asked to rush over things that are hard—in politics and in life—and the writers who have taught me most, including Audre Lorde, especially Audre Lorde, have taught me to stay with what hurts however much it hurts, until you have worked something out about yourself and the world. Audre Lorde also says that sometimes to survive we have to become stone. Sometimes to survive the weather you have to harden yourself. She invites us to embrace our imperfect broken bodies with bits and pieces missing. I think when the project is to survive heavy, hard histories, we do need multiple tactics; sometimes they are in tension with each other. Sometimes we need to lighten our loads, to laugh. Sometimes we need to be weighed down, to stop under the weight.
We are not going to get it right when we are living with wrongs. We are not going to build a house that is light enough to accommodate everyone. It is an ongoing, unfinished project because it is a question: how to build a feminist world when the world we oppose is the world we still inhabit.
Nishta J. Mehra for Guernica with a long interview with Sara Ahmed.

The privilege of giving career advice in international development

$
0
0
After Duncan Green mentioned George Monbiot’s career adviceand added some reflections from his aid industry policy angle, I am yet another (white) man with a stable career – this time in academia – who is supposed to tell you how to get ‘there’…

I am probably the most careful one when it comes to the ‘follow your passion’ discourse.

George Monbiot is not writing about the aid industry
In fact, two of his three routes he outlines are potentially quite terrible in connection with international development: Just going to the field and ‘doing it’ sounds like a voluntourism disaster to happen and ‘if you are fed up with mainstream employers just create your own brand’ (Monbiot uses slightly more radical and less creative industry language) will also lead to a challenging ‘career’-even with some professional experience under your belt.
To be honest, I find Monbiot’s reflections really not that helpful as there is little room for balance with other aspects of your existence: Working for a small front line organization may sound exciting, but with all those discussions around mental and physical well-being it is worth remembering looking after yourself when you are not supported by institutional arrangements and professional networks. ‘Doing it your way’ can be a route into burn-out-especially in our age of the entrepreneurial self.

Duncan Green started his career before ‘neoliberalism’

My short piece will not turn into a ‘state of the world’ reflection, but it is important to keep in mind that the institutional foundations of ‘a newspaper’ like the Guardian or ‘an INGO’ like Oxfam have changed profoundly and will continue to do so in the future.
The biggest challenge is the vast pool of qualified, diverse global talent that went through the ‘right’ Masters programs, ‘right’ internships and have access to the ‘right’ networks. They also did the traveling and living in Africa stuff in an attempt to offset the ‘right’ formal aspects of the CV with the ‘right’ informal aspects. To put it bluntly, neoliberalism has the remarkable and powerful ability to professionalize most aspects of our lives beyond simply making sure that qualified people do no harm in their jobs.

Leaving machine learning, algorithms, artificial intelligence, ‘robots’ and their impact on ‘careers’ aside for a moment, the audit-, ranking- and measurement-culture has become a pervasive aspect of any professional environment. And for most of us it will mean that we have to arrange ourselves with those realities.

How do you find the perfect balance between ‘bullshit tasks’ and writing a blog post on Friday?
David Graeber, yet another white men with a secure academic position, introduced the idea of ‘bullshit jobs’ as his contribution to critiquing the neoliberal system. They make for great mocking of the City and related industries, but the truth of the matter is that almost all professional jobs nowadays have some elements of ‘bullshit job’ attached to it-at least in the form of some ‘bullshit tasks’. On a regular day I could log into a variety of databases that facilitate my job at the university: A database to report grades, a database to approve an invoice for a book order, a database to report holidays and maybe a database to check student applications. You can joke about it with colleagues but the truth is that there are many administrative routines that govern my conduct at work and limit my creativity. But any ‘career’ in a large organization will come with some ‘bullshit tasks’ in exchange for many positive aspects. This was also one of the reasons why I wrote
5 reasons why everyone should work for a large organization at some point in their international development careersin 2015.
In the context of international development I disagree to some extent with Monbiot’s notion of ‘freedom’: Good development work relies on routines, small tasks done well – and using creativity, experience and judgment to interpret guidelines the right way so some small social change will flourish.

Is there actual career advice at the end of the post?

Yes- and no…
If you work full time in a large organization you will have to learn how to tame bureaucratic demons. That does not sound like the most challenging and creative professional endeavor, but it is part of the reality many of us will develop careers under. So if you have the opportunity engage at least once with a large organization-maybe even only to figure out that it is absolutely not what you wanted.

Based on my own experiences and talking to our diverse group of students in our MA Communication for Development program I am quite convinced that ‘our’ sector of international development is quite terrible at ‘career development’ and talent management. You will have to develop your own, there, I said it, ‘mini-brand’ that can showcase good work with passion and creativity. One challenge is to find that niche-and just because your organization likes your creative communication approach it does not mean that you should quit your job and run workshops now freelance…

The toughest question in terms of career building is the question of the slowly changing ethical framework of international development: How can I justify my engagement?
Duncan writes: ‘I loved writing; I was (broadly) on the left; I wanted to understand social and political change and if possible contribute to it.’
Is this still enough to build a career given our global Northern/ Western, male etc. privileges?
Since social change usually happens slower than we anticipate my tentative answer is ‘yes, to some extent’-but the more important questions for which I have no good answer at this stage is, to put it more provocatively, who should have a career in international development in the future and at what cost will they happen in a globally accelerating labor market?

Links & Contents I Liked 243

$
0
0
Hi all,

We are in the middle of packing boxes and prepare for the move to a new apartment next week, so I’ll keep the intro short:

Development news:Angelina Jolie & how celebrities shouldn’t engage in distant places; how much ODA is really spend on #globaldev? Can Gueterres disrupt UN bureaucracy? Uranium mining in Niger; once and for all: Don’t send your old stuff abroad/to refugees! Uganda’s new activism; the IMF’s social protection thinking is behind the curve; Gentrifying Kibera-Kenya’s well-known slum; Kony’s bodyguard talks; perceptions of poverty of India’s urban youngsters; Sean Penn has a new terrible aid work(er) movie out; the trouble with caste-free Bollywood movies; is the world really better than ever?

Our digital lives:
Participatory community mapping; how to ace narrative writing; the gendered challenges of paying women in exposure and as influencers; where are the mothers in news rooms?


Publication
:
Digital anthropology from the fields. 


Academia:The expensive political economy of academic conferences; publication, power & patronage; laboring academia-a long read.

Enjoy!

New from aidnography
The privilege of giving career advice in international development

The toughest question in terms of career building is the question of the slowly changing ethical framework of international development: How can I justify my engagement?
Duncan writes: ‘I loved writing; I was (broadly) on the left; I wanted to understand social and political change and if possible contribute to it.’
Is this still enough to build a career given our global Northern/ Western, male etc. privileges?
Since social change usually happens slower than we anticipate my tentative answer is ‘yes, to some extent’-but the more important questions for which I have no good answer at this stage is, to put it more provocatively, who should have a career in international development in the future and at what cost will they happen in a globally accelerating labor market?
Development news

Aid credibility at stake as donors haggle over reporting rules
The OECD’s statistical directives, including tables and annexes, already come to 294 pages, many about reporting ODA.
Closed-door committee meetings at the OECD regularly update the definitions of what’s allowable as ODA and how it should be calculated. Last year, for example, the members agreed new guidelines allowing certain types of military and security assistance to count. The debates tend to roll on: discussions continue on what support to the private sector should be included and how to measure it, while peacekeeping and security spending are attracting another round of attention.
Ben Parker for IRIN. Fascinating case study on how little 'data' tells you by itself, how little transparency is created through rules and regulation alone and how you need intermediaries like journalists to 'translate' the politics of data into the public sphere.

A disrupter at UN: Can new chief shake up bureaucracy to speed progress?

The UN “needs to be nimble, efficient, and effective. It must focus more on delivery and less on process, more on people and less on bureaucracy,” he said after taking the oath of office before the 193-member General Assembly of UN nations. Looking at UN rules and regulations, he said, “one might think some of them were designed to prevent, rather than enable, the effective delivery of our mandates” to secure global peace and prosperity.
Howard LaFranchi for the Christian Science Monitor. Spoiler alert: The answer to the headline is 'No!' ;)... as the quote above indicates: We have heard similar talk time and again and I doubt that any disruptive changes are likely to happen regardless of which male SG is in charge...

A forgotten community: The little town in Niger keeping the lights on in France

Back in Arlit, the stories of French former employees standing up to Areva are well-known. But the struggle for Nigerien workers to get recognised is even steeper than in Europe. “Both the legal system and the financial means to stand up for our rights are lacking”, says Dan Ballan. “In a couple of years, the uranium reserves will be depleted and Areva will leave, however the pollution and underdevelopment will stay behind.”
He may be right, but Areva will not be going far. About 80km away, a third and enormous new Nigerien uranium mine called Imouraren is being developed. “Lacking any perspective of another job, the workers will eventually move wherever the mine is”, says the local activist.
In our last hours in Arlit we drive around in town. It’s the afternoon, the sky is dark red, and a harsh wind is blowing. A new sandstorm is gathering. We try not to think of the particles it carries from the radioactive hills.
Lucas Destrijcker & Mahadi Diouara for African Arguments with a very nice piece of long-from journalism, sadly with the unsurprising bottom line that decades of mining have left very little positive impact on Niger.

Do Refugees Really Need Our Old Crap?

“We don’t know what it is to feel like every individual aid recipient,” he said. “We don’t know their priorities. Instead of giving people objects, which they often sell to buy things they really need, why not give them cash in the first place? Give people a choice on how to spend precious resources.”
So if you really want to help, instead of shipping off your baby carrier, maybe sell it on Craigslist and donate the proceeds to a well-rated charity. And if you prefer donating items, keep it local. Maybe there’s a homeless shelter or teen mom home in your community that could use a baby carrier.
Livie Campbell for The Development Set with an excellent report on the well-known debate on why you should not send old stuff 'to Africa'.

Uganda’s New Civic Activism: Beyond Egos and Logos

This new face of civic activism is challenging the old-style, conformist, traditional forms of organizing. This change will likely have wide-ranging implications for civil society generally and the struggle for social justice. If the new forms of activism are nurtured, they could have a greater impact than any traditional civil society organization (CSO) has recorded in Uganda in recent times. But the so-called big ego and logo CSOs view the new activism as a distraction, if not a threat, and still need to strike a constructive partnership with it.
Arthur Larok from ActionAid Uganda for the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace with a great long-read on the new forms of activism and how they challenge the aid industry.

The truth behind IMF’s claims to promote social protection in low-income countries

Despite the current objectives of the international community on social protection, the IMF continues to maintain and pursue an opposing policy position. The IMF appears to operate within a self-referential dialogue that is cut-off from the international policy consensus. A look at the paper’s reference list strongly supports this idea: out of the 22 studies cited in the paper, only one is not conducted by its own staff.
Thomas Stubbs and Alexander Kentikelenis for the Bretton Woods Project dissect a recent IMF study on social protection. This is an important reminder that just moving the IMF to Beijing, a suggesting from Christine Lagarde herself, will not solve more fundamental problems of the institution.

Kenya | Gentrifying Kibera

Firstly, the slum population keeps growing. Secondly, houses are useless to the poor without land tenure, security and infrastructure. Resident Michael Arunga, who represented Kibera civil society in the KENSUP planning committee, feels that the project was doomed from the start. “How can people without any income even afford decent housing? People have no livelihood.” He believes the scheme was started for “political reasons” and not genuine in assisting Kibera people to build better lives. Some former Kibera residents who did move in the new houses now sub-let them in order to make a living, he says, and still stay in shacks.
(...)
All this just to attract donor funding for the politically-connected? Yes, said the official: “The real intention of authorities in the slum upgrade is to milk Kibera dry and sustain its misery.”
Ken Opala for Zam Magazine on what is probably the world's most well-known slum and how efforts to change living conditions are encountering (stereo)typical development problems-social change is complicated...

This is what we can learn from Joseph Kony’s bodyguard

Kony — like Museveni in some ways — has never been rigid about anything except his own survival. I came to see Kony as a pragmatist of the first order. Kony has used bits of religion, including Catholicism, Protestantism and Islam, to advance theories that were all designed to prolong his rule. He has done the same with regard to traditional Acholi beliefs and even select Marxist theory.
Laura Seay for Washington Post's Monkey Cage interviews Ledio Cakaj's about his latest book.

When do upper middle-class urban youngsters start thinking of themselves as poor?

You can skip meals in private for days on end, or walk home for half an hour because you couldn’t even afford a bus ride, as long as no one knows about it. At the precise point when the lack hits your pride and there is no solution in sight, does the debt become the trap, and you begin to feel hunted.
Inasmuch as this book is a confession by many of that sense of wounded pride, it’s also, in their candidness and insistence on using their real names (some names have been changed on request) and details of their intimate financial dealings and fall from grace, a breaking of the pattern.
The refusal to live this lie, sit with a false sense of social achievement that in many ways society forces them to live up to. The fear of being unable to pay for drinks, dress a certain way, be seen at certain places, and be subsequently rewarded by the system for that behaviour. The insistence on being told and being seen is a lifting of the curtain of silence that surrounds it. This generation isn’t as broke or bereft of courage and integrity as it looks.
Gayatri Jayaraman for Scroll.in with a fascinating excerpt from his forthcoming book; this is an interesting pre-quel to the long read on whether the world is really getting better-and how people feel about it.

Review: Aid Workers in Love and War in Sean Penn’s ‘The Last Face’

At one point Ms. Theron’s character asks, in voice-over, “In this place of so much war, had I found peace?” The script, by Erin Dignam, doesn’t get much deeper than that. The romantic chemistry between Ms. Theron and Mr. Bardem feels forced throughout, never more so than in a scene of mutual seduction in a cutesy context of brushing teeth. Mr. Penn is more than competent in recreating the noise, gore and panic of war zones, but far less so in simulating the atmosphere of alienated romance common in 1960s European art films.
Glenn Kenny for the New York Times reviews another bad aid work(er) movie.

Missing in the Scene

Caste remains hugely important in India today, especially in villages where there are denser traditional networks and occupations,which are at their thinnest in the city. While there are Dalit millionaires, who prove to be exceptions to the rule, there are very few Dalits among the country’s new middle classes.
This absence of low castes among India’s better off means that Hindi cinema is caste- blind, rather than caste- neutral. Usually, everyone who mixes socially in such circles is upper caste. This is their version of a caste-free society, while lower castes perhaps dream of a caste-free society where everyone is so well off that caste no longer matters.
Rachel Dwyer for the Open magazine with a reminder that Bollywood's caste-free movies do not mean the system is no longer relevant.

Is the world really better than ever?

Nestled inside that essentially indisputable claim, there are several more controversial implications. For example: that since things have so clearly been improving, we have good reason to assume they will continue to improve. And further – though this is a claim only sometimes made explicit in the work of the New Optimists – that whatever we’ve been doing these past decades, it’s clearly working, and so the political and economic arrangements that have brought us here are the ones we ought to stick with.
Oliver Burkeman with a Guardian long-read that resonates with core development debates that argue that traditional economic growth-driven economies will continue to deliver benefits and lift people out of 'poverty'.

23 quotes by famous people if they had worked in nonprofit
“Watch your thoughts; they become words. Watch your words; they become emails. Watch your emails; they become meetings. Watch your meetings; they become more meetings. Watch these meetings; they become your destiny.” Lao-Tzu
Vu Le for Nonprofit: Awesomely Fun!

Our digital lives
Participatory Community Network Mapping as a Crucial Methodology for Social Innovation – Part 1 of an interview with Aldo de Moor

When done poorly, he cautions, community network maps can undermine community work by being an empty distraction, offering the seduction of a silver bullet, institutionalizing the misuse of power, and by using limiting language - language that closes down possibility, exploration and creativity, instead of opening them up.
But when done right, these kinds of maps can be powerful catalysts for empowerment and emancipation.
Christine Capra interviews Aldo de Moor for Greater than the sum about the potential of community mapping exercises.

Katherine Boo’s 15 rules for narrative nonfiction — now this is a “must-read”

Additionally, rather than “follow the money” or “follow the lies,” she says “follow the policy.” Policies are changing rapidly, and the impacts on poor communities are often obscured. Instead of just gravitating to the aberrant, which is our journalistic instinct, Boo suggests also thinking about ways we are interconnected.
Katia Savchuck for Nieman Storyboard with a great summary of Katherine Boo's rules for writing important stories.

Thousands of women try to make a living blogging and vlogging. Most fail.

There's various stats, and I have to look up the one I used in the book, but I think it's maybe 15 percent of content creators make more than $100 a year. It's a huge disparity. In terms of fixing it, one of the problems, again, is that people who already come from a position of privilege can afford to work for free, just like unpaid internships. So I think the most important resolution is one of two things. One is collective advocacy in recognizing this as a profession rather than a hobby, and also, calling attention to who pays and the amount. And so there was that ... I don't know, it was Who Pays Influencers website? Do you remember that? That was maybe a year and a half ago? I loved it, and it kind of disappeared.
Gaby Dunn for Vox talks to Brooke Erin Duffy’s about her new book and the gendered aspects of digital work.

Where Are the Mothers?

In an era of cost-cutting and layoffs, ongoing technological disruption, lack of public trust in our work, and a hostile political climate, newsroom environments still matter. It’s precisely because of these uncertainties that news organizations need to be smart about how to keep talented, diverse groups of journalists, including mothers with young children, in our ranks, doing the vital work that needs to be done. Paid family leave, inclusive, flexible work policies that benefit everyone, and improved office cultures are not tangential priorities; they are crucial to fostering a pipeline of young, innovative thinkers—the future leaders of our industry.
Katherine Goldstein for Nieman Reports. Very interesting research that raises many important questions about the future of work more generally.

Hot off the digital press

Digital technology, transformation and social change

The Lab and this issue focus our attention on squarely on technology and change. That includes slow change and fast change; small change and transformational change; change that we create; changes we want to make; changes we must make; and change that happens to and around us. It includes changes in the home and changes in our social and political lives; and changes in the Global North and changes in the Global South.
Jessice Noske-Turner with a special issue of the open access Wumen Bagung journal featuring some really interesting notes from the field of digital anthropology!

Academia

The Great Conference Con?

Kelsky said that if she had to predict the future of academic conferences, she’d anticipate a further shift toward virtual conferences, with more interviews via Skype, in recognition of the financial constraints facing many participants. At the same time, she guessed there would be a continued reliance on in-person conferences for those who can afford them.
In other words, she said, it’s “the continued feudalization of academia, where those at the top occupy a more and more isolated enclave of privilege and opportunity hoarding, at the expense of everyone else. Virtual options will mitigate this to some extent, but as you know, some of the deepest human engagement remains face-to-face, so that option will exist for, and benefit, those with funds.” Financial concerns notwithstanding, Reed, writing for Inside Higher Ed, said he wished academic conferences were a bigger part of community college life and cautioned against writing them off too quickly
Colleen Flaherty for Inside HigherEd reviews the current iteration of the of the love-hate relationship that many academics have with large, expensive conferences.

A Feminist Note on “Publication, Power, and Patronage”

To understand why prestige still marks a publishing system founded on the rhetoric of meritocracy, we’d need to not take that rhetoric at its word but instead understand how it has functioned discursively, and often nefariously, in an institution whose entire existence is predicated on keeping the channels narrow.And in doing that, we’d have to ask whether such a system is worth redeeming, and why. That is: to what end do we want to diversify the “four leading journals in the humanities”?
Whitney Trettien presents her research findings on how publications became the key currency of modern academia-and how that has created a (male) elite hierarchy.

Laboring Academia

Most graduate schools admit students to fill specific labor needs. One of the core functions of graduate programs is to enhance flexibility, always presenting just enough labor, just in time . . . The academic labor system creates holders of the Ph.D., but it doesn’t have much use for them . . . The system produces degree holders largely in the sense that a car’s engine produces heat—a tiny fraction of which is recycled into the car’s interior by the cabin heater, but the vast majority of which figures as waste energy that the system urgently requires to be radiated away.
Maximillian Alvarez for The Baffler. A long-read for the weekend about academia and the capitalist condition-Marc Bousquet's quote above was almost worth reading the essay ;)!

Links & Contents I Liked 244

$
0
0
Hi all,

Surrounded by moving boxes comes the latest link review!

Development news: Did Angelina Jolie really do harm on her film set? What are the Clooneys up to in Lebanon? Haiti's sewage problem; climate change and suicide in India; crimes against women in India; electoral information campaigns don’t work
anywhere; evidence-based policy-making in the tropics; sued over a critical facebook post; board trouble at Ushahidi? Corporate BS: Sending employees on voluntourism trips; aid workers as authors. 
  
Our digital lives:Transparency & accountability at G4S; the ‘mind trap’ of social entrepreneurism: class and breastfeeding; the price of unpaid internships.

Publications:
New open access anthropological textbook


Enjoy!

Development news

Angelina Jolie Refutes Vanity Fair’s Portrayal Of Controversial Auditions

Jolie said in a statement Saturday that the audition scene had been taken out of context. According to the actress, there were parents, guardians and non-governmental organization partners, as well as medical doctors, present throughout the entire filmmaking process, including auditions. She emphasized that no one was hurt by participating in the recreation of the film’s scenes.
Carla Herreria for Huffington Post. I also tweeted about the initial story and I am a bit puzzled that Vanity Fair may have gotten their story quite wrong and I'll promise myself to be even more careful about trusting established media brands...

Clooneys to help 3,000 Syrian refugees go to school in Lebanon

A $3.25 million donation from the Clooney Foundation for Justice, Google and HP will pay for transportation, school supplies, computers, content, curriculum and teacher training.
A spokesman for the Clooneys' foundation, Max Gleischman, said the organization had decided to support education for Syrian refugees through the public school system, instead of investing in private schools operated by SABIS, an international company which has prepared students for college and high school exams.
Riham Alkousaa for Reuters with another celebrity humanitarian story. Small numbers in every aspect, but at least this appears to be a 'do no harm' project with Clooneys' ego not in the driver's seat...

You Probably Don't Want To Know About Haiti's Sewage Problems

In the past five years, the story of one failed sewage treatment plant project offers the clearest example of the good intentions, poor governance and bad luck that contributed to Haiti's current sanitation crisis. It began with a young woman and a huge earthquake.
Rebecca Hersher for NPR's Goats and Soda captures the challenges of 'development' in an excellent nutshell of her story from Haiti.

Climate change causing suicides in India as crops fail

Optimists often suggest that society will adapt to warming. But Carleton searched for evidence that communities acclimatize to high temperatures, or become more resilient as they get richer, and found none in the data.
“Without interventions that help families adapt to a warmer climate, it’s likely we will see a rising number of lives lost to suicide as climate change worsens in India,” Carleton says.
Kathleen Maclay for Berkeley News presents new research by Tamma Carleton on the link between suicides and climate change in India.

What factors affect the occurrence of crimes against women in India?

As affluence in Indian states grows, there is likely to be a slight rise in crimes against women, but as the female to male ratio has already begun to rise, it is in turn likely to dampen the rise in these crimes. The efficiency of the judicial and police systems may be the deciding factor – and unfortunately, going by recent evidence, it may be optimistic to surmise significant improvements in these systems in the near future.
Geetika Dang, Vani S. Kulkarni and Raghav Gaiha for the Manchester University's Global Development Institute Blog present their latest research findings.

What works? Bringing more evidence to development

Hyde explained that there are different ways of interpreting the reasons behind the results. For example, it might suggest that information needs to be provided to voters earlier on, she said, adding that her takeaway is that it is difficult to make voters more informed, not that informing voters is a worthless task.
The findings confirmed what many democracy and governance practitioners have observed in their work in transitioning countries, that information in and of itself does not lead to political accountability, said Linda Stern, director of monitoring, evaluation and learning at the National Democratic Institute.“It served to put an exclamation point on the idea that exposure to information alone is not enough to change citizens’ political preferences and behaviors,” she told Devex via email.
Catherine Cheney for DevEx. To me, this reads a bit like an attempt to justify funding for a lost cause: 'Voter information programs are not working-but let's continue projects and explore every possible angle to justify them'-similar to the debate about employment skills programs it looks that there is very little evidence to justify them, but some political interest to continue regardless...

Evidence-based policy making in the tropics

While the paper is not a counsel for despair, it is a call for realism. Evidence-based policy making remains an admirable aspiration; but it may just be a long way away. Of the constraints addressed in our paper, the one most susceptible to immediate influence by both domestic governments and donors is the state of universities and think tanks in developing countries.
Stephen Howes, Ashlee Betteridge, Lawrence Sause and Lhawang Ugyel for the DevPolicy blog with an overview of their latest working paper on the challenges of evidence-based policy-making.

Cambodian philanthropist wins first round of defamation case
A Canberra law student has been ordered to pay the legal costs of a Cambodian philanthropist after her defamation defence was struck out in court.
Juanita Zankin must now rethink how she will fight allegations she defamed Geraldine Cox in a February Facebook post.
Michael Inman for The Canberra Times on the strange case of how a short, critical and temporary facebook post that addressed Sunrise Cambodia-and organization that has already received critical media coverage.

Stop orphanage volunteering and reduce child exploitation

Ms van Doore coined the term ‘paper orphaning’ as the active recruitment of children into orphanages or residential care institutions in developing nations for the purpose of ongoing exploitation through orphanage tourism and funding.
(...)
“Orphanage tourism and funding creates a demand for children to be available in orphanages to volunteer with, which ultimately drives recruiters to traffick children into orphanages,’’ Ms van Doore said.
Deborah Marshall for Griffith University News talks to Kate van Doore as part of the on-going debate in Australia to label orphanage tourism 'modern slavery'.

On governance: A quick assessment of Ushahidi and questions for its board

Why is Ushahidi’s board not independent, particularly given the amount of local and international public and foundation funding it receives?
Dutch Schultz, probably an alias, highlights some issues with Ushahidi's governance structures that I cannot verify or find additional sources for.

This Company's New Perk Is Sending Employees on International Trips

Any employee who has been at the company for at least one year and participated in payroll giving for at least six months (that could be donating between $2 to $150 per paycheck) is given the opportunity to travel to Nepal, Bolivia, Kenya or Ecuador on the company's dime. On these trips, Experticity volunteers could be working on a number of different projects depending on the needs of the place they visit, including building classrooms, community water systems, health clinics or personal hygiene workshops or training locals in micro-enterprises.
Rose Leadem for Entrepreneur. I am so sick and tired of corporate BS like this! Sending employees to some of the laziest voluntourism places to do lazy voluntourism projects is not motivating staff, but simply showing your corporate ignorance about #globaldev & social change. Go hiking in Nepal by all means, but don't build classrooms!!!

Aid workers as authors? We ask an Evil Genius named J.

J: What I generally see is an explosion of volume and style over substance. Professional looking websites, lots of team blogs and “communities” (maybe like this site), but also a lot of what feels to me like overly earnest self-indulgence (not this site). I miss some of the older blogs like Hand Relief International and La Vidaid Loca. It doesn’t all have to be funny or sarcastic. Aid Leap is excellent, but sadly The Pillar is no more. But even so, I miss the days when it was all a bit more fun and snarky and to the point, and a bit less “here’s 1,000 words on what I pondered as I savored my morning tea while overlooking Machu Picchu.” I feel like much of what passes for aid writing in general in 2017 is as much, or maybe more cultural performance than anything else, without actually exploring any kind of new territory in terms of ideas or issues.
Kasmiraa for Missing in The Mission talks to J./Tales from the Hood about aid blogging and writing-a highly recommended read on the past, present & future of writing about development on the Internet!

In case you missed this ;)!

Our digital lives
Transparency and Accountability: An Open Letter to G4S

The first thing to note is the largely inhospitable environment of the G4S AGM for democratic, rational dialogue and debate. The atmosphere and space of the AGMs have not, at least since 2014, delivered on openness or a guarantee of personal security necessary for a genuinely democratic forum.
David Scott on LinkedIn. His detailed reflections suggest, perhaps not entirely surprisingly, that G4S may not be interested in critical dialogue and discussing political questions at shareholder meetings...

Social Entrepreneurship’s All-American Mind Trap

Thus, rather than focusing on who the social entrepreneur is, a much more interesting question is why and how do various stakeholders come together in pursuit of socially entrepreneurial ends? How might philanthropy change its image of entrepreneurialism from an individualistic notion to a collective one, so that what we see at the end of the capitalization of new ideas is sustainable shared ownership or stewardship enterprises that have been and are continually fine-tuned to fit a system?
Fredrik O. Andersson and Ruth McCambridge for Nonprofit Quarterly address several issues that are important for #globaldev, including 'hero narratives', multicolored saviors and a general tendency to continue with consumerist-capitalistic approaches and expect them to lead to social transformation.

The class dynamics of breastfeeding in the United States of America

Well-off parents have access to the infrastructure that supports breastfeeding: longer maternity leaves, jobs that allow for pumping breaks, the ability to hire outside help to support a new mother, and—perhaps most importantly—immersion in a culture that unconsciously views breastfeeding as a desirable status symbol and pressures them to continue to that hallowed six-month mark and well beyond.
Breast milk has become a luxury good, another example of what the sociologist Elizabeth Currid-Halkett calls inconspicuous consumption: the investments in intangibles like health and education that increase social capital for the modern wealthy. And because these costs are largely invisible, it’s easy to frame breastfeeding as a free good equally available to all. The truth is much more complicated.
Corinne Purtill and Dan Kopf for Quartz with an interesting piece on something as 'innocent' as breastfeeding and how it has become a social signifier for class and wealth; expect similar developments in 'emerging economies' soon...

Unpaid internships damage long-term graduate pay prospects

“I expect some people will find an internship that enables them to do the job they really want to do and that will have the big labour-market return but, on average, an internship you take won’t lead directly to a job in the profession you really wanted or the profession you did the internship in.”
The study also found that those who took internships were less likely to go on to professional or managerial roles or be satisfied with their career compared with those who had gone straight into work.
(...)
Holford said that one reason for the earning disparity could be that graduates who took an internship were delaying the start of their careers which could often see them end up in entirely different occupations from the ones in which they did their work placements.
Jamie Doward for The Guardian with new research on the trickiness of unpaid internships...

Hot off the digital press

Perspectives: An Open Access Intro Anthro Textbook

Perspectives reflects the shared conclusion of SACC, the authors, and editors that open access publishing is one way to engage a new generation of students and, particularly, the diverse students who attend community colleges. If nothing else, we are hopeful that Perspectives can bring anthropology to a broader audience of students and general readers outside of our classes.
Nina Brown, Thomas McIlwraith and Laura Tubelle de Gonzálezon for Savage Minds reflect on the process and intention behind their new open access anthropology introduction.

Reporting the Retreat (book review)

$
0
0
To be honest, I am not much of a military history person. I am also not exactly a WWII person either when it comes to readings at the intersection of work and leisure.
But Philip Woods’ Reporting the Retreat-War Correspondents in Burma intrigued me for its sub-title and I really enjoyed the reflections it sparked vis-à-vis today’s challenges of war reporting and the complexities of truth in media more generally.

Philip Woods’ book about ‘the six-month, one thousand-mile retreat of the British and Chinese armies from Burma in the first half of 1942’ (p.1) is a very well researched historical case study of journalism, news media and the work of foreign correspondents. The book looks at a group of twenty-six correspondents who reported from Burma for newspapers and weekly newsreel broadcasts and, equally important, about half of the group wrote memoirs shortly after their assignment in South Asia.
The discrepancies between their daily work, always impeded by military censorship, and their frank book-length accounts are a vivid reminder that there never were ‘good old days’ when it comes to war reporting and that many of today’s challenges have remained through time, new (digital) media and many different war theaters.

Fake news, propaganda & for-profit news organizations
One of the things I found quite astonishing was the extent of censorship and how most of the journalists followed the directive to support the ‘war effort’ through their reporting: ‘Journalists had to present their dispatches to three authorities’ (p.57) and the chief civil censor once told journalist Leland Stowe:

I always ask myself if my dear devoted daughter in England would be alarmed by this (reporting). If she’d be alarmed, however true, it shouldn’t be reported (p.59).
So while Eve Curie, the only female reporter, shared a frank account in her book Journey Among Warriors published in 1943, ‘her newspaper reports displayed none of that gloomy realism’ depicted in her book (p.61). In the end, she ‘told a partial truth about the air war over Rangoon but it covered a greater deception about the state of war in the rest of Burma’ (p.62).
These are exactly the issues that lead to many of the debates we have today about biased journalism, partial truths and the spread of alleged or real ‘fake news’, often blamed on digital developments.

In practice, however, newsreel self-censored because they understood that their role within the cinema programe was to avoid alienating audiences and support the main film. Newsreel editors also realized the power of government to control access to locations and to film stock, and anyway naturally saw themselves as contributing to the patriotic war effort (p.84-85).
So both commercial and ideological leanings of news program producers played an important part in framing news, sometimes being very close to ‘fake news’ by re-enacting battle scenes (p.89).

Emotional toll of reporting & the birth of Magnum photography
In addition to newspaper and newsreel journalism, photo-journalism was the third important pillar of journalistic engagement. This was an era when Life magazine had a circulation of more than 3.25 million around the globe.
This is the time of George Rodger who saw himself as a ‘war photographer and no journalist’ (p.78) and who also wrote a memoir of his time in Burma. After his assignment ended in Asia he returned to Europe at the end of the war and was one of the photographers who photographed the victims of the Bergen-Belsen concentration camp. ‘His long experience of war had left him scarred and it is nor surprising that he did not continue as war photographer’ and became a founding member of the Magnum Photos cooperative in 1947 (p.79).

How depressing or encouraging is the long historical view?
Looking back to journalistic practice and professionalism 75 years ago offers some really interesting insights into today’s discourses around war reporting. What Woods describes as ‘inevitable preference for stories of European evacuees’ (p.126) rings very true with today’s discussions around the ‘value’ of Northern victims and ‘heroes’ in journalism or development communication.
And Fay Anderson’s observation that

essentially reporters were imagined as an archetypal cliché-resilient, hard-drinking, hedonistic, churlish, and cynical. Let us call it the Hemingway syndrome-the celebrated machismo (p.140)
seems appropriate to keep in mind in contemporary debates about aid worker well-being and expat lifestyles. And there was certainly no support system in place when reporters like so many others returned from the battlefields of WWII and were left alone in coping with their trauma.

Woods’ provides a measured conclusion, pointing out that war reporters regularly helped ‘wounded civilians or engendered refugees’ (p.146). They ‘embellished’ stories, but also wrote the proverbial ‘first draft of history’ (p.146) through their dispatches from the front lines.

Censorship set firm limits on what they could report and the pressures of the media market meant that positive, exciting and timely tales of military actions were the stories that editors, the military, politicians and the general public wanted from them, and the temptation was always there to take shortcuts to provide them (p.146).
I think it is important that Reporting the Retreat ends on a note that neither romanticizes nor dismisses the journalists’ engagement and hints at important structural challenges of how media and news have always worked. It is quite remarkable that war reporting and journalism from foreign places still evokes similar debates than it has done throughout the last eight decades.

Woods presents a really interesting case study by analyzing a broad range of material that deserve more attention from development or media scholars as well: Notebooks, diaries and memoirs together with media outputs help us to better understand the limitations and circumstances of how media discourses and public perceptions are shaped.

At the end of the day the book is also an important reminder that things are not necessarily getting ‘better’ or ‘worse’ just because of ‘the Internet’-understanding the truths behind war and peace has always been difficult and the genre of war reporting deserves particularly nuanced and critical interpretation. 


Woods, Philip: Reporting the Retreat-War Correspondents in Burma. ISBN 978-1-84904-717-3, 206pp, 20.00 GBP, London: Hurst, 2017.

Links & Contents I Liked 245

$
0
0
Hi all,

I'm wrapping up a fantastic week of teaching at a summer academy in Northern Germany! Lots of great discussions about the past, present & future of development and aid work!
I even managed to get a new book review on the blog, but since I spent a bit less time online there are also fewer links in this week's review. Nonetheless, they are still worth exploring and provide ample food for thought as always!

Development news:
The ultimate guide to the cash-based aid debate; South Sudan's bleak humanitarian situation; a neat overview over the economic cost of accepting refugees; how feminist is Canada's new foreign policy really? Why do UN peacekeepers rape? the value of spiritual lives of aid workers; MUST-READS: A charter school travels to Thailand; the preservation of privilege in social activism.

Our digital lives:
UN Social 500; an archive on the history of the chemical-industrial complex. 

Publications: New insights into participatory video; challenging the 'any work is better than no work' orthodoxy.

Enjoy!

New from aidnography

Reporting the Retreat (book review)

Philip Woods’ book about ‘the six-month, one thousand-mile retreat of the British and Chinese armies from Burma in the first half of 1942’ is a very well researched historical case study of journalism, news media and the work of foreign correspondents. The book looks at a group of twenty-six correspondents who reported from Burma for newspapers and weekly newsreel broadcasts and, equally important, about half of the group wrote memoirs shortly after their assignment in South Asia.
The discrepancies between their daily work, always impeded by military censorship, and their frank book-length accounts are a vivid reminder that there never were ‘good old days’ when it comes to war reporting and that many of today’s challenges have remained through time, new (digital) media and many different war theaters.
Development news

If celebrities like Jenna Fischer get educated by the recent NPR Goats & Soda series on cash-based aid by Nurith Aizenman this must be good ;)!

South Sudan: Time for humanitarians to get tough

The humanitarian situation in South Sudan is the worst I’ve known in two decades, and unless assistance can be predictably and safely delivered, the return of famine cannot be discounted.
However, the insecurity of the operating environment, coupled with the direct targeting of humanitarian action, and predatory bureaucratic processes, compromises the pace, scale and effectiveness of the overall response.
This is of course entirely unacceptable. Humanitarian partners deserve the protection and support of those they are seeking to assist, and government and opposition forces have responsibilities under International Humanitarian Law to both protect civilians, and facilitate the delivery of lifesaving assistance.
Simon Little for IRIN with a stark reminder about the situation and South Sudan-and some of the looming challenges for humanitarians around the globe.

The Real Economic Cost of Accepting Refugees

The economic effects of the new wave of asylum seekers and other migrants will be complex. The International Monetary Fund projects that this wave will raise economic growth over the long term by providing Europe with young and energetic workers. The labor market effects and fiscal effects are likely to be negative and small in the near future for some countries but more positive in countries with more flexible labor market regulations.
But the greatest determinant of these effects will be the extent to which continuing flows are shunted to just a few destinations or broadly shared. This depends less on migrants’ decisions than on the policy decisions of the recipient countries and their allies.
Michael Clemens for Refugees Deeply with good overview over key debates around refugees and labor market integration-it will be complicated and a lot depends on good policy-making...

Canada’s international aid policy is now ‘feminist’. It still won’t help women

That recipe of top-down, foreign-funded feminism did not work, because while the funds position women as benefactors, they have been unable to produce the grassroots-level changes that are required for crimes to stop and girls’ schools to flourish. Instead, local women, those cherished allies of foreign funders, have been deemed traitors by local populations who see them as having colluded with invaders. Shuttering shelters and closing schools in turn has become political theatre, a reclamation of pre-intervention authenticity.
Feminist foreign aid, however, does not only fail because of conflict-related resentment and an inability to engender grassroots moral change. It also fails because development aid in general continues to be administered and disbursed along colonial-era models. Decision-making around programmes is largely, if not exclusively, in the hands of donor governments and grant-makers rather than recipients; expat staff sometimes make 900% more than locals with identical jobs.
Rafia Zakaria for the Guardian does not mince words in her critique of Canada's 'feminist' foreign policy and the broader inequalities that underline the aid industry.

Why do some UN peacekeepers rape?

"When it comes to the UN, justice is extremely rare," she adds.
"The UN's gut reaction is always to cover up, to handle in-house, to make the problem go away," Lindstrom says.
"Yes, of course, rape happens everywhere, but there is no system where you have this type of legal protection for such crimes. These are people being sent to protect others, after all."
But Stephane Dujarric, a spokesperson for the UN secretary-general, disagrees, saying: "I don't think anyone is trying to bury these cases and trying to make them go away."
The spokesperson for the UN's peacekeeping operations, Olivier Salgado, describes the fight against sexual exploitation and abuse as "a top priority of the secretary-general and the entire leadership of the organisation".
Azad Essa for Al-Jazeera with a multi-part series on UN peacekeeping and sexual violence around those missions.

Understanding the Spiritual Lives of Aid Workers

As I have said before, there can be no ‘one size fits all’ approach to staff care. But at least acknowledging and working with these alternative forms of healing and self-care could serve two related purposes: of understanding better the spiritual lives of aid workers – as multi-faceted human beings rather than mere aid delivery robots – and of providing them with support that is grounded in their own cultures and belief systems.
Gemma Houldey continues the debates on aid worker well-being and providing holistic support in the context of aid work.

‘Black People Don’t Fly’: School Convinces Families to Try a Personalized Study-Abroad Charter
She spent the entire summer recruiting, but convincing parents to let their kids be a part of her school’s unique and unfamiliar model—which includes flying the students to Thailand and Laos for several months for a study-abroad program—is more difficult than it seems.
“I had one girl who was like, ‘black people don’t fly,’ so yeah, it's has been the struggle,” Hui says, “but I am getting through to families.”
(...)
“My objective is to build qualities of a leader, so when the student goes back to their home-based school, they will be successful,” says Hui. "One of the qualities we are teaching them is to be self-directed learners."
Students who went through Thrival World Academies’ pilot program in Oakland, California last year say that both traveling abroad and being encouraged to direct their own learning online made them more independent, a change their parents also noticed.
Jenny Abamu for EdSurge; there is A LOT going on in this article-charter schools, Chromebooks, disadvantaged students studying abroad, Thailand,...I guess this deserves a blog post on its own and it will remain a very complicated story about education and change.

Neither Radical nor Revolutionary: The Preservation of Privilege in Social Justice Activism

Why do folks on the margins need money and multiple college degrees in order to be taken seriously as an authority on their own lived experience within their own community? Because it makes the privileged folks who make the rules feel more comfortable with the idea of us having a voice? Probably. We’ve jumped through their hoops and they give us a treat and a pat on the head. These nonprofit organizations need to be made accountable not just for making more opportunities available to folks on the margins, but also for re-thinking how we choose to value voice and authority both on and within marginalized communities. It is the difference between talking ABOUT social justice and BEING about social justice. There needs to be effort made by these organizations to acquire more funds. Additionally, these organizations need to actually seek out hidden voices- voices who have not had the chance to be heard, let alone made popular. I know so many brilliant fellow trafficking survivors and sex workers who have immensely valuable things to say but because they are homeless, transient, destitute and barely surviving — they don’t get these opportunities.
Laura LeMoon on the privileges of the aid industry - in the US and in some ways everywhere where 'we' decide to 'help'.

Our digital lives
Leaderboard

The UN Social 500 is a success tracking program that recognises current UN staff and contractors who are promoting the work of the United Nations via their personal social media accounts, so helping to connect the work of the UN with the general public.
The UN Social 500 list of UN social media champions.

Monsanto sold banned chemicals for years despite known health risks, archives reveal

“Monsanto continued to produce and sell toxic industrial chemicals known as PCBs for eight years after learning that they posed hazards to public health and the environment, according to legal analysis of documents put online in a vast searchable archive.”
The Poison Papers archive has been analyzed by Bill Sherman, the assistant attorney general for the US state of Washington. Washington state and various west coast cities are suing Monsanto for PCB contamination. Sherman is quoted as saying that Poison Paper documents provide “damning evidence” that was previously unknown to the state.
Allison Wilson for the Poison Papers; this looks like a super-fascinating project and excellent example of how to digitalize and share important historical data!

Publications
Pathways to accountability from the margins: reflections on participatory video practice

Two of the central challenges in building accountability for marginalised people are how to reach and meaningfully involve the most excluded, and how to establish the kinds of relationships that mean they can achieve, influence and expect government responsiveness. This report explores how participatory video – an existing methodology for engaging marginalised people – can be adapted and strengthened to inclusively engage citizens and foster responses from decision-makers. It presents four propositions for achieving this.
Proposition 1:
Ensure inclusive engagement during group-forming and building.
Proposition 2:
Develop shared purpose and group agency through video exploration and sense-making.
Proposition 3:
Enable horizontal scaling through community-level videoing action.
Proposition 4:
Support the performance of vertical influence through video-mediated communication.
Jackie Shaw with a new report for IDS.

Re-employment, job quality, health and allostatic load biomarkers: prospective evidence from the UK Household Longitudinal Study

Formerly unemployed adults who transitioned into poor quality work had greater adverse levels of biomarkers compared with their peers who remained unemployed. The selection of healthier unemployed adults into these poor quality or stressful jobs was unlikely to explain their elevated levels of chronic stress-related biomarkers. Job quality cannot be disregarded from the employment success of the unemployed, and may have important implications for their health and well-being.
Tarani Chandola and Nan Zhang with an open access article for the International Journal of Epidemiology; interesting research with even more interesting implications for development when it comes to 'any job is a good job'...

Links & Contents I Liked 246

$
0
0
Hi all,

August still seems to be a bit quieter as we are slowly getting into gear for a new semester and new academic adventures! Nonetheless, there's always great food for thought and excellent weekend readings!

Development news:
UNICEF & the YouTube ambassador; China joins the pop-cultural discourse of White Saviors; Are ‘beg-packers’ a thing in Vietnam? Tanzania’s ghost safari-an old tale of modernization & development in today’s Africa; Africans are not waiting for their diaspora; new ways of being a digital Nigerian; chatbots & humanitarian assistance; ICC uses social media as evidence; Indonesia’s restrictions of the Internet also determine SDG success; how to involve communities in SDG monitoring; the history of foreign aid & American public opinion. 


Our digital lives:
Facebook & platform capitalism.

Publications:
Climate change meets humanitarian aid discourses; online protests harm companies; Nkrumah’s legacy of national self-determination.

Academia:
A virtual panel to discuss meetings, bureaucracy & more; how harmful is predatory publishing really?

Enjoy!


Development news


A very interesting take on the elections in Kenya-and probably on 'democracy' and its rituals more generally...

UNICEF Picks YouTube Star As Ambassador

Little Lilly would also be proud of Superwoman Lilly because, as the first ambassador from the digital realm, UNICEF is giving her free reign to create the kind of videos she knows viewers would want to watch. "They've really been collaborative," Singh says. "They said, 'Hey, we have never had an ambassador that does what you do. You tell us what you think is going to work.'"
Singh's biggest challenge will be figuring out how to weave UNICEF's education message into her own brand of comedic, visual storytelling — and getting her fans to engage. "Any time you reach out to an audience that wasn't cultivated for the purpose of advocacy, you're going to run into followers who are less interested than others," says Simmons. "If I had to place a bet on whether she will figure it out or not, I would bet on her."
Jackson Sinnenberg for NPR Goats & Soda. How different will Lilly's engagement really look like as a new generation of ambassadors focuses on digital storytelling tools?

China’s Wolf Warriors 2 in ‘war-ravaged Africa’ gives the White Savior complex a whole new meaning

Leng, a Rambo-style lone wolf fighter who miraculously dodges bullets and uses a mattress to stop a grenade, is charged with getting the adopted African child of a slain Chinese doctor to safety. He’s the first to survive a disease called “lamania” that has killed many locals, thanks to the doctor who discovered the cure before his death.
Lily Kuo for Quartz with a reminder that China's engagement in Africa is now also reaching pop culture.

No exception for foreign ‘beg-packers’ on Vietnam streets: tourism director

Street begging is not allowed in Vietnam, and the rule applies to locals as well as foreigners, Tran Chi Dung, the Kien Giang tourism chief, told Tuoi Tre (Youth) newspaper on Tuesday.
“No exception was to be made for foreign street beggars in Vietnam no matter how polite they appeared to be,” he said.
Dung was referring to a recent photo posted on Facebook of a foreign woman meditating on a pavement on Kien Giang’s Phu Quoc Island, with a note written in Vietnamese placed in front of her that reads “meditate for luck, need money.”
According to Dung, foreigners have long come to Vietnam seeking short-term jobs and even resorting to begging on the street to fund their trip.
Tuoi Tre News with another story of 'beg-packing'-it's difficult to get an idea of how big this phenomenon really is (or whether it really is a phenomenon at all...) beyond the catchy term...

Tanzania's ghost safari: how western aid contributed to the decline of a wildlife haven

“I work more and more with the World Bank or the African Development Bank,” says scientist Holly Dublin, “and I see what their plans and what they are giving loans for to these governments. It is like there’s a total disconnect. So what you are going to see is that of course, elephants come last. In fact, anything to do with wildlife comes last.”
(...)
The companies in the valley all worry about this too and have all employed their own techniques to try to stem the losses. The rice plantation has run education courses on modern agricultural techniques in order to help local people grow more rice in a smaller area; the teak plantation, in some places, has alternated teak and miombo to try to give the wildlife some space. The sugar plantation is trying to build up a forest area in one part of in the north of the valley where elephants are still sometimes seen, so that the elephants will continue to pass that way without stumbling into the plantations (a beehive fence to keep them in the forest has been strung along one point). But they agree that the problem is just getting worse.
Bibi van der Zee and Sophie Tremblay for The Guardian. This is a sad, almost timeless story about 'development', aid and modernization...

Dear African Abroad: Home is NOT Waiting For You

Remember that home is not your little project. Home is not waiting. Home is not frozen in your absence. Should you decide to do so, the home you left behind is not the one you will return to. Do not expect to be at home in all the same spaces. Feel your way in. Fall into place where you’re meant to. Home has changed, and so have you. Return as much as you need to, for as long as you must. Settle as necessary. Never count yourself greater for having left. Remember that the greatest experts are, to use this tired phrase, “on the ground”.
So, whenever it is that you come home, do so with your head bowed, with your ears sharp and attuned to listening. Take your shoes off at the door, be confident to speak and share the perspectives you’ve learned, but be quick to listen and learn how exactly it is that home needs you.
Priscilla Takondwa for Tiwale with a reminder that as countries in Africa are rapidly changing, so are notions of 'diaspora' or 'brain drain' and the impact of those who return 'home'.

New ways of being Nigerian

Rather than function as instruments of ethnic violence for politicians and ethnic chauvinists, young Nigerians as primary producers and consumers of popular culture can be at the forefront of this national re-orientation. As 21st century citizens of a global world, youth in Nigeria can channel their energy, education and digital literacies to bring about this change. This pan-Nigerian sensibility was on display during the brief Occupy Nigeria protests concerning the removal of subsidy and increase in the price of petroleum products by the Goodluck Jonathan administration in January 2012. Young Nigerians were at the forefront of this struggle and utilized social media platforms to coordinate the various protests.
Cajetan Iheka for Africa is a country shares reflections at the intersection of popular culture and digital transformation in the context of contemporary Nigeria.

Our experiment using Facebook chatbots to improve humanitarian assistance

Finally, we realize that we must prepare to manage all of the unstructured information that Food Bot will collect. Colleagues in the field are already weary of collecting yet more data that won’t be analysed or used. As a result, the team is working on setting up the infrastructure that is needed to process the large volumes of free text data that we expect the bot to produce. This is where our work with automated data processing and dashboards should pay dividends.
WFP's Mobile technology for food security monitoring on chatbots, mobile data collection and questions on how innovative ICT4D ideas can be incorporated into the larger scope of the organization.

And So It Begins… Social Media Evidence In An ICC Arrest Warrant

The arrest warrant against Mr. Al-Werfalli is the latest indication from the ICC that it is keeping up with developments relating to conflict, crime, and communication technology. The OTP noted in its Strategic Plan for 2016-18 that technology has led to a rapidly changing environment in which witnesses, victims, and perpetrators have access to smartphones and the internet. The Court has hired cyber investigators to conduct online investigations. Perhaps the arrest warrant from the 15th August is the outcome of these efforts. However, much work remains to be done to carve a way forward with regards to open source/social media evidence. Practitioners and academics are, in many ways, entering unknown territory. The approach taken to this type of evidence will prove crucial for any future proceedings in conflicts such as Syria and Yemen, where open source material abounds.
Emma Irving for Opinio Juris on how social media can have a real impact in the investigation of war crimes.

Without open and free internet, Indonesia will come short in achieving Sustainable Development Goals

On the one hand, the government show commitment to achieve Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) by 2030, on the other hand they want more control over internet. Can Indonesia’s government accomplish these ambitious goals and targets without giving more freedom for citizens online?
Eko Prasetyo for Panoply Digital with a reminder that the digital sphere (like any other space) will not unilaterally be a 'space for good', but remains a contested one between government interests of control and the possibilities of a free Internet to work towards the SDGs.

Monitoring the Sustainable Development Goals from the community-level

It was clear to us, through our attendance of side events and formal sessions of the HLPF, that governments are not working enough with their civil society partners to research, monitor and deliver on the SDGs. There needs to be space for civil society both to put the spotlight on the disaggregation of government data, and to illuminate the realities and knowledge of those people who, in the official data, remain invisible.
There is also a role for the United Nations, which needs to push its Member States harder to ensure that there is active civil society engagement in this voluntary reporting process.
Jo Howard and Tom Thomas for the British Academy with another reminder that making SDG processes meaningful requires work and political will to collect and interpret seemingly apolitical 'data'.

Foreign aid and American public opinion: A history

It is striking that the percentage of Americans thinking the U.S. spend too much on foreign aid hit what was then a post-Vietnam low in 1985, largely in response to President Ronald Reagan’s decision to offer food aid to Ethiopia as its Marxist government struggled with a calamitous and self-inflicted famine. As Reagan declared, “A hungry child knows no politics,” the public responded to a clear and specific use for assistance: feeding starving children. This uptick in popularity for assistance under Reagan is also notable in that it was counterintuitive: Reagan, as a small government conservative, expanded the aid budget and the overall program became more popular.
The next great shift in public opinion toward the assistance program came in the early and mid-1990s, after the fall of the Berlin Wall. The foreign aid program was suddenly bereft of its primary justification as a bulwark against communist expansion, and USAID had been scandal-plagued and badly mismanaged at the end of the President George H.W. Bush administration.
John Norris for DevEx with an interesting piece that looks beyond the usual 'Americans think their government spends 5/10/20% of the budget on foreign aid' narrative and traces some major developments throughout post-WWII history.

Our digital lives
You Are the Product

To sum up: there is a lot of research showing that Facebook makes people feel like shit. So maybe, one day, people will stop using it.
What if advertisers don’t rebel, governments don’t act, users don’t quit, and the good ship Zuckerberg and all who sail in her continues blithely on?
John Lancaster for the London Review of Books with a long-read on our digital lives and virtual connectivity in the age of platform capitalism.

Has Facebook finally given up chasing teenagers? It’s complicated

The young people I talk to for my research suggest that Facebook’s broad appeal and easy design presents a unique experience for them. Facebook is a field of potential social landmines, with the fear that the diverse user base will see everything they post – causing anxiety, hedging and inaction.
Having to negotiate this broad audience means young people seem to be less likely to use of some of the public aspects of Facebook, choosing instead to rely on aspects such as groups and private messaging. This explains why they seem to be increasingly relying more on platforms such as Instagram and Snapchat to interact with their peers, a trend also noted by other researchers.
In this light, the attempt to encourage teenagers to use the same features as they do on Snapchat when Facebook’s brand is so associated with a more public and socially difficult environment seems inherently flawed. We can’t say where the company will go in the future but it seems likely it will struggle to ever be as central to young people’s online social experiences as it once was.
Harry T. Dwyer for The Conversation presents his latest research, adding more nuances to the complicated question about the future of online platforms and 'the next big thing' for social networks.

Publications
IDS Bulletin calls for humanitarian aid and climate change sectors to work together

The editors, Siri Eriksen, Ruth Haug, Lars Otto Naess, Aditi Bhonagiri and Lutgart Lenaerts, question whether or not humanitarian aid should remain focused on ‘saving lives in the time of crises – or also engage in longer-term concerns, including climate change’.
They argue that ‘humanitarian crises appear dramatic, overwhelming and sudden. Aid is required immediately to save lives. On the face of it, linkages to longer-term climate change and adaptation appear far-fetched. However, the causes for humanitarian crises – such as the current food shortages in Ethiopia and on the Horn of Africa – are rarely sudden’.
Political and financial frameworks are needed to facilitate longer-term actions; alongside taking into account the experience and knowledge of local communities, and those directly impacted by climate change.
A new edition of the open access IDS Bulletin.

The Effect of Online Protests and Firm Responses on Shareholder and Consumer Evaluation

Contrary to recent studies suggesting that participation in online protests is only token support without any substantive effects, our results show that online protests do hurt. Firms can expect to suffer financial, reputational, and sales damage when an online protest campaign mobilizes consumers successfully. We also show that online protests are more likely to take firms by surprise than offline protests.
Tijs van den Broek, David Langley and Tobias Hornig with a new open access article for the Journal of Business Ethics.

An unintended legacy: Kwame Nkrumah and the domestication of national self-determination in Africa

The article identifies three key ways in which Nkrumah shaped the law of self-determination in Africa: first, by actively campaigning against ‘tribalism’ in Ghana; second, by enlisting the UN to prevent the secession of Katanga in 1960, thereby creating a crucial precedent; and, third, by playing a leading role in establishing the OAU in 1963, which went on to endorse the legal validity of colonial frontiers. In this way, Nkrumah helped settle arguments around the authentic self-determination unit in Africa, forging an unintended legacy that continues to shape the legal and political contours of the continent to the present.
Andrew Small with an open access article for the African Human Rights Law Journal

Academia
First (Virtual) Meeting on Meeting (MoM) #bureaucracy
¨I’ve been troubled by this idea of performance in meetings. On the one hand it seems straightforward, meetings are sites where professional (and other) identities are performed. And yet I know that the health managers I worked with would scoff at the idea that they were performing ‘status’ or ‘hierarchy’ – they would say that they were just doing their jobs. Some of the reviewers of our JRAI contribution also helpfully pushed us to question the way that we were using notions of performance in our analysis. I think for these reasons (and here I am echoing Tom’s point somewhat), also because of the influence of Annemarie Mol and other science studies scholars on my work, I am more drawn to terms like ‘enactment’ and ‘production’ in trying to make sense of what is made through meetings. I think this kind of move is important – I am not sure that Maia and I could have made the argument that we did in our JRAI article, that contemporary international development is a system of meetings, without this kind of subtle shift away from the performative.
Julie Billaud, Hannah Brown and Adam Reed for Allegra Lab. An interesting conversation about the role of meetings, including in the context of development.
In my own research
, I actually make links to performances and performance studies and do believe that they are important-even if people say that they are 'only doing their jobs'.

Who is Actually Harmed by Predatory Publishers?

We find that established publishers have a strong motivation to hype claims of predation as damaging to the scholarly and scientific endeavour while noting that, in fact, systems of peer review are themselves already acknowledged as deeply flawed.
Martin Paul Eve and Ernesto Priego with an open access article in triple-C that takes a critical look at 'predatory publishing' under the conditions of the neoliberal academy.

In case you missed this...

Links & Contents I Liked 247

$
0
0
Hi all,

Development news: Louise 'In Congo's Shadow' Linton is back! Bill Easterly admits that he was wrong! A special section on a 'Reading The Congo'; quitting Peace Corps; how to get into the conservation industry? Reality TV & humanitarians; global health & men - and so much more!

Our digital lives: Uruguayan Barbie; do advocacy documentaries work? The UK Home Office 'disrupted' NGO data; how men are shaping our contemporary cities.

Publications: Agribusiness in Latin America.

Enjoy!

Development news
In the line of fire


Finally, we must provide better duty-of-care to all staff on the frontlines, particularly national staff. International aid agencies are increasingly providing aid remotely in highly insecure environments. This means they are delivering relief through local partners and transferring the risk to them. Local and national partner organizations face an inadequate level of security and support from their international partners. We must provide better security training to equip them in the field, as recommended by the recent Presence and Proximity report on aid workers. Donors and international partners should ensure that national partners’ security needs are factored into proposals and budgets, so they have the resources needed to protect their staff.
(...)
Wars have rules. It is time to enforce these rules, rather than have brave aid workers needlessly risk their lives, and too many of the most vulnerable to be left alone in the crossfire and lose theirs.
Jan Egeland & Stephen O’Brien for Thomson Reuters Foundation with an important overview of key issues of last week's World Humanitarian Day.

Chinese vendors 'exploiting' African children removed from Taobao
The BBC got in touch with one buyer, who wanted to be known only as Mr Zhang, who said he paid 200 yuan ($30) for a video featuring African children for his bike business. He justified it by saying the ad was a good marketing trick and had attracted more customers.
When asked about whether the money reached the children in the end he said: "Why should I care that much? I only care about the marketing effect."
Customers on Taobao appeared to be delighted with the services while they were on offer and there appeared to be to be little consideration by vendors and customers of the risk of cultural insensitivity or even an awareness of China's chequered history with regards to race and advertising.
Yashan Zhao for BBC Chinese. As China engages more globally, including on the African continent, it seems that we will be seeing more replications of 'Western' mistakes when it comes to representation and communication!

The worst lady: how dodgy memoirs and Insta-spats made Louise Linton an infamous political spouse

Thank you, Treasury Barbie! Alas, it seems that other Instagram users couldn’t quite enjoy the post as the reach-out to the left behind that it was clearly meant to be. “Glad we could pay for your little getaway,” remarked another user, Oregonian mother of three Jenni Miller. “#deplorable.”
Did Louise realise that it would be smart to rise above this off-brand comment from one of her husband’s average Americans? I’m afraid she didn’t. Instead, she shot right back, and at some considerable length:
Marina Hyde for the Guardian. You probably noticed this week that Louise Linton is back and is adding more misguided communication to her #LintonLies notoriety after publishing 'In Congo's Shadow'. I purchased a print-on-demand paper copy of the book and will treasure it for research and teaching purposes!

'Reading Conrad in the Congo'


On NYT’s Misguided Nostalgia for Conrad
The point here is not necessarily to call out Prof. Jasanoff, but to highlight what seems to be an insatiable demand at the Times for orientalist pieces on Africa and Africans.
Ken Opalo also comments on Maya Jasanoff's NYT piece.

Jeffrey Gettleman’s tired tome

But it is likely that a more self-aware, self-critical version of Gettleman would not have come to occupy such a plum position within the hallowed halls of journalism. Gettleman is a great story teller. His prose is light and engaging. Handsome and photogenic, he is able to tell seductively simple stories about a continent that seems so overwhelming to most Americans. There will always be an audience for this type of work.
Keren Weitzberg for Africa is a country comments on another heavily criticized recent (mis-)representation of 'Africa' that makes me even more interested in finally reading Gettleman myself...

Bikinis not bombs: why isn’t the humanitarian sector getting intimate with Love Island?

Humanitarian workers have a prescribed identity and Thurlow does not conform. She’s most commonly seen in a bikini, on a show that is perceived as ‘lowbrow’ and she’s publically talking about her work on a platform that is not a conference – the Spanish villa had no trees to hang pledges and no communiqués were handed out. Tradition and a dour, do-gooder identity is holding back the sector.
Mel Paramasivan shares some interesting reflections on how a reality format like Love Island can be a tool for communicating development issues. I agree that humanitarian issues need popular support and that traditional campaigns or celebrity engagement have limitations in our mediatized environment. But at the end of the day the sector needs well prepared, reflective practitioners who can deal with complex situations and that's when reality formats often reach their limits.

A rich person’s profession? Young conservationists struggle to make it

“Foreign researchers and students arrive, conduct a project, publish a paper after returning home, and never go back again; is this conservation?” said Seth Wong, 26, who’s working on a graduate degree at Mississippi State University.
To help globalize conservation, Milner-Gulland called for more grants for students from developing countries to study conservation as well as for disadvantaged students at home. She proposed a program that would sponsor graduates to go to other continents for conservation training in a one-to-two year paid position, which she compared to the “type of fast-track graduate-level training that the big firms and civil service offer to their best and brightest.“
For Lucas Ruzo conservation is stuck in a non-profit model that is limiting.
“We need to move beyond the charity model, and embrace different legal operating structures,” he said. “Let’s fund innovation, innovation of the kind that doesn’t have a publication attached to the end of it.”
Jeremy Hance for Mongabay with a long-read that is relevant for large parts of the aid industry and how traditional forms of entering the sector seem more and more exploitative and outdated.

My Letter to PC

if I feel strongly about the changes that need to be made in PC, I should stay and work towards it internally. On the other hand, I feel I am taking up space when other voices have already been decentralized. PC and most PCVs have been co-opting HCN spaces since 1961, centering their reputed mission to help while crowding out the voices and efforts of HCNs, inadvertently prolonging neocolonialism. After a great deal of deep reflection and counsel from those who have dedicated their work to social justice, including RPCVs and others who have had experience in international aid, I feel it is more meaningful for me to do this work alongside my social justice-driven community back in the US. I have recently reconciled that my criticisms of PC are fair – that I do not agree with this work and I do not feel that choosing to stay and improve it will be productive. Furthermore, my criticisms of PC and this work to undo oppression (such as neocolonialism) is not just about PC, it is about a broader social justice mission and it is also personal (i.e. my experience as a female Asian American). Decidedly, it is wiser for me to leave PC and return to Baltimore.
Hyoyoung Minna Kim with a long open letter to the Peace Corps on why she is quitting her assignment and returning to the US to engage in 'aid work'.

How Do You Know When Your Resilience is Low?

Our resilience may erode slowly overtime if we are not bouncing back from normal stress and pressure. Or, it can drop quickly after experiencing a significant emotional event or a particularly stressful period. Knowing your current state of resilience can help you determine whether to carve out extra time for resilience enhancing activities.
Beth Payne for GovLoop with a handy overview on how to spot low resilience and some of the symptoms of psycho-social problems.

Global health: generation men

Generation Men in global health extends beyond multilateral and funding institutions. While the editor-in-chief of the British Medical Journal is a woman, both The Lancet and Science have men in this post. Of the top pharmaceutical companies, only one has a female chief executive officer.1 Furthermore, at least in the USA, most global health academic leadership positions are also dominated by men.2 These leaders are unquestionably fine men––but also unquestionably men.
There is much speculation about why this is the case. One explanation is that this is an area of work that favours those who do not serve as primary caregivers because working in global health requires spending extensive time in the field and travelling.
When I directed health programmes for the Open Society Foundation and was the acting Chief of Health at UNICEF, I travelled 75% of the time. For anyone serving as a primary caregiver, this much travel is simply impossible
Nina Schwalbe for The Lancet with a short reminder about the long way to go in global health leadership to achieve better inclusiveness and broader representation of women.

How can we build better partnerships for global health?

This is not to mention that “the computers have plastic over them half the time. Electricity, computers, literacy, there are all these issues. And the TelCo infrastructure! We have layers of capacity gaps to address,” said one person.
Linda Raftree for Wait...What? shares a summary from the latest NYC Tech Salon that read a bit like is 'who is who' of challenges in international development more broadly...

From Fiction to Fact

“NGOs and nonprofits for years have been able to have a transactional relationship with the public. What that means is that they’ve always had such high levels of trust with the public, with the government, etc that they’ve been able to tell a one-dimensional story,” Walkom says. “The way I look at it is, we’ve told you the story of need for so long that we haven’t actually stopped and started telling you the story of how we’re responding to that need.” She adds that the crisis in trust in business, governments and NGOs, that research like the Edelman Trust Barometer, has been indicating for years, means that one-dimensional storytelling isn’t working anymore.
Brittany Golob for Communicate with a portrait Save the Children’s Global Communications Director Kirsten Walkom.

Our digital lives
 
An interesting project, but I feel a bit ambivalent about the conventional use of Barbie as a representation of 'beautiful women' and her empowering activities.

The truth about inconvenient truths: ‘big issue’ documentaries don’t always change our behaviour

Advocacy documentaries should also be coupled with other behaviour change techniques to increase their chances of success. For instance, they should ask viewers to publicly pledge to change their behaviour or to set goals, give them tools to help form a new habit, or tell them exactly how to petition organisations and governments to make structural changes.
(...)
Documentaries can be a useful instrument in the behaviour change toolkit. But lasting change needs more than an engaging story on its own.
Kim Borg and Bradley Jorgensen for The Conversation. To be honest, I'm even more skeptical about behavior change than the authors-especially in the context of low-hanging fruits like pledges and petitions which require little personal effort and even smaller personal change.

Home Office used charity data map to deport rough sleepers

A chain of emails sent by senior Home Office immigration officials show how they used information that was designed to protect rough sleepers to target vulnerable individuals for deportation. The internal correspondence shows the Home Office repeatedly requesting and finally gaining access to a map created by the Greater London Authority (GLA) that identified and categorised rough sleepers by nationality.
The secret arrangement meant frontline outreach workers tasked with helping the homeless by collating data for the GLA were inadvertently helping the Home Office to remove people who were from the EU or central eastern Europe. In May 2016, the Home Office introduced guidance enabling immigration enforcement teams to deport EU nationals, purely on the grounds that they were sleeping rough.
Mark Townsend for the Guardian. Data is political. Data can and will be ab-/re-used if available. Governments often do not share your vision of transparency and openness-we will be reading more stories like this in the future not least in the context of 'ICT4D'.

Butlers to the cosmopolites? We’ll pay the price

Are we not – like those well-meaning natives in San Sebastian, Venice, Barcelona and Berlin – also suffering some of the brunt of cosmopolitanism? (...), renting an apartment if you do not have a job in i-gaming is now near impossible, and waste volumes have increased exponentially with evening-time collection hours rendering the streets a right dump.
It is a brusque gentrification that is hollowing out the community’s old haunts, now replaced with the vanilla blandness whose main consumer is the short- and long-stay tourist. Those with money dream of smoothening out the rough edges of the old towns to build waterfront properties. Those without the cash just see their streetscapes change, powerless.
Matthew Vella for Malta Today adds to the debate on how contemporary 'globalization', tourism and migration are adding new aspects of gentrification to globalized spaces, cities and islands...

Mansplaining the city

Not only are these four books by men, they’re largely about men. According to the books themselves, the factors that have contributed to gentrification—displacement of marginalized communities, systemically ingrained racism, unequitable housing policy—have been largely implemented by powerful men over the last century.
(...)
Even if we fantasize about cities that foster racial equity, or a matriarchal society-within-a-city, instead of our status quo of cities designed for and by men, the reality is that the shift towards just and equitable cities will only happen when a more diverse group of Americans are in positions to make policy decisions that shape our neighborhoods.
Alissa Walker for Curbed with a long-read/book review essay on gender, power and the contemporary (American) city.

Richard Florida Is Sorry

The notion that creativity could solve these urban problems — either from above, with monumental art galleries, or from below, with bearded clusters of hipsters, is a symptom of this profound transformation.
Richard Florida was right when he said that the “creative economy” is the new way of the world. But its development didn’t happen how he imagined. Rather than launching humanity into a new phase of prosperity, the new economy simply holds the different elements of late capitalism together — making it palatable for some but deepening its crises and contradictions for others.
Sam Wetherell for Jacobin on one of the key male thinkers behind aforementioned debates on how 'our' cities should look like.

Publications & Academia
Introduction to the Special Issue: Agribusiness, (Neo)Extractivism and Food Sovereignty: Latin America at a Crossroads?

Despite these trends, the study of the ‘everyday’ of agricultural policy-making, production, commercialisation and consumption have recently garnered attention in Latin America, as a result of the rapid industrial agricultural expansion, and the consequent resistance by local communities that have attempted to reclaim their agricultural sovereignty. More than ever, the fields of Latin America have become conceptual and direct battlefields, where ideological, economic, political and cultural positions clash. The expansion of the agroindustrial frontier, fuelled by technological advances in genetically modified crops and the large-scale use of pesticides and fertilisers, is one aspect of the intensification of extractivist activities that have dominated the region’s recent political economic model, further increasing tensions surrounding environmental issues and land use (...).
Counterbalancing the advances of industrial agriculture, some rural communities and environmentalist groups have sought to promote and strengthen alternative agricultural models through practices as diverse as polycropping, seed saving, agroecology schools and judicial resistance.
Ana Estefanía Carballo, María Eugenia Giraudo, Diego Silva and Johannes Waldmueller with an overview over the forthcoming Alternautas writings on Agribusiness.

Reading #Harvey through a #globaldev lens

$
0
0
In 2013 I posted some readings that I found particularly helpful in the aftermath of Typhoon Haiyan that struck the Philippines.
Many articles are still relevant in the current situation with Harvey and the flooding in the South of the United States.
But there are also new, relevant articles that have started to link Harvey to broader questions of international development and humanitarian aid and that are interesting food for thought in 'our' industry.

So I just start an annotated special link review and will add readings as I come across them-and please feel free to highlight interesting readings in the comments or on Twitter!

Epic Floods — Not Just In Texas — Are A Challenge For Aid Groups

Anzalone: For better or for worse, when people look at the U.S. response system, we have a very mature federal disaster response system, starting with FEMA [the Federal Emergency Management Agency]. It's a machine. Immediately before landfall of Hurricane Harvey, the governor of Texas requested aid for long-term recovery projects.
You don't see that in Nepal, Bangladesh or India. In Nepal and Bangladesh, the government simply doesn't have the resources. There is no tax base to support that robust response and recovery system. Their process to rebuild is complicated by underlying development issues that are inherent in those countries.
Malaka Gharib for NPR Goats and Soda interviews Jono Anzalone, vice president of international services at the American Red Cross, and he stresses the differences between developing countries' and American responses to humanitarian disasters. Great starting point for a discussion on how different systems really are...

The Red Cross Won’t Save Houston

Some people get personally offended by talk like this. They are seeing pain, they are being generous, and they hope it might help—just like I did watching the pictures from Indonesia from my cubicle years ago. The people suffering in this storm deserve all of that and more. But what you learn when you really dive into these situations is that momentary intentions, no matter how kind, are not enough—not on this scale. Those past, ineffective, and opaque disaster responses, from Haiti to New Jersey to the Gulf Coast, have created a legacy of mistrust, not only of the Red Cross but of the entire humanitarian aid apparatus its iconic brand represents. We can’t afford to do that again.
Jonathan Katz for Slate is critical of traditional approaches to disaster response, especially involving the American Red Cross, and highlights important insights from previous disaster responses in developing countries.
His book on post-earthquake Haiti, The Big Truck that went by, is still an important book to understand the limitations of the humanitarian system.

Google’s surprising choice for Hurricane Harvey donations

“People want their money used in real time,” said the senior aid worker. “That’s what killed the Red Cross in Haiti. They were sitting on tens of millions of dollars years later.”
A disaster fundraising expert gave a mixed reaction. He said that Google was showing a “welcome sign of belated humility”, by not attempting to pick how to spend the money itself. Familiar with the work of CDP, the expert said they were “sensible folk”, and the use of an intermediary made sense. However, he also questioned the charity’s capacity and its experience to handle the expenditure and monitoring of “quite significant” sums of money. The expert noted that many disaster relief groups had tried and failed to form fundraising relationships with Google and there may be some “sour grapes” among them.
The senior aid worker agreed, adding that other NGOs will be wondering: “Are you serious? Center for Disaster Philanthropy got the button on Google?!”
Ben Parker for IRIN. As the tweets below indicate this is an evolving story about big data, bit tech and new/old forms of humanitarian engagement in the digital age of philanthrocapitalism...

Melania Trump Rocks Flawless Emergency Aid Look En Route to Texas
Melania Trump has bravely opted to survey the Harvey damage in aviator sunglasses, a flawless blowout, a silky olive green bomber jacket with what appears to be limited water repellant capabilities, and actual stilts. The president, meanwhile, has had his khakis pressed in preparation for a light drizzle on the golf course. I am trying to imagine something less appropriate and cannot, although something will surely happen tomorrow to give me new ideas.
Ellie Shechet for Jezebel's The Slot. Disaster response always involves a celebrity element, especially when said celebrities travel to 'the field'...

Update 31 August

Melania Trump, Off to Texas, Finds Herself on Thin Heels
But to dismiss all this as merely much ado about heels, or an example of the pettiness of our divided electorate, is to ignore the reality of the current conversation around the president — to pretend not to notice how sensitized everyone has become to his unpredictable reactions to major events, and to deny the power of the telling detail to invite applause, condemnation or misinterpretation.
It is precisely the superficial nature of clothing, the fact that garments are immediately accessible to all, that makes them the go-to stand-in for more nuanced, complicated emotions and issues.
Vanessa Friedman for New York Times Fashion & Style with a more sophisticated analysis of the President's trip to Texas.

When disaster relief brings anything but relief

The thinking is that these people have lost everything, so they must NEED everything. So people SEND everything. You know, any donation is crazy if it's not needed. People have donated prom gowns and wigs and tiger costumes and pumpkins, and frostbite cream to Rwanda, and used teabags, 'cause you can always get another cup of tea.
CBS News features NPR's Scott Simonwith yet another important #SWEDOW reminder: Do not send your unwanted stuff to people who suffered through a humanitarian crisis! This classic post by J. needs no further introduction:

Update 1 September
Melania Trump and the Chilling Artifice of Fashion
That’s what models — and in this case also presidents — do: They inhabit anonymously temporary, unreal worlds born of the realm of luxury logo goods. The devastation in Houston is a tragedy, but so too is this administration’s blank, model’s stare — its mirrored shades in the face of human sorrows. This is not just about fashion. It’s about the urgency of recognizing a certain genre of hypnotizing, dehumanizing spell, and snapping ourselves out of it.
Rhonda Garelick for The Cut...wow, the Trump visit to Texas unleashes some serious pop-cultural reflections on fashion, privilege and disaster tourism!

Hurricane versus Monsoon
Did the rest of the world's media do a little better at keeping an eye on Asia?
Yes.
So far, the GDELT data suggests that non-American media have kept up some coverage of the Asian flooding, despite throwing resources at the Harvey story.
The gap here is smaller – when Harvey was drenching Texas, it got three or four times as much coverage as the Asian disaster.
Ben Parker for IRIN with another interesting story and graphs on how global disaster media coverage is spread unequally.

Links & Contents I Liked 248

$
0
0
Hi all,

We welcomed close to 200 new students this week in our ComDev program and both the US and large parts of South Asia experience disastrous flooding situations. I started a special link review that links Harvey to broader development issues. But there is so much more going on this week & lots of food for thought:

Development news:
USAID’s largest health project is in trouble; elections in Angola; how to tackle sexual violence in emergencies; more UN(DP) reforms; digital change in rural India; NYT’s West Africa Bureau Chief uses a mobile phone; another Gettleman review; missing female leaders in the UN system; the fallen idol of Myanmar; how to overcome inequality with foreign aid; don’t tell poor people to work harder and live smarter; Harvey & corporate hubris.

Our digital lives:
The neoliberal panopticon of a Romanian call center; humitas; Google suppresses critical think tank voices; the whiteness and privilege of startup media; a book bought its way in the bestseller lists.

Publications:
Does tweeting journal articles make a difference? Civic tech in the global South; a history of participatory research; NGOs as journalists.

Academia:
Learning to learn in digital environments.

Enjoy!


New from aidnography

Reading #Harvey through a #globaldev lens

There are new, relevant articles that have started to link Harvey to broader questions of international development and humanitarian aid and that are interesting food for thought in 'our' industry.
Development news
Largest USAID health project in trouble

The supply chain project is implemented by a consortium led by Chemonics International, which has grown to become USAID’s largest implementing partner — in large part because of the Washington, D.C.-based contractor’s surprise takeover of U.S. global health supply chain programs two years ago. The USAID contractor leased a 50,000 square foot office space in Crystal City, Virginia, to help accommodate the new project.
When USAID issued a request for proposals to implement the GHSC-PSM project in January 2014, many assumed the coalition of organizations already implementing USAID’s supply chain projects would maintain their hold on them.
USAID’s announcement in April 2015 that Chemonics had submitted the winning bid — effectively unseating a partnership of organizations led by John Snow, Inc. — sparked a contentious flurry of award protests, delaying the project’s transition by several months. The Partnership for Supply Chain Management filed protests with both the Government Accountability Office and with the U.S. Federal Court of Appeals, both of which were denied.
Michael Igoe for DevEx with the totally surprising finding that USAID's effective and efficient private sector implementing partners do not deliver great results...cudos for DevEx to publish a story that may interfere with the business side of their operations.

Election unlikely to herald the change Angolans have been clamouring for

On 23 August Angolans went to the polls to elect a new parliament, and for the first time in the lives of a great majority of the population, a new president. José Eduardo dos Santos, who ruled the country for 38 years, did not run this time as his party’s top candidate.
(...)
Despite this, it’s likely that the elections will bring more of the same, and only slow and gradual improvements — if at all — of the lives of most Angolans. Lourenço is very much a product of the system. He has the backing of the party and the armed forces, which is an improvement over dos Santos’ previous intended successor, (former) vice-president, Manuel Vicente.
Jon Schubert for The Conversation on Angola's recent historical elections.

Dispelling five myths about sexual violence in emergencies

No one questions when humanitarians prepare food, tents or medical supplies in advance of a typhoon, expecting these supplies will save lives. The same logic must apply to programmes that prevent and address gender-based violence. It is unethical to wait for proof of wide-scale abuse; action must take place at the earliest moments of a crisis response.
UNFPA on how to better prepare and respond to sexual violence against women in humanitarian situations.

UNDP’S new Strategic Plan is a chance to rethink and refocus

One of the things we try to do in the new Strategic Plan is to talk directly about the importance and value of our network, not just for UNDP but for the whole UN Development System and for our partners. Part of this is our substantive expertise on various issues covered in the Sustainable Development Goals: our work on poverty, governance, resilience and climate, gender, etc. But the second part, just as importantly, is the tremendous value we provide as a result of our physical network and presence: our country offices, our infrastructure, our local knowledge and our presence on the ground.
Joseph D'Cruz on the perpetual quest of the UN system to change, reform, stay relevant and being subject to political support (or lack thereof)...

The quiet digital revolution in Chandrapur

The dashboard showed that among those in the 18-70 age group eligible for the Pradhan Mantri Suraksha Bima Yojana (a subsidized insurance scheme), only 90 out of a total of 631 people were covered. The village also drew a blank on health insurance—none of the 174 eligible people (classified as below the poverty line) were covered under the Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana.
Almost a year later, the results are strikingly visible.
A sub-divisional officer in Mul is using the dashboard to find villages where she should conduct Aadhaar camps. She hovers over the red dots in the map to zero in on areas with the lowest use.
The block development officer in Mul wants to track how his block is faring on the Open Defecation Free parameter. The snapshot shows what percentage of households don’t have toilets; he clicks again to find out which villages in particular are lagging behind.
The electricity department can now find out exactly which households are still not connected to the grid. And being the only such database on LPG use in the country, the ministry of petroleum now knows which households to target for providing cooking gas connections.
That’s not all. The district collector, Ashutosh Salil, will now be able to rely on the data dashboard to cross-check in real time what officials claim needs to be done, and also to appraise villagers’ development priorities during his field visits. “Earlier if I had to budget Rs100 for 10 sub-districts, I would distribute them equally,” he says. “That can’t be correct allocation if a block has been covered before and does not need more resources.”
Aarti Gupta for Live Mint with an interesting case study from India and the potential of 'big data'; as always, there is a a very thine line between data informing policy-making and state surveillance...

The Technology Our West Africa Bureau Chief Relies On
And, yes, people are huge users of social media like Facebook and to some extent Instagram. Nigerians in particular are very active on Twitter. Besides business people, many others do not have a laptop. In urban areas, a lot of people have smartphones, especially young people, and if they don’t have one, they desperately want one.
Dionne Searcey for the New York Times. It seems that the NYT is a bit unlucky with their recent coverage of 'Africa' (see Gettleman book review below); her story reads a bit like 'look Western/Northern/American people, your fellow humans in Africa also use digital tools and have digital lives' and those 2002-style photos of her on a *mobile phone* in a village and taxi? Please...

Beach Reads: Jeffrey Gettleman's 'Love, Africa'

I can imagine someone with little familiarity with Africa or Gettleman's reporting to be enthralled by "Love, Africa." Gettleman comes off as a fearless, risk-taking journalist who gets kidnapped and detained just often enough to have great stories while not losing his life. And it is obvious from the way he writes about her that he is deeply in love with his wife and has been since they met. But the overall effect of the book for anyone with even a passing familiarity with the continent is to wonder why media outlets like the New York Times insist on continuing with the tired old tradition of having foreign correspondents cover the world rather than hiring the many competent local journalists who have far deeper contextual knowledge and are just as adept at translating complicated situations for Western audiences as are their American counterparts.
Laura Seay's review for Washington Post's Monkey Cage.

Where Are the Female Leaders at the UN? Gender Bias Persists

Interestingly, all five senior female leaders I talked to had field experience and combined their work with family life. In talking about their time in the field, they characterized it as having put a strain on their families, but they identified individual coping strategies. This juggling reflects the complex functioning of gender biases in the UN: female leaders are confronted with biases, find strategies to deal with them but still identify field experience as “problematic” for women.
Pervasive gender biases can help explain why so few women move to the higher echelons of the UN. But overcoming these biases is even more difficult than marshaling political will, especially in an international environment where gender biases are more rampant than ever.
Ingvild Bode for PassBlue about complex challenges around women and leadership in the UN system.

Fallen idol

The world, however, and the Western democracies in particular, refused to take her at her word. Governments, international organisations and activist groups of all kinds raised her high on a pedestal, as a living symbol of the peaceful struggle for democracy and human rights in Myanmar — indeed, everywhere. For many, she was seen almost as an ethereal being, remote, pure and beyond reproach. Buddhists in her own country considered her a near-bodhisattva, whose enlightened work and suffering deserved the utmost reverence. She counted US President George W. Bush and UK Prime Minister Gordon Brown among her most ardent fans. “Star struck” celebrities like the singer-songwriter Bono took up her cause. When she was not under house arrest, others flocked to her door, seeking a photo opportunity and the right to say that they had met her.
There were other factors that made her seem special. To stay in Myanmar and pursue her political calling, she sacrificed her personal life, her UK-based family rarely being able to visit her. In 1999, when her devoted husband was dying of cancer, she did not go to his bedside for fear of being refused entry back into Myanmar. Her commitment to the cause of democracy and human rights was total. She was also intelligent and well educated. It was relevant too that she was a striking woman, always impeccably dressed in traditional Myanmar costume, with a command of the English language, a quiet dignity and a winning smile. While hailed by feminists as a “warrior woman”, she made a strong personal impression on many statesmen.
Andrew Selth for the Mekong Review on Aung San Suu Kyi, politics and our quest for impeccable political heroes and representatives of democratic struggles.

The Development Delusion: Foreign Aid and Inequality

There are many effective solutions we might consider. One would be to democratize the institutions of global governance—like the IMF and the World Bank—so that nations of the global South have a real voice when it comes to decisions that affect them. Or, alternatively, we could shift the development-related functions of the IMF and the World Bank to a more democratic institution, like the United Nations.
A second move would be to aggressively reduce the debts of countries in the global South. This would roll back the remote-control power that rich countries exercise over poor countries and restore sovereign control over economic policy at the national level. It would also free developing countries to spend more of their income on health care, education, and poverty-reduction efforts instead of just handing it over in debt service.
Third, we need to put an end to structural adjustment conditions so that developing countries can gain access to finance while retaining the right to use tariffs, subsidies, capital controls, social spending, and other measures they might need to manage their economies and reduce poverty. In the South, some hope that the New Development Bank and the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank—both capitalized largely by China—might provide alternative sources of finance that don’t demand painful economic conditions, but it is too early to tell.
Fourth, we need to shut down illicit financial flows out of developing countries. There are a number of ways to approach this. We could stop trade misinvoicing by fixing the WTO’s customs rules. We could close the tax havens or roll out financial transparency rules that would put an end to shell companies and anonymous accounts. We could require multinational companies to report their profits in the countries where their economic activity actually takes place. Or we could impose a global minimum tax on corporations, which would eliminate their incentive to evade national taxes altogether.
Jason Hickel for American Affairs with a long essay on the past, present and future of 'development'.

If you’ve never lived in poverty, stop telling poor people what they should do

Despite the commonly held belief that only teens should or do work for the minimum wage, the fact of the matter is that millions of Americans of all ages, a/genders, and educational levels support their families on hourly low-wage jobs. That includes seniors, disabled people, and women of color.
The answer, then, is not that poor people live differently, but instead, that we create a society and an economy where people who work full time can live in the community where they work.
No amount of cutting back on luxury spending or driving extra hours for Uber can change the fact that there is literally nowhere in the country where a minimum wage job can support a family, that good union jobs have been in decline for decades, or that housing costs have priced people out of their homes. Cutting coupons, commuting by bike, and enjoying outdoor activities can’t really fix that.
Hanna Brooks for open democracy with reminder that advice for people living in poverty can often be an convenient excuse not to discuss structural and political issues and hide behind individual narratives of working harder and smarter...

Harvey reveals corporate hubris regarding safety

In Rennard's world, compounds don't burn, they degrade. Chemicals don't explode, they combust. The smoke is noxious, but he won't say if it is toxic.
This may be appropriate in a chemistry class, but a concerned public expects straight talk, which it's not getting.
If we learn nothing else from Harvey, let it be the danger of hubris. Despite claims to the contrary, executives will decide that mitigating a risk costs too much, and subsequent events will prove that they made a horrible mistake.
That's why regulators, journalists and citizen groups have a role to play in demanding accountability and revealing the risks taken. Because when it comes to chemicals, the public shares in the consequences of a bad decision and often pays the highest price.
Let's be honest, Harvey is not causing accidents. The storm is revealing the risks executives willingly took. No one has the right to shrug their shoulders and say, "C'est la vie."
Chris Tomlinson for the Houston Chronicle. I contemplated adding it to my my 'Harvey & globaled' list because it's an interesting reminder about the BS that is CSR. Companies dealing with dangerous, toxic materials do not really care about their environmental impact-they tick boxes of minimal standard and hope to get away with trouble when big disaster strike aka as 'capitalism'...

Our digital lives
The fantasy of the middle class: exploitation in a Romanian call centre

From the beginning of the training period an artificial system of ambivalent social relationships is built between employees, and between employees and their superiors. On the one hand, the operators are fed the lie that they are part of a team where hierarchy is irrelevant and everybody works towards achieving maximum productivity, which will ensure the welfare of everybody involved. The competition between different teams is efficient since the stakes are high for everybody: the losing team loses their jobs. On the other hand, every individual is encouraged to be competitive: there are internal competitions between members of the same team. The metric lists are displayed for everybody to see, which leads to constant reproach or glorification from your peers depending on individual results. There is an actual walk of fame in companies, the entrance corridor where every model employee gets a floor tile with their name engraved on it.
Elena Chiorean for PoliticalCritique.org with a great/sad example of the panopticon of contemporary capitalism and the neoliberal transformation in Romania.

Humitas: a new word for when humour and seriousness combine

In my PhD research, however, I argue that when it comes to making a point, comedy does not come naturally lower in the pecking order than seriousness. In some places and times, they have been equally important and the division between them is blurred.
(...)
Like everything in a neoliberal society, humitas could be reduced to a commodity whose only role is to sell things such as dodgy political ideas or friendlier business brands. But it can also be a way of acknowledging and embodying the world’s absurdity while still trying to change it for the better.
Kate Fox for The Conversation on her research on serious humor...interesting food for thought to think about aid humor, irony and memes...

Google Critic Ousted From Think Tank Funded by the Tech Giant

Google’s willingness to spread cash around the think tanks and advocacy groups focused on internet and telecommunications policy has effectively muted, if not silenced, criticism of the company over the past several years, said Marc Rotenberg, the president of the Electronic Privacy Information Center. His group, which does not accept corporate funding, has played a leading role in calling out Google and other tech companies for alleged privacy violations. But Mr. Rotenberg said it is become increasingly difficult to find partners in that effort as more groups accept Google funding.
Kenneth P. Vogel for the New York Times on the company that once had 'Don't be evil' as their corporate tagline...

On Mic.com and Minority Life in Startup Media

Regardless of how woke any cis straight rich white man is, the fact is that he will have severe blind spots if he lives in America because his experiences are so fundamentally different from minorities. Maybe it’s time to consider that a management team heavily dominated by white men would make situations like the ones Jeffries describes nearly inevitable, and that the solution would ultimately be not only to hire more minorities, but encourage a culture where they can speak freely, then actually and consistently listen to them.
Meredith Talusan with a great long-read on startup media, biases, privileges and the limitations of having white men in charge...

Updated: Did This Book Buy Its Way Onto The New York Times Bestseller List?

How does a book with such a low Amazon ranking that’s ‘temporarily out of stock’ suddenly become the most read book in YA? How does something that has next to no organic blogging coverage or even Twitter buzz do this? If the only Twitter gossip for your book is variations of ‘Seriously, has anyone heard of this book?’ you’ve got problems.
If you have actually heard of or even read this book, please get in touch because we are baffled.
Kayleigh Donaldson for Pajiba. This story is less about a particular book and more about the fact that rankings, metrics, data can and will be manipulated and always require critical analysis rather than being taken as 'objective' measurements.

Publications

The unbearable emptiness of tweeting—About journal articles

The ideal that tweeting about scholarly articles represents curating and informing about state-of-the-art appears not to be realized in practice. We see much presumably human tweeting almost entirely mechanical and devoid of original thought, no evidence of conversation, tweets generated by monomania, duplicate tweeting from many accounts under centralized professional management and tweets generated by bots. Some accounts exemplify the ideal, but they represent less than 10% of tweets. Therefore, any conclusions drawn from twitter data is swamped by the mechanical nature of the bulk of tweeting behavior. In light of these results, we discuss the compatibility of Twitter with the research enterprise as well as some of the financial incentives behind these patterns.
Nicolas Robinson-Garcia, Rodrigo Costas, Kimberley Isett, Julia Melkers, Diana Hicks with a new open access article for PLOS One.

Civic Tech in the Global South : Assessing Technology for the Public Good

This book is comprised of one study and three field evaluations of civic tech initiatives in developing countries. The study reviews evidence on the use of twenty-three information and communication technology (ICT) platforms designed to amplify citizen voices to improve service delivery. Focusing on empirical studies of initiatives in the global south, the authors highlight both citizen uptake (yelp) and the degree to which public service providers respond to expressions of citizen voice (teeth). The first evaluation looks at U-report in Uganda, a mobile platform that runs weekly large-scale polls with young Ugandans on a number of issues, ranging from safety to access to education to inflation to early marriage. The following evaluation takes a closer look at MajiVoice, an initiative that allows Kenyan citizens to report, through multiple channels, complaints with regard to water services. The third evaluation examines the case of Rio Grande do Sul’s participatory budgeting - the world’s largest participatory budgeting system - which allows citizens to participate either online or offline in defining the state’s yearly spending priorities.
New open access book by Tiago Peixoto and Micah Sifry for the World Bank.

Participatory research: Where have we been, where are we going? – A dialogue

Of note is the fact that the early roots of participatory research were found in the global South, specifically in Africa, Asia and Latin America. Of further interest is the fact that for the first 20 to 25 years, participatory research was a discourse located almost entirely outside formal academic circles but rather in social movement structures and civil society circles.
Open access article by Budd Hall and Rajesh Tandon in Research for All.

ARTICLE: NGO’s incidentally fill in for journalists

Indeed, none of the interviewees saw themselves as journalists, although one referred to a colleague as one. Despite the journalistic features of some of their work, the NGO members still see themselves strictly as advocates. Thus, in the case of Cyclone Pam, the members of 350 Pacific became “unintentional journalists”, producing a form of “hybrid journalism”, Spyksma concludes.
Journalism Research News features a new research article from Journalism Studies by Hannah Spyksma.

Academia

Learning to learn could be built into online courses
By showing that learning is a skill within large-scale digitally mediated programmes, the research will help to develop both the quality of programmes and the capacity of learners to make the most of them.
In a society categorised by fast-moving technology, business disruption and multiple career changes, knowing how best to learn will be a critical skill.
Sandra Milligan for University World News with interesting insights into digital learning beyond easy measurements and assignments.

Links & Contents I Liked 249

$
0
0
Hi all,

If you happen to be in Tallinn, Estonia early next week, I'd love to catch up at and around the DigitalisingDevelopment event which I will be attending!

In other news:

Development news:
Can robots take over garment-making? South Africa's development vision beyond growth; Kenya's election observer industry; the fake Brazilian surfing war photographer; India's Aadhaar biometric program; how to change the hierarchy of suffering? Fashion from Ghana; a level playing field for African tech innovation; geeze Louise (Linton)! ODA modernization.

Our digital lives:
Are nonprofit news sites preaching to the choir? Platform capitalism & the young; panel anxiety & diversity.

Publications:
Social media & violence reporting; cash transfers plus.

Academia:
IRB nightmares; de-/re-valuing work in China.


Enjoy!

New from aidnography

Reading #Harvey through a #globaldev lens
This post now features some interesting updates!

Development news
A new t-shirt sewing robot can make as many shirts per hour as 17 factory workers

For now, SoftWear Automation only sells its automated t-shirt work line in the US. Santora says the company needed to start local because it would be too difficult to service all its technology if it opened up internationally. They still need time to scale. (The home-goods robot is already available internationally.) But if foreign firms, like Tianyuan Garments Company, want to produce in the US, SoftWear Automation is happy to supply them with their sewbots.
Marc Bain for Quartz. As careful as one has to be when tech sites report the disruption of an industry primarily based on one company, this is a glimpse into the future; the question of how low-skilled workers at the periphery will continue to participate in the global economy is going to be one of the biggest challenge for our generation as 'work 4.0' unravels.

Obsession with growth won’t help South Africa’s economic recovery

Not enough attention has been given to job creation. The South African economy has for a very long time experienced jobless economic growth. This meant that the country’s jobless rate remained stubbornly high for many years. Recent figures of unemployment touching 27.7% are indeed worrying. Youth unemployment is said to be 52%. Any plan that addresses only economic growth without the creation of job opportunities will be found wanting.
The South African government’s priority should be to boost employment, by focusing on sectors that can easily generate jobs. I welcome the suggestion to boost the small, medium and micro-enterprises sector by giving them a share in public procurement. Small enterprises have been recognised for their potential to aid sustainable economic development and to create jobs.
The plan does not give details of overhauling the most important sectors of the economy: mining and agriculture. These sectors are key to generating growth and employment and can be used to drive economic transformation and empower communities that are at the margins of the economy.
Mohammad Amir Anwar for The Conversation with a view from South Africa and similar questions of how 'sustainable development' can look like in a future of jobless growth and many challenges for young, low-skilled men.

Kenyan court ruling puts ‘election observer industry’ in a tight spot

“I think with this ruling, the Supreme Court has redeemed itself.”
The same, unfortunately cannot be said for international election observers, according to Wanyeki. “It shows there’s a problem with the election observer industry. They focus too much on the pre-electoral process and the process of voting. The problems are always with the counting and the tallying. They don’t focus on that enough, they don’t have the resources to look into that,” she explained.
(...)
“I feel a real anger about the way they treat us. I’ve had diplomats say to my face that, speaking in the light of history, this election was an improvement [from past elections]. I’m sorry we do not live in history, we live in the here and now and we have a right to free and fair elections,” said Wanyeki. “Their attitude in condescending, neocolonial and by saying things are improving, they’re treating us like small children. Hopefully this ruling is like egg on their face.”
Leela Jacinto for France24. A lot has been written on the Kenyan supreme court ruling, but I think we need to discuss traditional election observing further; in the age of the Internet and more sophisticated ways of influencing elections traditional notions of showing up at the polling station may become increasingly outdated. So what could election observing 3.0 look like?

Brazil 'surfing war photographer' Eduardo Martins exposed as fake

In between trips to Mosul in Iraq, the Syrian city of Raqqa under the control of so-called Islamic State (IS) and the Gaza Strip, Eduardo Martins enjoyed surfing.
He shared glimpses of his life with his almost 125,000 Instagram followers.
Until it all came crumbling down when a BBC Brasil investigation found out that Eduardo Martins was a completely fictitious character.
For years, someone using that name had been stealing pictures taken by professional photographers who had risked their lives in conflict to get them.
Eduardo Martins fooled journalists and picture editors by making slight alterations to the images, such as inverting them, just enough to elude software that scans pictures for plagiarism.
The BBC with a story about a fake war photographer with a life story too good to be true...

The Privacy Battle Over the World's Largest Biometric Database

Despite these implementation challenges, the scariest parts about the program for privacy advocates are its ubiquity and lax security. According to the technology engineer Anand Venkatanarayanan, when biometric information is used to access a service via Aadhaar, such as purchasing a new cell phone, the service provider receives that person’s demographic data (name, address, phone number), and the government receives the metadata—specifically, the date and time of the transaction, the form of identification used, and the company with which the transaction was carried out. That information can paint a fuzzy but intimate long-term picture of a person’s life, and raises concerns about both government surveillance and private-sector abuse.
(...)
Over the last few years, Russia, Tunisia, Morocco, and Algeria have all expressed interest in the Aadhaar program, and according to reports, representatives from Tanzania, Afghanistan, and Bangladesh recently visited India to learn more about implementing an Aadhaar system of their own.
Namrata Kolachalam for The Atlantic with a report from India and insights into their biometric database program.

Does the Data Security Risk of a Billion Indians Handing Over Biometric Information Outweigh the Benefits?

Instead, ordinary Indians are more focused on how Aadhaar has changed their lives. “I think it’s a good idea because before this, my two children and I had no identification, no passport, only a ration card,” says Anita Pereira, a domestic helper from the city of Pune. “The Aadhaar card supports so many things—if I want to do a passport, go to the bank, book a railway ticket.”The Aadhaar card has allowed millions to finally be included into the formal economy. They can now open a bank account, borrow money from the Reserve Bank of India (the country’s largest lender), send and receive remittances, and purchase SIM cards. It’s also enabled mobile payments and other cashless transactions, crucial in light of last year’s disastrous demonetization drive
Sandy Ong for Newsweek also writes about Aadhaar, highlighting benefits as well as stressing the unclear legal framework around it.

Editorial: We must topple the hierarchy of suffering

Our problems are not restricted to shrinking ad revenues, rapacious duo-polies and dwindling circulation. One of our biggest problems is our inability to tell the story of the person in Freetown calling the names of her relatives across the debris in such a way that she is heard as loudly as US First Lady Melania Trump in stilettos at the scene of a hurricane.
Our thoughts are with all the victims of flooding and mudslides in Texas, in Sierra Leone, in Niger, in Yemen, in South Asia. And our thoughts are also with all those whose suffering will never truly be acknowledged because the rest of the world has failed to realise humanity as a unified entity.
We need to talk about the multiple biases underpinning these inconsistencies. But it is not enough to talk. We must demand better of our media, of our governments, our aid agencies, ourselves.
An editorial from the Mail & Guardian raises interesting questions about the role of (South) African media in the global media landscape and how 'distant voices' can be heard in the global news mainstream.

We don’t need white tech saviours in Africa – we need a level playing field

And there were many innovators at TED. Bright young things whose eyes glistened as they spoke about how they were “excited and humbled” by the opportunity to help. It was all very virtuous, and all very useful, so why was my pulse throbbing in my temple?
What sat so uncomfortably with me was that not only does the narrative of the white saviour in Africa seem untarnished, it is now celebrated as the entrepreneur creates much-needed jobs, solves seemingly intractable problems and is clad in a T-shirt and not a dog collar. Our wide-eyed adoration ignores that success is only partly down to ambition and graft. There are cultural and economic impediments for the African innovator.
The economics are fairly obvious. As the journalist and author Aimee Groth wrote in 2015: “Entrepreneurs don’t have a special gene for risk – they come from families with money.” Access to capital, and to the collateral to put up, makes all the difference. The cultural explanation is, as always, far more nuanced, but equally debilitating. I suspect it to be pan-African, but can only speak for the parts of south, west and east Africa where I’ve lived. There, I’ve seen a system that privileges everything foreign and white.
Eliza Anyangwe for The Guardian on TED talks, white saviors and tech innovations that are still dominated by Silicon Valley discourses.

The social media fashion mogul from Ghana


Louise Linton Somehow Manages to Make It Worse

In the interview accompanying the photo spread, Linton offers a compelling apology. She takes all the blame onto herself, she says she learned her lesson, she says she’s growing as a human being. She pauses, “overcome with emotion.” She realizes the irony of apologizing while wearing a ball gown. She’s not a spoiled rich girl lording her wealth over others as though it imbues her with moral superiority; she’s a sweatpants girl! A nearby caption reads, “Louise Linton, seen here in her living room, wears the Easton halter neck trumpet gown with exaggerated bow back detail by Ines de Santo.” That particular line of dresses tends to cost from the upper-four to lower-five figures.
Erin Gloria Ryan for Daily Beast is not a Louise Linton fan ;)!

Changing the rules of aid: understanding ODA modernisation

This animated presentation provides an overview of the drivers behind aid reform and what the process and timelines for change look like. It also presents a summary of key changes expected, and introduces some of the implications for policy and practice, and for anyone who works with ODA data.
Development Alternatives with a great video-highly recommended to students (and in all fairness I also learned 1 or 2 things about the ODA reporting jungle...).


Our digital lives
Are nonprofit news sites just creating more content for elites who already read a lot of news?
But I think the larger problem remains: Are they going to use that foundational support to figure out ways to extend their reach to new audiences and to audiences that aren’t already getting a lot of high-quality news? I think that’s one of the big questions.
Laura Hazard Owen talks to Rodney Benson for Nieman Lab. A vital discussion for those 'communicating development' and wondering what the future of development or humanitarian journalism can be beyond 'preaching to the choir' in the well-known niches of the Guardian, NPR or IRIN...

Trust, Technology and The Young

Platform capitalism is restructuring labour markets and social relations in such as ways that opting out from it is becoming an option available only to a privileged few. Moreover, we found teenagers whose parents prohibited them from using social platforms often felt socially isolated and stigmatised. In the real world of messy social reality, platforms can’t continue offload their responsibilities to parents and schools. We need some solutions fast because, by tacitly accepting the terms and conditions of platform capitalism – particularly when it tells us it is not responsible for the harms its business model facilitates – we may be now passing an event horizon where these companies are becoming too powerful, unaccountable, and distant from our local reality.
Huw Davies for iai on the challenges of resisting platform capitalism when there are teenagers around...

Panel anxiety & diverse representation

We managed to bring in our own examples of ensuring that diverse perspectives and backgrounds exist in our work, both in front of and behind the lens. We also delved into the essential benefits of working with cast and crew members of all orientations, genders, cultural backgrounds and abilities. In my own work, this is extremely important when working in local cultural contexts, or with vulnerable women and children, just to give a few examples. Wherever possible, I believe we should be working with local crews and supporting women in the industry— not only because they have greater knowledge and access, but also because we can then invest in more meaningfully developing those ecosystems.
Keeya-Lee Ayre shares her reflections on diverse panels and meaningful engagement at conferences, workshops or other public speaking opportunities.

Publications
Assessing the Role of Social Media and Digital Technology in Violence Reporting

This paper assesses the role of social media and digital technologies in the reporting of violent events, and evaluates their relative strengths and weaknesses as compared to other means available. It seeks to understand how social media and digital technology data are collated, how reliable the data are, and what practical and ethical issues are associated with their collection and use.
Tony Roberts and Gauthier Marchais with a new IDS Working Paper.

How to Make ‘Cash Plus’ Work: Linking Cash Transfers to Services and Sectors

Such initiatives have thereby addressed some of the non-financial and structural barriers that poor people face and have reinforced the positive effects of cash transfer programmes. In design of such programmes, further attention should be paid to the constraints faced by the most vulnerable and how such constraints can be overcome. We conclude with recommendations regarding the provision of complementary support and cross-sectoral linkages based on lessons learned from the case studies. More research is still needed on the impact of the many variations of ‘cash plus’ programming, including evidence on the comparative roles of individual ‘plus’ components, as well as the knowledge, attitudes and behaviour pathways which influence these impacts.
Keetie Roelen, Stephen Devereux, Abdul-Gafaru Abdulai, Bruno Martorano, Tia Palermo and Luigi Peter Ragno with a new paper for UNICEF-Innocenti featuring vase studies from Chile, Ethiopia and Ghana.

Academia
My IRB Nightmare

I sometimes worry that people misunderstand the case against bureaucracy. People imagine it’s Big Business complaining about the regulations preventing them from steamrolling over everyone else. That hasn’t been my experience. Big Business – heck, Big Anything – loves bureaucracy. They can hire a team of clerks and secretaries and middle managers to fill out all the necessary forms, and the rest of the company can be on their merry way. It’s everyone else who suffers. The amateurs, the entrepreneurs, the hobbyists, the people doing something as a labor of love. Wal-Mart is going to keep selling groceries no matter how much paperwork and inspections it takes; the poor immigrant family with the backyard vegetable garden might not.
Bureaucracy in science does the same thing: limit the field to big institutional actors with vested interests. No amount of hassle is going to prevent the Pfizer-Merck-Novartis Corporation from doing whatever study will raise their bottom line. But enough hassle will prevent a random psychiatrist at a small community hospital from pursuing his pet theory about bipolar diagnosis. The more hurdles we put up, the more the scientific conversation skews in favor of Pfizer-Merck-Novartis. And the less likely we are to hear little stuff, dissenting voices, and things that don’t make anybody any money.
Scott Alexander for Slate Star Codex. An interesting story about the bureaucratization of higher education and research (just like in any other industry really) and how well-intended ideas may stifle small-scale innovation, yet may indirectly support big players that have (unlimited) resources to jump through administrative hoops...

Devaluing Human Labor

This radical reduction in wages has been justified by claims that transportation is a deskilled profession and that service providers are merely acting as extensions of technologies (such as GPS navigation and customer-driver pairing algorithms). However, I found in my research on the ride-sharing industry in China that such characterizations are misleading. Firstly, ride-sharing services depend upon the knowledge, skills, and social relations of drivers. After joining the platform, drivers learn which smartphones work best with the app and which telecommunication networks offer the most reliable service in the areas that they operate. They develop strategies for making customers happy and boosting their user ratings. The drivers form online communities to share tacit knowledge about things like earning subsidies and promotions and avoiding getting caught by the police in places where the app is still illicit. Though these processes of enskillment, knowledge-making, and socialization often go unacknowledged by ride-sharing firms, they constitute an indispensable human infrastructure that enables the smooth functioning of technological platforms.
Shuang Frost for the Society for East Asian Anthropology. I am not entirely sure whether I share her enthusiasm of a bright, capitalist future-present in China, but definitely interesting food for thought!

Links & Contents I Liked 250

$
0
0
Hi all,

Link review #250 should be an occasion to pause and reflect for a moment-just not this week which is far from over yet and it has been quite hectic
So let me just say 'THANK YOU!' for producing awesome content, sharing great stuff-and being around virtually!

I wrote What I learned from curating thousands of #globaldev articles almost exactly a year ago and it still remains valid.  


Maybe a plain and simple review with a special section on Irma & #globaldev is the answer to the question of what's next or where to go from here...

Enjoy!

New from aidnography

My updated lecture on humanitarian communication in the age of social media:

Full video:

#Irma & #globaldev special section
After Irma, let those who use our tax havens contribute to the repairs

And would it be possible, he asked, for such future public investments to be conditional on the tourism industry ploughing back profits into public funds used for development? In this way, the taxpayers who propped up tourism could also benefit from reinvestments into areas such as health, education and transport for all.
While some may cynically dismiss this question, raising concerns about corruption of public finances in poor countries, the question Browne asked, even before the hurricane hit, was a good one: how should those extracting value from a place contribute to it?
But the questions are complicated and perhaps even uncomfortable for those asking them. The relief efforts needed are larger than they should be due to how these countries have been starved of tax revenue precisely because they have chosen to be tax havens.
Mariana Mazzucato for the Guardian with yet another reminder of the many political and social aspects of 'apolitical' , 'natural' disasters.

UK urges changes to international aid rules to help hurricane-hit islands

“The response would have been just as large and swift regardless of the aid rules,” he said. But he added: “The prime minister is frustrated with the rules as they stand.”
The Conservatives have said they are thinking of changing the legal definitions surrounding the use of the protected aid budget, and have already stretched the envelope to include security and peacekeeping measures.
Patrick Wintour for the Guardian. Rather than increasing the aid budget these developments will probably mean that less money will be used for development in the narrower sense. If Britain wants to help their overseas territories there are ways without re-defining 'aid'...

How to tell the stories of those worst affected by a disaster like Hurricane Irma

Location, or the severity of hazards, cannot sufficiently explain why Irma had such a severe impact. There needs to be an acknowledgement of why Caribbean nations are far more vulnerable to natural hazards than the US.
This requires a long hard look at the political and economic situation of these islands. For example, several reports have raised worries over the heavy reliance on a handful of sectors, such as agriculture and tourism, which will be severely impacted by Irma in the long-term. Countries with diverse economies are better able to recover following a disaster; but Caribbean countries will find recovery far more challenging, given their low economic diversity.
Gemma Sou for The Conversation also highlights some important aspects to create longer-term narratives that capture the complexities of how disasters and recovery happen on the ground.

Hurricane Irma: U-Report works to protect children

Some quick internal conversations via WhatsApp between the UNICEF Regional Advisor and U-Report LACRO Coordinator in Panama and it’s agreed that we should use U-Report to provide vital information. We need help from the Global Innovation Centre. A quick email or two later and the Bangkok office gets things going and gives the green light to promote with U-Report Global via Facebook in the countries in the path of Hurricane Irma – from St Kitts to Antigua, Haiti to Barbados, we want people to know basic life-saving information. And in this part of the world, that means having everything available in English, Spanish and French.
Victoria Maskell for UNICEF shares some insights into how UNICEF communicates around Irma and activates digital platforms.

Innovative but dull: disaster insurance is starting to pay off

But in the wake of these disasters, there is some surprisingly good news: Millions of dollars of relief finance are already being paid without fuss, social media campaigns, or photo-ops. What is this remarkable “innovation”? The answer is dull: it’s insurance.
(...)
None of these financing arrangements are silver bullets. They can‘t substitute for risk reduction, solid preparedness planning, and informed decision-making.
But they can help to provide the glue that holds it all together, making sound planning beforehand worthwhile.
Stefan Dercon for IRIN on how donors like DfID and the World Bank work with local agencies around disaster insurance schemes.

Robert De Niro has personally pledged to rebuild Barbuda after 90 per cent of its structures were destroyed

De Niro and billionaire James Packer had bought the former K Club Resort on Barbuda last year but had yet to begin construction on the property; their original proposal faced controversy with the island's residents, who legally have ownership of all land in Barbuda and a right to vote on all proposals.
Clarissa Loughrey for The Independent. No humanitarian emergency is complete without celebrity engagement; this time celebrity investors want to get involved in rebuilding tourism-complex challenges ensue...

Development news
Push to end orphanage volunteering as World Challenge stops trips for students

The world's biggest school-based volunteer travel company, World Challenge, will no longer offer trips to orphanages in the developing world after research showed the practice was harming vulnerable children.
Advocacy agency ReThink Orphanages said a revolving door of volunteers was making abandonment and attachment issues even worse.
Ruby Jones for ABC News Australia with more good news from the interesting developments around outlawing orphanage tourism as a form of modern enslavement.

Growing cities: more chances, more insecurities

Well we've done ethnographies with people between 2013 and 2016 including people who have been part of the violence, for example with people who are hit men or people who are involved in gangs or mafias. And what we realized through working with them is that nobody really wants this lifestyle. And often it's the case that, due to their marginality or due to lack of opportunity they end up going down these avenues which they don't necessarily enjoy.
So I have faith in people and I think that we just have to try and focus more on listening to the voices of the people at the ground level and creating positive interfaces for them with each other so that the city doesn't become an area of competition — it becomes an area of co-operation.
Amiera Sawas talks to DW about her research on urbanization and violence.

Eat, pray, live: the Lagos megachurches building their very own cities

Finally, the man who keeps the money coming in, who gives this entire neighbourhood its raison d’être, the de facto mayor of what is effectively an entirely new piece of city, takes his place on the vast stage and picks up the mic. The 75-year-old Daddy GO wears a grass-green short-sleeved suit, bow tie and gold watch. After praying on his knees at the lectern, he climbs to his feet.
“Will somebody shout Hallelujah?”
Ruth Maclean for the Guardian with an interesting example from Nigeria on what 'urban development' can look like and how new social contracts and movements are changing perceptions of 'Africa' every day...

Why Oxfam is moving its headquarters

They want us to stand with them in pulling together the knowledge they need, the evidence they need. They need our global power to be able to hold their leaders accountable to them. So we need to be on the ground with them.
Winnie Byanyima for the BBC.

An Experiment Gives Cash Aid To The Poor. Is That Ethical?
Seen in this light the experiment is a sort of side-benefit to the main objective — a way of making a virtue out of the vice that not everybody can be covered. Given that Niehaus can't provide every single poor person in Kenya with the payouts, he argues, isn't the most ethical course to at least make the effort to measure how much of a difference cash aid makes for those getting it compared to those who do not? After all, if researchers find that cash aid has a big impact that kind of evidence "increases the chances that some of the other villagers might get a decent income in the future too" if governments and other charities are inspired to give out more cash aid.
What's more, says Niehaus, GiveDirectly's use of a lottery to decide which villages get the payouts isn't just ensuring that the data from its randomized controlled trial is as accurate as possible, it's distributing the cash aid in the fairest possible way.
Nurith Aizenman for NPR Goats & Soda with a great review of some of the core ethical challenges around RCTs and giving out cash.

Media Development Needs a Community of Scholars

Unlike in other sectors of development, such as governance and public health, media development has no cohesive community of scholarship that can help us understand and address new challenges or develop new ways of thinking in the quickly evolving and complex media space. The weak linkages to scholarship around media development issues are not because such scholarship does not exist, but rather because the scholarship is scattered across academic disciplines. One can find important research related to media development at academic conferences for communications, political science, anthropology, and many more.
Paul Rothman & Nick Benequista for the Center for International Media Assistance outline an framework for a media 4 dev community that can bring together different aspects of a diverse practical and scholarly community.

Our digital lives



Men Are Entertaining and Women Are Awkward: An Analysis of Speaker Perceptions

Without exception, men were more likely to choose positive attributes to describe themselves (e.g., intelligent, comfortable, entertaining) and women were more likely to choose negative attributes (e.g., nervous, awkward, terrified). In fact, men were much more likely to choose positive attributes — eight attributes generated differences of 10 points or greater.
Annie Pettit for Gender Avenger with more insights into the underlying issues that may lead to #allmalepanel...

Never underestimate the influence of a Brussels conference organiser

For the women who are still deliberating whether to sign up to the database or not because they doubt their own expertise, do not underestimate what you already know! You probably know more than you think and at this time in your career it’s more important to improve your speaking and presentation skills than your expertise.
While there are certainly etiquettes and unwritten rules about how to organise conferences in Brussels, it doesn’t mean things can’t change. People in Brussels seem to have mixed feelings about going to conferences.
Some consider them a waste of time unless they get to speak. Yet, others go – for the free food, the connections one can make, or to actually learn something new.
Charlotte Brandsma, Corinna Hörst and Louise Langeby for Euractiv also discussing gender aspects of conference planning and the value of diverse participants. Whether or not more conferences and events in Brussels are really necessary is a different debate...

A survey of independent media in the South asks if “movement journalism” can help newsrooms better cover social justice strife

Simonton recently took a deep dive into the community and minority-owned media landscape of the American South — so deep, in fact, that she spent over a year researching and reporting her findings in a 62-page report called Out of Struggle. Her report takes stock of the independent media landscape in the 13 states of the traditional South, from Texas to Florida to West Virginia, and was commissioned by Project South.
“We have good stuff that people are doing, [but] it’s very localized. How do we strengthen that and expand that impact?” she told me. “That’s what we think we can bring to the mix: finding some ways to offer services, support, training, et cetera, to increase the amount of journalism that’s going on in these already existing media outlets.”
Christine Schmidt interviews Anna Simonton for Nieman Lab with another aspect of 'media development' and the convergence between 'development' issues of the global North and South!

Publications

Emissaries of Empowerment

We suggest that because modern white feminist interventions retain this implicit orientation towards rescuing non-Western women from their own societies, cultures, and contexts, they also retain many of the same dynamics of these early exercises in white saviordom. Specifically, they center the intervenors rather than marginalized women, and favor the abandonment of complex narratives in favor of simple stories of abject victimhood. These dynamics are further entrenched by the drive to capture the attention of the Western public, generating a feedback loop between donor priorities and media coverage. What gets lost in the process is politics. Consequently, these interventions often inadvertently reinforce, rather than combat, one of the main drivers of women’s marginalization and injury: their depoliticization by the state.
Kate Cronin-Furman, Nimmi Gowrinathan & Rafia Zakaria with a super-interesting paper which is part of The Politics of Sexual Violence Initative at CUNY.

Double-edged Sword: Vigilantes in African Counter-insurgencies

Reliance on vigilante groups often is a faute de mieux solution for states facing a threat they cannot address alone. But as the cases in this report illustrate, there are better and worse ways of doing so, and of ensuring that a short-term expedient not turn into a long-term headache.
New report from the Crisis Group.

Behind the attacks: A look at the perpetrators of violence against aid workers

This analysis focuses on the 258 incidents (24 per cent of those recorded between 2011 and 2016) in which it is known that an organised group was responsible. We recognise that the small sample size limits the strength of quantitative analysis. However, even though the ‘unknown’ category is large, we can safely say that most of these unidentified perpetrators are neither state actors
(because military operations of state actors are relatively easy to identify) nor members of global NSAGs (such as IS and Al Qaeda, who have incentive to claim credit and thus self-identify
most of the time). In other words, most perpetrators in the ‘unknown’ category are likely to be national- or sub-national-level militia, un-affiliated individuals or small criminal groups.
Moreover, the results from the subset accord with qualitative findings from interview evidence and document review, increasing our confidence in the validity of the sample.
Humanitarian Outcomes with a new report and another interesting aspect on the complexities and multiple shades of grey of violence markets in which humanitarian aid work(er) operate(s).

Digital Economy and Digital Labour Terminology: Making Sense of the “Gig Economy”, “Online Labour”, “Crowd Work”, “Microwork”, “Platform Labour”, Etc

This paper analyses the myriad terminologies that have arisen in relation to the digital economy and digital labour. In detailed tables, it assesses the prevalence and currency within research literature of nearly 30 different terms. It then provides a definition for each and summarises the typical content of literature using the term. It also summarises current popularity of related Twitter hashtags.
Richard Heeks with a new working paper for Manchester University's Global Development Institute.

Academia

What should ECRs and PhDers consider when choosing a conference? Purpose, cost, and motivation
For starters, conferences are getting more and more expensive – see above – and that’s unjust; I don’t like the disparities that this creates. And yes, I do try to help PhDs and contract-research folk get to conferences – and yes, that means allocating money from my research budgets for that purpose. But an individual action hardly addresses the problem. We really do need to do something about the costs of getting together to do our jobs.
But even if conferences were cheap, I’d still hate them. I find it hard to simply be at an academic conference – rushing from room to room – or worse still, venue to venue – for papers where presenters never have enough time and where there is often no time at all to discuss. I often can’t manage a full day of sitting and listening. I get very antsy and have to skip a session just to break up the monotony. (And don’t start me on enduring hour after hour of crappy powerpoints.)
Pat Thomson for LSE Impact Blog with some measured advice on how to attend academic conferences. I may have some more fundamental issues about the conference-academic-industrial complex, but Pat makes a more balanced point about the chances and limitations of attending conferences.

Why We Post: Digital methods for public anthropology

There is the danger that an emphasis on public engagement could lead to the neglect of communicating with academic audiences. However, the main academic contribution of the WWP project is not just the open access book series, but also journal articles that are specifically designed to engage in academic debate. In addition, the team felt that the skills they developed by writing content for the MOOC and website were valuable, not only for communicating with the public but also for developing their academic arguments. We should not be limited by narrow conceptions of dissemination or indeed by the apparent divide between public and academic anthropology, especially when it comes to producing ethnographically-nuanced modes of education. Teaching an appreciation of the richness of diversity around the world by presenting learners with topics as familiar as social
media, but appropriated in vastly different forms, can be a tool for both personal and societal transformation.
Laura Haapio-Kirk with an open-access article in Teaching Anthropology on how to engage audiences with anthropology in the digital age.

Links & Contents I Liked 251

$
0
0
Hi all,

The developments at Third World Quarterly were definitely the top story in my networks this week-a fascinating case study about changing academic publishing cultures, core values of development research & broader questions about 'whose voices count' in debating international development in public arenas.


But there were many other interesting readings as well, of course:

Development news: Barbie Savior travels to Nambia; UN leadership & gender parity; Sri Lanka's adoption baby trade; the limits of what free menstrual pads can solve; how bad is the new Tomb Raider movie? How the ICRC avoided a PR disaster with the gaming industry; C4D & digital thinking; no apps necessary: topping up phone credit for refugees; BRICS have not been able to challenge global governance; field experiments & re-visits; new books on Bangladesh's & China's development; thinks tanks & female leaders; who belongs in the new Lagos? A long-read about Nigeria's conflicts in Jos; girl gangs of El Salvador.

Our digital lives: New university course in China on how to become an Internet celebrity: the Yoga-industrial complex; resettling in rural Nova Scotia; female art & empowerment.

Publications: Anthropology & hip-hop; Robert Chambers is back!

Enjoy!

New from aidnography

 Development news


INTERVIEW: UN should be flagbearer when it comes to gender parity, stresses top official

And this is not only about numbers, although numbers are very important. But it also has to do with being able to attract and retain and motivate women. It also has to do with special, temporary measures when situations need to be corrected because of this parity gap. It also has to do with creating an enabling environment because there is a cultural aspect to it. And we also need a cultural shift. So as I said, I think this time we have targets that are bold but are realistic – that parity at the senior level should be reached in 2021. In most of the [UN] system, [parity] should be reached by 2026, and there will be a few outliers that will go until 2028. That is the ultimate target.
As UNGA comes to a close an interesting interview with Ana Maria Menéndez on gender and leadership inside the UN system.

Sri Lankan baby trade: Minister admits illegal adoption trade

Up to 11,000 children may have been sold to European families, with both parties being given fake documents.
Some were reportedly born into "baby farms" that sold children to the West.
Sri Lanka's health minister told the Dutch current affairs programme Zembla he would set up a DNA database to help children find their birth mothers.
About 4,000 children are thought to be have ended up with families in the Netherlands, with others going to other European countries such as Sweden, Denmark, Germany and the UK.
The BBC was one of many media outlets that has covered the story sparked by a Dutch TV program.

The Problem With Free Menstrual Pads

Giving out pads is only part of what needs to be done to help girls manage their periods. It's not a "silver bullet solution," says Bethany Caruso, a postdoctoral fellow at Emory University.
Courtney Columbus for NPR Goats & Soda with an important reminder that has been at the center of most development work since it started: Giving out 'stuff' always needs to be connected to local realities, broader social dynamics and power relations-and changing those will require a lot of efforts.

Tomb Raider: is the Alicia Vikander reboot just Gap Yah: The Movie?

White Saviour Barbie is so popular that they’ve now made a movie about her, starring Alicia Vikander. True, they’ve called the movie Tomb Raider for some reason, but anyone with half a brain can see from the trailer that it’s really about White Saviour Barbie.
(...)
Perhaps the film will have a bit more depth and all this gap-year malarkey has only been forced into the trailer for the purposes of exposition. After all, we’ve yet to hear her say either of the two sacred gap year mottos – “They don’t value life as much here” and “These people have nothing, but they’re so happy”.
Stuart Heritage for the Guardian is not happy with the latest trailer for Tomb Raider.

How the international Red Cross turned a PR disaster into DLC

It is that presentation that inspired the Laws of War DLC. In it, players take on the role of an international humanitarian aid worker. They are tasked with clearing unexploded ordinance from the same battlefields which they fought over in Arma 3’s base game. In the roughly five-hour mini-campaign, players see that fictional conflict from all sides, including from the perspective of civilians caught in the crossfire.
(...)
By creating prohibited cluster munitions as an in-game asset, and by also teaching the controversies surrounding their use, Rouffaer believes that gamers have a more complete picture of modern warfare for the first time. “Everyone on the forums says, ‘Yes! Thank you! Give us civilians and humanitarian workers and cluster munitions and we will use these new guns to eradicate as many of the first group as possible,” Rouffaer said. “But by saying that, it means that they will have consciously been saying, ‘We are going to break the law.’
Charlie Hall for Polygon with an interesting case study on gamifying humanitarian aid and the complexities for serious discussions between a billion dollar industry and traditional organizations like the ICRC.

8 reasons to think digital communication in development

Digital communication is more engaging and meaningful to the individual. It allows communication participants to effortlessly be part of and influence the dialogue, and to contribute and be recognized through co-creation and visibility. This explains the rapid growth of social media users worldwide.
UNICEF's Tomas Jensen with 8 important aspects of communicating development in the digital age-definitely food for thought! I wonder whether you could play devil's advocate and outline examples of how these 8 aspects can create exactly the opposite, negative effect...

How about we stop building apps for refugees and top up their phones instead?

Today’s blog is a guest post from Fahim Safi. Originally from Afghanistan, Fahim is now seeking asylum in Belgium and acts as one of the administrators of the mind-boggling group, “Mobile Credit for Refugees and Displaced People.” This volunteer-run organization has already provided over $750,000 of mobile credit to people on the move. No this isn’t yet another effort to build “apps for refugees” here — it’s simply a question of topping off their phones, and it’s one of the smartest solutions we’ve seen.
Fahim Safi for NeedsList. This sounds like a great and unglamourous way to support refugees and their communication-no new app, no hackathon, no European capital city-based incubator involved!

BRICS needs a new approach if it’s going to foster a more equitable global order

But it’s hard to see how they expect the bank to meet this commitment if it continues to place more emphasis on speed in project implementation than on identifying and managing the adverse environmental, human rights and social effects of its projects. To fulfil their commitment to promote a more just and equitable global economy the BRICS will need to up their game.
(...)
There are reasons to think the BRICS leaders could be persuaded to adopt a human rights based approach to making global economic governance more democratic and responsive to the needs of developing countries and for a more just, equitable and sustainable global economy. They, and their colleagues in other developing countries, are governing societies with continuing, and some cases worsening poverty, inequality, unemployment and environmental degradation levels. And they don’t seem to have an effective strategy for meeting this challenge.
Danny Bradlow for The Conversation wonders whether BRICS summits and the new development bank are really having an impact in promoting alternatives to traditional global governance approaches.


Six Questions with Chris Udry
Tavneet Suri spent time in the communities in Akuapim in Ghana that Markus Goldstein and I had surveyed five years previously. She documented remarkable changes in the external environment facing pineapple exporters, driven by the introduction of sea freight routes that substantially reduced transportation costs. This, in turn, changed the relationship between farmers and exporters in important and subtle ways that Rahul Deb and Suri model in their JDE paper. This is a great example of a light touch “re-interview”; it did not depend on access to individual level data from the earlier research, but by building on the original survey was able to observe institutional changes that would otherwise have been obscured.
David McKenzie & Markus Goldstein for the World Bank Development Impact blog talk to Chris Udry about field experiments.

Two top authors compared: Hossain on Bangladesh and Ang on China

So what I would dearly love to see is the two of them forming a dream team to swap countries (or methodologies), because I want to know more about the missing ‘why’ in China, and the ‘how’ in Bangladesh. The traumatic chaos, bloodletting and famine of Maoism must have had at least as profound an impact on China’s decision makers as the events of the 1970s in Bangladesh. And Ang could help Hossain more fully explain the alchemy by which a chaotic and ineffective government somehow gets officials to do good things (or at least not get in the way). I’d also like Hossain to take a look at the gender aspects of China’s rise – almost entirely missing from Ang’s book.
Duncan Green for fp2p talks to Naomi Hossain and Yuen Yuen Ang in light of his recent reviews of their respective books.

Do think tanks need more female leaders?

Whether female leaders foster gender equality depends on both the individual leader as well as the nature of the organization’s structures, processes, and norms. In a blog post on the gender dynamics of knowledge organizations, Priyanthi Fernando, former Executive Director of Sri Lanka’s Centre for Poverty Analysis reminds us that “A discussion of women’s participation and ascension to leadership roles in think tanks [assumes] that think tanks are also gendered organizations, and that somehow women led think tanks could behave differently, and that there are organizational practices that might ‘relieve some of the barriers to inclusion and promotion that women face in think tanks.’”
As a starting point, it is essential to look at both the organization and how gender is integrated across its policies and practices, as well as the leader’s style and characteristics. This is an essential next step for anyone interested in understanding why and how female leadership should be fostered, the difference it can make, and the importance of supporting organizational approaches to gender equality.
Shannon Sutton for IDRC with more food for thought on gender and leadership in the philanthropic sector and another reminder to engage with power relations that go beyond a female leader.

OluTimehin Adegbeye-Who belongs in a city?
Underneath every shiny new megacity, there's often a story of communities displaced. In this moving, poetic talk, OluTimehin Adegbeye details how government land grabs are destroying the lives of thousands who live in the coastal communities of Lagos, Nigeria, to make way for a "new Dubai."
LONG READ: Seven Bloody Days of Summer
His hypothesis is that the transition from military to democratic system of governance unwittingly hurt the status quo. “Pandora’s box opened over the land with the allocation of resources and political positions as democracy came in 1999. Abacha was no longer there to keep a lid on things with his iron fist so underlying tensions and rivalries that could not erupt under military rule, came to the fore. That year, we were running all the time. If it wasn’t Kano, Kaduna, Lagos. Democracy had become demon-crazy.”
Has democracy been an enabler of violence? The jury remains out on that; in the meantime, there have been repeat episodes of the crisis in 2002, 2008 and 2010. The trauma remains for survivors and their families even as the Middle Belt remains a potential hotspot for violence. Even more scary is the fact that both indigenes and settlers used weapons they kept in their possession from the first crisis — and those tools of trade remain dormant but ready.
Eromo Egbejule reports from Jos in Nigeria with events that culminated in September 2001 and shed a light on the complexities of the country's developments since the end of Abache's dictatorship.

The Girl Gangs of El Salvador

Elena had never been a typical gang recruit, or a typical gang member—her social class, her relationship to the boss, and even her sexuality reserved for her a rare position as an insider-outsider. But she could have just as easily become a typical victim.
When she saw those dead bodies in the dirt that day, Elena had kept her cool. As soon as the car rolled past the police and the caution tape, she told her friend to drive, just drive, to keep on driving. Then, one of the lucky ones, she engineered a way to disappear herself from El Salvador altogether.
Lauren Markham for the Pacific Standard Magazine with a long read from El Salvador and troubling insights into the lives of female gang members and the broader context of violence in Latin America.

Our digital lives
University Opens Course for Aspiring Net Celebs

Beginning this semester, Chongqing Institute of Engineering, a private university in southwestern China, is offering a three-month course for aspiring internet celebrities, Beijing Youth Daily reported Thursday. The program is run in cooperation with a local company, which will be in charge of teaching the first crop of 19 students how to be better livestreamers.
“They said that after graduation, the school will arrange for us to sign contracts with the company to be wanghong,” one of the students told Beijing Youth Daily, using the Chinese word for such online celebrities. “I think it’s great — if I do well, I can become famous.”
Wang Lianzhang for Sixth Tone with some of the latest developments in digital celebrity aspirations in China...

Do yoga, work harder: how productivity co-opted relaxation

“These companies that sell relaxation tools and techniques are kidding themselves if they don’t understand this is part of an acceleration of our economy and expansion of work into all aspects of our life,” says William Davies, a lecturer at Goldsmiths University and author of The Happiness Industry. “It’s a cruel mentality where everything can be used or should be useful, and if it isn’t, I’m not trying hard enough. That’s one problem. The other problem, of course, is that where you once had things that added intrinsic value for people, they’ve become captured in some way.”
Paula Cocozza for the Guardian on life hacks, the happiness industry and the yoga-industrial complex...

Chemistry of Fire

When I was an outsider, an Obruni, I belonged to universities and jobs and professions—the necessary, easy belonging of adulthood. But I found little satisfaction there. Jobs change, classes end. Now, as I tug on my heavy yellow gear and try not to trip over my own feet, I realize it is the excitement and camaraderie of service, of answering the pager-bomb, that has made this rural Nova Scotia village more of a home than any other place I’ve lived.
Emily Bowers for Understorey Magazine reflects on her return to her parental village in Nova Scotia after more than decade working in Africa to find fire-fighting and belonging.

The Latin American Women Artists Who Fought Patriarchy with Their Bodies

Despite this, few of these artists would have referred to their work as “feminist.” Instead of a desire to advocate for women, their sensibilities were heavily shaped by the revolutionary struggle and the widespread resistance of their respective countries—even if their works did reflect a repertoire of issues addressed by feminism, such as motherhood, civil rights, and sexual violence.
“Many of these artists were active in left-wing movements,” explains Cecilia Fajardo-Hill, co-curator of the exhibition “Radical Women: Latin American Art, 1960–1985” at the Hammer Museum in Los Angeles. “But for them, the rights of women were secondary, and the Left considered that feminism was bourgeois and imperialistic.”
(...)
Beyond Latin America, crucial to this dialogue are the Chicana and Latina artists who were working in the United States at the time. “Usually the Latin American and the Latina / Chicana art worlds are kept separate, which is an artificial, colonial construct,” Fajardo-Hill argues. “Latina and Chicana artists were responding not only to patriarchal politics that were as oppressive as those faced by their counterparts in Latin America, but also to a second-wave feminism that was often indifferent to the issues faced by women of color.”
Benoît Loiseau for Artsy reviews a new exhibition project in Los Angeles, but also shares fascinating insights from Latina and Chicana artists and their struggles for empowerment.

Publications

Hip Hop Constellations

This guest-edited issue is titled ‘Hip Hop Constellations’—a title the editors Nanna Schneidermann (Oslo and Akershus University College) and Ibrahim Abraham (University of Helsinki) use in order to highlight the idea of popular music as significant but contingent social practice. The articles published here hence cover various values and significations that hip hop culture takes on in Denmark, Mexico, South Africa, Tanzania, Uganda, and between Sweden and Chile. The broad sweep of this issue ranges from
neo-liberal socialist ‘gangstas’ to the nostalgic sampling of ‘national culture’, all the way to hip hop as the ‘outsourced’ vehicle of the Scandinavian welfare state’s projects. It is through the breadth of the material analysed in this issue that one begins to appreciate the special character of hip hop as both inseparable from certain key ideas and imagery that approaches universal
recognisability, and as a field that remains susceptible to the significant revaluation of constituent symbols or ideas.
New open access issue of Suomen Antropologi.

Can We Know Better?: Reflections for Development

Robert Chambers contrasts a Newtonian paradigm in which the world is seen and understood as controllable with a paradigm of complexity which recognizes that the real world of social processes and power relations is messy and unpredictable. To confront the challenges of complex and emergent realities requires a revolutionary new professionalism. This is underpinned by a new combination of canons of rigour expressed through eclectic methodological pluralism and participatory approaches which reverse and transform power relations. Promising developments include rapid innovations in participatory ICTs, participatory statistics, and the Reality Check Approach with its up-to-date and rigorously grounded insights. Fundamental to the new professionalism, in every country and context, are reflexivity, facilitation, groundtruthing, and personal mindsets, behaviour, attitudes, empathy and love.
Robert Chambers' latest book is available open access from Practical Action Publishing!
Viewing all 750 articles
Browse latest View live