↧
Hi all,Long week, but lots to read for you over the weekend ;)!
Development news:US peacekeeping cuts; celebrities helping Somalia; celebrities (different ones…) romanticizing poverty; localizing aid in Syria; gold mine misery in Liberia; India’s suicides; where did the HONY money go in Pakistan? ICT4D in Nepal; teachers, refugees and mobile phones; talking back to Gates.
Our digital lives:Karen Attiah and diversity; romanticizing the gig economy.
Publications:Besieged universities in Egypt, aid data graveyards (and how to avoid them…).
Academia:Time-sucking job applications; breaking the shackles of medical journal publishing.
Enjoy!
New from aidnography
Academic conferences as neoliberal commodities (book review)Nicolson’s book is a short new book that addresses one of the favorite academic products researchers love to hate.
(...)
As academic conferences have both been an aspect of my research and my blogging, I want to take this opportunity to add a few aspects from my ethnographic and media and communication background.
Development news
Trump Administration Eyes $1 Billion in Cuts to U.N. PeacekeepingThe paper, which was reviewed by Foreign Policy, urged Security Council members to “consider whether current peacekeeping operations continue to be the best-suited mechanisms for meeting the need of those on the ground and achieving the council’s political objectives, or if changes are needed. That is, are current missions ‘still fit for purpose’?”
The proposed U.N. cuts, which were drafted by the White House Office of Budget and Management, show that the Trump administration is seeking far deeper cuts to the U.N. in the international affairs budget than to the State Department or USAID. Last week, the White House released a preliminary budget projection — known as the skinny budget — that called for cuts of 28 percent to international organizations in the 2018 budget.
Colum Lynch for Foreign Policy with more bad news from the US.
Why there’s no need to panic on UN peacekeeping cutsSome Security Council diplomats say there is room to make missions work better, and that could mean some cuts in funding – though such efforts may now be associated with the White House, where top officials have shown contempt for the UN as an institution. "There is an opportunity to have a tougher approach with the UN on where they spend their money, using money as an incentive for reform,” insisted one non-American Security Council diplomat. If the US approves deep funding cuts without a parallel re-assessment at the UN, diplomats may be less sympathetic.
US reviews of peacekeeping missions, noted de Coning, “will probably prompt the UN Secretariat to also do its own internal reviews, and other member states, especially those in the Security Council, will also need to form their own opinions, and have a basis for doing so.”
“This is not necessarily a bad thing. It is always good to be under pressure to review your goals, objectives, effectiveness, and efficiencies,” he added. “The proposed cut to 25 percent will be politically symbolically important for the US, but the real reduction in costs would come from pressure to bring down the overall $8 billion budget.”
Samuel Oakford for IRIN with more details on the proposed American peacekeeping budget cuts and a reminder that these things are, well, complicated and tend to take more time than some politicians hopefully staying in office...
Social Media Star Has A 'Crazy Idea' To Help SomaliaAnd the specialists are glad to hear about the campaign's change of plans: "More and more as opposed to flying in goods, we're looking for local areas" to get food, said Paul Spiegel, a professor and the director of the Center for Refugee and Disaster Response at Johns Hopkins. What's more, transport by truck is less costly than by plane and so would be a better long-term model if the Love Army campaign continues.
But the source of the food is just one issue. There's also the matter of protecting food before it is handed out so it isn't looted, says Challiss McDonough, a World Food Programme senior regional spokesperson based in Nairobi, Kenya.
Natalie Jacewicz for NPR Goats and Soda with another 'celebrities trying to save the world' story from the social media age; while some learning and reflection seems to be going on, there's a strong risk that this will end up as yet another celebrity-saving-Africa story-just this time new celebrities replace Sean Penn, George Clooney and Madonna...
Kim Kardashian And ‘Poor-nography’: The Dangers Of Celebrities Romanticizing PovertyThe glorification of poverty is intrinsic to the wider perception that this generation’s trendmakers have never actually endured any kind of palpable struggle. Taylor Swift’s girl squad and the Kardashian family’s Instagram photos are too clean and neat, and all celebrities can do to earn “authenticity” is to co-opt the visual signifiers of struggle — a yellow stained wall, blurry photos, ripped jeans and dirty hair. Essentially, the socioeconomic barriers that preclude people like Kardashian from being viewed as “genuine” or “empathetic” can’t be dismantled. The best she and her peers can do is to attempt to appear like the every person.But the rich acting poor isn’t emulation or flattery. Indeed, the aesthetic Kardashian is glamorizing is a daily reality for many — often born out of cyclical patterns of institutional bias, social stigma, cultural abuse, and a whole system that is rigged to ensure that those poor stay poor, while the rich jealously guard their privilege.
Kat George for The Establishment with an excellent essay on celebrity, poverty and false empathy-obviously very much at the heart of any celebrity #globaldev engagement!
Aid Inside Syria: Time to Go Small in a Bigger WayAs a result of their ability to enter places that were off-limits to non-Syrian organizations -- including besieged and hard-to-reach areas —these Syrian groups were often taken on by the UN agencies and INGOs as partners that would do the actual delivery of goods and services and implementation of programs. With very few exceptions, these groups could not receive funding directly from international donors or the United Nations because they did not have the organizational and operational history that would make them eligible. In fact, for the first several years of the conflict, many of these groups survived primarily on private donations from their own networks, which allowed them to deliver aid to locations that the bigger groups could not reach.
These operational Syrian groups were--and still are—taking on risks to life and limb in order to provide assistance to their own communities. They are daily witnesses to events inside Syria and to the humanitarian needs of the people they serve. But for several years, few international partners engaged with these groups as a way to learn about what was happening on the ground within Syria on a daily basis. Instead, INGOs often demanded the implementation of projects that donors insisted upon but that were not always useful to the population they purported to help.
Daryl Grisgraber for Refugees International with insights on what 'localization' and 'working on the ground' really means for Syrian NGOs and the 'international (donor) community.
How a gold mine has brought only misery in LiberiaIt’s difficult to pin responsibility for the mine’s failures on any individual because it’s hard to identify the successive true owners of New Liberty Gold. Aureus is part of a long list of shell companies named in the Panama Papers leak, many of them registered in opaque jurisdictions.
Emmanuel Freudenthal and Alloycious David for IRIN with a case study on how tax evasion and offshore legislation ultimately hurts vulnerable people and that international organizations cannot and probably do not want to do much about it when the 'resource curse' strikes yet again...
Why A Rich, Orderly Himalayan State Has India’s Highest Suicide RateWhile there are similarities between Sikkim and other states with high suicide rates and drug abuse, said Nancy Palmu Chankapa, a clinical psychologist in Gangtok, stressing it wasn’t possible, yet, to pin a single reason for the state’s high suicide rate. Several cases that she has dealt with have been related to family problems, alcohol abuse, mental illness, and extra-marital affairs. My investigations–focussed on the link between drug abuse and suicide–across South and East Sikkim districts show that suicide and drug abuse were indeed linked.
Sarita Santoshini for India Spend with an important reminder that 'first world problems' and lifestyle changes in emerging economies are global issues with complex local impacts.
Remember Pakistan’s ‘Harriet Tubman’ who got $2.3 million from Humans of New York? This is what she has done with itBrandon Stanton, as well as all the donors who donated this money, had placed their absolute trust in this NGO as well as “Pakistan’s Harriet Tubman”, Syeda Ghulam Fatima. It would be a tragedy if it turns out that they have betrayed this trust.
In Pakistan, NGOs receive hefty donations with little or no oversight, with the result that very few projects exist beyond documents and photographs. Neither the government nor the press follows up on these grand projects, and foreign donors are shown lengthy but misleading reports or fabricated photos, in attempts to satisfy them. When some donors insist, they are fobbed off with excuses of “security situation”, and those who swindle these foreign donors are easily let off the hook. It is shameful that, despite the best of intentions, a great campaign and a huge fundraiser, HONY has been unable to put a dent in the slavery situation in Pakistan.
Hamza Rao for Daily Pakistan follows up on the fundraising campaign for one of the projects in Pakistan featured by Humans in New York. As we always say in #globaldev: It's complicated...
NGOs in Kathmandu and Mountain Cell Towers in Ramechhap: ICT4D Projects in NepalWe saw cell towers high in the mountain passes ostensibly to facilitate the overseas remittances that these communities so depend on, but also facilitating digital communication amongst the villages themselves. Although the gender digital divide in Nepal is high (as it is throughout most of South Asia), there is a urban/rural divide at work there: women in Kathmandu are much more likely to own and use a phone regularly than those in the rural districts of Ramechhap, for example.
But the economic situation has potentially paved the way for an educational or development one. These remittances have fostered greater infrastructure investment for mobile, which in turn can be used to create entrepreneurial activities, educational opportunities and more. Some went so far as to make mobile repair the focus of their efforts creating women entrepreneurs along the way. The point is ultimately that if we can spot these underlying developments in other fields (remittances and finance, for example), we should be able to track a parallel path to some sort of development opportunity as well.
Michael Gallagher for Panoply Digital shares impressions from recent ICT4D work in Nepal.
How teachers use mobile phones as education tools in refugee campsTeachers of refugees demonstrate the fine and crucial balance between actively harnessing innovative technology to support refugee education and leveraging what is already in use in refugee communities. In particular, our research finds that relationships are at the core of how teachers of refugees use technology for support both in and out of the classrooms. Teachers for Teachers is an exciting new model that reflects this idea. Peer supported learning and a mobile mentoring component of the program assist teachers in Kakuma to strengthen their relationships among teacher cohorts locally and to expand their relationships globally; these networks offer an exchange of experiences to develop new pedagogies and approaches to curriculum in multicultural and transnational refugee settings.
Sarah Dryden-Peterson, Negin Dahya, and Dacia Douhaibi for Brookings with a detailed assessment of mobile phones as teaching tools.
Gates Foundation’s rose-colored world view not supported by evidence The letter focuses so unwaveringly on foreign aid that you’d be forgiven for believing that charity is all that’s needed to address poverty. We hear nothing of the systemic forces that drive poverty and inequality in the first place, such as – to name just two relevant examples – tax evasion and avoidance, and intellectual property rights.
Martin Kirk and Jason Hickel for Humanosphere with some feedback to Bill Gates and the Gates foundation.
Our digital lives
Karen Attiah Is the ‘Warrior of Diversity’ Channeling Journalism Into ActivismThough Attiah says that sometimes it can be toxic to be a women of color in online news (because internet trolls), as a mentor, she still encourages young women from the continent and diaspora to assume the role of “warriors for diversity” in the global media landscape. For her, it comes down to this, “It’s my purpose and who else is going to counter that flat, one-dimensional narrative that I don’t like?”
Eunice Onwona for okayafrica. Many years ago I responded to one of Karen's blog posts about development graduate studies and the role of criticism and I have been following her great writing since!
The Gig Economy Celebrates Working Yourself to DeathA Fiverr press release about “In Doers We Trust” states, “The campaign positions Fiverr to seize today’s emerging zeitgeist of entrepreneurial flexibility, rapid experimentation, and doing more with less. It pushes against bureaucratic overthinking, analysis-paralysis, and excessive whiteboarding.” This is the jargon through which the essentially cannibalistic nature of the gig economy is dressed up as an aesthetic. No one wants to eat coffee for lunch or go on a bender of sleep deprivation—or answer a call from a client while having sex, as recommended in the video. It’s a stretch to feel cheerful at all about the Fiverr marketplace, perusing the thousands of listings of people who will record any song, make any happy-birthday video, or design any book cover for five dollars. I’d guess that plenty of the people who advertise services on Fiverr would accept some “whiteboarding” in exchange for employer-sponsored health insurance.
Jia Tolentino for the New Yorker with yet another reminder about the detrimental side effects of the gig economy and platform capitalism.
Hot off the digital press
Besieged Universities: on student rights in Egyptian public universities post 2013The report titled “Besieged Universities: A Report on the Rights and Freedoms of Students in Egyptian Universities from the Academic Years 2013-2014 to 2015-2016”, documents and analyses cases of violations that pertain to students’ right to assembly, organisation, education and freedom of expression. We were able to monitor legislative and security violations committed by the Egyptian state, as well as administrative violations committed by university administrations in the form of disciplinary sanctions against students.
Additionally, the report analyses the effect such violations had and continues to have on the Egyptian student movement.
New report from The Association for Freedom of Thought and Expression, AFTE, jointly published with the Norwegian Students’ and Academics’ International Assistance Fund, SAIH (the good people from the Rusty Radiator award...).
Avoiding Data Graveyards: Insights from Data Producers & Users in Three CountriesUsing a theory of change, we identify nine barriers to the use of data and corresponding operating principles for funders and producers to make demand-driven investments in the next generation of development data and statistics.
Samantha Custer and Tanya Sethi for AidData with a new report.
Academia
Time-sucking academic job applications don't know enormity of what they askThese requests are now not just part of tenure-track job ads, but applications for visiting assistant professorships, postdoctoral fellowships, and (gasp) sessional positions. When search committees ask for more documents -- for more time-consuming, carefully constructed, well-proofread expressions of one's commitment to the academy -- they are asking for more unpaid, unseen academic labour that yet again falls more heavily on those already bearing the burden of disability, responsibility and precarity.
Alana Cattapan for The Rabble. The piece is written from the perspective of contingent faculty who have to put in a lot of free/unpaid time to apply for positions. But applying for any academic 'thing' (job, fellowship, grant,...) is time-consuming and tiresome. It usually starts with the fact that no one accepts a CV, but only their own forms.
I also wonder what the purpose is to ask 100+ applicants to submit syllabi right away-do committees simply use this as a cheap opportunity to source material for their own syllabi? Do they even read them? Why not ask short-listed candidates only for a full application (my guess in North America: Overly bureaucratic HR is afraid of lawsuits...)? Especially for teaching "gigs", you probably only need a CV and a good Skype call to figure out whether a candidate can teach the course...
The shackles of scientific journalsFinally, science needs to stop relying so much on journal publication as the only recognised credential for researchers and the only path to career progression. Tools exist that report how often a preprint has been viewed, for example, or whether a clinical data set has been cited in guidelines for doctors. A handful of firms are using artificial intelligence to assess the scientific importance of research, irrespective of how it has been disseminated. Such approaches need encouragement. Journals may lose out, but science itself will benefit.
The Economist discusses changes in (medical) journal publishing and argues for an end of the journal impact factor fetishism.
In other news, Elsevier desperately tries to defend its business follow...explore the #acrl2017 hashtag for more discussion around open access publishing
↧
I bought Dean Karlan and Jacob Appel’s book Failing in the field: What we can learn when field research goes wrong as a potential addition to our Research Methods course reading list. And while the short and very well written text provides some practical insights into how to learn from failure in development field research, the further along the book I read, the uneasier I grew about some of the underlying discourses of the book.
First and foremost, the book is about randomized controlled trials (RCTs), surely the authors’ expertise, and at no point in the book is the view on field research broadened. Today, conversations about poverty alleviation and development are much more focused on evidence than they were before-a shift due, in large part, to the radical drop in the price of data and the growth of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) (p.2).
This obviously sets the tone for the book, but it also phrases ‘failing’ and ‘field research’ in a certain way right away: Failing happens when you do not do your RCT homework correctly before, during and after field research in communities in the global South. Relationships, power dynamics and very often people disappear from the authors’ view and the failing never engages with multi- or trans-disciplinary perspectives of learning and avoiding failure. But let’s return to these aspects a bit later.
A refreshingly engaging narrative on getting field work right
The great strength of the book is that it is part of an interesting new genre of books that is written in a more conversational style. In a very accessible, relatively jargon-free way the short book reminds me more of a series of ‘super blog posts’ or edited interviews and is a welcome break from academic textbooks or original research articles. There is a difference between the double-spaced pre-print journal article pdf file that easily runs for fifty pages and this handy hardcover book that is suitable for undergrads, practitioners and researchers alike to discuss some common challenges and how to do a better research job: Bottom line, a bad RCT can be worse than doing no study at all: it teaches us little, uses up resources that could be spent on providing more services (even if of uncertain value), likely sours people on the notion of RCTs and research in general, and if believed may even steer us in the wrong direction (p.11).
In the first part, Kaplan and Appel present ‘leading causes of research failures. These are definitely worth highlighting, but I would have liked to see maybe one chapter that addresses the broader context, not just technical problems in setting up and implementing a research study.
But there is a black box, a ‘research team’ or ‘a partner organization’ and I would have liked to look more inside it: How is failure communicated within different institutional frameworks (universities, donors, governments, communities), where is the modern equivalent of Latour’s laboratory life? And much simpler: Did you talk to an anthropologist, geographer or engineer about the study?
The majority of researchers who are cited by name in the book are men, and there is often an ‘I failed’ tone to insights rather than ‘we fixed it’. There are definitely some ‘voices’ missing in the conversation and I wonder whether that could be a major aspect of failure that has not been addressed so far.
Make (tough) decisions and pull out if necessary
One of the important common themes in the second part with six longer case studies is finding ‘good enough’ solutions to the research challenges outlined in the previous part that fit different contextual layers. The challenges of the case study on credit and financial literacy in rural Peru (chapter 6) sum up the sentiment well: (I)ntegrating technology is more of a hurdle that the researchers had initially thought, and future efforts will likely require a bigger investment to lay the groundwork for success. Not only must the educational content be high quality, but there are prerequisites, too: well-trained and charismatic trainers, functional equipment, power, and reasonably tech-savvy users, to name a few (p.82).
Some of these challenges have already been discussed in the ICT4D community, but I am actually a bit more worried about a ‘successful’ project of that nature rather than the ‘failing’ one introduced in the book. Does better technology lead to better results or to a tech-solutionism that looks good for researches but maybe not for the rural communities?
As chickens are back in the development spotlight thanks to Bill Gates and his critics, the poultry loan case study (chapter 9) is a good reminder how tricky the implementation is: Fixed on an idea, with a grant disbursed and partially spent, and a project team ready to go to the field, the dissolution of the original sugarcane plan triggered a similar loss frame: We are going to lose our opportunity to learn, balk on this grant, and disappoint our funders; what can we do? (pp.112-13).
Regardless of your good intentions, methodological sophistication or data-driven plans development interventions will remain complicated, messy and can often not easily scaled up from one local context to the next.
Don’t leave the field to the political scientists & economists!
As I said in the beginning, I wish that there was maybe one extra chapter to address qualitative aspects, the location of ‘the field’ (as opposed to multi-sited research including sites in the global North and along the aid chain(s) or aspects of culture and power that other disciplines have engaged with for a long time. Maybe some projects even fail because of their multi- or trans-disciplinary nature and because researchers overestimated the impact it would make on field research?
And while the book certainly is a proof of the importance of communicating failure and writing about field research differently, I would have liked to see those communicative aspects maybe part of the five mantras for better research that the authors propose in their conclusion.
Engaging in a well-understood context or careful data collection are certainly important points to take away from the book, but I am a little worried that people, culture and other ‘softer’ aspects may get ignored too easily: Cultivate buy-in from senior management down to front-line managers and employees (p.134).
This language perpetuates a managerial discourse and possible mindset that may ultimately contribute to some failing rather than eliminating pitfalls.
At the same time, this is the biggest achievement of the book as a conversation starter about better and good enough field research and doing a research job ethically and well.
Failing in the field is a great primer for students and non-academic researchers who are embarking on the exciting journey of data collection and fieldwork. But while getting research design and implementation right, we should remember not leave the ‘the field’ to the political scientists and economists alone ;)!
Karlan, Dean & Appel, Jacob: Failing in the field: What we can learn when field research goes wrong. ISBN 978-0-691-16189-1, 176pp, GBP 24.95, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2016.
↧
↧
Hi all,
A busy week wrapped up with a fresh book review and the Friday link collage!
Development news: Why do expats earn more than locals? Southern online workers (also) get a rough deal; advice on development career starts; Niger Delta suffocating in oil; how dangerous was Zika? More on chickens & cash; Comic Relief needs to become political; gendered leadership gap; the irony of accessing the humanitarian ICT forum remotely; burnout in the field.
Our digital lives: Facebook fundraiser individualize risk & support; do-good capitalism is a lie; AI misinformation epidemic; #NakedDiplomacy
Academia: Female sessional instructors’ heavy gender toll; Elsevier & Dutch open access; can universities have local and global engagement?
Enjoy!
New from aidnography
Failing in the field (book review)And while the short and very well written text provides some practical insights into how to learn from failure in development field research, the further along the book I read, the uneasier I grew about some of the underlying discourses of the book.
First and foremost, the book is about randomized controlled trials (RCTs), surely the authors’ expertise, and at no point in the book is the view on field research broadened.
(...)
At the same time, this is the biggest achievement of the book as a conversation starter about better and good enough field research and doing a research job ethically and well.
Failing in the field is a great primer for students and non-academic researchers who are embarking on the exciting journey of data collection and fieldwork. But while getting research design and implementation right, we should remember not leave the ‘the field’ to the political scientists and economists alone ;)!
Development news
Secret aid worker: Why do expats earn more than the rest of us?Is it hypocritical for an aid agency to come to a developing country looking to improve local lives, yet economically discriminate against local staff within their organisation? Or is there a line that separates extremely poor citizens targeted as beneficiaries from the average working citizen? Are their needs, such as equal treatment in the workplace, irrelevant?
This week's Secret Aid Worker column for the Guardian Development Professional network went viral as the comments below the piece and for example on the 50 shades of aid work facebook group show. My 2 cents:
I wish the article was bit more nuanced; we can oppose expat aid workers as a matter of principle, but let's focus on the current reality. Expat aid workers are embedded in a different, secondary financial economy-including pension, insurance, mortgages at home and financial burden of temporary placements-many aid workers do not have generous UN or diplomatic moving allowances. Many local staff in the 'back office' also work closer to regular 40-45 hours per week, many expats work more hours (there are variations, of course). So comparing both groups 1:1 is tricky. I agree on benefits in addition to salaries, travel allowances, schooling support etc. for local staff and a tougher discussion on 'standards of living'; again, many expat NGO workers probably live less privileged lives-and then again, UN workers and diplomats are always part of an elite-whether you are an EU citizen working in Africa or an African citizen working in Geneva and New York. So there should be a more nuanced discussion on absolute and relative privilege, salaries and other financial commitments, rather than focusing on the 36K 12 day consultancy (I want once of those ;) )
Online workers get a rough dealNow a study of online workers in the developing world has found there are far more people seeking work than there are jobs available, which drives pay downwards.
(...)
But over two-thirds of respondents said that “gig” earnings were important to their household income. And over half said their work involved complex tasks – a sign of stimulating work. Some said they preferred it to working in a business outsourcing setting, such as a call centre.
Graham told the meeting that “platforms give little back in the way of taxes but make use of a nation’s resources”. He called for more thought to be given to regulation, market-based solutions modelled on fair trade organisations and new ways of approaching labour rights.
Aisling Irwin for SciDev.net with more insights from global capitalism and the growing gig economy.
Advice for international development careers: 6 points (and a few sub-points) for graduating seniorsLet’s assume you’re smart, talented, hard-working. You’ve traveled a bit and you think you know how the world works. I have some terrible news for you. The problem isn’t even that you’re wrong in what you know. The problem is that the world is infinitely more complex and nuanced than you imagine. Your knowledge is correct, but it barely scratches the surface. That will always be the case. Never forget it. Stay humble and stay hungry.
Dave Algoso should blog more ;)! A great overview over some recurring career questions!
A country suffocating in oilAfter half a century of rampant oil extraction, the Niger Delta is one of the most polluted places in the world. The oil companies’ pipelines are outdated and rebels keep blowing up the pipes. A battle has erupted over oil – and it is taking away thousands’ of people’s water.
Christian Putsch with a multi-media story for Germany's WELT.
Why Didn't Zika Cause A Surge In Microcephaly In 2016?"Misdiagnosis is a reasonable hypothesis. But it's not clear that this explanation accounts for the whole story," says Ko, an epidemiologist, who is studying mothers and babies born with Zika in the northeast part of Brazil.
Ko think's there's another possible explanation: When a pregnant woman contracts Zika, that might not be enough to cause microcephaly in all cases. In other words, Zika might not be working alone.
Since the surge in Brazil's microcephaly cases in 2015, many scientists began to wonder whether a second virus could be involved. Maybe another infection combines with Zika to make the disease worse and increase the risk of birth defects.
Michaeleen Doucleef for NPR's Goats & Soda with an update about the impact of Zika-and a reminder how complex 'epidemics' can be-and how little we know about the interplay of various factors around viruses.
Getting Kinky with ChickensIn all of those conversations with friends, colleagues, policy makers, and students all kinds of difficult and pressing development questions have arisen that research could address. Never, ever, ever has “chickens versus cash” arisen as an issue at all, much less as the remotely possible “best investment” in research.
Lant Pritchett from Center for Global Development weighs in on the responses to Bill Gates' chicken for development proposal.
Africa deserves better from Comic ReliefIt shouldn’t be afraid to talk about the triumphs of African nations as much as it does their challenges, even if those successes aren’t always the result of western charity. Comic Relief retains a narrow perspective that fails to convey the bigger picture of progress in the continent, which is that life expectancies are up by over 10% in 37 African states
(...)
Those that want to hide in the sanctuary of the charity’s “non-political” status should ask what solutions aren’t political when famines never take place in a functioning democracy.
Comic Relief should have higher expectations of itself and its audience – we can still be charitable even when the message is laden with politics.
David Lammy for Guardian's Comment is free section wants traditional giving and charity be become more political and discuss structural developments-both positive and negative-rather than just raising money 'for children'.
The gendered leadership gap and the humanitarian sectorLeadership equality isn’t about simply having the same number of women and men in positions at the top or in the organisational structure, it is about ensuring that there is equal opportunity for both women and men to get there – and that when they do, they are equally supported, valued and remunerated.
Ayla Black for the DevPolicy blog summarizes key debates around women and aid leadership.
The end of the 'humanitarian' enterprise? One of the key questions from the WHS is how does the humanitarian community make the Grand Bargain a reality? The Grand Bargain’s purpose is to leverage off the diverse expertise and experience of the global humanitarian community so we can anticipate and prepare for a crisis. The Grand Bargain’s core is the need to ‘work together efficiently, transparently and harmoniously with new and existing partners...’ so we can deliver assistance and protection to the world’s most vulnerable. Is this possible to achieve if the worlds super powers are continuing to ignore the necessity of foreign aid and working collaboratively to achieve global peace and security?
Joseph Camilleri with a reminder of how much and how quickly the rhetoric of a 'grand bargain' has been sidelined by the politics of 2016 and 2017...
A new case must be made for aid. It rests on three legs. A nuanced discussion of aid matters because a hurricane is threatening the consensus on international development. The crisis of faith in globalisation threatens to disrupt traditional routes to growth and poverty reduction, especially via labour intensive manufacturing, supported by free trade. Automation and the deployment of robots will disrupt and restructure the global jobs market. And the imperative of climate action, in all countries, will reconfigure markets and prices around the world. Aid had better be ready to deal with these: to take on future challenges, not relive those of the past.
Simon Maxwell guest writes for From Poverty to Power. Another interesting think-piece, but I wish there was a bit more diversity when it comes to the authors of such reflections...
A Remote Look at the Humanitarian ICT ForumHowever, I cannot help but be a little disappointed in how poorly this meeting was geared towards people attending remotely. While, from what I have seen, the conference was blessedly free of Powerpoint presentations it would have been nice to have slightly more supporting material for people who could not be there in person.
Timo Luege with a reminder that many organizers need to do better in including the virtual audience-and in the case of Google that seems particularly ironic...
Burnout in the FieldI read somewhere that burnout occurs when passionate, committed people become deeply disillusioned with a job or career that has previously provided them with identity and meaning. This work has defined me for nearly a decade.
I have spent my entire working life chasing after opportunities, jumping into new job after new job and spending a lot of time in difficult places with significant responsibility. Stuck on a base, often working late, an early evening curfew, and sleeping just a few metres away from your office, you have no choice but for this to become your life. As a result, your personal life back home suffers and, as it can feel, your sanity.
There’s no ‘cure’ exactly, for burnout, but the good thing is it can take just a short time to recover if you put the right things in place.
Emily Gilbert for MSF. Why aren't there more aid organization that encourage this kind of reflective and critical engagement with the industry?!?
Our digital lives
Facebook's fundraisers now help you raise money for yourself and friendsBut to stick to social good, the new personal fundraisers can only span six categories: education (like tuition and books), medical (like procedures and treatments), pet medical, crisis relief (like natural disasters), personal emergency (like house fires or theft), and funeral and loss. As the product rolls out, however, Facebook hopes to include more categories and evolve them over time.
Matt Petronzio for Mashable. To me, this seems the perfect American solution to individualizing risk and outsourcing systemic issues to 'the crowd'. Why should the school board pay for Mrs Adam's books (one of the screenshots) when 'the community' can do it as well? And don't buy insurance (or maybe you won't qualify for it)-your garage catches fire and you ask your 'friends' to fix it...also very disturbing in terms of transparency: "Hi 798 facebook friends, my mum is really sick and I need to see her but can't pay for my ticket because I just lost my job-can you help?"
“Do-Good” ExploitationThis kind of rhetoric reveals the seedy underbelly of “benevolent” capitalism. When capitalists play the do-good card to squeeze more performance and loyalty out of their employees, and then conveniently cite business necessities when it benefits them, then doing good becomes little more than their latest exploitative tool.
But Agrawal’s rhetoric also reveals the inherent conflict between the needs of companies and the needs of workers. And that is the structural reality of capitalism, no matter how personally altruistic individual capitalists might be.
Sarah Ngu for Jacobin with an important reminder to always question the latest wave of 'do-gooding', philanthropic, Silicon Valley-style capitalism!
The AI Misinformation EpidemicThis pairing of interest with ignorance has created a perfect storm for a misinformation epidemic. The outsize demand for stories about AI has created a tremendous opportunity for impostors to capture some piece of this market. When founding Approximately Correct, I lamented that too few academics possessed either the interest or the talent for both expository writing and for addressing social issues. And on the other hand, too few journalists possess the technical strength to relate developments in machine learning to the public faithfully. As a result, there are not enough voices engaging the public in the non-sensational way that seems necessary now. Unfortunately, the paucity of clear and informed voices has not resulted in a silent media. Instead, the void has been filled by charlatans, bombarding the public with incessant misinformation, much of it spread by opportunists, eager to seize upon the public’s interest.
Zachary C. Lipton for Approximately Correct with a preview of his critical writing on the tech-industrial bubble speak 'something with robots' industry.
#NakedDiplomacy in a Changing WorldWith regard to the use of technology and social media for the resolution of today's armed conflicts Tom cautioned against hyper-optimism. The Iran deal was not tweeted live, traditional diplomacy carries on far away from the screen. Where social media can be very important is in mobilising public constituencies behind peace which then forces elites to make compromise. On balance we can remain positive as each time there has been a technological leapforward in the quality of democracy this has promoted coexistence and reduced conflict.
Guy Banim introduces a interesting new book by Tom Fletcher.
Academia
She’s Hot: Female Sessional Instructors, Gender Bias, and Student EvaluationsWhile I can’t provide recommendations about what kind of system should replace student evaluations, what I can say is that based on the feedback that I’ve received and conversations I’ve had with other female instructors, gender bias in the classroom, and academia, is a serious problem that needs to be addressed openly, with honesty and compassion. Not only do these biases end careers, but they also deprive students of superb instructors.
Andrea Eidinger for Active History with an detailed criticism of the gendered implications of student evaluations.
How Elsevier plans to sabotage Open AccessA mere € 232.40 per open access article might seem like a fairly good price for an open access article, but there is more. The ‘pilot’ comes with major restrictions on who can publish where.
The first requirement is that the corresponding author, typically the first or last author on a paper, should be affiliated with a Dutch institute. A fair requirement perhaps, for this is a Dutch deal, but not very open minded for a multinational such as Elsevier. Also this restriction is anything but accommodating for researchers working in international partnerships.The second devil is in the seemingly long list of details: the journal titles eligible for open access.
Sicco de Knecht for Hackernoon dissects the recent open access deal between Elsevier and Dutch academia. In the end, it is just another source of revenue for the big players and most unlikely to change any mindsets and business models.
Can universities be locally and globally engaged?concerning university policies there are at least two communities and they don’t come together, they don’t even talk to each other.
We tried with the report to bring together the global community and the competitiveness community. These are two separate sets of academics and politicians and we have tried from the beginning to have this mix in every chapter. But I must confess that they had different opinions and did not reach a common view. That is interesting in itself. People – researchers of higher education – are studying universities and university policies from each perspective and coming together as a community but not talking to the other community.
It shows how difficult it will be to attain the dual engagement we are talking about. There is a dominance in the day-to-day work of universities of local demands. They are on the table of rectors every day, the demands of society. So that is prevailing and the discourse about the global needs, if there, is present in a softer way.
It should not be like this. And that is why our final conclusion is making a call to universities to include the global perspective in their mission, not just bring it into their day-to-day work, but into the definition of their work.
Brendan O'Malley talks to Francesc Xavier Grau for University World News. An interesting discussion that reminds me to some extent of similar ones in the aid industry: Why should 'we' give to 'them' when we also have needs here...?!?
↧
Hi all,
Some writing took place ‘behind the scene’ this week, but there’s still time for a great link review with lots to explore across all the themes!
Development news:Diabetes in Mexico; malpractice in Ghana; immersive storytelling; organizational growth-what is it good for?; UN bureaucracy in Lebanon; the forests of the Congo Basin; BBC Media Action’s new data portal; gender security for aid workers; case studies on drones for humanitarian use; African podcasts.
Our digital lives:Digital newsrooms in Botswana & Sri Lanka; the demands of friendliness; love in the time of cryptography.
Publications: New books on industrialization, doughnut economics, cultural anthropology, women in the digital sector & Nepal’s peace process.
Academia: A day in the life of an academic mom; rules for academic commentary in media; crowdsourcing needs more scrutiny; the myth of tenured radicals in the neoliberal university.
Enjoy!
Development news
Some great tweet to explore at #WCPH2017!
How Diabetes Got To Be The No. 1 Killer In Mexico"Diabetes is now one of the biggest problems in the health system in Mexico," he says. It's the first cause of death. It's the first cause of disability. It's the first cause of early retirement. It's the main cost for the health system."
Diabetes costs the Mexican health care system billions of dollars each year.
The disease can lead to serious eye problems including blindness, nerve damage that requires amputations and kidney failure, among other issues.
Jason Beaubien for NPR Goats & Soda on one of the big issues for the future of #globaldev: Changing lifestyles, public health and the shift from poverty to 'Western' diseases as a threat to development and social change.
Development Malpractice In Ghana There is a huge opportunity cost to failure. When you do something stupid, you either a) wreck something that is working or could have worked, or b) or blow the people’s one chance to get anything ever. Once a well is drilled, a clinic built, or a program delivered, an NGO or government official checks a box, and future resources go somewhere else. Failure is worse than nothing.
Kevin Starr for SSIR with story of failure from Ghana that goes beyond the typical fail-fest-high-fiving and addresses real impact, malpractice and consequences beyond 'failing better' or learning.
How can NGOs use Immersive Storytelling to further their cause Producing 360 films is getting cheaper, but I did overhear someone say they produced a film for around $35,000 which is cheap. Is it cheap? What is the return on investment? Maybe it’s more to do with training opportunity cost as I genuinely don’t believe that NGOs will recoup the costs of producing a 360 film with donations. One of the panellists claimed that VR increases the conversion rate for NGOs by 100%, another panellist estimated 80%. I didn’t challenge this or ask what they meant by conversion rate – I should have done. Are they talking about donations? Are we due to see an army of street fundraisers armed with VR headsets in the future? Scary thought.
David Girling for Social Media and Development shares some reflections on a recent event on the future of immersive journalism and storytelling.
The Refugee Rethink: Part TwoFirst, it turns out financial growth is not a proxy for growth in impact — it’s just financial growth. The “more awesome” bit didn’t work out; at best we just got bigger.
Second, influence works both ways. In trying to influence others, you can be influenced yourselves. You can unwittingly become part of the status quo, even become its very instrument.
And, third, mediocrity at scale is worse than low-level or isolated mediocrity. Large organizations, well-intentioned or not, can become over-confident. And when compounded by immense financial pressures (bills to pay, and growth needs growth), they can move further and further away from the customer: refugees and people in need.
Daniel Wordsworth for the American Refugee Committee shares critical reflections on the aid industry.
Communication as aid: Key takeaways from the Humanitarian ICT Forum“The biggest takeaway for me has been that the humanitarian community is way behind the status of technology in the field,” said Anahi Ayala Iacucci, senior director of humanitarian programs at Internews. “The reality is that the humanitarian technology landscape is ... advancing really fast and we are late.”
She attended the conference to get a sense of the humanitarian ICT sector today, after three years working away from this community in Liberia and South Sudan, she said. Walking away from the conference, she advised humanitarian professionals to approach the private sector with clear asks; but also to realize that it is not an NGO, and is not there to serve the humanitarian community.
Catherine Cheney for DevEx shares her reflection from the ICT Forum. A bit heavy on the buzzwords, but in the end also a reminder that 'innovation' is a collaborative process not just a replacement of the aid industry with the ICT sector.
UN Resistance Threatens Effective Aid to Syrian Refugees DFID and ECHO should now find a way urgently to open this tender up to other service providers—including private sector organisations such as Mastercard and PayPal—to take on the role over which the UN agencies are squabbling. (This may need some tweaking of procurement rules.) That kind of competition would push the UN agencies to improve their offer, or be driven out of this market. And in the long run, that would be better for everyone.
Owen Barder for CGDev with a case study on bureaucratic procedures vs. potential aid delivery impact on the ground.
The world’s craving for chocolate and coffee is damaging Africa’s forestsThe threat to forests is largely influenced by the move of harvesting for export-oriented commodities from South America and Southeast Asia to Africa. An abundance of land, lax land regulations, and cheap labor has contributed to large-scale landholders acquiring 22.7 million hectares of land across sub-Saharan Africa in the last decade. From 1980-2000, 95% of the cropland expansion in Africa replaced forest.
Abdi Latif Dahir for Quartz with some scary numbers and trends from Africa and the Congo Basin-environmental degradation is real and expansive!
Do U.N. forces work closely with host country governments? Not in Congo.The FARDC does not have much more trust in the blue helmets. Reflecting conspiracy theories that have widespread currency in Congolese society, many officers believe the U.N. mission perpetuates the country’s lack of security to prolong MONUSCO’s presence. This allows U.N. personnel to continue to benefit from their generous salaries and risk allowances. These beliefs have given rise to the popular expression “no Nkunda, no job,” referring to one of DRC’s most notorious ex-rebel leaders.
These negative mutual perceptions are both a cause and a consequence of weak interoperability between the two forces. Many officers interviewed for my research were skeptical about the “jointness” of joint operations, stating that MONUSCO has limited influence on drawing up operational plans. Such weak interoperability hampers MONUSCO’s capability to protect civilians and circumscribes the possibility for knowledge and skills transfer.
Judith Verweijen for Washington Post's Monkey Cage blog shares some of her insights from her research on UN peacekeeping non-cooperation in Congo.
How the Congo crisis reshaped international relationsAt the center of this divergence of views were also different visions of the UN and its potential and utility in managing the process of decolonization. The ending of the secession by UN forces in 1962 reflected that African and Asian countries could implement anti-colonial policies through the UN, even when this was contrary to the interests of European colonial powers. By destroying Western consensus, highlighting the agency of anti-colonial actors and demolishing the last vestiges of Belgian colonial rule in the Congo, the UN action thereby represented the first important defeat of imperialist internationalism in Central Africa.
Alanna O'Malley for Africa is a Country with a historical essay on the crisis in Congo and how it changed international relations-not least it because the question 'Who killed Hammarskjöld?' still needs answers.
Five questions our data portal can help answerEnter our new Data Portal (view on desktop), which brings together data, reports and visualisations from surveys conducted in 13 developing countries that there aren't a lot of statistics about. Over five years, we asked more than 75,000 (rarely polled) people about what they think, feel and want. The portal covers a range of issues from what they’re most worried about to how interested they are in politics.
We want these insights to help development leaders, practitioners and researchers better understand ordinary people in the developing world so they can produce more effective strategies, projects and communications.
Sonia Whitehead for BBC Media Action presents their new data portal.
Gender Security for Aid Workers Part 2Perhaps the most important learning I have taken from this experience is the rarity of these conversations. Most participants say that this is the first time they have ever had this discussion in a work-related context. The absence of discussions about gender security among aid workers is a security problem in itself. Unless men and women can become comfortable talking openly about the varying security risks they face, there is less that can be done to mitigate the likelihood of the events or the impact that they will have.
In closing, I would like to challenge you to do two things.
First, ask yourself, what are the security issues that concern you the most in your work context? And, what are you personally doing to mitigate the chance that you might be involved in a critical incident?
Linda Wagener for the Headington Institute with more food for thought on the emerging issues on gender and safety in humanitarian aid.
How Drones Can Help in Humanitarian CrisesAt the core of the research were 14 case studies from 10 countries that looked at the impact of drones in situations ranging from search and rescue, to damage assessments and camp management to transporting medical samples.
Denise Soesilo & Timo Luege for the Swiss Foundation for Mine Action presenting their latest report on Unarmed Aerial Vehicles in humanitarian contexts.
Kamal R Mahtani: Using systematic reviews to reduce research waste—who really cares?Scientific, ethical, and economic reasons make it essential to conduct a systematic review of existing evidence before considering a new study. Failure to do this is simply poor practice. This recent survey shows that there is still work to be done to ensure that this principle is clearly and demonstrably supported. Given their large budgets and major influence on what does and does not get financial support, funding agencies have a particular responsibility to lead this initiative.
Kamal R Mahtani for bmj; this may fit equally well in the Academia section, but systemic reviews are also a topic in development research and they deserve more attention/funding.
Top African Podcasts
With the continued rise of reliable internet, free audio programmes, popularly known as podcasts, are making a buzz on the continent. Here are few podcasts we really think you should check out.
Africa.com with an interesting list of podcasts from, on and about the continent.
Our digital lives
A tale of two (digital) newsroomsThe secret is to deliver a stream of digital content so valuable that users simply can’t do without it. That meant taking a close look at exactly who Echelon is targeting and what really makes them tick, from the fund manager or entrepreneur to members of the Sri Lankan diaspora keen to reconnect with their home country.
“While we expected to be updating skills, discovering processes and sharpening awareness, we didn't expect to be confronted with challenges about understanding our audiences and breakthroughs around our own products,” Echelon Editor-in-Chief Shamindra Kulamannage wrote.
Timothy Large with interesting insights from the 'digital news front lines' in Botswana and Sri Lanka.
Politeness isn’t enough; we now demand friendliness. And it’s destroying authenticityBut from another perspective, the constant need to put on a good face and charm others can look dystopian. The first episode of Black Mirror’s latest season, “Nosedive,” shows a not-too-distant future where every person has an individual score, made up of ratings given by every person they encounter throughout the day. This rating doesn’t just affect their ability to get a cab ride, but what property they can rent or jobs they can have. It’s a world of constant, forced optimism and no genuine emotions.
Olivia Goldhill for Quartz with yet another aspect of self-branding, self-optimization and public performance in an era of the quantified self...
Love in the Time of Cryptography“I feel like what we keep in our minds is more important,” he wrote to me over WhatsApp recently. “The accuracy of it is…mah.” This is his disdain for this digital accuracy, and it captures something. There’s an obvious, almost legalistic veracity of moment-to-moment logging, but that loses a truth that the impressionism of memory catches better. I didn’t fall in love with him word by word or sentence by sentence. I fell in love with him slowly and steadily through time, in the spaces between the words, held up by the words. Losing the words sometimes feels frustrating, but that forgetting also removes the scaffolding from a finished past—a past that was never really containable in a logfile.
Quinn Norton for Backchannel with a beautiful story that does exactly what the title promises.
Hot off the digital press
Review of Doughnut Economics – a new book you will need to know about But great ideas, and brilliant framing, still make change – and this book is a classic combination of both. If only 10% of the ideas get implemented, the world will be a much better place. And I’m always happy to help if Kate wants to write a follow up – Doughnut Politics anyone?
Duncan Green with a book review for From Poverty to Power.
Perspectives: An Open Invitation to Cultural Anthropology The first peer-reviewed open access textbook for cultural anthropology courses. Produced by the Society for Anthropology in Community Colleges
A great new open access resource that confirms that anthropology is at the forefront of innovative publishing and breaking with old habits and traditions!
Women’s Pathways to the Digital Sector: Stories of Opportunities and ChallengesThis study aims at understanding the role of ICT in realising women’s rights, gender equality and women’s economic empowerment in order to identify the challenges and opportunities for women and girls to partake in ICT education and employment. The following presents a two-fold approach, consisting of a desk study and biographical interviews. The 22 portrayed women work in different roles in ICT and come from developing as well as emerging countries from all continents
Panoply Digital on behalf of the German Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development.
Two steps forward, one step back: the Nepal peace process In reviewing Nepal’s peace process, this 26th edition in our Accord series takes a special focus on the function of power on inclusion, and the role of the peace process as a means to facilitate transition from negative to positive peace, or from horizontal (elite) to vertical (societal) inclusion.
Conciliation Resources with a substantial 150 page document on the Nepal peace process.
Academia
A Day In The Life Of An Academic MomBlogger Tania Lombrozo is an academic — and a mom. Here, she gives a window into what that's like day-to-day.
Tania Lombrozo for NPR with a pretty accurate picture on how many academics spend their 12 hour work days in the 'ivory tower'...
Lagassé’s rules for academic commentary in popular media Op-eds and blogs are a great way of offering an informed, but provocative perspective. If there’s a topic in your area of expertise in the news, you should write about it and use your knowledge to offer a novel perspective, particularly if you expect most columnists to stick with rote points. You can also use op-eds and blogs to put new ideas out there. If you’ve got a hunch about something based on your expertise, then you can use these venues to test the waters. In both cases, however, it’s imperative that you tell the reader that you’re being exploratory or that you’re making an educated analysis, not representing the findings of a research project.
Philippe Lagassé with some basic points on how academics can engage with journalism in a win-win way.
With great power comes great responsibility: crowdsourcing raises methodological and ethical questions for academiaAs researchers and academic knowledge producers, we should not forget the parameters of knowledge production. We need to think about and reflect on the methodological underpinnings of new digital methods. To begin, we should reflect on who and what the “crowd” is and what this means for our particular study. To do so, we can draw on a pragmatist methodology that requires us to be candid about what we do and why, in relation to our end goal. We should remember that crowdsourcing stems from business and the structure of many commonly used platforms will shape our data.
With crowdsourcing come great opportunities, but also great responsibility.
Isabell Stamm and Lina Eklund for LSE Impcat of Social Science with a reminder that 'sexy' digital methods still need a lot of critical academic reflection-and that a lot of c'crowd' is happening inside a black box of propitiatory systems that researchers do not have full access to.
Just Wait Until I Get Tenure This is as true on campus as it is on the factory floor, in offices, in retail establishments. Professors routinely acquiesce to employer demands that they be repeatedly assessed, with techniques that imply that student performance and even success in life can be correlated directly to what a teacher does in the classroom. Really, it is no different than when college administrators urge faculty to tighten their belts because better times are coming. Like sheep, they comply, year after year, but those good times never come. Faculty just continue to lose weight. The professor who says, wait until I get tenure and then I will activate my radical heart and soul, is lying.
Michael D. Yates for Counter Punch on the myth of tenured radicals.
↧
Hi all,
If you are celebrating Easter you are probably looking for some good readings for the long weekend!
Development news:AP investigates UN peacekeeping troubles in Haiti; do we need less humanitarian crises appeals? The complexities around outsourcing surrogacy; extreme poverty to rise in Southern Africa; Skoll World Forum between innovation & buzzword bingo; ICT4D failings around Syrian refugees; how to protect staff who have to watch digital atrocities? Aid worker lives in the Philippines; Is ‘beg-packing’ a thing in Asia? Finding a good M&E guide; #allmalepanel.
Our digital lives: Who benefits from ‘fake news’? How Al Jazeera grew its video audience.Publication:C4D Network Mapping study.
Academia:A syllabus for the refugee crisis; #OER17 was a good conference; gendered academia& women’s service load; the extinct species of the dangerous academic.
Enjoy!
Development news
AP Exclusive: UN child sex ring left victims but no arrestsU.N. officials went to Haiti to investigate, but the Pakistanis abducted the boy to keep him from detailing the abuse that had gone on for more than a year, according to Peter Gallo, a former U.N. investigator familiar with the case.
Finally, the men were tried in a Pakistani military tribunal, and eventually sent back to Pakistan. In theory, the tribunal could have allowed for better access to witnesses, but it's unclear whether any were called. The Pakistani authorities also refused to allow the U.N. to observe the proceedings. In the end, one man was sent to prison for a year, according to Ariane Quentier, a spokeswoman for the Haiti mission.
"It's an indictment of how the whole U.N. system works," Gallo told the AP.
Pakistan's military has refused several requests for comment on the case.
Paisley Dodds for AP highlights some of the inherit governance problems in UN peacekeeping in her detailed long-read. When undemocratic, untrained and unaccountable armed forces are deployed around the world to 'keep peace' they are exporting their ethos to other parts of the world. More money for better training and selection of peacekeepers and a more substantial involvement of better trained armies would be a first step-but it costs money which no country is really willing to invest and political effort; the UN pretty much needs to take the peacekeepers they get offered-and in Haiti it has done a lot of harm.
Crisis appeals cost us political actionEqually culpable are the development investments and political processes that have failed to resolve the protracted conflicts that push countries and communities to the brink.
So, rather than using fear and pity to raise awareness and funds, why not use social and mainstream media to tap into public outrage and activism and address what put these countries in crisis in the first place?
This means putting pressure on politicians to invest political capital and energy into ending conflicts. It also means pushing aid agencies and their donors to act early and with a substantial injection of funds to prevent loss of life and human suffering where we know it is likely to occur.
Christina Bennett for ODI. I am not sure what 'evidence' and mainstream media can do right now about Yemen, South Sudan or parts of Nigeria. There is neither political will nor any movement towards long-term, preventative action. The fact that the aid industry resorts to talking about 'the worst crisis ever' is a sign of the helplessness of those who have been around, who have been on the ground and who have been sending warning signs when 'the West' first decided that they should turn a blind eye on Saudi-Arabia's military action in Yemen, for example.
Outsourced labour: international surrogacy and women’s rightsBut the voice that we perhaps most need to hear in this debate is the voice of women who work as surrogates. As governments scramble for answers, both in developed and developing countries, it is this voice that is missing from policy debates. Parents seeking surrogates to carry their children have mobilised and organised in many countries – including in Australia, where they advocated successfully for a parliamentary inquiry. Western feminists are debating and disagreeing on this issue. But it is not our bodies and livelihoods that are on the line.
Civil society and development actors may need to consider how best they can support the raising of surrogate voices, so they are not marginalised in debates that centre on their own protection and exploitation.
Ashlee Betteridge on the Devpolicy blog presents the emerging issue around global surrogacy with a broad range of interesting arguments, focusing on Australia and Cambodia as case studies.
Extreme poverty set to rise across Southern AfricaFirst, Southern African economic growth has not and is not expected to trickle down to the most vulnerable members of society. Southern Africa has the highest level of inequality (as measured by the Gini coefficient) of any region in the world and is expected to see a slight increase in inequality over time.
Second, Southern Africa has not and is not expected to register economic growth that is high enough to both provide for its rapidly growing population and pull up those already in poverty. The region as a whole is expected to average 3.5% annual growth (see Figure 3 for regional variation) to 2040, which is lower than every other region on the continent save for Central Africa. Meanwhile, population growth is expected to average 2% over the same time period.
Alex Porter for the Institute of Strategic Studies with an important reminder that the macro debate on 'the world is in a better state and fewer people live in poverty' is much more complicated; capitalist growth is not the 'solution'.
The end of the new age of humanitarianism: Insights from the Skoll World Forum So if I haven’t made it clear: The terminology in this community is incredibly fuzzy and fraught. It’s not just at the Skoll forum where well-meaning people use terms that sound wonderful and then seem to vaporize into thin air (the meaningfulness of the terms, that is; not the people) when you ask for precise definitions or specifics. This is a semantic ailment that afflicts the entire humanitarian community.
Tom Paulson for Humanosphere with a long piece from the Skoll forum. The Bono picture almost made me not read it. I did in the end & it's a good piece, but I wonder whether it's focusing too much on the 'VIPs'-all of which already get a lot of airtime. I do like that the article points out some of the 'buzzword bingo' around the discourse of 'social entrepreneurism'-I bet 'innovation', 'digital' and 'impact' featured heavily in the discussions as well...
Techno-utopian solutions to Syria’s refugee crisis fall shortGrassroots groups like CRP also stress the importance of proximity and detailed local knowledge when designing programmes. Those backing tech projects from afar often don’t fully understand the needs they’re trying to serve, or how they fit into the broader context.
(...)
Critics say while RBK has proven its model works, for it to make a real difference, it must be able to reach more young refugees.
“The big question is, is this model scalable?” asked one aid worker familiar with the programme. "If it doesn’t scale, this fantastic, high-quality solution risks being a drop in the ocean.”
Sara Elizabeth Williams and Rana Sweis for IRIN with some insights on ICT4D projects in Jordan. We will be reading a lot more about failed tech projects, scaling-up that never happened and how the 'gig economy' leaves many behind in the coming years.
When watching violence is your job: workers on the digital frontline Traditionally, organisations have provided care and resilience training for staff sent on mission to work on the physical frontline, which is obviously important. There is a need, however, for this training to be extended to those working with distressing social media imagery—those working on the digital frontline. Managers and organisational structures need to be sensitive to vicarious or secondary trauma and the associated risk of post-traumatic stress disorder. While staff working in danger zones do, to some extent, have their mental health needs recognised, a stigma connected to mental wellbeing and viewing distressing imagery in the main headquarters of an organisation exists. Lifting this stigma—and the associated barrier to seeking help—is required so that those researchers who find and verify content sourced from social media can effectively raise awareness of human rights abuses.
Sam Dubberley for open democracy with an important reminder that mental well-being efforts should not just be limited to the traditional 'field' of humanitarian work, but also extend to the digital front lines.
Preliminary results from survey of aid and development workers in the PhilippinesOur current research in the Philippines is beginning to provide support for this statement. As you can see below, most -77%- agreed that “Filipino aid workers generally get paid less than expat (non-Filipino) aid workers doing the same or similar jobs in the Philippines.”
Tom Arcaro continues his inquiries into aid worker voices, looking at the Philippines and the relationships between expat and local aid workers.
'Beg-packers': White tourists who beg in southeast AsiaWe find it extremely strange to ask other people for money to help you travel. Selling things in the street or begging isn’t considered respectable. People who do so are really in need: they beg in order to buy food, pay their children’s school fees or pay off debts. But not in order to do something seen as a luxury!
(...)
This turns our continent into a caricature, a mystical land full of adventures or, in other words, a playground for white people. People come here on a journey of self-discovery, eager for exotic experiences. Sometimes, I want to ask them: what makes you think that this kind of behaviour is normal in Asia? Why don’t you do the same thing at home?
Sarra Grira for France24's The Observers. These are interesting observations from Asia, highlighting some of the problems of backpacking, voluntourism and journeys of self-discovery in the global South.
The Best Project Monitoring and Evaluation Guides
Vipul Nanda for Socialcops with a great range of resources that can serve as a primer into M&E guides.
If Men Really Didn't Like All-Male Panels, There Wouldn't Be All-Male PanelsUnfortunately, throughout our work at GenderAvenger we’ve found that nothing works quite as well as a little shame to motivate an organization to take action and be accountable. An old GenderAvenger friend, Ron Fournier, has a policy that when he finds himself on an all-male panel for work he will then immediately call the organization out publicly on social media. This draws attention to the problem, rallies people to support, and more often than not makes conference organizers think a little harder about their all-male panels for the next event.
Soraya Membreno for Gender Avenger with a reminder on how to deal with (and hopefully avoid) the notorious #allmalepanel...
Our digital lives
Who benefits from using the term ‘fake news’?All three of these constituencies have a claim to a grain of truth about fake news, and have forced it onto the agenda. It should also be acknowledged that the historical circumstances of 2016-2017 have been rather particular: a US election and an EU referendum involving very polarized choices in the context of a collapse of deference. So many promoting the concept of fake news have an axe to grind, but at the same time it cannot be denied that structural changes in media systems are transforming the procedures for verifying and distributing news.
Damian Tambini for the LSE Media Policy Project blog with a reminder that the 'fake news' agenda comes with a, well, agenda. Without a lot of evidence many stakeholders are discovering the concept-and if I was Jeff Jarvis and Facebook and other companies offered me 14 million to research 'fake news' I also wouldn't hesitate to tell the world how important it is...
We grew monthly Facebook video views 500% to 100M in six months. Here’s what we learned.We want to start important conversations, and add to others in a meaningful way. We want to showcase more people with stories, rather than stories with people. That could mean more mini-docs, more in-depth stories, more Facebook Lives from places and people that our audience can only find on Al Jazeera English, and a greater focus on markets such as India, Pakistan, Nigeria, Kenya, Uganda, South Africa, Indonesia, Malaysia, and the Philippines.
Ziad Ramley and Yasir Khan for AJ Labs with fascinating insights into Al Jazeera English' digital video efforts.
Fantastical MapsFlorida devotes just 18 pages to the megacities of the developing world. Most of his suggestions, like so many of the glittering renderings and fantastical maps that populate contemporary discourse about cities, are both theoretically appealing and practically infeasible. The right ideas at the wrong time.
(...)
It’s indicative of the tenor of this book, which is heavy on studies from sociologists and economists (at one point, there’s a page where more than half the sentences introduce a new ratio), but addresses history only in short anecdotes, and politics hardly at all. This blindness to the perversity of American politics (which Florida otherwise follows closely) weighs heavily on the book.
Henry Grabar review Richard Florida's latest book for Slate. It is important in the sense that sense that reminds us that 'evidence' and 'innovative ideas' are not enough to create sustainable and transformative social change-and that politics in many ways provides stronger resistance to change than in the decades before.
Hot off the digital press
Launch of our Network Yearbook and 2016/17 Network Mapping Study (March 2017)The most significant C4D approaches that are used are behaviour change and advocacy; followed by media development, social change communication and social mobilisation.
C4D contributes to many different programmeareas or themes in development, as determined by country context; key areas are health, education, and agriculture.
Many varied C4D areas (strategies, channels and tools) are used; and while social media and broadcasting are dominant channels, approachesand strategies are highly varied, but with a prioritising of participatory and edutainment methods.
The C4D Network presents findings from their recent global mapping exercise.
Academia
Syllabus: The 21st Century Worldwide Refugee CrisisTogether with faculty from the departments of Philosophy, Political Science, History, Geography, Economics, Education, and Environmental Studies, as well as a visiting photographer, representatives from two NGOs, and a Syrian refugee scholar, students study different aspect of the crisis to explore ways in which we, as global citizens, can contribute to alleviating this crisis.
Vassar College with an interesting course-and fantastic syllabus that can inspire your own teaching on the topic!
Conferences and CompatibilityThe danger of these kinds of conferences is that the feel-good vibes could hide some much-needed critique. In a space like oer17, many of us are already struggling as dissenters on our f2f contexts and just delighted to be in a space where others understand us without us having to defend our ideas from A to Z. However, we may be missing opportunities to be more self-critical, as Simon Ensor’s blogposts suggest (he participated virtually, but was a huge part of the conference experience for me). We may also consider the space harmonious and friendly, but we may not be aware of how it feels to others.
Maha Bali for The Chronicle summarizes her experiences at the #OER17 conference. An interesting example that shows both the possibilities of what academic conferencing can mean in the digital age even if there are some inherent challenges about the purpose of like-minded academics getting together. But conferences can be more than 'neoliberal commodities'...
Relying on Women, Not Rewarding Them“We find strong evidence that, on average, women faculty perform more service than male faculty in academia, and that the service differential is driven particularly by participation in internal rather than external service,” the study says. “When we look within departments -- controlling for any type of organizational or cultural factor that is department specific -- we still find large, significant differences in the service loads of women versus men.”
All that matters because service loads “likely have an impact on productivity in other areas of faculty effort such as research and teaching, and these latter activities can lead directly to salary differentials and overall success in academia,” the paper says. “In the urgency to redress not only differences in time use but compensation imbalances, as well, the service imbalance is one that deserves to rise to the forefront of the discussion.”
Colleen Flaherty for Inside Higher Ed with new research on gendered roles in academia. It's a complicated topic-maybe women have more 'impact' through their service work and men get the praise for publishing yet more books and articles with less impact on students and society? But the current system of metrics and numbers clearly rewards publishing over basically anything else...
The Dangerous Academic is an Extinct SpeciesThe corporatized university, like corporations generally, is an uncontrollable behemoth, absorbing greater and greater quantities of capital and human lives, and churning out little of long-term social value.
(...)
The corporatized university serves nobody and nothing except its own infinite growth. Students are indebted, professors lose job security, surrounding communities are surveilled and displaced. That is something dangerous.
Left professors almost certainly sense this. They see themselves disappearing, the campus becoming a steadily more stifling environment. Posturing as a macho revolutionary is, like all displays of machismo, driven partially by a desperate fear of one’s impotence. They know they are not dangerous, but they are happy to play into the conservative stereotype.
Yasmin Nair for Current Affair with lots of food for thought.
↧
↧
This has become a pit of a pet peeve of mine, but I am getting increasing annoyed when colleagues announce new publications and only include a direct link to the (mostly) paywalled source.
Especially on social media I often roll my eyes when links start with ‘sciencedirect.com’, ‘tandfonline.com’ or ‘cambridge.org’. Your exciting new product deserves better!
For the majority of ‘members of the public’, i.e. ‘normal’ people on social media this will almost inevitably lead to the frustrating experience of being faced with a paywall; if they are lucky they can still read the abstract, but it still feels like missing out. I doubt that anybody would share your article further.
I am, in fact, an academic with access to many journal databases-and I still find the experience of following a link to the publisher’s website frustrating!
Most of the time I use social media on a mobile device-usually not connected to the university network which often enables direct access to the article through my IP address-so I end up at said paywall as well.
Even if I have access to the full article I am faced with the comprehensive 19 page or so pdf file that may get saved to a folder on my computer (a.k.a. ‘pdf graveyard’)-or not. At this particular point in time I am probably not interested in your (full) paper yet anyway.
Create a simple landing page for your articles and academic work!
Usually a simple blog post with the abstract of the article, but also key findings, is a great start. Blog posts I can read and share!
The blog post also contains a LINK to the pre-print platform of your choice (Academia, ResearchGate etc.) or the option to download the pre-print directly from your website. THEN there is also a LINK to the journal’s homepage where I can download the full paper.
In my experience even a little effort goes a long way-imagine the one journalist who comes across your blog post or the curated link review that takes up your article because it can be read and shared relatively freely.
Academic colleagues and students should be able to find your article through Google Scholar and their libraries, but do take some minutes and create a window into your great research and important findings! Also, if you promote your article on Twitter and other networks your teasers should generate enough interest so readers click on the link, get hooked by the stuff they read in the blog post, download your paper-and cite away ;)!
↧
Hi all,
Welcome to a jam-packed link review!
Development news: #BringBackOurGirls-All they got was a hashtag?; pepsi-fication of resistance; Kathmandu is building back unsafe; mo’ #globaldev money, but less for poor people; the right way to give; has the aid industry lost its humanity to jargon and numbers? A new WFP graphic novel in South Sudan; should we treat refugee camps as long-term urban spaces? Outdated election observing; developing countries and digital start-ups; how to avoid stealing stories; the danger of a single story; Communication with communities in Haiti; Follow the car! Peacebuilding & material objects; one of those girls
Our digital lives:How will comms teams look like in 5 years’ time? Crowdfunding is reshaping giving; inside the bleak world of content moderation.
Publication:Academics on Twitter.
Academia:The deadly sins of statistical misinterpretation; how detailed should grading scales and matrices be? Reflections on an academic career.
Enjoy!
New from aidnography
The salary gap between expat and local aid workers – it’s complicatedOne issue that seems to get lost in the salary discussion is the risk of aid work being reduced to a capital city-centered endeavour. The global elite is as much present in Geneva or London as it is in Bangkok or Nairobi, but the bulk of aid work takes place in the field and we need to ensure adequate benefits for local and expat aid workers in different environments.
So how can we ensure that frontline health workers or drivers in the regional hubs are included in the conversation rather than focusing on who should have the right to send their children to the private American school?
Don’t post direct links to your new journal article!In my experience even a little effort goes a long way-imagine the one journalist who comes across your blog post or the curated link review that takes up your article because it can be read and shared relatively freely.
Development news
Three Years Later, the Chibok Girls Are Still Missing — And All They Got Was a HashtagThe reality is that much more can be done. I’ve come to gradually reduce my guilt by doing something for each social cause I tag. It may be donating, volunteering, marching, or directing and producing a documentary like the one I made about the Chibok girls. I’m not a filmmaker by training. In fact, as a Nigerian(born)-American(naturalized) former educator, Waiting for Hassana mostly began as a passion project I pursued with friends to bring the story of these girls back to the forefront. It’s through the strength of Jessica’s narrative — a Nigerian woman, now age 20 — that we hope audiences leave feeling linked to her life and her story. She is no longer an unknown under some now-defunct hashtag.
Funa Maduka for Teen Vogue on #BringBackOurGirls and how the hashtag inspired further action as a filmmaker.
The Pepsi-fication Of Resistance Has A Long And Ugly HistoryThis sanitization is not only lazy and rooted in inaccuracies, it’s dangerous, as it silences the cries of revolutionary [Black] people. Moreover, it creates the false and damning sense that if your form of protest is not equivalent to that of a Care Bear hug, it is not legitimate.
And no surprise here: Whitewashing has also long played a role in all this.
(...)
Simply put, the goal of Pepsi’s ad was…to sell Pepsi. They’re in the business of making money, and in this case, they attempted to make money by getting you to associate resistance with Pepsi. The subtext was both evident and icky: Grab a Pepsi, and you could become a revolutionary, too!
Riot gear, pepper spray, tear gas, and Black and Brown folx being beaten and disappeared into police vehicles by sadistic cops are missing from this representation because no sane capitalist would want to buy into that side of resistance. Nor is that something Pepsi would like to associate itself with.
Clarkisha Kent for The Establishment with a great essay that takes the issues raised by the Pepsi ad to the next intellectual level for discussion!
Building back unsafe“The earthquake shook people’s houses, but did not shake their mindset,” says Dinesh Pathak, another Tokha Municipality engineer. “They are trying to save some money, but their greed could cost them their lives next time.”
Om Ashta Rai for Nepali Times with a view from Kathmandu and a mindset that has been plaguing some parts of development and planning in Nepal for years and decades...
Development aid rises again in 2016 but flows to poorest countries dipOverall, total net ODA rose in 22 countries in 2016, with the biggest increases in the Czech Republic, Germany, Italy, Poland, Slovak Republic, Slovenia and Spain. For some the increases were due to higher refugee costs. ODA fell in seven countries, with the largest declines seen in Australia, Finland, the Netherlands and Sweden. Of the several non-DAC members who report their aid flows to the OECD body, the United Arab Emirates posted the highest ODA/GNI ratio in 2016 at 1.12%.
2016 saw Germany join five other countries – Denmark, Luxembourg, Norway, Sweden and the United Kingdom – in meeting a United Nations target to keep ODA at or above 0.7% of GNI. The Netherlands slipped back below 0.7% to join 22 other donors under the threshold.
The OECD with some numbers on aid budgets.
The Right Way to GiveWe really can make a difference by thinking twice before putting postage on material stuff, and instead putting money we'd spend on postage directly into a local organization's coffers. Ask your neighbors, members of your religious community and your social networks what organizations or initiatives are already doing good work. Organizations on the front lines of the emerging famine crisis need our help, but they also need us to think critically before providing it.
Noelle Sullivan for U.S. News with a reminder to think before donate and to think even harder before you send stuff to 'Africa'.
Secret aid worker: we've lost our humanity to jargon and statisticsHave the lofty ideals of development to reduce global inequality and give all people a decent quality of life been abandoned in pursuit of making the very, very poor only very poor? The bar for success has been lowered so far, I’m afraid all of us in the aid sector just walk right over it. And in doing so, we have side-stepped our humanitarian calling.
The Guardian's Secret aid worker column with a widely shared and discussed piece on the 'soul' of aid work.
U.N. creates striking graphic novel to spark empathy around South Sudan famineNow, LL3: South Sudan takes readers to the world's newest country to meet just a few of the 4.9 million South Sudanese people impacted by food insecurity and learn about the lifesaving efforts to help them.
Matt Petronzio for Mashable introduces the second installment of the WFP-sponsored graphic novel Living Level 3. I reviewed the first installment last year and look forward to reading the next story!
Q&A: Former Zaatari refugee camp chief on the tandem approach to urban planningWe’re working within a logic that has, so far, been that governments are in charge of hosting displaced people, but they shift that responsibility to humanitarian agencies. None of these structures have the right reflexes and the right skill set to develop a functioning system that is ecologically and economically sustainable. That responsibility needs to be handed over in order to ensure sustainability, innovation and change.It’s basically building a new city, and that is not done by the development agency. That is done by, for example, a public private partnership. It's not about a tech provider helping a [nongovernmental organization]
Helen Morgan talk to Kilian Kleinschmidt for DevEx about re-thinking refugee camps and understanding them as long(er)-term urban spaces. Definitely food for thought-and tricky to sell to many host governments...
International election observation is decades out of date. I should know.However, one result of these two shifts – the rise of the tick-box, combined with a diluted version of decentralised observation – is that scrutiny of elections has become heavily focused around the day of voting itself.
Observers are dispersed to their stations just a few days prior to the vote, and governments and electoral commissions concentrate their energies on mounting an Election Day that conforms to international norms, precisely for the benefit of international officials.
This means that the preceding weeks of campaigning around the country get much less scrutiny. Yet it is in this period that systemic violence, widespread bribery and unjust infringements on freedoms of movement and expression can ensure that an election is far from “free and fair”, even if voting day itself is exemplary.
Stephen Chan for African Arguments. It's a piece from February, but still relevant ;)! He makes a good point that 'elections' often get reduced to the act of voting-great to create news images (I wrote about it here on the blog Burkas, ballots & the unbearable lightness of democratic rituals), but only one aspect of 'free and fair elections'-especially as the digital age is adding a whole different layer of complexity to the whole election process.
How Context Impacts Developing Country Digital Start-UpsGovernments must do more to build up local digital sector institutions which act as key intermediaries both within the local digital economy and between local and global digital economies.
Digital start-ups must self-analyse the constraints and freedoms imposed by their embeddedness. And they must customise models and methods from the global North; for example, rescoping the Lean Start-Up methodology to take a broader bi-sectoral and socio-political remit.
Richard Heeks for Development Implications of Digital Economies (DIODE) Strategic Research Network with research findings on start-ups in Africa.
No More Stolen StoriesAt last, the hardest part in the process is the presentation. For a full profile description, go back to the subject and read them what you wrote. This might be uncomfortable, but you should do it anyway. They lived it, so they’re the best person to edit it. Let them tell you where your facts go astray or where they feel you’re misrepresenting them in the story. It is time consuming and nerve-racking, but it’s the right thing to do, and who ever said that was easy?
Jeff Paddock for La Ceiba with some good guidelines and resources on how to ensure ethical storytelling.
The danger of a single authorSo while it seems admirable to get more people to read works that address cross-cultural experience all the while shoring up a dwindling book-publishing industry, as is so often the case with literary celebrity, the choice of Americanah may have less to do with aesthetic merit, in the end, than with the narrow geopolitical space allotted to African fiction in the West. This then swiftly undermines Adichie’s celebrated caveat about “The Danger of a Single Story.”
Lily Saint for Africa Is A Country on selecting Ngozi Adichi's book as the winner of the 'One book, one New York campaign'.
What a Feedback Loop Looks LikeOne of the central ideas of ‘Communication with Communities’ (CwC) is that information — both its provision and collection — shouldn’t be a standalone activity; rather, it should be something that occurs continuously and is integrated into programming no matter the sector. Aid workers focused on health, nutrition, community and should all have a role in the ‘information ecosystem,’ as face-to-face communication is a widely trusted means to receive information and give their feedback.
(...)
An emergency response isn’t meant to be a static pillar; it’s a mutable organism that should adapt to the ever-changing needs of a population in crisis. And those needs are often readily expressed by affected communities. We just need to be there to take them seriously.
Rose Foran for Internews on how communication for/in/with development has worked in Haiti.
M&E Thursday Talk - Follow that car! Telling the story of conflict and peacebuilding through material objectsResearchers, including Monitoring and Evaluation specialists, face a crisis of access in many conflict and post-conflict areas. Often it is too dangerous to conduct on-site research and so researchers have to be innovative in the methodologies they use and may have to investigate proxies for the phenomenon they wish to observe. This webinar was based on a case study of following material objects (the social life of things) as a way of narrating conflict, peacebuilding and humanitarianism. It will illustrate how 4x4 (SUV) usage in Darfur can be useful in putting together a conflict analysis. It draws on an on-going research project that engages in methodological scoping in relation to peacekeeping data and humanitarian information systems.
Roger MacGinty for dm&e for peace presenting research on alternative everyday peace indicators and how SUVs can help you in conflict analysis.
One of those girlsI don’t know how to tell my parents that I won’t be subscribing to this twisted mating ritual. I want to find someone who’s going to love me for me. Someone who wouldn’t run because they found out I used to have sleepovers. These ideas are an issue. For my parents they represent a barrier between me and the perfect Arab life they have planned. Sometimes I wish I wasn’t like this. That I could just follow the rules, not ask questions and just accept things the way they are. But I have to remind myself of all the girls who grew up in households less permissive than mine, of all the girls that wouldn’t have been allowed to even think these things, let alone discuss them. I have to recognize my privilege and use it in a way that will benefit them. The fights I have are not for me alone; they’re for my sisters, my cousins, my friends, and every girl who’s ever been told not to wear that outfit lest Auntie thinks she’s one of those girls.
Asmaa Mabrouk for sister-hood is one of those girls-those girls that will hopefully continue to write great stuff and change the world!
Our digital lives
communications teams – how will they look in 5 years’ time?Gone, or at very least going, are the days of communications teams' primary functions being press related. The days of churning out press releases, cutting out articles and chasing our tails at the behest of journalists are making way for dynamic, responsive and engaging campaigns, with perhaps a whole lot of tail chasing at the behest of the general public, who won't wait very long for our responses on social media.
And everyone seems to agree that also gone are the days of silos and specialisms within a communications team, partly because even the mammoth councils are being forced to reconsider their familiar way of working in the face of budget cuts.
Shirah Bamber for comms2point0 with a perspective from a UK city council that raises interesting questions for, among other things, the aid industry as well.
How Will The Rise Of Crowdfunding Reshape How We Give To Charity? People still appear willing to give to organizations–and repeatedly–if they can mimic the level of supposed transparency that makes crowdfunding appealing. Such groups may even offer an additional benefit at a time when more sites seem to catalog almost every type of human suffering. “You see all those cases and they keep coming,” adds Nilsen at AFP. “Giving to a charitable organization is one way to feel like you are a part of something bigger.”
It’s probably not a coincidence that GoFundMe and GiveDirectly both operate extremely lean and clearly show where each donation will wind up. Both are enabling person-to-person transactions with trust that recipients themselves will know how best to use the funds. Even in the cases of a specific GoFundMe going viral, there’s no mandate for campaigns to have to explain how the overflow will be used, beyond the fact that lots of people are obviously now watching.
Ben Paynter for Fast Company on how donating is changing in an era of crowdfunding and what impacts it has on traditional organizations and campaigns.
A new documentary goes inside the bleak world of content moderation“The Moderators” explores the answer, going inside on office in India where the process happens. Directed by Ciaran Cassidy and Adrian Chen, a journalist who has written about the moderation process, the documentary is a window into a largely hidden part of the internet work force: employees who sit in an office and make decisions about whether to remove explicit photos, or who examine dating site profiles to weed out fakes.
Colin Lecher for The Verge introduces an interesting and slightly disturbing documentary on how digital companies keep their sites 'clean'.
Hot off the digital press
A systematic identification and analysis of scientists on TwitterIn this work, we have developed a systematic method to discovering scientists who are recognized as scientists by other Twitter users through Twitter list and self-identify as scientists through their profile. We have studied the demographics of identified scientists in terms of discipline and gender, finding over-representation of social scientists, under-representation of mathematical and physical scientists, and a better representation of women compared to the statistics from scholarly publishing. We have analyzed the sharing behaviors of scientists, reporting that only a small portion of shared URLs are science-related. Finally, we find an assortative mixing with respect to disciplines in the follower, retweet, and mention networks between scientists.
Qing Ke, Yong-Yeol Ahn and Cassidy R. Sugimoto for PLOS One for academic nerds like me who are interested in Twitter and scientific communication.
Academia
The seven deadly sins of statistical misinterpretation, and how to avoid themStatistics is a useful tool for understanding the patterns in the world around us. But our intuition often lets us down when it comes to interpreting those patterns. In this series we look at some of the common mistakes we make and how to avoid them when thinking about statistics, probability and risk.
Winnifred Louis and Cassandra Chapman for The Conversation with a primer on how to engage with statistics.
Should professors tell students exactly what they expect?One problem is that expectations anchor students. The minimum becomes the maximum, and limits what students achieve. "I've got three economics journal articles. That's enough, time to move on."
Also, overly explicit expectations are an inadequate preparation for the real world. In a work environment, no one will say "I expect your research report to be spell checked and have page numbers. And, by the way, it should not be plagiarized". Part of the human capital gained in a university education is knowledge of the unwritten rules, the social norms and conventions, of intellectual life.
A related point is that part of understanding the course material is understanding what's important and what's not. When students are told precisely what will be on the exam, their ability to identify key concepts - to figure out what matters - is not tested. Instead, what's tested is students' ability to read and follow instructions. The students who succeed are the ones who are able to successfully imitate the model answers posted on the website, not the ones who come up with creative and innovative ideas.
Frances Woolley for Worthwhile Canadian Initiative with nuanced discussion on the down- and up-sides of grading scales and matrices for assessing students' work.
Some Lesser Known Lessons from AcademiaI have heard early career graduate students or undergraduates considering academia say things like “I wouldn’t mind starting out at a place like the University of Kansas,” or some other institution they perceive to be of similarly low prestige. Let me be clear: you probably won’t get a job at Kansas. Getting a job at Kansas would be fantastic and is therefore exceedingly difficult. For nearly all students outside of the very top graduate programs, a job at Kansas (or similar institution) is almost certainly your best-case scenario. If you have family ties that prevent you from living outside a certain area, or a partner with an inflexible job, you will be very unlikely to find an academic job.
Daniel McCormack provides a critical assessment of what a career in academia will probably mean for many (especially in North America).
↧
You read about the references to The Onion, saw the outraged tweets and global disbelief as Saudi Arabia was elected into the UN Commission on the Status of Women.
‘Electing Saudi Arabia to protect women’s rights is like making an arsonist into the town fire chief. It’s absurd.’ Hillel Neuer, director of UN Watch is quoted by The Independent.
But as justified as critique of Saudi-Arabia is, it is important to look beyond the headlines and re-affirm a few core working principles of the UN system (some of which you can and should be critical about-but that’s another blog post, perhaps).
Saudi-Arabia is a normal member state of the UN
Saudi-Arabia is a regular member state of the UN. The UN system does not judge, there are no ‘good’ or ‘bad’ members-there are just members. According to the international justice system Saudi-Arabia has not been found guilty of any crimes or wrongdoings-no matter how questionable its engagement in Yemen is. Diplomatically speaking, there is no difference between Sweden, Saudi-Arabia and Vanuatu. It is a core principle that keeps the UN working with more than 190 member states. So for the UN bureaucracy there is nothing special about Saudi-Arabia as one of the members of a UN commission that relies on regional representation.
Member states do things, not ‘the UN’
Secondly, it is important to point out that ‘the UN’ did not do anything or appoint anybody. Member states voted-and some voted for Saudi-Arabia. International politics and diplomacy are messy, favors and support are sometimes negotiated behind the scenes, but that is true for many countries or commissions.
Plenty of states also openly support Saudi-Arabia, for example the UK and the US by supplying arms to them. That is bad-but it is also perfectly legal and the UN is not above the law or in the business of making moral judgements.
Can the work in the commission enhance accountability?
Third, it is worth having a look at the actual work of the commission and how Saudi-Arabia as a member might fit into it: Under its current methods of work, (...) at each session the Commission:
Holds a ministerial segment to reaffirm and strengthen political commitment to the realization of gender equality and the empowerment of women and girls as well as their human rights and to ensure high-level engagement and the visibility of the deliberations of the Commission;
Engages in general discussion on the status of gender equality (…)
(…)
Addresses emerging issues, trends, focus areas and new approaches to questions affecting the situation of women, that require timely consideration;
Plays a catalytic role for gender mainstreaming in the United Nations system
(…)
Agrees on further actions for the promotion of gender equality and the empowerment of women by adopting agreed conclusions and resolutions
As powerless as the commission may be in real terms, it does typical UN things-diplomacy, meetings, highlighting issues; why is it a bad thing to have Saudi-Arabia involved in these activities? How would excluding the country, including public shaming, help the commission and ultimately women in the country? The UN believes in incremental change and there are small signs that women’s rights are improving.
In theory, working in such a commission involves issues of transparency and accountability, yes, soft politics, non-binding targets and the occasional lofty speech.
Including a country like Saudi-Arabia in these dynamics is still not a bad idea-the UN system usually does not do punishment and believes that communication and cooperation are important aspects of how global governance works-with all its flaws and limitations.
So just to be clear: There are many things you can and should be critical about when it comes to Saudi-Arabia – but electing them as a member to the Commission on the Status of Women is actually the right thing to do within the context of UN diplomacy.
Other members should put pressure on Saudi-Arabia-especially behind the scenes, but the UN is not the right scapegoat for messy international relations and hypocritical relationships that include money, oil and weapons…
↧
Hi all,
Another good week for #globaldev debates!
Development news:Special section on the aid industry in contemporary America kicks of this review; sweatshops & industrialization in Ethiopia; Turkey’s crackdown on NGOs; Should World Bank staff visit the field? IKEA is upgrading its refugee shelters; Nepal earthquake anniversary; the complexities of social change in ‘mini-Indias’; local aid workers in the Philippines; the gig economy in the South; ICT4D for girls & women; bad schools may not always be bad ideas; can the UN system do innovation? #allmalepanel? There’s an app for/against it!
Our digital lives:Facebook admits government exploitations; Silicon valley won’t be fixing health systems in the global South; rich charities are getting richer; thought leaders & plutocrats.
Publication:Blockchains for development.
Academia: New UnPaywall extension.
Enjoy!
New from aidnography
Electing Saudi-Arabia to the UN Commission on the Status of Women is not a bad ideaThere are many things you can and should be critical about when it comes to Saudi-Arabia – but electing them as a member to the Commission on the Status of Women is actually the right thing to do within the context of UN diplomacy.
Other members should put pressure on Saudi-Arabia-especially behind the scenes, but the UN is not the right scapegoat for messy international relations and hypocritical relationships that include money, oil and weapons…
Development news
I’ve worked in foreign aid for 50 years—Trump is right to end it, even if his reasons are wrongIf the aid industry were to listen to its critics, it would have to conclude that development aid ought to be less about money and more about collegial discourse, with “us” admitting that we really have very few answers. By far the most important conclusion to draw is that if the goal of development aid to poor countries is to be met, our agencies need to become smaller, not larger; we need to take a back seat and “do” less. Indeed someday soon, we need to prepare to go out of business. No industry wants to hear this, but aid is not like the auto industry. It was meant not to last.
Tom Dichter for Quartz.
It’s the end of foreign aid as we know it, and I feel fineLess infusion of external expertise might make more way for people with embedded, grounded knowledge. Maybe less “expertise” could make way for leaders, organizations, and movements, led by people of color, who are not in the business of aid to build careers and income, but are heading the call of needed social transformation to save their own communities. They have been doing less with more for ages – literally.
Jennifer Lentfer for HowMatters.
Dismantling USAIDAdvocates of a USAID merger make two basic arguments: that USAID is poorly managed and can’t be trusted to carry out U.S. foreign policy objectives, and that significant savings can be achieved by bureaucratic consolidation. Both are based on outdated information and faulty logic.
(...)
Dismantling USAID is the bad penny that keeps on turning up to distract attention from the real challenges to U.S. foreign aid and diplomacy. Those who want to see measurable progress in reducing global poverty and hunger and preventing conflict and crisis ought to stand up for the agency best placed to achieve it.
Diana Ohlbaum for LobeLog.
The debates around the aid industry, USAID and the purpose of international development have been discussed quite widely this week. I still would like to see more emphasis on the notion of development as a global solidarity project and movement to battle inequalities at various locations rather than focusing on organizational industry fatigue alone...
America is Regressing into a Developing Nation for Most PeopleThe richest large economy in the world, says Temin, is coming to have an economic and political structure more like a developing nation. We have entered a phase of regression, and one of the easiest ways to see it is in our infrastructure: our roads and bridges look more like those in Thailand or Venezuela than the Netherlands or Japan. But it goes far deeper than that, which is why Temin uses a famous economic model created to understand developing nations to describe how far inequality has progressed in the United States. The model is the work of West Indian economist W. Arthur Lewis, the only person of African descent to win a Nobel Prize in economics. For the first time, this model is applied with systematic precision to the U.S.
Lynn Parramore for the Institute of New Economic Thinking featuring Peter Temin's new book with more food for thought on 'third world America'.
Everything We Knew About Sweatshops Was WrongFor poor countries to develop, we simply do not know of any alternative to industrialization. The sooner that happens, the sooner the world will end extreme poverty. As we look at our results, we are conflicted: We do not want to see workers exposed to hazardous risks, but we also worry that regulating or improving the jobs too much too quickly will keep that industrial boom from happening.
Chris Blattman and Stefan Dercon for the New York Times. For me, this paragraph is worth further discussion as Jeff Sachs has started to talk about 'sustainable development' again. I doubt that the world can industrialize itself out of 'poverty'; the environmental impact, resource use and the way manufacturing is bound to change (automation etc.) will make it more and more difficult to rely on this traditional concept; also; globalization is a fickle thing-once garment workers become "too expensive" in Viet Nam jobs move to Burma-and there will be a new Ethiopia around in a few years time. I wonder whether the underlying development model needs more radical re-thinking?
Turkey steps up crackdown on humanitarian aid groupsAid groups still operating in Turkey were reluctant to comment openly on the matter for fear of their own licenses being revoked. But off-the-record interviews with IRIN suggest a shrinking operating space for international NGOs, many of which are based along the country’s southern border, providing cross-border relief to the northern Syrian provinces of Aleppo and Idlib.
Diego Cupolo for IRIN with more bad news from Turkey.
Are World Bank staffers, and projects, suffering from too much screen time?That means it is not sufficient for World Bank staffers to rely on computer models or second-hand reports about a bank-funded project’s efficacy, panel members said. Those responsible for ensuring a project does not cause undo harm to the environment where it functions can fall into a mode of accepting the reality described in project designs, instead of getting their boots muddy and examining it for themselves, said Fuggle.
Michael Igoe for DevEx reveals surprising news about the World Bank still not having anthropologists and better practices for field visits and finding out what is going on 'on the ground'...
IKEA refugee shelter to be redesigned following safety fears and design flawsRefugee consultant Killian Kleinschmidt told Dezeen that colleagues had told him of further issues including lengthy assembly time, narrow doors with a raised sill that prevents wheelchair access, and draughtiness.
"It takes four hours to assemble, it doesn't have a groundsheet and it's not modular as it should be," he said. "There have been complaints about the wind going through. It doesn't take into consideration that people like to adjust the space themselves and that is part of their dignity."
Marcus Fairs for dezeen. It's great to see that IKEA seems to be listening and is willing to learn from feedback. It is also a reminder that any notion of 'company walks in and tells development industry how to innovate' should come with note of caution and longer-term strategies to engage with the complex realities on the ground.
Nepal quake survivors struggle to rebuild two years later“The reconstruction slowed down because our government acted as if it was a routine period. This was a time of crisis,” said Kattel, who along with his wife, were recently named "People of the Year" by a local magazine.
“The role of the government should be to speed up the recovery, but there’s no coordination among the government ministries,” he said.
Deepak Adhikari for DPA International with one of many more reminders that two years after the earthquake reconstruction is often slow and flawed...
Unlocking the potential of technologyEthnographer and photographer Laura de Reynal has been documenting the work of organisations, such as Mozilla and One Laptop per Child who are helping communities to get online for the first time.
BBC News features interesting pictures which reminded me of a piece that appeared in 2012 on this very blog: OLPC in Ethiopia: The thin line between digital innovation, cargo cult and peoples on parade
Why cookie cutter models don’t work in development This is not just about national borders. A vast country like India is a collection of several mini-Indias. All with distinct contexts.
(...)
Supply side interventions such as making toilet construction easy, wouldn’t be enough to raise toilet coverage in Rajasthan. Demand generation efforts focused on the key need of the local population (which isn’t convenience, but may not be health either) will likely play an important role.
Jithamithra Thathachari and Rishi Agarwal for IDR Online on the complexities of scaling up, replicating and affecting behavior and social change in India.
Maybe local aid workers could do most expat roles better and more cost-effectivelySo does my hypothesis – that local aid workers can do most expat roles better in the Philippines – prove true? TBC, needs further research! But I definitely think it’s high time to acknowledge the changing, increasingly stronger existing capacities in countries like the Philippines, and have a frank, honest and constructive discussion about the international development and humanitarian sector’s way of working in the future.
Arbie Barguios with some preliminary findings on aid worker voices from the Philippines which ad nicely to the debate around aid worker pay and expat privileges...
What do we know about ‘online gig work’ in developing countries?The gig economy was supposed to ‘disintermediate’ – putting northern clients directly in touch with southern online workers, but that didn’t last long. Because of the heavy role that reputational feedback scores play in online gig work platforms, work tends to flow to intermediaries/middlemen who already have a high score. These intermediaries then re-outsource that work, keeping a part of the client’s fee for themselves.
Duncan Green presents a new report from Oxford Internet Institute on the gig economy in the global South.
6 Recommendations for Supporting Women and Girls’ Power, Voice and Influence Through Digital ICTsIt is important to take on board that women and girl’s empowerment, whether through use of digital ICTs or other resources, is multidimensional and non-linear. The use of digital ICTs may therefore empower women in some areas of their life while reducing their power in others –as when women have more public voice but are subjected to increased violence.
The digital divide also means digital ICTs may increase the power of some women while reducing the power of others. For programming to be better informed by learning on the conditions under which (different groups of) women and girls are able to use digital ICTs to increase their power, voice and influence, there is a need for more research grounded in established social and political theory, including development and gender studies.
A Guest Writer for ICTWorks presents 8 findings from a new ODI report in the context of ICT4D.
The World Needs More Bad SchoolsWe know that learning levels in poor countries are abysmally low. In an earlier post, I showed that in half of the fifty or so developing countries where we have data, fewer than 50 percent of women who left school after fifth grade could read a single sentence.
Sending kids to school has huge social returns, particularly for girls. Not only are the wage returns to a year of schooling generally estimated at around 10 percent per annum, but more educated women have fewer children and their children are less likely to die. This is somewhat puzzling if school isn't even teaching them to read.
Justin Sandefur for Center for Global Development with a cheeky headline for his post that comes with proper data and great insights on the paradoxes of funding education and schools.
Organizational change across the United Nations - Case study on innovation and changeLooking beyond UNHCR to WFP and UNICEF, among other UN agencies, it concludes that there is currently little evidence that the UN has fully embraced innovation as an essential part of efforts to reform the system and the entities within it, so that it can adapt to the new realities it faces. Neither is it clear that efforts to introduce innovation have spread far beyond the dedicated units that have been set up. The case study also suggests that the UN is not keeping up with the international public sector, which is increasingly recognising that it needs to find new ways of working if it is to cope with the rising demands being placed on it. At the moment there is a very real danger that, for the UN, innovation will remain something practiced by the few – typically, younger Programme staff – in ways that have limited potential for driving change within the UN.
Mads Svendsen shares some not exactly surprising findings about the innovation discourse and bureaucratic realities in the UN system.
The GA Tally Is Ready for Conference Season. Are You?All this to say, counting is powerful. Time and again we’ve seen organizers shocked to find that their own panels or organizations have failed to include women in any substantial way, all because they never actually took the time to count. Often, just pointing out the numbers can lead to real change. So what are you fighting for in your own communities? What are you counting? Let the GA Tally app connect you to an entire community that is just as passionate as you are about promoting women’s voices and that will continue to have your back and make some noise until we see results.
Soraya Membreno introduces Gender Avenger's new app to count and visualize the #allmalepanel.
Our digital lives
Facebook admits: governments exploited us to spread propagandaIn a white paper authored by the company’s security team and published on Thursday, the company detailed well-funded and subtle techniques used by nations and other organizations to spread misleading information and falsehoods for geopolitical goals. These efforts go well beyond “fake news”, the company said, and include content seeding, targeted data collection and fake accounts that are used to amplify one particular view, sow distrust in political institutions and spread confusion.
Olivia Solon for The Guardian. As long as facebook doesn't open up its data vault and algorithms we will see more unaccountable manipulation with long-term devastating political outcomes...
Silicon Valley Needs to Stop Pimping Out Patients to Alleviate White GuiltThis new model for healthcare financing could be revolutionary. But rolling out an untested, unproven, and currently unsustainable model in low-income countries that will have a hard time saying no to externally-funded solutions could do more harm than good for patients.
Jennifer Foth for the Development Set with yet another reminder that 'Silicon Valley' will not automatically be part of any solution and can equally likely be part of more money, more problems.
Rich charities keep getting richer. That means your money isn’t doing as much good as it could.You can think of this as the nonprofit sector’s inequality problem. The rich get richer: Well-established, brand-name organizations see spikes in donations, especially during crises. Smaller groups, including those that are deemed to be more effective than their better-known peers, and especially those serving the extreme poor, are left to muddle along.
(...)
That said, we can’t let donors off the hook for the inefficiencies of the nonprofit sector. While most individual donors say they care about nonprofit performance, nearly two-thirds do no research at all before making a donation. Nor do they demand evidence of effectiveness from charities. Until that changes, we can be certain that some nonprofits do great work and others do little or no good at all. But wouldn’t it be nice to know which was which?
Marc Gunther for Vox revisits the charity effectiveness and impact debate-and reminds us that rising inequalities are a problem in the sector just like everywhere else.
I signed up to 100 charity email lists. Here’s what I learnedLooking at the content of the emails, I did not have the impression that many organisations were trying to build a relationship or have a dialogue with me. One of the reasons that telephone and face-to-face fundraising have worked so well for charities over the years is because a representative of the charity has a conversation with a supporter or potential supporter, and builds and establishes a rapport.
The emails I received were heavily skewed towards being donation asks. Over a third of all emails I received were donation asks, and in fact I only ever received emails with donation asks from 6 charities.
The organisations with the best and most engaging content took the principle of having a dialogue with me as a potential donor – but adapted it to email and the longer timeframe needed compared with face-to-face or phone conversation. I was sent surveys, quizzes, case studies, and made to feel like I was part of the organisation. And only then was I sent a donation ask. Fewer than 10 charities adopted this approach from the 98 I signed up to.
Glyn Thomas for Just Giving with insights into the art of newslettering...
‘Thought Leaders’ and the Plutocrats Who Love ThemThe primary talent demonstrated by the “thought leaders” who rise to the top of this stew—people like Thomas Friedman, Niall Ferguson, and the heavyweight champion, according to Drezner’s own poll (in which I participated), Henry Kissinger—is to somehow flatter great wealth even as they pretend to challenge it. Should they pull it off, they get to feel good about themselves as enormously well-remunerated and highly respected public servants. The truth, however, is that by comforting the comfortable, they end up further afflicting the afflicted.
Eric Alterman for The Nation reviews Dan Drezner's book which is also on my reading list...
Hot off the digital press
Blockchain for Development – Hope or Hype? Some argue that within 20 years, blockchain will disrupt society more profoundly than the internet has disrupted communication and media. With the reported potential to replace powerful financial institutions with a new form of cheap and secure banking globally, could it also transform development? It has the potential to offer new ways to track aid and tackle corruption, facilitate smart-aid contracts and cut costs for international payments, but experience suggests it is through adding value to existing development processes that it could have the most benefit.
Kevin Hernandez with a short IDS briefing note on blockchain's potential for development.
Academia
UnPaywall Read paywalled research papers for free.
Click the green tab and skip the paywall. It's fast, free, and legal, powered by our database of millions of author-uploaded PDFs.
This looks like a neat tool-and is yet another reminder to share research papers in formats other than the paywalled journal article!
↧
↧
3 May marks the annual World Press Freedom Day. The Nordic Information Centre for Media and Communication Research (Nordicom) which hosts the UNESCO Chair on Freedom of Expression, Media Development and Global Policy at the University of Gothenburg launched its latest publication The Assault on Journalism-Building knowledge to protect freedom of expression edited by Ulla Carlsson and Reeta Pöyhtäri.
This substantial volume contains 34 chapters and is organized in four parts, covering key articles, broader reflections on journalist safety research and framework, empirically grounded case studies and a final highlighting key statistics around journalist (un)safety:The aim of the of this publication is to highlight and fuel journalist safety as a field of research, to encourage worldwide participation, as well as to inspire further dialogues and new research initiatives.
Guy Berger summarizes the focus on journalism well in his chapter Why the World Became Concerned with Journalistic Safety: If those actors who do journalism are important enough to be protected, including so they may enjoy digital security, then they are surely also important enough to merit the associated conditions of freedom, pluralism, independence and gender equality. In this way, attention to safety – a topic that is proving to be a powerful concern in its own right – can be a key to opening other doors, both politically and practically, which can improve the condition and contribution of journalism in the digital age (p.42).
Journalism safety as research field, advocacy strategy and best practice tool
Ari Heinonen highlights one of the key strengths of the edition in his Explorations in an Emerging Research Field: This collection of articles can also be read as a showcase of different solutions regarding research settings, methodologies and other factors to be considered while conducting research in this field. As a whole, these articles demonstrate that a new important interdisciplinary research field is emerging (p.144).
The research case studies cover an impressive range of countries and Syed Irfan Ashraf and Lisa Brooten’sTribal Journalists under Fire from Pakistan exemplifies the connection between local and global issues, a key thread throughout the 350 page volume: The threats have become such a common occurrence that journalists rarely mention the perpetrators of violence or the state’s responsibility for their protection. In the face of significant threats, tribal reporters’ dependence on group solidarity is based on the principle of reciprocity – the expectations and obligations that bring tribal journalists together as they work to navigate the complicated and dangerous intersection of state, militant and foreign interests (p.157).
Sallie Hughes and Mireya Marquez-Ramirez’ chapterHow Unsafe Contexts and Overlapping Risks Influence Journalism Practice from Mexico highlights the intersection of law, ‘good governance’ and new forms of financial support for independent media, issues that are discussed in many other countries as well:The study also found that economic risk stemming from the financial position of a media firm compounds physical risk and promotes censorship. These findings should raise the priority of Mexican initiatives to strengthen public and non-profit media and make government advertising transactions more transparent (p.313).
Lilian Ngusuur Unaegbu’sSafety Concerns in the Nigerian Media is a noteworthy contribution from Africa that focuses on another core theme of the volume, the gendered aspects of journalistic engagement around the globe:There is an urgent need to mainstream gender into existing frameworks and to develop additional media policies with strong gender perspectives (p.183).
Faye Anderson’s chapter onAustralian News Photographers, Safety and Trauma is yet another reminder of how closely issues that are discussed in the aid industry are linked to contemporary journalism: One of the most traumatic aspects of the photographers’ lives is the demise of their profession, the collective loss of colleagues and mentors and the greater reliance on freelance photographers devoid of support. It is deserving of greater consideration not only of the historical neglect, but the newspaper industry is experiencing seismic institutional change, and the safety of photographers has become more compromised and precarious (pp.233-234).
My short overview certainly cannot do justice to the rich content, but it should highlight the diversity of cases that are presented under a unified approach of journalism safety. Journalism beyond White House press conferences
Among many other things, the book is also a powerful and timely reminder to expand our focus away from the media frenzy in the United States or disingenuous global development reporting by UK’s Daily Mail. In many countries journalists struggle with various powerful groups for an informed and critical debate guided by the ethos of good journalism, not simply producing ‘traffic’, viral news or outrage about alleged or real ‘fake news’.
All in all, the book delivers something of a ‘complete package’: It features a wide range of authors who often get less space when discussions are dominated by North American journalism discourses featuring celebrity researchers and well-known institutions.
None of the chapters presents a research study in all its details, but rather focuses on summarizing main aspects with plenty of references to explore ‘further readings’, research articles or book-length discussion of a specific context. This keep the 34 chapters somewhat connected and allows for browsing or using them for teaching case studies, for example.
This approach highlights the importance of connecting research with practice and advocacy and to write about it in an accessible, concise way. Important food for thought for communicating development
Many topics resonate with current debates in humanitarian aid and the aid industry more broadly, for example mental health, staff safety, new forms of local-expat collaborations and the chances and limitations of digital tools. Many of the chapters also suggest to me that issues around journalism and ‘media development’ may become more closely aligned with other core areas of ‘real’ development. This is not just about ‘communicating development’, but about engaging with inequalities or injustices that often are the root causes that development tries to tackle. As a new generation of local journalists joins the industry in a digital area of more affordable reporting tools and new outlets for journalistic products, the aid industry can only benefit from closer collaborations. At the same time, meaningful cooperation requires time, effort and money and not every citizen journalism initiative leads to fair and balanced stories. As most of the time in development, it’s complicated…
This is a great open-access collection that goes far beyond journalism safety and highlights many important issues in communicating development and social change topics in our mediatized world!
Carlsson, Ulla & Pöyhtäri, Reeta (eds.): The Assault on Journalism: Building knowledge to protect freedom of expression. ISBN 978-91-87957-50-5, 341pp + annex, 29 Euro (free download), Göteborg: Nordicom, 2017.
↧
Hi all,
You’ll notice the new layout; there have been a few problems with Blogger’s dynamic themes so I switched to a more traditional one. The blog loads faster and looks better on mobile devices, but is certainly not on a path for winning design awards…let’s see how I can tweak things a bit-and if you have feedback, comments and complaints you know how to reach me!Back to business:
Development news:Kenya’s florticultural industry does not look rosy; saving children who don’t want to be saved; let Thousand Currents flow! Geo data and U.S. airstrikes; the tricky discourse of ‘social accountability’; a good example of celebrity advocacy; ‘working from home’ and the duty of care; the local-expat relationship in the Philippines; digital technologies exclude marginalized people; young male MBA guy wants to ‘disrupt’ development; the heroines of Haiti’s revolution; award-winning documentary on coco farmers in Ghana; ISIS and long-term effects of indoctrinating children.
Our digital lives:How valuable is facebook data really?
Academia:How many interviews and focus groups are (good) enough? Academography.
Enjoy!
New from aidnography
The Assault on Journalism (book review)Many topics of this edited volume resonate with current debates in humanitarian aid and the aid industry more broadly, for example mental health, staff safety, new forms of local-expat collaborations and the chances and limitations of digital tools. Many of the chapters also suggest to me that issues around journalism and ‘media development’ may become more closely aligned with other core areas of ‘real’ development. This is not just about ‘communicating development’, but about engaging with inequalities or injustices that often are the root causes that development tries to tackle.
(...)
This is a great open-access collection that goes far beyond journalism safety and highlights many important issues in communicating development and social change topics in our mediatized world!
Nigeria: The Paradox | Medea VoxNigeria is a nation of paradoxes. Crime and corruption, Boko Haram and Niger Delta militants. But Nigeria also has one of the largest movie-producing industries in the world, Nollywood, and Nigerian culture is spreading all over the world. Nigeria’s glass is half empty, half full, as today’s guest Eromo Egbejule describes it.
Eromo Egbejule and I talked Nigeria during his visit at ComDev-and Richard from Medea was kind enough to produce a podcast from our ramblings ;)!
Development news
Why prospects of flower farms don’t look so rosyA further look at the numbers shows that the value of horticultural — and specifically cut flower — production went down after 2012 for three consecutive years and only rose last year. During those three years, some companies were so adversely affected that some closed shop.
No wonder experts have poured cold water on job availability and the sector’s potential to create job, with floriculture the worst affected. In fact the industry is haemorrhaging jobs as flower farms go through a rough patch or are entirely shut down.
Macharina Mwangi for Business Daily with a familiar pattern on how 'business' is supposed to lift 'Africa' out of poverty, but that many industries are very fickle to global movements and often do not contribute to long-term sustainable growth and employment options.
When NGOs save children who don't want to be savedWhen it comes to children, one of the most powerful of these is that they are all inherently vulnerable and thus in danger when at work or on the move. The result is that many migrant working children are automatically assumed to be victims of trafficking when they are away from home, with the blame put variously on irresponsible parents, weak states, or abstract poverty. UN staff are taught to think like this, and the journalists who interview them are inevitably taught to think the same.
(...)
Almost overnight, thousands were laid off, with many ending up in far worse conditions - on the street, in sex work, or in dangerous factories even further under the radar. Surely it would have been better for him to address the power of US corporations buying from Bangladeshi factories, demanding an extension of labour rights and good pay all the way down to the young workers in question?
Neil Howard for Al-Jazeera with a very interesting long-read on perceptions of 'beneficiaries', media representations of 'vulnerable children' and an aid industry that often ignores complexities around children and work.
'International development' is a loaded term. It's time for a rethinkToday, Thousand Currents is focused on addressing our shared global challenges, not just the issues faced by a marginalised community or a poor country. That requires new approaches from donors in acknowledgement of this complexity – unrestricted financial support, multi-year timeframes, and new skills and personnel that reflect the world we want to see.
We dropped “international development” from our name, because when small, yet formidable pockets of people power come together, that’s when Thousand Currents sees results.
Jennifer Lentfer for Guardian Global Development Professionals on why IDEX changed its name to Thousand Currents!
U.S. Signals Possible Airstrikes in Somalia by Asking Aid Groups for Their Locations“It is not unusual that when there is a ramp up in U.S. military engagement and a bombing campaign somewhere — as is now signaled by the White House with the Somalia announcement — that USAID would reach out to humanitarian partners to get deconfliction information to ensure that the military campaign doesn’t inadvertently target humanitarians,” said Jeremy Konyndyk, director of the Office of U.S. Foreign Disaster Assistance during Obama’s second term.
Samuel Oakford for The Intercept on how humanitarian aid organizations may be indirectly forced to cooperate with the US military and how geo-location data becomes a powerful tool in contemporary warfare...
Social Accountability from the Trenches: 6 Critical ReflectionsSocial accountability is recognition that there exists a lack of engagement with the public institutions that are so critical to our daily lives, a lack of influence in decision-making and more importantly, a lack of voice for expressing our needs, concerns and demands. We believe that social accountability approaches enable citizens, especially the voiceless and the powerless, to engage with state institutions in a proactive and constructive way to demand and exact accountability and responsiveness.
Gopa Kumar Thampi for the Global Partnership for Social Accountability is spot-on with his six issues on how social accountability can move from discourse to critical practice for social change!
Accountability and celebrityDone right, deploying the talents of famous people to raise awareness and funds can bring advantage to both celebrities and people hit by humanitarian disasters. But without firm evidence, my gut tells me that in the triangular relationship between celebrities, aid agencies and affected people, it is the celebrities who come out on top.
Nick van Praag for Ground Truth Solutions recaps some essential aspects of celebrity engagement in humanitarian aid.
Letter From Iraq: Cutting Transatlantic Aid And Turning Away Refugees Is ImmoralYoung Americans and Brits in particular have a role to play. They can no longer chalk up bad policies to politicians backed by their parents. To those who say, we have enough problems at home without taking on these international challenges, we say, let us address both by tackling both. It’s ‘both and’, not ‘either or’. Our international policies, after all, are reflections of the state of our society’s soul. Let’s demand that our leaders represent our interests abroad by acting in the interests of those in need abroad.
Not to act is to act. Not to speak is to speak. Inaction can be a unique version of cruelty. We are at risk of abandoning the major achievements of the 20th Century - the widespread recognition that rights of protection extend to all people by simple fact of being human.
Marcus Mumford for Huffington Post with a good example on how celebrities can communicate development. Assuming that he wrote the piece himself (or was at least involved in the writing) this is a very good example of how celebrities can use their 'power' to communicate and advocate.
When ‘working from home’ isn’t as nice as it soundsA) because it meant not only living with your colleagues, which is bad enough, but also turning your home into an office. As an aid worker told me “it drives you crazy” B) because by the time you settled into the job, it was time to leave. On top of that it could have had serious legal consequences like this situation illustrates:
(...)
But what happens when you don’t have a home to go back to and when your home is a dangerous war-zone? It’s time that INGOs realise that staff care does not simply mean a session with a psychologist pre or post deployment, or a training on psychosocial support. It’s about caring for your staff by complying also with legal matters. That’s maybe why some prefer to call it “duty of care”.
Alessandra Pigni for Mindfulnext with an important reminder on how to provide a safe work environment when the expat lifestyle magazines tell you that all you need is a laptop and you can work from 'anywhere'...
The local – expat relationship: its complicated.A second question probed for an additional dimension of this same topic. Nearly half -49%- of the respondents noted, regarding interactions with their foreign colleges, that, “They listen to the advice of local people and try to understand the local context/culture sometimes (emphasis added).” Another 8% indicated, “They rarely listen to the advice of local people nor try to understand the local context/culture.” In sum well over half -57%- responded in a way that indicates they feel less than fully respected by their expat counterparts.
(...)
So here’s what I am seeing from the quantitative data. Filipino aid workers believe they are getting compensated far less for doing the same job, many sense that expats feel they are superior to them, feel less than respected by their expat colleagues, and yet, tellingly, the vast majority have a positive experience working with expats.
Tom Arcaro continues his inquiries into the complex relationships of aid workers in the Philippines.
Digital technologies excludeI remain optimistic about the potential for using digital technologies in social justice and human development. We found initiatives in Philippines that genuinely inspire optimism, but we also need to be mindful of the potential for technology to exclude the most marginalised.
There are always imaginative ways to secure the participation of marginalised groups, including blending offline and online activities and using analogue as well as digital technologies. The main take-away from the research so far has been underscoring the lesson that if we intend digital development initiatives to include the most marginalised, then we need to design for equity from the outset.
Tony Roberts for Making All Voices Count shares his reflections on digital development in the Philippines.
When is giving to charity the wrong thing to do?We also need to be conscious consumers and harness the democratic function of the market economy to signal demand for vertically integrated ethics in the economy.
(...)
We also need good people working in business. Business is the normative way in which people rise out of poverty.
Amy MacMillan Bankson for MIT Management Sloan School. There was quite a bit of discussion on my facebook about this piece-a young white male MBA student talking about 'fixing development' by embracing consumerist capitalistic recipes; Being a 'good' consumer and making sure that 'good' people work in business is most likely not leading to social transformation and sustainable development...
Heroines of the Haitian RevolutionFor Anglophone readers and students, Dance is an ideal way to enter the world of colonial Saint-Domingue and the Haitian Revolution. The novel does not focus on the uprising of the enslaved in Saint-Domingue’s Northern Province, depicted in Carpentier’s well-known The Kingdom of This World. Instead, it focuses on Port-au-Prince and the colony’s Western Province, where planters battling one another first armed their slaves. Vieux-Chauvet brings this complex and swirling political and military conflict to vivid life, with many key revolutionary figures, including Vincent Ogé and Alexandre Petion, appearing as characters in the novel.
(...)
Dance on the Volcano, like Vieux-Chauvet’s other works, disrupts and disturbs, in part because of the counterpoint between moments of softness and of harshness, possibility and terror, dreams of change and the reality of a system that closes in and traps us. At the center of the stories she tells in Dance, and in all of her novels, is the idea that art is a way of refusing the silencing, cruelty, and destruction of life at the heart of any social order based on exclusion and violence.
Laurent Dubois for Public Books reviews a new novel from Haiti.
University film scoops Higher Education OscarTelling the story of life for female cocoa farmers in Ghana, the film uses participatory video - whereby female farmers used video cameras to chart aspects of their lives – to highlight how access to land, capital and markets often remains the preserve of men. Despite their efforts, this shows how women’s ability to reap the financial rewards of their efforts is often limited.
Congratulations to my former IDS DPhil colleague Elizabeth Fortin who as involved in the award-winning documentary!
ISIS schools and indoctrination of childrenOne of the biggest mistakes of the western world in recent years has been to underestimate the long term formation of Islamic State’s ideology and state, military capabilities and brutality. By learning from this mistake we must now increase and share knowledge about the issues above, collaborate on preventive measures and find ways to deal with the upcoming and long-term threat towards western societies, but maybe even more important a major social development dimension in the region with a growing generation of children who have lived under Islamic State ruling and indoctrinating tentacles of “education”.
Michael Krona is one of my department colleagues and does important, amazing, mind-boggling research on the world of ISIS and its mediatized ideological ecosystems.
Our digital lives
I'm an ex-Facebook exec: don't believe what they tell you about adsConverting Facebook data into money is harder than it sounds, mostly because the vast bulk of your user data is worthless. Turns out your blotto-drunk party pics and flirty co-worker messages have no commercial value whatsoever.
But occasionally, if used very cleverly, with lots of machine-learning iteration and systematic trial-and-error, the canny marketer can find just the right admixture of age, geography, time of day, and music or film tastes that demarcate a demographic winner of an audience. The “clickthrough rate”, to use the advertiser’s parlance, doesn’t lie.
Antonio Garcia-Martinez for The Guardian with an important reminder not to trust everything you hear about the power and value of facebook data. Facebook sells advertising, hence it doesn't mind if 'we' believe that it sits on this mountain of valuable data that companies are keen to exploit for their marketing. Just because this is facebook's business model does not mean that the data is actually that valuable.
AcademiaRiddle me this: How many interviews (or focus groups) are enough?These data from our study suggest that a sample size of two to three focus groups will likely capture about 80% of themes on a topic — including those most broadly shared — in a study with a relatively homogeneous population, and using a semi-structured guide. As few as three to six focus groups are likely enough to identify 90% of important themes.
Emily Namey for FHI360 with a question many students will ask at some point during their preparation for their thesis work...
Academography and Disciplinary EthnocentrismIn any case, in one of those predictable ironies of academic history, ethnocentrism can afflict not just the “traditional” disciplines, but also the more contemporary interdisciplinary fields that have emerged alongside them. One would think, for instance, that Science and Technology Studies and the more recently-inaugurated Critical University Studies would be closely linked together. I would certainly hope so, since that my own work focuses on the links between French university politics and the epistemic culture of a left-wing French philosophy department. And yet I find, to my considerable dismay, that these two little worlds are deeply segregated from each other, as if we faced an “ethnocentrism of interdisciplines.”
Eli Thorkelson for Platypus with a great post on studying (academic) organizations. I think that ethnocentrism is only one important aspect of 'academography'; anthropology in this field is very good at 'studying down', looking at teachers, adjuncts or students, but less powerful in studying up (yet). I haven't come across an ethnography of university board meetings, salary negotiations with senior management or an 'Inside the REF' account-not just a journalistic long-read, but a real ethnography. So lots to discover in our own organizations...
Contingent No MoreThe core self-worth of the typical American academic is deeply invested in the notion that we’ve spent most of our lives rising to the top through determination and intelligence. And as a reactionary and masochistic correlate to that faith, we harshly link each other’s professional failures and our own to some presumed lack of such qualities. We feel like it would diminish our life’s work to admit in public that, actually, the system is rigged, that many of our successes are due more to luck than anything else, that most of the “best work” is not being produced at all because the collective, variable talents of our community of thinkers and teachers and partners are being wasted in the competitive pursuit of individualistic success that our livelihoods depend on.
(...)
It’s also true that loving something means you will fight for it—and that’s increasingly the only option we have left. But this struggle is vastly complicated by the realization that what we’re actually fighting for—an independent, communal, decently compensated life of the mind—has been taken hostage by the very thing we’re now fighting against: the ever more corporatized and compromised higher education scene.
Maximillian Alvarez for The Baffler on The Academy.
↧
Hi all,
It's a sunny Friday afternoon in Sweden! Enjoy stimulating readings, great documentaries, a poem & the odd Tweet!
Development news:UN’s new top humanitarian is a highly qualified white British man; revolutionizing mindsets at the WHO; ICC turns 15; how Liberian child soldiers fought in Iraq; refugee real estate in Kenya; are the best days for selling cheap Chinese goods in Africa over? An overview over one of our favorite questions: Does foreign aid work? Uganda & the limits of entrepreneurism; the aid industry’s LGBTIQ blind spot; is localization of aid the answer? A special section on campaigning & communicating development; social media in Africa; how to communicate as a non-profit; NGO-Nothing Going On?
Our digital lives:A poem; advice for new bloggers; review ‘Twitter & Tear Gas’.
Publications:World Bank’s Higher Education for Development evaluation; gender differences in scientific collaboration (a paper written by 5 men…); security in the vernacular.
Plus: Which tools to use for analyzing Twitter for research?
Enjoy!
Development news
UK technocrat appointed UN humanitarian chief - reportsBen Ramalingam, leader of the Disasters and Development group at the UK university think tank, the Institute of Development Studies, says Lowcock is a “great choice”, pointing to his technical and financial background. Ramalingam told IRIN Lowcock would be most tested by the charged political landscape and “re-casting the role of OCHA for a changing world.”
Another observer pointed out that Guterres had appointed few women to the critical senior positions in the areas of political, peace and security, nor had there been visible progress in breaking the lock the Security Council’s five permanent members hold on them.
Ben Parker for IRIN on the new appointment of Mark Lowcock as USG for Humanitarian Affairs. Another interesting trade-off between obvious qualifications and the traditional older, white, Western male profile...
We need a revolution in mindsets at the top of the World Health Organization The irony is that never has medical science been so productive and yet health inequalities so wide. That is why continuing to do more of the same is not an option. While extra funding is always welcome, much more necessary is a revolution in mind-sets and attitudes. This means organisational innovation to drive universal health coverage, foster collaboration, strengthen national health capacities, and forge partnerships that respect health as a fundamental human right. Hence, the centrality of WHO.
Mukesh Kapila for The Guardian on the challenges ahead for the new WHO Director General...can any UN organization realistically all of that?
15 years on, the International Criminal Court is still trying to deliver on its promiseBut the essential complaint that has driven animus in parts of Africa remains very much alive: Is the ICC capable of administering impartial justice in a world of vast inequities? Some aspects of the African critique are easily dismissed. Most of the African investigations that the court has pursued were explicitly requested by the governments themselves, including in Uganda, Congo and the Central African Republic. And the court lacks jurisdiction in many non-African countries where crimes and oppression are endemic, including Iraq, Syria and North Korea. Nor has the court been completely motionless outside of Africa. In January 2016, the court launched an investigation in Georgia, although it has not yet brought any cases there.
Those realities don’t entirely absolve the court of regional or political bias. In several non-African situations where the court could investigate, it has dragged its feet. Most notable is Afghanistan, where the court has had a “preliminary examination” open for more than a decade.
David Bosco for Washington Post with an important reminder of how difficult international justice is, how politicized processes are how the ICC tries to navigate all these different challenges (any Silicon Valley takers who want to 'disrupt' international criminal investigations and introduce some 'innovative' ideas on how to challenge bureaucratic organizations ;) ?!?).
Child Soldiers Reloaded: The Privatisation of War
How private companies recruit former child soldiers for military operations in Iraq, Afghanistan and elsewhere.
Mads Elleso for Al-Jazeera with an interesting documentary on the global dimensions of the privatized military-industrial complex.
Kenya’s black market in “refugee real estate”The informal system makes it possible for industrious camp residents to make a living, and the income from shelter and business sales can make it easier for refugees to fund repatriation or ease the transition to resettlement countries.
But the black market in refugee real estate also foments disputes and corruption.
Cory Rodgers for IRIN with another interesting story on how refugee camps are so more than just a temporary shelter for refugees...
The best days of selling cheap Chinese goods in Africa are overToday, Eastleigh is home to at least 50 malls, each housing hundreds of stalls selling often identical merchandise from manufacturing hubs like Guangzhou or Yiwu in southern and central China. “The business is too slow and the malls are too many. You can see it from the stores, all selling the same things, the same quality,” says Mohamed Ali, who owns a menswear store in Amal Plaza, a five-story mall on Eastleigh’s main road, First Avenue.
(...)
Still, local entrepreneurs and business people think something has to change. “Africa will have to rely on itself and rely on local industry, local factories. That’s a long-term solution,” says Hussein, of the Eastleigh business association. He’s considering opening his own garment factory in Kenya. “This,” he says, referring to the import of goods from China, “is a short-term solution.”
Lily Kuo for Quartz with a great long-read on African-Chinese trade relations. Regardless of how trade and consumption patterns are changing, questions about (cheap) consumption and its hidden cost versus creating some local development will remain.
Once more into the breach: Does foreign aid work?It is important not to overstate the impact of aid. Foreign aid has not been the major driver of development progress over the last 20 years, nor will it be in the future. Long-term development progress depends primarily on the economic and political institutions that are built over time in low-income countries, and the actions taken by those countries themselves. Aid programs (alongside diplomacy and other tools of international engagement) are not the driving force behind development, but they can help support development progress along the way.
So don’t let the skeptics fool you with their shouted and erroneous claims that there is no evidence that aid works
Steve Radelet for Brookings revisits one of the all-time favorite debates in international development...it is still a good overview over the question whether 'aid works', but in the end, it always was and always will be complicated-and political on how and why aid works some of the time...
Stop Celebrating Entrepreneurship In AfricaThe high rate of entrepreneurship in the developing world should not be celebrated or encouraged but lamented. Self-employment is a response to the environment in poor countries. Not their golden path out of it.
When most Americans graduate college they go get jobs. The vast majority do not start businesses. They have options. Ugandans and most other Africans don’t. Ugandan are reluctant entrepreneurs. They are not there by choice but out of pure survival.
James Crawford with a reminder from Uganda that self-employment and entrepreneurism discourses will not be the 'solution' to eradicate poverty and many structural barriers remain that prevent educated and qualified young people to pursue other careers in other industries.
Q&A: Emily Dwyer on the humanitarian sector's LGBTIQ blind spotWorking with local organizations, it is important to understand what those gender identities and sexual orientations are — many of which don’t fall neatly into the LGBTIQ+ boxes that aid agencies might be more familiar with. It also allows those organizations to understand what might be possible within the local political, cultural, social, and legal environment with which they work. It’s really important to take advice, take leadership from, and engage with those local organizations. Of course that’s not an easy thing to do. It involves a longer term trust building between those organizations and within the communities that those organizations work with. But starting with the local organizations is a great place to start.
Abigail Seiff for DevEx talk to Emily Dwyer about the long and difficult road of the humanitarian industry to fulfill its promises on being inclusive and equal.
Be Careful What You Ask ForThe discussion of localization is beginning to deepen. Here (summarized) is an opening salvo from Charles Lwanga-Ntale, director of the Kenya Academy Centre: localization often seems to resemble ‘deconcentration’, a process whereby the systems and structures of the existing humanitarian sector are exported downwards.
Mark DuBois, the Humanicontrarian, shares some interesting reflections on how to resist the localization discourse in development as a form of putting faulty technocratic systems in local place and expect miracles...
Outcry Over Photo Showing The Face Of A Girl Allegedly Being Raped"This is the elephant in the room: how we view the suffering of distant others," says human rights activist Robert Godden of Rights Exposure, which helps nonprofits and governments create effective and ethical campaigns. "What if this photo series was taken in the U.S. or the U.K. — would the girl have been presented this way?"
He adds, "Another good question to ask is: If this was a family member of mine, would I want them portrayed like this?"
Amid a barrage of protests from readers, photojournalists and human rights activists, LensCulture took down the photo hours after it was posted.
"But at this point, the magazine said nothing," Chesterton says. "There was no statement, no acknowledgment of the absolute human rights abuse of that young woman, of that child."
Michaeleen Doucleff for NPR Goats & Soda with an interesting ethics debate on representations of suffering and the 'distant other'.
Daniel Wordsworth, CEO of American Refugee Council, posted this on LinkedIn: This is about what we are doing in response to Somalia famine. These guys from lovearmyforsomalia gave done such a great job. Without them we couldn't be getting to the places shown in this video
The video was posted a couple of days ago and already has 550K views.
As with most campaigns, my feelings are a bit ambivalent. The campaign raised a lot of money and the fact that Jerome partnered with a professional humanitarian organization was already a great idea as it reduces the impact of 'two white French dudes saving Somalia' narrative. The video is obviously an interesting example of contemporary...well, advocacy or campaigning really: It speaks to the right audience (YouTube channel with 1.1 million followers) and comes as a fast-paced introduction to Somalia and the famine. Personally, I like the balance between SUVs driving through sand dunes (drone footage?), a few historical facts about the country and those two guys listening to people in remote places. It's obviously very condensed, but I appreciate that this is not a 90 minute lecture, but at 14 min YouTube video. I get a sense of these 2 guys willing to listen and learn-it becomes quite political around the 10:00 mark.
Fly on the Facebook Wall: How UNHCR Listened to Refugees on Social Media In “From a Refugee Perspective” UNHCR has now summarised their findings from the ten-month project. The main thing I really liked about this project is that UNHCR invested the resources for proper qualitative social media monitoring, as opposed to the purely quantitative analyses that we see so often and which rarely go beyond keyword counting. To complement the social media information, the team held focus group and other discussions with refugees who had arrived in Europe.
(...)
But in the end, the team did not engage online. Why they decided to only be a fly on the wall, rather than share information of their own, is not discussed in the report. My guess is that they were worried about being inundated with questions, while not having the capacity to respond.
Timo Luege for Social Media for Good introduces the new UNHCR report From a refugee perspective.
The Definitive List of Anti-Poverty Campaign AdsWriting a list of good campaign ads? That was a little more difficult.
Brendan Rigby for WhyDev wraps up this section with more good examples of how development issues can be communicated well.
The Uses and Abuses of Social Media in AfricaA recent conference at the University of Edinburgh went “Beyond the Hashtag” to explore the impact of social media in Africa. Don’t worry if you missed it, because Brooks Marmon has written this great summary of the key findings to bring you up to speed.
Brooks Marmon for Democracy in Africa with a great overview over some of the current debates in the research community when it comes to engaging with social media in Africa.
Communications 101: Talking about your nonprofit Over the next few weeks, we will publish a series of detailed, do-it-yourself articles on how to create engaging content for both offline and online platforms.
In the meantime, here are three things that you can adopt immediately to help with your organisation’s communications.
Devanshi Vaid for the India Development Review kicks off an interesting series of practical ideas on how nonprofits can communicate better.
Film Review: N.G.O. – Nothing Going OnWhat appears to be a light-hearted and entertaining comedy on how Ugandans screw mzungus over and over again (in all aspects of life) is at its core a deep critical reflection on the exponential growth of NGOs in the country – if not the sub-Saharan African continent.
Simone Datzberger for Africa at LSE. I'm curious to watch the whole documentary now, but this sounds like great food for thought and debate!
From the 'not really development news and yet very telling of the state of development in the US' department...
Golden career advice of the week:Our digital livesPlay TheoryHer shoe tumbled from my trembling fingertips
I always attempted to put it back onto the slender foot
But I realized that it was no use
I was powerless over this plastic girl
And so I went to my computer
Where I entered into a world
Where I could manipulate everything
With only a blank page
And a keyboard
From Understorey Magazine. Meredith Bullock is a 16-year-old girl who has cerebral palsy. She is in grade 11 at Sacred Heart School of Halifax; her poem won first prize at the MSVU Girls Conference. Brave and Reckless’Advice for New WordPress Bloggers– Part 1I knew nothing about blogging. But I did know that all communities have their own unique culture and through a combination of trial and error, generous mentors and reading several really good guides to WordPress, I found my footing here.
Christine Ray for Brave and Reckless with some advice not just for the WordPress crowd...
Anti-Authoritarian Book Club: Twitter and Tear GasThe short version of Tufekci’s argument is that social media provide powerful ways for activists to organize and to get their messages out, but that the types of activism have their own drawbacks. Ad hoc movements can assemble quickly, both in physical space (Gezi Park) and online (#BlackLivesMatter), and they can deploy powerful viral messages (the Battle of the Camel). This helps them leapfrog over repression, interia, and mass media censorship – but also over much of the institution-building work that allows protest movements to enforce message discipline, switch up their tactics, and lever their momentum into other realms. Their heavy use of platform-based social media also leaves them vulnerable to algorithmic fragmentation, pervasive surveillance, and disinformation campaigns.
James Grimmelmann for The Laboratorium reviews Zeynep Tufekci’s new book Twitter and Tear Gas: The Power and Fragility of Networked Protest.
Hot off the digital press
Higher Education for Development: An Evaluation of the World Bank Group's SupportAlthough this evaluation assesses past performance, much of which predates the 2013 World Bank Group strategy, with its twin goals of eliminating extreme poverty and promoting shared prosperity, the evaluation is intended to be forward-looking. Although higher education can contribute to the twin goals, it is by no means guaranteed.
As interesting as this new World Bank report may be, it is presented in the most technocratic and bureaucratic way and I doubt that I want to spend too much time reading the details...
Gender differences in scientific collaborations: Women are more egalitarian than menBy analyzing a unique dataset of more than 270,000 scientists, we discovered substantial gender differences in scientific collaborations. While men are more likely to collaborate with other men, women are more egalitarian. This is consistently observed over all fields and regardless of the number of collaborators a scientist has.
Interestingly, this PLOS open-access article lists five male co-authors...
Special Issue: Security in the Vernacular The special issue presents new analysis and case studies, which aim to challenge and refresh the established policy consensus around violence reduction and security. They are distinctive in focusing upon the vernacular or local understandings of those at the receiving end of direct and structural violence; and in analysing the insurgent margins where violence and insecurity are most concentrated.
The new Peacebuilding special issue is open access!
Academia
Using Twitter as a data source: an overview of social media research tools (updated for 2017)Following his initial post on this topic in 2015, Wasim Ahmed has updated and expanded his rundown of the tools available to social scientists looking to analyse social media data. A number of new applications have been released in the intervening period, with the increasing complexity of certain research questions also having prompted some tools to increase their data retrieval functionalities. Although platforms such as Facebook and WhatsApp have more active users, Twitter’s unique infrastructure and the near-total availability of its data have ensured its popularity among researchers remains high.
Wasim Ahmed for LSE Impact Blog with a really useful overview over digital analysis research tools.
↧
One of the topics that certainly makes a mark on this year’s academic research, public engagement and publishing trends is the critical engagement with new social movements, forms of protest and so-called revolutions-and how to predict, analyze and contextualize their impact on social change.
Paolo Gerbaudo’s book, but also recently published monographs by David Karpf and Zeynep Tufekci are some of the key titles on my ‘read & review’ shelf right now. Even though all of them deserve a nuanced analysis some of the key findings point in a similar direction: ‘We’ were too quick to talk about social media revolutions. Movements need to combine online and traditional protest strategies for longer-term impact. Short-term activism and activities may not lead to medium-term sustainable, inclusive change. Building or fostering democratic, accountable systems is…complicated. And traditional social, political and economic structures are surprisingly (?) resilient as hashtags trend, demonstrations form on facebook and movements exchange messages on WhatsApp. These trends emerge across case studies from diverse places such as the Ukraine, Turkey, Egypt, North Africa as well as Occupy tents in London or New York City.
There were a couple of reasons why I selected Frédéric Volpi’s Revolution and Authoritarianism in North Africa for review.
First, Volpi is looking at Algeria, Libya, Morocco and Tunisia-four diverse societies and political systems that experienced very different ‘revolutions’/revolutions in 2011. Second, he is adopting a macro-analytical perspective and is less concerned with ethnographic details of ‘the streets’. And quite frankly, the third reason was that books published by Hurst are usually interesting, readable and well-edited contributions to shape my own thinking and teaching.
‘None of these outcomes are particularly novel in terms of long-term institutional equilibria, nor are they particularly surprising’
I am happy to say that the book managed my expectations very well! Maybe a bit unusual for a book review, I will start with a ‘spoiler alert’ as we fast forward to the penultimate page of the book: In democratization and revolution studies, the outcomes of the Arab uprisings can be placed in already well-established categories. We have successful transition processes leading to democratic consolidation, as in Tunisia. We have entrenchment of liberalized autocracies, as in Morocco. We have situations of authoritarian status quo, as in Algeria. And we have situations of state failure and conflict, as in Libya. None of these outcomes are particularly novel in terms of long-term institutional equilibria, nor are they particularly surprising as historical occurrences for these polities. The Arab uprisings point to a set of processes that led from one known institutional model-in this case, more or less open authoritarian regimes-to other institutional equilibria (p.172).
As you can imagine, much more is happening in the book before Volpi arrives at his final conclusions. One of the key strengths of the preceding narrative is how well the author finds the balance between four different countries and their trajectories. The book offers just enough insights into each country to provide a framework for discussion without blurring the boundaries on ‘North Africa’ or ‘MENA countries’ that often dominate contemporary discussions.
Why didn’t we see the revolutions coming?
Many political scientists have been challenged by claims that they were unable to predict the turmoil in the countries in question. They have been also been tasked with predicting the future: What will happen next-and when will we have Western-style democracies that will serve their population and help ‘us’ with the ‘war on terror’ or the ‘refugee crisis’? In all cases, protest episodes end in a formal return to institutionalized politics, usually in the shape of an electoral democracy-be it as a substantive system of governance or as a front for continuing authoritarian rule (p.5).
So right from the beginning we are reminded that there was neither a historical vacuum, nor that substantial ‘globalized’ or ‘globalizing’ external forces had major influence, a point I will return to at the end of my review. What mattered in the end often depended on more or less spontaneous elite decisions, i.e. what happened in the ‘second stage’: The first stage corresponds to the implosion of the ruling authoritarian system. (…) The second stage corresponds to the reconstruction of practices and discourses around the demands of the protestors and counter-propositions of the regime (…). The third stage involves the reconstruction of routinized behaviors in and by this new system of governance (p.7).
Volpi’s analysis clearly challenges any notion of path dependency and I will try to highlight in the following paragraph how different the revolutions evolved in the four countries-despite a similar window of time, geopolitical proximity and global climate.
In Algeria, the revolutionary potential somewhat failed to gain wide-spread momentum: The reversion to ‘normality’ was the result not so much of the Algerian regime using the ‘correct’ combination of repressive and cooptative measures to diffuse unrest, as of behavioral and ideational shifts that unfolded without sufficient speed and directionality. As a result, new arenas of contention and protest dynamics failed to become self-reproducing (p.87).
More prominently, the Libyan regime disappeared, but it is important to note that it was not simply an anti-Gaddafi ‘implosion’ of the country, but that there competing narratives and struggles going on that ultimately created the singular mediatized story: Protestors developed local self-help networks in order to cope firstly with repression, and then in order to deal with the withdrawal of the security forces and the progressive shutdown of state institutions and public services. (…) These local rearticulations of power-outcomes of protests that developed relatively independent of one another-began to create an ideational and material challenge for the regime at the national level (p.92).
And in Tunisia old and new media worked together-probably a not-so-surprising reminder that ‘Twitter revolutions’ never really existed: In informational terms, the (new) media helped raise the profile of the revolt and articulate a perspective that countered the official version given by the regime at home and abroad. As before, a combination of old and new media outlets proves most effective at conveying counter-discourses (p.101).
The transformations in Tunisia are also a reminder that state institutions rarely exist as a unified whole and that ‘the government’ can be very strategic how it uses ‘the army’ or ‘the police’ to (dis-)engage with protests: Instead of trying to prevent protests as much as possible, the security forces targeted those protest actions that the regime found most subversive of the authoritarian status quo (p.124).
And finally Morocco where the King seemed to have found a way on how he used the positive aspects of the conflict to strengthen ‘reformed’ institutions: The identities and behaviors of the actors of the uprising had co-evolved with those of the regime to produce a situation in which they could coexist and conflict with each other within the symbolic and institutional order imposed by a ‘reformed’ monarchy (p.152).
An interesting question then is how important the security sector is in predicting the outcomes of protests-and how ‘we’ can ensure it from all too easily becoming part of transitional problems as we have seen in many instances in Afghanistan, Iraq and elsewhere. In Algeria and in Morocco, the early winding down of the unrest ensured that that cohesiveness of the security forces was not tested in the same way that it was in Tunisia and Libya (p.164).
Revolutions as if states mattered For scholars and policy-makers alike, the ability to explain routine politics becomes the main objective of the analysis. The political causality of extraordinary episodes is discounted, and so are the interactions at work at the time (p.154).
As I mentioned in the beginning of my review, Volpi’s analysis relies on internal developments. French involvement in Algeria or American meddling in Libya do not seem to play a major role; I wonder whether we tend of overstate such external forces-or whether there is a level of external support that may not be easy to pin down; nevertheless, external factors let alone strategic regime change may play a smaller part as events unfolds quickly ‘on the ground’. Things could indeed have happened otherwise, and other continuities could have been showcased (p.173).
The book suggests that events were very much driven locally-and although they happened in neighboring countries very little indicates that it can be justified to talk about a ‘global protest wave’ or ‘global movement’.
As you can imagine from my rather long review, I thoroughly enjoyed Revolution and Authoritarianism in North Africa. It provides plenty of food for thought and discussion and will certainly make a very good introductory text for students before they start discussing the countries, societies and revolutionary dynamics in more detail. Volpi’s book also makes a very important contribution to the emerging debate on how ‘we’, particularly in academia, need to continue with nuanced and careful analysis as mediatized events gain momentum and sound bites replace complex reflections. Especially the political science and international relations community also needs to admit how limited their power of prediction really is when contested spaces are re-negotiated.
Learning from my interactions with journalists, my only point of critique is that the text is at times quite dense and requires a willingness to engage with academic language. But the book should spark enough interest to discuss these issues with the author and bring his analysis into mainstream debates.
Volpi, Frédéric: Revolution and Authoritarianism in North Africa. ISBN 978-1-84904-696-1, 232pp, 25.00 GBP, London: Hurst & Company, 2017.
↧
↧
Hi all,
A long week comes to a summery, sunny conclusion!
Development news:Once more: Does aid work?! Media & democracy in Afghanistan; Cameroon’s ‘auntie army’; do women in Latin America get empowered by microfinance? Traveling in Uganda; the trouble with medical voluntourism; RCTs-it’s complicated; One Belt, One Road & questions of economic empowerment; private security & inequality; how UNDP Eurasia communicates; C4D for vaccination; Read-of-the-week: my poor mother wasn’t trash.
Our digital lives:Switching the lens on service & serving; the ideas industry.
Publications:Management in a neoliberal world; live poor, die young.
Academia:Why haven’t MOOCs replaced professors? Flipping the classroom the right way.
Enjoy!
New from aidnography
Revolution and Authoritarianism in North Africa (book review) There were a couple of reasons why I selected Frédéric Volpi’s book for review.
First, Volpi is looking at Algeria, Libya, Morocco and Tunisia-four diverse societies and political systems that experienced very different ‘revolutions’/revolutions in 2011.
Second, he is adopting a macro-analytical perspective and is less concerned with ethnographic details of ‘the streets’. And quite frankly, the third reason was that books published by Hurst are usually interesting, readable and well-edited contributions to shape my own thinking and teaching.
(...)
I thoroughly enjoyed the book. It provides plenty of food for thought and discussion and will certainly make a very good introductory text for students before they start discussing the countries, societies and revolutionary dynamics in more detail. Volpi’s book also makes a very important contribution to the emerging debate on how ‘we’, particularly in academia, need to continue with nuanced and careful analysis as mediatized events gain momentum and sound bites replace complex reflections.
Especially the political science and international relations community also needs to admit how limited their power of prediction really is when contested spaces are re-negotiated.
Development news
Should America Keep Giving Billions Of Dollars To Countries In Need? Nonetheless, researchers have tried for decades to connect the dots between aid and growth, says Glennerster of the poverty lab at MIT. But results have been mixed. "I can show you 40 papers that have appeared in economic journals in the last 10 to 15 years saying that there's been no relationship," says Kenny. "Twice the number that say there is. Some say it's a mix. All those stories are plausible."
Malaka Gharib for NPR Goats & Soda. As much as the piece provides (yet another) overview over the 'Does aid work?' debate, I would have liked to read about other aspects of 'aid'-including humanitarian aid or 'softer' forms of support that may not lead to economic growth, but to better media, governments and societies in the longer term. Aid can be many things-but it should also play a role in working towards global solidarity, connect citizens and communicate inequalities as well as addressing them.
‘The media here is one of the greatest tools of democracy’Still, the challenges to independent journalism in Afghanistan are immense and growing. Reporters face physical attacks and intimidation from the Taliban, warlords, criminals and the country’s own U.S.-backed government, which has imprisoned at least 60 journalists, according to media watchdog groups. And funding for media from the United States and other Western governments, is dwindling, leaving many radio stations with aging equipment sorely in need of repair.
“Afghanistan’s is a donor-created media, that’s the reality of it,” Maimanagy said. “There is no advertising market of any significance and there isn’t going to be for a long time. There is this adamant enemy that considers media a promoter of values they don’t believe in, like women’s rights and democracy, and they are not timid about attacking journalists.
We don’t know what this all means for our future. But we know that the media here is one of the greatest tools of democracy, and we need to fight for it.”
Sharmini Boyle for Internews with an important reminder of what media can and should do in democratic societies once you leave the overheated filter bubbles in our own backyards...
Cameroon's 'auntie army' of rape survivors battles sex abuse of girlsAlthough funded for many years by the German development agency GIZ, RENATA receives small grants from international donors, but is no longer fully sponsored by anyone.
So the aunties work as volunteers, often holding down second jobs as hairdressers, shop-stall owners, teachers, restaurant managers to make ends meet.
Some of their revenue is under threat following President Donald Trump's order to reinstate the global gag rule that bans U.S.-funded groups around the world from discussing abortion.
Aba, the RENATA spokeswoman, said despite their dwindling resources, she and the other aunties are determined not to give up.
"We won't lower our arms - we will continue, we will find other revenues. We will continue our fight," she said.
Inna Lazareva for Thomson Reuters Foundation with a piece from Cameroon featuring civil society engagement to support girls and women.
Microfinance & Austerity: No Womens' Empowerment without Community Involvement
How austerity policies and microfinance can bankrupt rather than empower women. Professor Girón discusses why microfinance cannot replace development banks.
My travels in Uganda, like life, were not as perfect as the picturesI posted beautiful pictures of my trip to the islands, with an incredible jungle trek and a beautiful sunset. But I didn't show you how my friend and I were left stranded on a ferry port after the bus took our money and left. I didn't show you the tears I shed while trying to negotiate with a boda driver to take us to the city. I didn't show you the pain of the motorcycle digging into my lower back as we tried to fit three people and two luggage bags on an hour-long ride along a dusty, dry road.
Facebook is a fraud.
No wait, scratch that. I am a fraud.
Uganda is a beautiful country with beautiful people with incredible stories who gave me so many opportunities as a dancer and international worker. You'll find all of that in my photos.
But that's not the whole picture. It's all too easy for me to post the highlights, to watch the "likes" pop up one after another in my notifications, and to read comments like "Girl, I'm jealous!"
Justina Li for the Globe & Mail. The complexities of life, travel and 'going to Africa'...it's not just an experience for social media feeds...
The Trouble with Medical "Voluntourism"Empirical data about the medical voluntourism industry is sparse. The most-cited figure estimates up to 10 million volunteers travel abroad annually, spending approximately $4 billion. Volunteers are predominantly young women; the number engaged in international medical volunteering is unknown.
(...)
Ultimately, patients and local health systems need foreigners’ good intentions to be re-directed towards the people on the ground, already doing the meaningful work in the long term. Putting the safety and needs of local health systems and patients first will ensure help doesn’t harm.
Noelle Sullivan for Scientific American. I think I have posted one of Noelle's pieces before-but as the summer and end-of-semester travel season starts, an important reminder to those venturing abroad...
Randomized control trials for development? Three problemsSimilarly, we decide (sometimes using RCTs) that people save too little. Perhaps they even said so in a survey. However, did that survey ask whether they would also like to spend more on their children’s education, or dietary diversity, or better doctors, or any other specific reasons? No. But we researchers “know better.” So when we find we can nudge them into saving more, we think we are helping when, perhaps, we are doing them a disservice because of our tunnel vision.
Jeffrey Hammer for Brookings. For me the key point to take away from the debate is that context, nuances, culture, attitudes etc. matter a lot-rather than tweaking the quantitative foundations behind RCTs. Whatever the 'next generation' of RCTs will look like it will need more communication experts or anthropologists rather than 'better' econometric input.
China’s ‘One Belt, One Road’ Initiative: Can A Bilaterally-Negotiated ‘Globalization 2.0’ Internalize Human Rights, Labor, and Environmental Standards?The One Belt, One Road Initiative may indeed lead the world towards its “Fourth Industrial Revolution”, but the lack of other truly competitive sources of foreign financing is what ultimately reinforces China’s monopolistic advantage over foreign-financing of infrastructure and connectivity projects. It should also serve as a prudential warning for developing countries, to be vigilant about their own regulatory environments and institutional capacities and to avoid “neocolonialism” achieved through negotiating disparities in bilateral arrangements. Directly internalizing international economic, social, and cultural rights, international labor agreements, and international environmental agreements – (to many of which China is already a State party) into the long-term domestic regulatory frameworks governing One Belt, One Road projects is one way of redressing the bargaining imbalance for developing countries and ensuring mutual accountability for all global partners in China’s push as a ‘responsible power’ driving ‘Globalization 2.0’ bilaterally through the One Belt, One Road initiative.
Diane Desierto for EJIL:Talk. Even though this is a long-read with lost of legalistic aspects I found this one of the most interesting pieces this week in connection with China's 'new Silk Road' endeavor. It is am very interesting piece which addresses very fundamental questions about development, participation, ownership and new forms of power!
The industry of inequality: why the world is obsessed with private securityBut when private security enables the rich and even the middle class to bypass the state, this can intensify a country’s inequalities. Regarding the expansion of private security in Latin America, the UN Development Programme has warned: “This phenomenon further increases inequality, as social groups have different capacities to deal with crime.”
(...)
Speaking to the Guardian from Bangalore, where he teaches at Azim Premji University, Jayadev observed that India has witnessed a broad “succession of the rich from the rest of the economy”.
Many people there, he said, already “rely on private services in every facet of their lives” to provide “all of the things the state might [otherwise] ... including security”.
Claire Provost for The Guardian with an interesting piece that exemplifies very well what 'inequalities' mean-and that many states are unlikely to 'catch up' with basic services, including security, and the '1%' paying their way out of these challenges will only slow down service access for the remaining majority.
How to stop the global inequality machine And it doesn’t help that developing countries have the deck stacked against them at the World Bank, the IMF and the WTO. Because rich countries have all the power in these institutions, they get to make the rules that shape export prices and wages in the rest of the world.
The point is that wages are not somehow naturally low in the south – they have been made low by design. Wages are an effect of power.
Jason Hickel for The Guardian with more food for thought and discussion-his new book is on my summer reading list.
UNDP Eurasia – social media strategies Blogging has been a major part of UNDP Eurasia’s outreach for at least 5 years now, before I started working here. We call this part of our strategy to Work Out Loud – don’t share only your success, but your failures as well. There’s as much for people to learn from your failures as from your successes – and they’re almost always more interesting. Blogging allows us to share results from the field without having to go through the formalities of finishing a project and producing an 80-page report. Blogging also allows us to reach younger crowds or those coming across our content on-the-go because of its more conversational tone. Finally, blogging helps put a human face on the work that we do. If we’re doing our job right, then it’s personal and fresh and interesting and brings in audiences who wouldn’t normally tune in
David Girling interviews interview with Mehmet Erdogan for Social Media for Development with insights into UNDP social media strategies.
The Comprehensive 'Communicate to Vaccinate' Taxonomy of Communication Interventions for Childhood Vaccination in Routine and Campaign Contexts
![]()
Without a comprehensive framework integrating communication interventions from routine and campaign contexts, it is not possible to conceptualise the full range of possible vaccination communication interventions. Therefore, vaccine programme managers may be unaware of potential communication options and researchers may not focus on building evidence for interventions used in practice.
Jessica Kaufman and colleagues for BMC Public Health with new research on an important C4D topic.
My Mother Wasn't TrashIn the United States, our approach to solving Appalachian poverty doesn't differ substantially from our approach to solving African poverty. In both cases, outsiders came in to exploit resources and left generations of poverty in their wake. While the process was substantially more extreme, racist, and violent in Africa, in both cases conservative political leaders think those left behind economically should just make better decisions and stop being poor. That approach will not work in either instance. Neither will sending food and secondhand clothing. And don't even get me started on the idiotic and theologically-flawed thinking that leads fundamentalist Christians to think they can solve poverty by evangelizing the poor folk.
While we must not approach any instance of poverty, whether in Kinshasa, Congo or Frakes, Kentucky, with the flawed notion that we fully understand it, we must understand that the solutions will be found in action both by those who are impoverished and by those who are not. This is not a problem to be fixed by condescending outsiders, but neither is it a problem to be fixed only by those who are impoverished. Neither group can fix it alone.
The process starts, I think, with taking time to listen. Then, we can try to understand. I might understand it a little better than most because I grew up white trash. I have seen my mother and my family members and my neighbors be forced to make impossible choices between a limited number of shitty options. I have at times had to make those impossible choices myself. Even having grown up poor and having spent my academic career researching and writing about poverty, I do not claim to understand it fully. We must realize that there exists no single narrative about Appalachian poverty. Not all poor people are the same. Not all impoverished families fit into a single category even if they are united by similar demographics.
Joshua Wilkey for This Appalachia Life with personal, challenging reflections on poverty and 'helping the poor' that 'we' in the aid industry are also faced with regularly.
Our digital lives
These three pictures make a powerful statement about race and power among women For the photographer, the baseline intention of the project was to bend race expectations. "When you see an image of someone from a different background, what is your expectation of them?" Buck asked rhetorically over the phone. "When you see an image from someone [of a different race], what is your expectation of them and are we challenging it? Why do we expect a certain thing from someone of a [certain race] and expect them to be serving another [race]?"
Sarah A. Harvard for Mic with more details on flipping the perspective on serving and service.
The “Ideas Industry” and Populist Reaction in Education PolicyOverall, Drezner leaves a troubling impression about the state of policy deliberation in American politics and the influence of wealthy patrons. His argument also helps to shed some light on the polarization that has developed within education policy between a reform movement supported by many wealthy philanthropists and thought leaders (such as Bill Gates, Eli Broad, and the Walton family) and a populist reaction involving teachers, unions, and scholar activists like Diane Ravitch.
Sarah Reckhow for HistPhil reviews Daniel Drezner’s new book which is also on my summer reading pile.
Hot off the digital press
Journal Issue #5 ManagementMany of the contributions point to how management is entangled in contemporary economics that engage in managerial micro-control. In particular, the management of public institutions, cultural or educational, is under attack, and so are its workers (and if not existing under the threat of closure, they operate under enforced austerity and self-monitoring, especially but not only in the West). The result is a hyper-individualised isolated student or worker who is addicted to work and pathologically tired and numbed. Such an individual is expected to contribute to the current economy, rather than maximise their interests, or, and more importantly, engage in productions of solidarity that mobilise critical thinking and creativity.
New open access issue of the PARSE journal.
Inequality: Live poor, die youngThe Death Gap presents a Marxian view of inequality as a societal disease that in turn produces biological disease, dispersed differentially across the sociopolitical hierarchy. Although he is a physician, Ansell uses metaphorical language that may stump readers in biomedical fields. Moving beyond epidemiological frameworks that model what would happen to an individual exposed to a single causal factor, Ansell weaves a much more complicated story, in which structures of disadvantage affect every step of the process of survival. The Death Gap provides an overarching framework for understanding the root cause of ethno-racial and economic disparities in illness that seamlessly weaves together the very best research in epidemiology, public health, medical sociology, health policy and psychology.
Abigail A. Sewell for Nature reviews The Death Gap.
Academia
Why Haven't MOOCs Eliminated Any Professors?What MOOCs can’t do is mentor, coach, guide, and connect. The role of the professor is in part to profess - but in much larger part to educate. The educator / learner relationship at the heart of all high quality postsecondary education can no more be scaled than any other crucial human relationship. MOOCs have thrown into sharp relief just how valuable an education is that is built upon relationships. If a MOOC replaces a course, then perhaps that course should be replaced.
Joshua Kim for Inside Higher Ed with some interesting suggestions on why MOOCs have not (yet?) 'disrupted' education as fundamentally as some may have thought. I think MOOCs when used well can continue to be a good marketing tool: 'If you liked this overview, why not sign up for more?'. I also think that MOOCs can be integrated into regular courses, thereby creating more incentives for completing the course and getting proper credits if not degrees. But the core business model of higher education is still working reasonably well...
Flipping, active learning and the post-truth eraActive learning continues to emerge as practice and we are going to find it hard going at times, precisely because there will not be any one path. Students need to be part of helping make this happen and the most profitable way of doing that is by making them genuine stakeholders in the process. That means bringing them in at the curriculum design stage, talking with throughout the delivery phase about running adjustments and debriefing afterwards.
If post-truth has taught us anything, then it’s that passionate commitment counts for a lot. We’re passionate about making L&T work better, so let’s use that together all the other academic values we hold, to effect change.
Simon Usherwood for Active Learning in Political Science on the challenges of making 'flipped' classrooms work.
↧
Hi all,
This is actually blog post #502!
Wow…and it’s actually still one of the fun parts of the work week :)
This week features a lot of international organizations-and mostly it’s not good news…
But my quote of the week comes from Clelia O. Rodríguez and it addresses many issues both in #globaldev and #highered:
The corridors of the hallways in the institution where I currently work embodies this faux-solidarity in posters about conferences, colloquiums, and trips in the Global South or about the Global South that cost an arm and a leg. As long as you have money to pay for your airfare, hotel, meals and transportation, you too could add two lines in the CV and speak about the new social movement and their radical strategies to dismantle the system. You too can participate in academic dialogues about poverty and labor rights as you pass by an undocumented cleaner who will make your bed while you go to the main conference room to talk about her struggles.
Development news:The debate around the 2 UN experts killed in Congo; the WHO is spending a lot of money on travel; the World Bank has an internal clash over language and writing culture; is the world ‘plundering’ Africa? Being young & unemployed in Sierra Leone.
Our digital lives:Speech by New Orleans Mayor on confederate monuments and memory; smart slums: Good or bad? No ‘big bets’ for Hewlett foundation; big data & the distancing from politics.
Publications:NGOs in the 21 century; cities as humanitarian actors; emerging providers in #globaldev; 50 years of Asian Development Bank.
Academia:Fasting & fieldwork; academia, poverty & ‘intellectual masturbation’; academic engagement in the digital age. Enjoy!
Development news
For 2 Experts Killed in Congo, U.N. Provided Little Training and No ProtectionThe killings have also stirred a sharp debate over the United Nations’ responsibility to prepare and protect the people it hires to investigate wrongdoing around the world. Ms. Catalán and Mr. Sharp belonged to a panel of six experts authorized by the Security Council to investigate rapes, massacres and the exploitation of Congo’s vast natural resources.
Kimiko de Freytas-Tamura and Somini Sengupta for the New York Times with the piece that sparked a lot of discussions this week. The case is complicated-but among many other things it is a reminder that we project a lot on the UN system: Today we suggest 'health insurance for consultants'-and tomorrow there will be 'the UN system is wasting X million dollars on a cushy safety net for external experts' headline somewhere. And a lot of UN work is (still) actually dangerous, requires a lot of dedication and can quickly become a plaything for various political interests...
Families of 2 U.N. Investigators Slain in Congo Speak OutThere is abundant evidence that these murders were premeditated and that no amount of training could have altered the outcome.
No member of the United Nations Group of Experts on Congo had been killed before, and there was no reason to expect abduction or murder. For this reason, we are pressing the secretary general to appoint an independent international criminal investigation team to identify the perpetrators and their chain of command and to help ensure that those responsible face justice.
A letter from the families in response to the New York Times article.
Who is to blame for the murders of Michael and Zaida?There is no doubt that the United Nations can do a much better job supporting the various groups of experts and panels that are in charge of monitoring the sanctions regimes (North Korea, Somalia/Eritrea, Sudan, Central African Republic, etc.). When I was coordinator of the DRC group in 2008, we never received any security or investigative training, we had to use our private Yahoo! and Gmail email addresses, and we didn’t have any analytical software to organize our notes or do network analysis.
On the other hand, the Times article takes some pot shots. Yes, we did not have health insurance––but the experts have the status of consultants and as consultants anywhere are expected to purchase their own health care, and all of the current members are insured. Yes, we did not have security escorts, but the UN peacekeeping mission in the Congo is perceived as a party to the conflict (they conduct joint operations with the Congolese army) and the experts would not be able to access many of the armed groups if they went with a UN escort. And yes, better training on many issues would be great, but the current members of the group of experts do have considerable experience and are not “woefully unprepared.”
Jason Stearns from The Congo Research Group at NYU
AP Exclusive: UN health agency slammed for high travel costsWHO said Sunday that nearly 60 percent of its travel costs were spent on sending outside experts to affected countries and for national representatives to attend WHO meetings.
During the Ebola disaster in West Africa, WHO’s travel costs spiked to $234 million. Although experts say on-the-ground help was critical, some question whether the agency couldn’t have shaved its costs so more funds went to West Africa . The three countries that bore the brunt of the outbreak couldn’t even afford basics such as protective boots, gloves and soap for endangered medical workers.
Dr. Bruce Aylward, who directed WHO’s outbreak response, racked up nearly $400,000 in travel expenses during the Ebola crisis, sometimes flying by helicopter to visit clinics instead of traveling by jeep over muddy roads, according to trip reports he filed.
Maria Cheng for AP News with another story from inside the UN system. I am pretty sure that some managerial aspects can be improved-but the WHO also has a mandate to bring policy makers together or respond in crisis situations, balancing long-term and short-term goals of visibility, planning and being an inclusive global organization.
World Bank's Star Economist Is Sidelined in War Over WordsRomer asked for shorter emails and insisted presentations get straight to the point, cutting staff off if they talked too long, said another person familiar with the matter. He canceled a regular publication that didn’t have a clear purpose, one of the people said.
But researchers didn’t like the curt way Romer often conveyed his message, said two people familiar with the matter. Staff were upset by what they saw as his abrasive emails, and they didn’t feel Romer listened to their concerns, these people said. Researchers were flummoxed by some of his stylistic hangups, including a distaste for the conjunction “and.”
Romer was frustrated with what some see as the dense, convoluted style of many of the department’s reports. He pushed researchers to write more clearly, using the active voice to be more direct.
Andrew Mayeda for Bloomberg. And another international organization made it into the news this week! The world of words and discourses of economic writing at the Bank have become part of a leadership conflict-development research gold ;)!
World is plundering Africa's wealth of 'billions of dollars a year'Forstater said: “There are 1.2 billion people in Africa. This report seems to view these people and their institutions as an inert bucket into which money is poured or stolen away, rather than as part of dynamic and growing economies. The $41bn headline they come up with needs to be put into context that the overall GDP of Africa is some $7.7tn. Economies do not grow by stockpiling inflows and preventing outflows but by enabling people to invest and learn, adapt technologies and access markets.
“Some of the issues that the report raises – such as illegal logging, fishing and the cost of adapting to climate change – are important, but adding together all apparent inflows and outflows is meaningless.”
Karen McVeigh for The Guardian with the piece that goes along with some of the tweets above.
The topic always ensure a good amount of sharing and traffic, but it is good to see Maya Forstater given space to challenge underlying research at the same time!
As More Aid Flows to Fragile States, a Call for a Better ApproachThe findings show differences in general donor behavior in fragile and stable countries. Donors are more likely to provide aid through another organization in fragile states rather than directly, but are less likely to work jointly with other donors in fragile states. And fragile states receive less aid from multilateral donors, like the United Nations or World Bank, than stable states, but receive more “multi-bi” aid, a mechanism wherein individual donors can pool funds in a trust which are then administered by a multilateral agency.
Sreya Panunganti for New Security Beat with a slightly technical overview over how aid flows to fragile states.
A Young World - Sierra LeoneHow do young people in Sierra Leone cope faced with staggering rates of youth unemployment of over 50%? Umaru Fofana talks to young people in the capital, Freetown, as they struggle to make a living.
Umaru Fofana for BBC World Service on one of the big issues around the world: Un- and under-employed young people who cannot simply entrepreneur their way into the labor market...
Ayahuasca Shaman Dreading Another Week Of Guiding Tech CEOs To Spiritual Oneness“These days, I can’t even look at my calendar without cringing—it’s pretty much all tech execs,” said Salazar, adding that he had thought the developed world’s interest in the ayahuasca tea ceremony was generally a positive until it became his full-time job to provide celestial guidance to Bay Area venture capitalists and app founders who had learned about the practice through a Viceland special. “I believe this source of healing should be available to everyone, but lately it seems like the people I guide toward a vision of cosmic wholeness are all 32-year-old billionaires hoping to gain a deeper insight into their SEO strategy or whatever.”
Don't worry-this is literally from The Onion! :)
Our digital lives
Transcript of New Orleans Mayor Landrieu’s address on Confederate monumentsAmerica was the place where nearly 4,000 of our fellow citizens were lynched, 540 alone in Louisiana; where the courts enshrined ‘separate but equal’; where Freedom riders coming to New Orleans were beaten to a bloody pulp.
So when people say to me that the monuments in question are history, well what I just described is real history as well, and it is the searing truth.
And it immediately begs the questions: why there are no slave ship monuments, no prominent markers on public land to remember the lynchings or the slave blocks; nothing to remember this long chapter of our lives; the pain, the sacrifice, the shame … all of it happening on the soil of New Orleans.
So for those self-appointed defenders of history and the monuments, they are eerily silent on what amounts to this historical malfeasance, a lie by omission.
Derek Cosson for The Pulse with a transcript of an outstanding speech by New Orleans Mayor Mitch Landrieu.
Smart slums: utopian or dystopian vision of the future?The smart slum is still a peripheral idea, but we can speculate on the likely impact of extending this ‘smartness’ to slums and make two competing claims. Firstly, that development professionals should be wary of smart slums repeating some of the negative impacts of ICT4D; and secondly, that a push for smart slums could be appropriated for social justice.
(...)
It may also be that sensors and smartness paradoxically limit citizenship rather than extending it, if citizens just participate by generating data and real resource decisions are made elsewhere. This is a dystopian version of smart slums as a way to subdue and control.
Dan McQuillan for Goldsmiths with interesting reflections on ICT4D, urban living and the challenges of connecting slums in the digital age.
Against “Big Bets” The sort of philanthropy required to make progress on challenges like these is very nearly the opposite of that being pushed by big bet enthusiasts. It takes money, to be sure. But it also takes time and patience—a great deal of both, in fact—and a commitment of human as much as financial resources. It takes willingness to learn from others and to develop real partnerships with grantees, while hearing from (and listening to) intended beneficiaries.
It is not about pushing lots of cash out the door while looking for speedy results, but about becoming part of and helping to nurture an ecosystem of grantees, beneficiaries, and other funders whose efforts, cumulatively and over time, help make progress. It is about coming to understand a problem deeply, developing a thoughtful approach to address it, observing what happens, changing one’s understanding based on evidence and experience, and—most important—being willing, if need be, to take these same steps over and over again.
Larry Kramer for SSIR on why the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation is not betting on 'big bets' investments.
Persuasion and the other thing: A critique of big data methodologies in politicsIn political deployments of big data analytics and inferential modeling, what is at stake is the ability of the powerful to see and meaningfully engage with a consenting electorate. A claim could be made that if current trends continue, and big data psychographic methodologies become a primary means of electioneering and governance, actively attempting to reduce the effectiveness of that dataset would be an unethical move. But there are other ways for governments and campaigns to encounter their electorates, to figure out how best to represent their constituents. A town hall may have the potential to be messy, loud, and unpredictable, but it allows an encounter between the people and their elected representatives. Referendums on specific issues, given to the public for a direct vote, can’t reveal private information: your vote on medical marijuana legalization won’t reveal if you’re gay.
As a modern democracy, the US excels in developing new mechanisms to distance the individual from the power of their vote. Big data methodologies and the inferential analytics they power as deployed in elections present yet another move to push people, in all their loud, messy, demanding changeability, out of politics. But unlike gerrymandering or the electoral college, this move can be actively resisted on the individual level.
Molly Sauter for Ethnography Matters with a long essay that rightfully demands the reader's attention. She provides some excellent links between the superficial 'companies are manipulating elections online' claims and broader reflections on how such processes further distance people from politics.
Hot off the digital press
NGOs in the 21st Century - The Opportunities Presented by Digitalization and GlobalizationThe question is whether current organizations and structures that are called to solve these gigantic tasks are truly equipped to do so, or whether it might be necessary to restructure them. Why is this vitally important?
- In charitable organizations, “business models” based on donations are often no longer competitive and are thus no longer viable.
- In recent years, while many organizations have rapidly grown and have often multiplied their “business volume,” their capacity has not kept pace, nor have they been able to keep up with the trends of digitalization and networking.
- Internal / external reporting and evaluation systems designed to meet the requirements of financial institutions have ballooned into administrational “monsters” – with many organizations now expending more energy on producing reports than on fulfilling their mission statements and thus impacting the world around them.
Successfully transforming NGOs to meet the needs of the 21st century means developing up-to-date and cooperative networks, adopting the Internet-of-things (IoT) as a concept, enabling decentralized and direct collaboration with units of competence, and developing synergies with partners.
Daniel Emmrich and Kilian Kleinschmidt with a new report for Wieselhuber Consulting.
Cities as Humanitarian Actors in Contexts of DisplacementTaking a range of examples from across the world, this report will examine how new arrivals are received and integrated into cities within formal and informal spaces; how cities address everyday issues relating to housing and shelter, health and education; how urban citizens build socio-cultural communities of solidarity in periods of uncertainty and transition; and the role of civil society in these processes to support and engage with displaced populations. It examines the idea of cities as humanitarian actors, highlighting good practices and initiatives in different urban contexts that address current humanitarian challenges relating to migration and forced displacement.
Megha Amrit for the UNU Institute of Globalization, Culture and Mobility.
Emerging providers’ international co-operation for developmentThis paper shows that development co-operation from emerging providers – i.e. countries beyond the OECD Development Assistance Committee (DAC) – significantly increased in recent years, reaching 17% of total global development co-operation in 2014. It also presents a rough estimate, of USD 300 billion, of broader international co-operation by emerging providers and it sets out what types of instruments are used to provide this broader international co-operation.
Julia Benn and Willem Luijkx for the OECD. For some inexplicable reason there is a smiley face next to the title on the official OECD page...
Banking on the Future of Asia and the Pacific: 50 Years of the Asian Development BankFocusing on the region’s economic development, the evolution of the international development agenda, and the story of ADB itself, Banking on the Future of Asia and the Pacific raises several key questions: What are the outstanding features of regional development to which ADB had to respond? How has the bank grown and evolved in changing circumstances? How did ADB’s successive leaders promote reforms while preserving continuity with the efforts of their predecessors?
The ADB celebrates its 50th anniversary with this new official publication.
Academia
The Fast and The Curious Can I justify eating or drinking during Ramadan to protect the integrity of my research process? Will this make me a lesser Muslim? Maybe. Probably. To most — definitely.
I struggle with how to reconcile these thoughts in my head. The goal of my work is to uncover hidden truths, latent needs, and undiscovered barriers that percolate through people’s lives. But I can only do that work if I’m perceived as neutral, objective, and unassuming — or at the very least, worthy of trust and respect.
I choose to abide by the things I admire about my faith and that align with my values. Fasting, at its core, is about understanding those who have to live day in and day out on an empty stomach. And the ultimate goal of my research is aligned to that same goal — of understanding how people live, think, and survive. This is my workaround. It is not the neatest workaround. But if my ultimate goal is understanding, for that I can choose to eat.
As Ramadan is about to start Sarah Fathallah shares her reflections on academic fieldwork under the conditions of fasting and cultural expectations of food and drink.
How academia uses poverty, oppression, and pain for intellectual masturbationThe corridors of the hallways in the institution where I currently work embodies this faux-solidarity in posters about conferences, colloquiums, and trips in the Global South or about the Global South that cost an arm and a leg. As long as you have money to pay for your airfare, hotel, meals and transportation, you too could add two lines in the CV and speak about the new social movement and their radical strategies to dismantle the system. You too can participate in academic dialogues about poverty and labor rights as you pass by an undocumented cleaner who will make your bed while you go to the main conference room to talk about her struggles.
Clelia O. Rodríguez for RaceBaitR with excellent food for thought on privilege, neoliberalism and existing in academia.
Rules of engagement: seven lessons from communicating above and below the lineSo it can work. Productive engagement online is possible. But be acutely aware of the many pitfalls and pratfalls that can befall you, not least those listed above. To engage as productively as possible, follow Wendig’s advice and regularly tend to those weeds.
And don’t be surprised if many of those who publicly “critique” your efforts don’t even read past the title of your post/video/article before they vent their spleen. You’ll find that nothing is quite as irritating as those who want to engage without engaging.
Philip Moriarty for LSE Impact Blog on academic engagement in the digital age.
↧
Hi all,We are currently examining and discussing about 20 excellent MA thesis projects which is always a great way to wrap up the teaching term!
I wish I had a bit more time for blogging these days, but at least there are some great readings to explore this Friday!
Development news: Is the World Bank in trouble? Collecting data in India; Humanitarians at the WEF; Sri Lankan peacekeeping scandal; new film on the ‘madness’ of war in Sri Lanka; bad health clinics hurt developing countries; would Haiti be better off without aid? A rare insight into Eritrea’s political leadership; Timorese migrant workers in Northern Ireland; Digital India is no place for women; the world’s most watched soap; the boy & the starfish-a tale about #globaldev; alternatives to growth; the pdf graveyard; long-read on photography & conflict; the privatization of US armed forces; Bono visits an old pal.
Our digital lives: Creating a ‘social enterprise’-it’s complicated; precarity as freedom in Japan.
Publications: Changing social norms, attitudes & behaviors; Africa’s youth employment challenge.
Academia:Political science journals are biased against women; cancer, care & hope-a medical ethnography of a Tanzanian hospital.
Enjoy!
Development news
The World Bank Has Bigger Problems Than Bad Writing From an outside perspective, it certainly looks as if the World Bank is an institution in need of great change. And the problem goes far beyond poor communication.
(...)
Morris and Gleave suggest a number of other roles the Bank could step into, including disease response, funding scientific research, making municipal loans or simply acting as a think tank. But this isn’t very encouraging -- it paints the picture of an organization shambling onward out of sheer momentum, an expensive bureaucracy looking for a purpose.
Noah Smith for Bloomberg continues last week's debate about trouble at the Bank...but predicting the end of the World Bank is a bit like betting on an end of expat-driven aid work: It's unlikely to happen any time soon!
India’s ‘successful’ toilet campaign may be missing its mark “Looking at the list, we found a large number of duplicate entries – so the same household being mentioned multiple times,” Avani Kapur, Accountability Initiative’s lead researcher in public finance, told Humanosphere. “We also found households and even villages misclassified – a household that’s supposedly in this village is actually in another village.”
Because the reporting system is bottom-up – households reporting to local leaders, who report to national ministries – Accountability Initiative found a “big disconnect” between the number of villages that have been declared open-defecation free and those that have been verified as such.
Joanne Lu for Humanosphere with yet another reminder of how difficult it (still) is to collect reliable data on a large scale in developing countries. We often tend to overestimate the quality of data, collection tools and analysis.
Princes and bankers and aid! Oh my!She agreed there’s an argument for humanitarians having a seat at the table where the power brokers are – including those who play a part in causing the crises. However, her concern is that major international NGOs “are not really there to shine a light on the political deadlock and how it is negatively impacting the humanitarian situation, and it just becomes hobnobbing with the elites. It doesn’t become a space where we are the conscience of what’s happening.”
Far from “holding power accountable”, she worries that nobody is even discussing how to prevent protracted crises from starting in the first place.
Annie Slemrod for IRIN with a piece on humanitarian participation at the WEF-which highlights some broader questions of how the humanitarians can 'speak truth to power'...
UN Peacekeepers: How a Haiti child sex ring was whitewashed The alleged abuses committed by its troops abroad stem from a culture of impunity that arose during Sri Lanka's civil war and has seeped into its peacekeeping missions. The government has consistently refused calls for independent investigations into its generation-long civil war, marked by widespread reports of rape camps, torture, mass killings and other alleged war crimes by its troops.
Katy Daigle & Paisley Dodds continue AP's closer look at UN peacekeeping operations and how impunity 'at home' is damaging peacekeeping missions abroad.
Film breaks silence on ‘madness’ of Sri Lanka civil warDemons in Paradise, which is premiering at the Cannes film festival, tells of the bloodbath that drove some Tamils to take up arms in the three decade-long insurgency that tore the island apart.
But the documentary also shatters a taboo by insisting that some of most horrific violence the minority endured was at the hands of their supposed defenders, the Tamil Tigers.
And the “hard truth” comes from the mouths of former Tamil fighters themselves.
“By making this film I know that I will have to face harsh, perhaps even hateful criticism from both communities,” Ratnam said.
The Hindustan Times with a new documentary film project that seems very much linked to the previous story on 'rogue' peacekeepers.
Too Many Health Clinics Hurt Developing Countries Local councils, seeking to grab the biggest possible slice of the pie, began to push forward new projects, leading to rapid and uncontrolled expansion of the health system.
(...)
Rather than continuing to pursue the uncontrolled proliferation of poorly equipped and operated health-care facilities, policymakers should consider a more measured approach. Of course, people living in remote areas need access to quality health care, without having to navigate rough and dangerous roads that can become virtually inaccessible during some periods of the year. But outreach services and community health workers could cover these areas much more effectively. The value of such an approach has recently been demonstrated in Ethiopia, where health outcomes have improved.
Samuel Kargbo for Project Syndicate with a reminder that building any kind of 'simple' infrastructure like school buildings or health facilities comes with the high cost of running them properly.
Development expert: ‘Haiti would be better off without international aid’Haiti would be better off without aid. Or at least, without the bad kind of aid that allows the administration and the elites to continue without changing. It would be better to create the conditions in which change could happen. If we get involved, we should do so in an intelligent way, even if that is less visible in terms of the value it brings. I am not saying that all aid is bad. For example, the international presence should allow us to put pressure on the corrupt state.
Rather than funding road building, which is very expensive in Haiti, we should ensure the laws are in place to look after the roads that are built using international aid. That is even more important than building the road itself.
Cécile Barbière talks to Joel Boutroue for Euractiv on the limits of aid in Haiti and how difficult it is to do development differently.
Take me to your leader: Eritrea’s Isaias AfwerkiAfwerki enjoys and never misses the endless commemorations of major battles that the nation celebrates with great fervor. All top government officials are expected to suspend their work and leave town for days to accompany him. During these junkets, in the midst of his endless jokes and ridicule/praise, officials get a feel for their current status with the president.
In addition to the routine public ridicule and humiliation most officials undergo, President Afwerki is known for physically assaulting top government officials including ministers or national figures, such as journalists. His character is taken as the model and it trickles down the lowest ranks.
Having effectively demolished all public institutions and structures, Afwerki’s character and his legacy will take a generation to fix. As he frequently utters in some private occasions, however, is unfazed. The “country is his sole creation whose existence depends on his personal whim.”
Abraham T. Zere for Africa Is a Country with some rare insights into Eritrean political leadership.
Transitional livelihoods: Timorese migrant workers in the UK Among those who have returned to Timor-Leste there is an overwhelming sense of having achieved a better place or status in life than they had before they went to the UK. That is because the money they earned in the UK enabled them to improve their conditions in Timor-Leste, either through starting or improving a business, or by earning the cash required to get married and/or build a house. Not only did this improve their family’s economic circumstances but often increased their status in the community as well. Those that have become fluent in English and achieved a greater understanding of western workplace culture have an advantage in obtaining higher paid work in offices with international links when they return home.
Ann Wigglesworth for the DevPolicy Blog with a reminder of positive aspects of remittances and labor migration and the familiar challenge of finding a place between Timor-Leste and Northern Ireland.
Digital India Is No Country for Women. Here’s WhyThe digital divide is thus not simply a question of access to digital technologies but about the capacity to make meaningful use of the access to technology. In Madhya Pradesh, as in many parts of rural and semi-rural India, this capacity is directly shaped by gender biased belief and value systems that impose restrictions on the education and free mobility of women.
(...)
While digital economy allows opportunities for ‘flexi-work’ and diminishes the reliance on physical workspaces, digital literacy must not aid in reinforcing the traditional gendered segregation of private and public. Unless accompanied by broader shifts in social and cultural belief systems, it can lead to further restrictions on the mobility and autonomy of women. Therefore, unless these digital skilling programs are grounded within a broader education curricula, they will create a generation of young people that are essentially only application operators, capable of specific tasks
Urvashi Aneja & Vidisha Mishra for The Wire with an excellent piece on the gendered complexities and inequalities of ICT4D in India.
Indian soap tackles taboos to become one of world's most watchedAn Indian soap opera whose themes include acid attacks, domestic violence and high rates of abortion of female foetuses has quietly become one of the most-watched programmes on the planet.
India’s public broadcaster announced in April that the audience for Main Kuch Bhi Kar Sakti Hoon – I, a woman, can achieve anything – had, in two seasons, exceeded 400 million viewers “and counting”.
Michael Safi for The Guardian with an interesting case study on the impact of 'edutainment'-I'm expecting a range of research papers and PhDs coming out of this ;)!
This story about a small boy and starfish explains global developmentAt its very core, this story can help us unpack ethical, practical and theoretical issues of humanitarian assistance and global development. At the same time, it is an accurate reflection of the current state of these industries. Simply solutions are continually offered to complex challenges, girls and women are largely excluded and so-called beneficiaries are seen and treated as powerless, uneducated and poor.
Brendan Rigby for WhyDev unpacks the seemingly simple story of 'doing something is always better than doing nothing' when a young boy want to help a stranded starfish washed ashore a beach. Great summary of a discussion we had on facebook!
Growth is dying as the silver bullet for success. Why this may be good thing This is a disastrous prospect for our economies, which have been designed to grow – or perish. But it is also a window of opportunity for change. With the disappearance of growth as the silver bullet to success, political leaders and their societies desperately need a new vision: a new narrative to engage with an uncertain future.
In my new book, I argue that as we begin to recognize the madness behind growth, we start exploring new paths. These include: forms of business that reconcile human needs with natural equilibria; production processes that emancipate people from the passive role of consumers; systems of social organisation at the local level that reconnect individuals with their communities and their ecosystems, while allowing them participate in a global network of active change makers.
Lorenzo Fioramonti for The Conversation on how to challenge economic growth as the core measurement of 'development'.
Please Stop Publishing to PDF GraveyardsAnd I am willing to be crazy and say that a poor farmer, pregnant mother, or caring parent couldn’t care less about yet another peer-reviewed journal article, or its citation.
(...)
Sadly, too many research organizations fail to connect their research to actual impact. They consider impact the work of others, even thinking of it as less important than their scientific discovery.
Wayan Vota for ICTworks with, well, a bit of a rant perhaps ;)...I agree that research findings should at the very least be presented in an open, accessible and shareable way (Don’t post direct links to your new journal article!). There is a growing pdf graveyards-often hidden behind academic journal paywalls. However, academia does more than wanting to help 'poor farmers'. Teaching students a critical understanding of ICT4D or reflecting on broader, theoretical issues are core things I do-and sometimes a round-table, policy note or blog post will not do the trick. We need to communicate better with each other-and sending each other 20 page journal articles or a full 52 page report will not be enough...
Photography and Modern ConflictMore recent, and complicated, revolutions have not been as clear cut, as Stallabrass exemplified with Tim Hetherington’s coverage of the civil war in the Congo. He explains that in situations like this: “the ideological issues at play are far murkier, if they are drivers of war at all. The competing sides are generally composed of small, informal militia forces, which may suddenly shift allegiance, and what these forces want from photojournalism is far from certain. These militia groups usually avoid direct combat with each other, preferring to conquer and hold territory by terrorising civilians, and then exploiting their captive populations and land to the hilt. The resulting wars divide people by ethnicity, tribe or religion as groupings from which to loot an area of diamonds, gold or coltan, funding continuing warfare and enriching militia leaders. Violence is often extravagant and put on display—a dismembered and tortured body is dumped in the street, for example—to frighten people into compliance or drive them away. Usually, a wider display of that violence in the media is unwelcome.”
Jérôme Sessini, Thomas Dworzak & Julian Stallabrass discuss the changing nature of war, violence and conflict and the role of photography in covering it for Magnum Photos.
The Creeping Privatization of America’s Armed Forces In other words, about half of our armed forces is outsourced to private military contractors. These contractors, to include the company formerly known as Blackwater, are now increasingly owned by private equity firms. Thus, American and international security is largely in the hands of private equity partners.
Bryan Stinchfield for Newsweek with an important reminder about the size of the military-industrial complex; also a good reminder when stories about 'UN bureaucrat flew business class' rants emerge: Nothing beats the waste of money when it comes to U.S. military...
Our digital lives
Get real: Bessi Graham on the pitfalls and promises of ‘social enterprise’“I speak with a lot of nonprofits in the sector and it’s very easy for them to be swept up in all the hype and think, ‘Great! We’ll set up a social enterprise or a business and within months it’ll be generating income.’ But that’s not the reality—there’s no business that does that, much less a business that’s trying to grapple with a tough social or environmental problem. “Potential to fail is going to be part of the game. It’s just part of what you have to cope with. We don’t do ourselves any favours when we’re not being honest about that.”
Nicole Richards talks to Bessi Graham for Generosity Mag on the complexities of starting a social enterprise to quickly make money, do good and be happy...
Precarity as Freedom? Youth, Neoliberalism and the Dissolution of ‘Japan, Inc.’Subject to increasing levels of economic competition coupled with hierarchical control, office workers are increasingly choosing to withdraw from their corporate ‘cages’ in pursuit of a new autonomy as independent neoliberal subjects. Psychologically and morally detached from their companies, more and more young employees are increasingly willing to take on the financial risk and losses they may incur in leaving their companies; picking precarity over corporate constraint in a determinedly self-motivated (if not quite positive) manner.
Shuto Fukuoka for Culture and Capitalism with some reflections on how capitalism is changing in Japan-and how precarious career paths are actively pursuit by today's younger workers.
Hot off the digital press
Changing gender and social norms, attitudes and behavioursThis annotated bibliography presents studies of programmes that aim to bring about changes in gender and social norms, and changes in wider attitudes and behaviours. Much of the literature and some programme designs recognise the need to change social norms in order to change behaviours, such as HIV/AIDs prevention and better sanitation and hygiene.
Huma Haider for GSDRC with an interesting literature review for the C4D community.
Africa’s Youth Employment Challenge: New PerspectivesWho are the youth and what is the problem? Are entrepreneurship and self-employment the solution? And what about youth aspirations? Such questions are addressed in this issue of the IDS Bulletin, drawing from the literature on how development research affects policy and noting that it says little about how young researchers move into policy engagement. Articles consider the evidence on youth employment policy and interventions, the politics of youth policy, the changing nature of young people’s work, and the promotion of entrepreneurship.
The latest open-access IDS Bulletin.
AcademiaSome of the top political science journals are biased against women. Here’s the evidence.The data shows that they publish a lower proportion of articles written by women than there are women in the discipline as a whole.
(...)
Here’s the general pattern we observed: The journals that publish a larger share of qualitative work also publish a larger share of female authors. Conversely, the more a journal focuses on statistical work, the lower its share of female authors.
Dawn Langan Teele & Kathleen Thelen for the Washington Post with not really surprising findings; as always, 'excellence' and 'impact' are much more complicated to assess than simply looking for the latest quantitative study in a high-impact journal.
Cancer, Care and Hope – A Hospital Ethnography on Palliative Care in Dar es Salaam, TanzaniaHospital spaces exist because of the significance of medical advances, experience and achievements, and their relationship to the environment. Street and Coleman use the notion of Foucault’s heterotopia to describe the complex character of the hospital space. Hospitals are places with inscribed meanings, still part of society, but also detached. Places where people are sheltered away because they are – due to their illness and being in need of support – ‘off the norm’. By looking at the example of the ORCI, we find a largely well-equipped hospital which is infused by local and global health politics, international donor practices, developments in health service provision, lay knowledge, and adapted to local conditions.
Andrea Buhl for Medizinethnologie. This is definitely a long read-but a read well worth your time! The author shares insights from her PhD research in Tanzania and highlights the wonderful nature of ethnography to combine global discourses with local culture(s)!
↧
I stumbled across Conrad Keating’s biography of Ken Warren, a tropical medicine and philanthropic pioneer at the Rockefeller Foundation, by chance and was immediately intrigued. Kenneth Warren and the Great Neglected Diseases of Mankind Programme-The Transformation of Geographical Medicine in the US and Beyond covers many interesting aspects of my research interest in (auto)biographies and historical accounts of and from seminal figures in the context of global development. It also tells us a lot about the academic, research and international aid industries from the 1950s until his death in 1996 and invites the reader to reflect about all the changes that have happened-and the stability of some discourses that surround us today.
Warren, ‘a scientific investigator ahead of his time’ (p.7) pioneered research on tropical diseases at the interface of medical and what we today what call ‘public health’ research and as program manager at the Rockefeller Foundation he was instrumental in creating a unique long-lasting network for research and capacity building and shaped policy and practice of international organizations such as the WHO or UNICEF.
As you probably know by now, I will approach my review from a communication for development perspective-focusing on what the story of Ken Warren’s life can tell us about today’s approaches and practices when global academia, transnational policy and local aid work meet.
A life in the #allmalepanel lane
Laurie Garrett’s review of the book in the Lancet is entitled When Big Men ruled global health and the absence of women in the narrative or on most of the photos in the book is striking. It ads to the clear top-down, North-South dynamic somewhere between lavish dinners in Oxford, UK, retreats in Bellagio, Italy or scientific research training in Woods Hole, Massachusetts. It is not the total opposite of the Chambers’ian notion of ‘putting the last first’, because there was a genuine passion about improving the lives of millions of poor people, but the ‘success through (male, American) ego’ narrative certainly has participatory, bottom-up blind spots.
Working in an age of grand strategies
There is a certain appeal to read about an age before work-life balance debates, tenure track worries and laborious grant application writing. Lead by Warren who ‘pushed himself, pushed the future and pushed the people who came within his gravitational pull’ (p.9) his ‘autocratic, peremptory management style (which) certainly forced a high tempo and high productivity’ (p.12) reminded me of similar colleagues of his age: UNICEF Director Jim Grant inspired many followers in a similar way and managed to achieve some incredible successes in global well-being in the 1970s and 1980s. It was not only the age of leap-frogging successes around ‘neglected diseases’, but also a time of Universalgelehrten-the German expression for polymaths: Warren’s fascination with schistosomiasis, communication theory, and information systems led him to write two major scholarly bibliographic works chronicling the entire literary history of the disease over a 100-year period (p.22).
He was also good at self-promotion and advocating for his research area turning mainstream attention to tropical diseases.
The Rockefeller years-before philanthropy turned into philanthrocapitalism
Responsible for Health and Population at Rockefeller, Warren became a ‘scholar-activist’ cornerstone working towards the next big thing after the Green Revolution for which program staff Normal Borlaug had received the Nobel Prize in 1970.
Warren emphasized ‘collaborative and interdisciplinary research’, advocated for long-term funding for 8 years, included ‘young investigators’ and started a ‘global network for communication’ with an annual conference often at Bellagio as the highlight, in short ‘the Great Neglected Diseases of Mankind Network was born’ (pp.33-34). Of course, there was no peer-review committee and no consensus; the entire group was selected single-handedly by Warren. (…) He prided himself on his personal network, on knowing everyone (p.34).
Warren work illustrates well how different those ‘good old days’ were for grant recipients, the foundation’s standing and scientific progress: the project involved 161 scientists and clinicians and 360 trainees, of which 150 were from the developing world, and resulted in the publication of 1800 papers. This was all accomplished at the cost of approximately 15 million USD (55 million in 2015 values)-a prodigious rate of return on the investments by any standard (p.40).
It was an age before conferences and many other aspects of the world turned into neoliberal commodities.
And how much better are our digital, over-networked and constantly measured approaches really?!
Another ‘big man’, Halfdan Mahler of the WHO led ‘the philosophical redirection away from the curative toward preventive care’ (p.56) clashed with Warren’s vision, but by collaborating with yet another ‘big man’, Robert McNamara of the World Bank, Warren’s efforts on evidence-based selective health care culminated in the 1993 WDR Investing in Health.
When Jim Grant joined the Warren-Mahler-McNamara circle a window opened ‘to launch one of the most audacious international health projects ever attempted-to protect the world’s children from 6 killer diseases in 100 countries’ (p.69).
In the end, all good things most come to an end. Warren’s leadership and management style, including ‘perceived financial extravagances’, became more and more obsolete as Rockefeller underwent a period of professionalization as well as financial and programmatic re-orientation. His ‘ingrained sense of entitlement’ (p.112) probably did not strengthen his position in the foundation.
His subsequent work in academic publishing, ‘Warren was ahead of most health professionals in investing in the capacity to collect large amounts of accurate data and make it available to many’ (p.125), led to short-lived collaborations with controversial entrepreneurs.
I cannot assess whether ‘Warren’s legacy was being obscured by an invisible wall of historical amnesia’ (p.132).
Ken Warren certainly had a vision for how best to align scientific discovery to the reduction of disease. Coupled with his innate excitement for science, he brought knowledge and creativity to one of the most influential positions in international philanthropy and health (p.134)
And Maybe Warren ‘would make greater efforts to ensure that more people in developing countries were doing the work’ (p.141) if he were still alive.
From my point of view the book was certainly an unexpected gem for my collection. A traditional biography which opens up some interesting reflections on how our (research, development, policy) world used to work, a glimpse into the life of a big man with big ideas and big impact-yet a subject to dominant discourses and existing power relations. A father who had little time for his children and maintained an impressive global network in the pre-digital age.
Research, philanthropy and development have certainly changed. His self-promotion must seem tame in an age of TED-talk celebrities, his all-male events would not go uncriticized and his work at Rockefeller appears to be traditional in an age of disruptive billionaires.
And yet some of his traits, his enthusiasm and vision to think big for a better world can still inspire in our age of micro-management, impact factors and uber-professionalization in many aspects of our work and life. Keating, Conrad: Kenneth Warren and the Great Neglected Diseases of Mankind Programme-The Transformation of Geographical Medicine in the US and Beyond. ISBN 978-3-319-50147-5, 150pp., 32,09 Euro, Heidelberg: Springer, 2017.
↧
↧
Hi all,
I spent the last three days at a great conference! But I also managed to post a new book review and submit my link review on time-I'm definitely digitally exhausted right now...
Development news from Yemen, UK, Ethiopia, Syria, Bangladesh & Canada-plus much more #globaldev stuff!
Our digital lives with Western 'poverty hero' narratives, investors in Kenya & calling out big data BS.
Publications on humanitarian challenges & impact of counter-terrorism measures on NGOs.
Academia: Academics 'out-dangering' each other; decolonising development knowledge & the dreaded 'Should'...
Enjoy!New from aidnography
Kenneth Warren and the Great Neglected Diseases of Mankind Programme (book review) From my point of view the book was certainly an unexpected gem for my collection. A traditional biography which opens up some interesting reflections on how our (research, development, policy) world used to work, a glimpse into the life of a big man with big ideas and big impact-yet a subject to dominant discourses and existing power relations. A father who had little time for his children and maintained an impressive global network in the pre-digital age.
Research, philanthropy and development have certainly changed. His self-promotion must seem tame in an age of TED-talk celebrities, his all-male events would not go uncriticized and his work at Rockefeller appears to be traditional in an age of disruptive billionaires.
And yet some of his traits, his enthusiasm and vision to think big for a better world can still inspire in our age of micro-management, impact factors and uber-professionalization in many aspects of our work and life.
Development news Tom Murphy reflects on the temporary hiatus of The Humanosphere and the difficult funding landscape for independent humanitarian and development journalism.
Aid Coordinator in Yemen Had Secret Job Overseeing U.S. Commando ShipmentsNajwa Mekki, a spokeswoman for Unicef, said the organization had contracted with Transoceanic through September 2016 “to provide warehousing services in Yemen,” but was not aware that the company was also helping supply the military.
“We would not enter into contracts that would create risks for Unicef operations or our personnel,” Ms. Mekki said in a statement.
Adam Goldman and Eric Schmitt for the New York Times with a much-discussed article; many UN staff members attending #2017HHLConf were really unhappy about the reporting and accused NYT for ignoring importing nuances and complexities-it seems that even the NYT likes to go for the catchy headline...
'We've been giving for years and seen no benefit': why voters are losing faith in NGOs lots of people do support development aid, and we should be listened to as well. But the first step to persuading those who are sceptical probably isn’t convincing them to care about people far away. Many of them do think that people everywhere matter. It’s probably got more to do with showing them that there are at least some big, far-away institutions which they can trust, and engaging them in conversations about global poverty that are deeper than the occasional appeal for famine relief.
Adam Ramsay for The Guardian. "Let me give you some examples, mostly from a conversation with a largish group of older women"- I am pretty sure that said group of old women would have responded in a very similar way in 2007, 1997, 1987, 1977, 1967 or 1957. So we have to be a bit careful when taking 'the voice of ordinary people' as a yardstick of a broader sentiment. It's Ok for journalism, but should not be confused with research.
Another important point comes is highlighted in the quote: That's exactly what many charities would like to do but find it difficult under current legislation: Explain inequalities and poverty in a politicized, structural way rather than appealing to 'saving children'. That's not necessarily NGOs' fault or expresses a lack of trust per se. There is value in communicating complexity, highlighting interdependencies and linking ordinary people across the globe-so I am much more hopeful than simply listening to the stereotypical woman on the street...
Why the money development charities spend in Britain is so vital to their work The domestic programmes of large charities such as Islamic Relief and Oxfam GB offer new ways of seeing development and thinking about poverty. By working on poverty in the UK, they explode the myth that poverty is something that happens only “over there” and to other people. The reasons why people become and stay poor are present in British society too. Work to address these causes is inevitably political, in the same way that development work overseas is political in Uganda, Myanmar or Afghanistan.
Susannah Pickering-Saqqa for The Conversation with another piece on linking local and global development charity work in the UK.
LGBT, female aid workers at risk of sexual assault, report findsNow a new report published on Tuesday by the Feinstein International Center, part of Tufts University, has confirmed both groups’ findings, but also put forward concrete recommendations for aid agencies and the United Nations to follow in order to prevent, and better respond to, cases of sexual harassment and assault against aid workers.
Furthermore, while the Tufts report states that the majority of the victims are women, it also points to troubling levels of sexual identity harassment, blackmail, threats and assaults against LGBT workers, which can be especially dangerous in countries where homosexuality is illegal, and even punishable by death.
Sophie Edwards for DevEx introduces the new STOP the Sexual Assault Against Humanitarian and Development Aid Workers report.
'Who Threatens You?' Researchers Asked Teen Girls Affected By Conflict"Some of the lessons [from the study] are that maybe we need to think more about teaching girls about healthy relationships and dating," Stark says. Working with men and young boys is critical, she adds: "Boys grow up in their households observing how to be men and take on these hypermasculine personas. Girls grow up thinking that to be a good partner and a good wife is to do what your husband tells you."
Courtney Columbus for NPR Goats & Soda with new research study on girls in Ethiopia and the challenges around violence and abuse they are facing.
Long Read: How the Syrian War Changed How War Crimes Are DocumentedWhile Syrian groups collecting evidence may help fill the gaps left by international mechanisms, political players and international accountability are the only way to solve the deadlock. For Alkatlaby, the message for international actors is simple: “We are doing our work. Please do something with it.”
Cristina Roca for News Deeply with a sobering long-read on the accountability gap in international politics.
Let’s build African research centers in AfricaWhy is it seen as neutral and acceptable to build prominent centers of African studies outside of Africa, managed primarily by people who are not from Africa?
Rachel Strohm comments on the new LSE Centre for Africa in London.
Development is not a science and cannot be measured. That is not a bad thing Our logframes are fictions – necessary fictions, but fictions nonetheless. This is, perhaps, the fundamental way in which development differs from the private sector and scientific endeavors. Both are artificially bounded systems, in which it is possible to trace causality with some degree of certainty. At the simplest level, for instance, company-level success is a function of profits and losses – can you sell goods and services for more than they cost to produce?
There’s no way to limit the variables in play when it comes to, say, improving education or health outcomes, or the attempt to end genocide. The closest approach that we have are randomized control trials, yet proving replicability across countries and time remains a significant – and prohibitively expensive – challenge.
Michael Kleinman for The Guardian weighs in on the challenge of measuring success in #globaldev.
The development workers’ guide to talking to other people about developmentThey say: “I wish I could be more like you, but I just don’t know if I have it in me.”
What they mean: “When I say have it in me, I mean, I’m not sure if I could give up my lifestyle of free boardroom drinks every Monday, Tuesday, Thursday and Friday. Plus, our company gave us free iPads last year. Have you seen this amazing app which can help predict your wife’s mood based upon the timing of tidal waves? Amazing…”
You should say: “Sure, I had a promising career as an accountant/brain surgeon/plumber once too, but then I started to realize that this is where I wanted to be. How does that app work again?”
Weh Yeoh with a reality-check on how to talk development to civilians ;)!
“If you don’t have food security what development can you have?” – Naomi HossainBut Bangladesh is a very different society, it’s very fractious and competitive, people do resent the closing of the political space. Some say it is directly related to the rise of extremism and that’s been a bit of a shock in Bangladesh. I think that might be true but I don’t know. What is worrying is the closure of the space for civil society and the media could have a real impact on the government’s transparency and responsiveness. So for instance if we were to have a major food crisis somewhere remote now, it’s not entirely clear to me that the media would free to report it, and that the government would feel pressured to respond. It’s something we have to watch.
Naomi Hossain talk about her new book on Bangladesh for South Asia @ LSE .
The Canada most people don’t seeAnd you can be forgiven, I suppose, for not really caring about that other Canada. How can you? You don’t see it. You don’t know anyone who lives there. You rarely hear about it on the news, and when you do, the Prime Minister or some other politician is always there to reassure us they really care and they’re making things better. There will even be a few Hoop Dancers on the Canada Day stage, because we’re very inclusive and sensitive in this Canada. So sensitive, in fact, that when someone satirically proposes a cultural appropriation prize, we are collectively incensed. Things like that aren’t tolerated in our Canada.
Meanwhile, in the other Canada, Angela Cardinal was shot and killed seven months after her ordeal in the courthouse. In the other Canada there are 89 communities without safe drinking water. A child is more likely to be sexually assaulted than to graduate high school. The murder rate is worse than Somalia’s and the incarceration rate is the highest in the world. Imagine if that was your Canada. Imagine your rage if your children lived there.
Scott Gilmore for Maclean's with a reminder that inequalities and poverty still exist in the politically correct Canada of Justin Trudeau...
Our digital lives
The West Spreading New Wave of Feel-Good Movies and False HopesThe West is busy manufacturing ‘pseudo reality’. And in this grotesque pseudo-reality, several deprived individuals like starving chess players, street vendors and slum dwellers are suddenly becoming rich, successful and fulfilled. Millions of others, all around them, continue to suffer. But somehow, they don’t seem to matter much.
There is a new celebrity group in making – let’s call them the ‘glamorous poor’. Those ‘exceptional individuals’, the glamorous poor, are easy to digest, and even to celebrate in the West. They are swiftly and cheerfully integrating into the ‘mainstream’ club of the global ‘go getters’ and narcissist rich.
Andre Vltchek for off Guardian examines recent pop-cultural (re)presentation of poverty and 'development' in mainstream movies.
It’s time to fix the startup funding landscape in KenyaAs things stand, capital is misallocated. Nepotism, racial bias, misplaced pattern matching, and so on, have a higher bearing on who gets capital than the quality and soundness of the idea. The local landscape is littered with such examples. Do local founders have to change and be more aggressive? Perhaps, but the investors also need to realise that when you come to Kenya, 48 million Kenyans will behave and act like Kenyans, so perhaps it’s a good idea to adapt to how they think and act and not expect them to behave like Americans (or Europeans) because, after all, the target market is Kenya/Africa.
Thomas Sankara with some sobering reflections on the start-up culture in Kenya-many of which sounds surprisingly like the development challenges of the bad old days that investors wanted to 'disrupt'...
How to Call B.S. on Big Data: A Practical GuideRemember that if a data-based claim seems too good to be true, it probably is. Conclusions that dramatically confirm your personal opinions or experiences should be especially suspect.
Michelle Nijhuis for The New Yorker lists some of the common themes to keep a critical mind when faced with 'big data'-great classroom conversation starter!
Hot off the digital press
'Humanitarian action in disaster and conflict settings'The report records the insights that were drawn from two rounds of an expert panel, in which 30 key humanitarian actors with great experience in the field participated.
The goal of the expert panel was to establish an informed, evidence-based study about some of the most pressing challenges that are currently hampering the effectiveness of aid, as well as to collect observations of highly experienced practitioners on trends and recent experiences in the field.
Roanne van Voorst and Dorothea Hilhorst with an interesting new report on humanitarian challenges for the Institute of Social Studies.
The impact of international counter-terrorism on civil society organisationsThis report examines the impact of international counter-terrorism frameworks on the work of civil society organisations. In particular, it explains the role of the Financial Action Task Force in setting international standards that affect the way in which civil society organisations are regulated by nation-states, their access to financial services, and their obligations to avoid proscribed organisations
and other entities deemed to pose a ‘terrorism’ risk.
New report by Ben Hayes for Brot fuer die Welt.
Academia
The Ethics of Fieldwork PreparednessResearch in contentious environments often produces stories that wow search committees and make for entertaining conference presentations. But experienced field researchers often view the same stories that impress their colleagues with deep concern. We worry about an intellectual trend that increasingly rewards researchers for “out-dangering” one another (often with dubious scholarly gain). This doesn’t mean scholars should abandon fieldwork; it means that we should take the practical and ethical components of its planning and implementation more seriously. We can start by asking simple questions about first aid, check-ins, transport safety, and data protection.
Milli Lake and Sarah E. Parkinson for Political Violence @ a Glance share an important discussion on how to manage danger in an ethical way and not get carried away by 'out-dangering' each other.
Decolonising development: power dynamics in the knowledge sectorEvidence is not what you think. Ask a researcher what evidence is, and they’ll likely talk about methodological rigour, randomized controlled trials and systematic reviews. Ask a policymaker, and they’ll tell you about talking to a head teacher at a local school, or inviting an expert to testify before a committee. In order to see research feed meaningfully into policy in developing countries, we need to understand how policymakers in these countries view evidence and what their needs are. Our Evidence-Informed Policy Making Toolkit aims to contribute to this, in part by focusing on four types of evidence used for policy: statistical and administrative data, citizen knowledge, practical experience, and (last but not least) research.
Emily Hayter for INASP with a great overview over some of the issues around 'decolonising' development research and policy.
The Dreaded 'Should'As a result, I find myself wondering how much of the right now people miss due to these patterns. What might academe be like if we were encouraged to celebrate the present moment instead of wishing for the future? What might it be like if we came together against the broader cultural patterns that create such conditions? Until those conditions can be changed, I also wonder what little things each of us can do in our own lives to ease the dreaded should we face and help to lessen the negative consequences of such patterns.
J.E. Sumerau for Inside Higher Ed with an important reminder to celebrate the here and now-and not always live for the future when funding, time and all the other good things will fall in place!
↧
I read Platforming - what can NGOs learn from AirBnB and Amazon?by Paula Gil Baizan, World Vision’s Global Humanitarian Director for cash based programs with interest-but also some astonishment.
I disagree with a lot of her arguments and the general sense that (I)NGOs and other humanitarian actors should turn into entities similar to the giants of platform capitalism.
First and foremost, I find it quite astonishing that a senior manager of an INGO does not even hint at the hidden cost, exploitation and side effects that platform capitalism comes with.
It is a bit more complicated than ‘Amazon and AirB’n’B are good with data’.
From the, shall we say diplomatically, difficult conditions in Amazon’s warehouses and its broader corporate culture to the bigger issue of precarious employment (e.g. Deliveroo in the UK) or the challenges AirB’n’B is increasingly posing on urban rental markets and related service industries (e.g. in New York, Barcelona or Berlin), a picture emerges that many vulnerable workers are actually worse off due to said platforms.
I find it difficult to see how charities, non-governmental organizations and humanitarian actors that by their very mandate engage with marginalized, vulnerable constituents should mirror parts of their operations after these platforms.
But besides these broader philosophical issues I also have some more detailed points of critique that will follow the flow of Paula’s original post: A platform recognises its biggest asset is not the real estate nor the intellectual property, it is the intangible network of people who need services and those who can deliver them.
I would go as far as rephrasing the sentence as follows: ‘A platform recognizes that real estate and infrastructure are expensive to create and maintain and outsources these problems to its quasi-employees or third parties, i.e. the government’.
But humanitarian aid by definition takes place in an environment where infrastructure no longer exists or never existed in the first place. And connecting ‘both sides’ is easier said than done and either involves a lot of vetting or will attract the equivalent of an army of Deliveroo delivery people to the aid industry; talking about professionalization… Are NGOs ready to transform data into our most valuable asset?
I would like to see evidence that supports the claim that NGOs have valuable data. Sure, they have some data, but that data is collected in remote locations and from ‘poor people’ which raises huge questions about data quality and the value of that data.
Facebook as a platform makes money by convincing advertisers that their money is well-spent. Many NGOs have expertise (and data) about specific, relatively small contexts and comparing them in a central database could be interesting, but involves huge investments, synchronization of collection tools etc. In the end, there is only one Uber in the city-not 25… NGOs will be valued not only by the amount of cash grants they manage to disburse, but by the size of their networks and the positive connections made between actors in each particular environment while delivering the cash grant (be it beneficiaries, local NGOS, private sector, government, etc.)
This does not sound too bad in theory, but in practice it is much more complicated. I definitely acknowledge the benefits of cash transfers and at the same time want to stress that as most other debates in development things can be quite complicated.
Bringing together proprietary data from private companies, non open-access government data and from ‘beneficiaries’ immediately raises questions about reliability, comparability and cooperation. I also have difficulties seeing how non-governmental organizations should be put in charge of this task and how they are qualified to work with conflicting interests of stakeholders let alone data protection issues. Data is sensitive, but also very political.imagine if humanitarians responsibly analysed the information we collect anyway on beneficiary needs, and used it to understand them and their contexts so well we would know what beneficiaries need before they need it.
As my colleague Linnet Taylor is arguing in a lot of her research, simply exporting the complicated, politicized ‘Northern’ debates of data power to the global ‘South’ will most likely mean replicating our problems around rights, opting-out, government surveillance etc. And even if we leave the legal and policy frameworks aside, I find it difficult to see how you could collect data in, say, Chad or the Central African Republic with a quality that would allow behavioral targeting and prediction. How do we marry data protection, cyber security and humanitarian principles into operational standards?
In the end, the big problems are not the first two issues: data protection and security could be solved; but the insurmountable challenge lies in the ‘humanitarian principles’: Amazon just started deliveries in Australia and it will be interesting to see how it can deal with the country’s remote challenges. And if AirB’nB hosts have a tendency to discriminate against certain user groups it poses new challenges for the platform in terms of liability and other consequences.
The bigger point is that algorithms, the powerful fuel of platforms, can be biased.
Ultimately, the challenge is that humanitarian aid principles and NGO work cannot compromise, they have to go to the distant, remote, destroyed places, the ‘loss makers’ inhabited by people who will unlikely to be transformed into consumers any time soon.
To cut a long story short: I would be a bit more careful in predicting a future of the humanitarian sector based on data-driven cash programs where NGOs mimic global capitalistic platforms.
I would also like to see a much more critical engagement with the concept of platform capitalism and the (hidden/outsourced) cost in an ‘industry’ that by definition should work for the marginalized delivery person rather than the Silicon Valley hedge fund manager.
Ideals and practices based on social justice, equality and changing power relations should always guide the work of NGOs-and sometimes those efforts cannot be simply measured by data collected along the supply chain...
↧
Hi all,Welcome to a packed Friday link review!
Development news: The UN’s ‘new way of working’; political inaction and the Congo; Canada’s feminist foreign policy; Facebook roles out disaster mapping; how to fix the humanitarian system; automation will destroy jobs in Africa; can Africa’s youth ‘hustle’ their way out of unemployment? The gender digital-divide in Myanmar; climate change projects as empowerment opportunities; opinion leaders use social media for development information; a little donation will not end poverty; how can practitioners & academics come together? 220 pounds for a visa for Nigeria? Twitter responds :)
Our digital lives: Design education’s lack of understanding power; mansplaining; print it out and they will change!
Publications: E-Book on dependency theory; ODI on the Grand Bargain; IMS on media environment trends; anthropology of social media in South India.
Academia: Can facebook become a learning platform? A poem on a university’s brand new community initiative.
Enjoy!
New from aidnography
Is platform capitalism really the future of the humanitarian sector?I would be a bit more careful in predicting a future of the humanitarian sector based on data-driven cash programs where NGOs mimic global capitalistic platforms.
I would also like to see a much more critical engagement with the concept of platform capitalism and the (hidden/outsourced) cost in an ‘industry’ that by definition should work for the marginalized delivery person rather than the Silicon Valley hedge fund manager.
Ideals and practices based on social justice, equality and changing power relations should always guide the work of NGOs-and sometimes those efforts cannot be simply measured by data collected along the supply chain...
Development news
The "New Way of Working": Bridging aid's funding divideEssentially though, the NWOW is about closer collaboration between humanitarian and development response through the pillars of: “collective outcomes”, “comparative advantage”, and “multi-year timeframes”.
(...)
These interventions, like the World Bank’s engagement in Yemen, bring important new funding and capacity to humanitarian crises. But they can also carry significant risk due to the perilous nature of the security situations in the countries in question.
“There is a risk that premature development intervention can be undone quite quickly,” cautioned Nadine Walicki, a senior strategic advisor at the Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre in Geneva. “There have been cases of new housing provided for returnees, for instance, literally being burnt to the ground.”
Louise Redvers for IRIN. There's a lot going on in this long article...it almost reads a bit like a wedding manual: 'The UN wants something old, something new, something borrowed and something blue' to reform the humanitarian system ;)!
The U.N.’s Tragic Inaction on CongoCongo has few committed and powerful allies. In fact, a large part of its budget is supported by the very Western governments demanding accountability, and its army is backed up in the east by the largest United Nations peacekeeping force in the world. These paradoxes point to a critical, uncomfortable truth: In Congo, the biggest stumbling blocks can be apathy and a lack of political will. We can find out who killed Mr. Sharp and Ms. Catalán just as we can deliver justice for the hundreds of Congolese who have lost their lives in the Kasais. We just have to care enough.
Ida Sawyer and Jason Stearns for the New York Times. The piece is actually much better than the headline suggests and does not simply blame 'the UN' for the events in Congo.
This What a Feminist Foreign Policy Looks LikeCanada still only spends approximately 0.26% of its GDP on international aid, compared to the 0.7% benchmark established in 2005, and critics have said that calling for a new era and a fundamental shift without allocating any new funding seems disingenuous. “Feminism should not be used as a buzzword or a way to easily brand a political policy. And if you are going to label it as feminist, it must have real substance. Unfortunately the Liberal budget did not provide a single penny for international aid,” said Robert Aubin, a Canadian MP and international development critic from one of the main opposition parties.
Meanwhile, others have pointed out that Canada announced just last week a dramatic increase in military spending – by approximately $13 billion CAD, or a full 73% – and find it difficult for the government to claim that not even one additional dollar of aid will be available to implement the policy changes. What does this mean about how serious the Canadian government is with their new approach?, critics argue.
Penelope Starr for UN Dispatch. A feminist foreign policy is much easier said than done...
Surveillance for good? Facebook tracks disaster victimsThe disaster maps may well have value in terms of strengthening Facebook’s brand, but Meier said he had also observed “a genuine interest in making sure this has a measurable impact”.
“I’m hoping that… it sends a bit of a signal to other Silicon Valley companies. I hope these companies realise they actually have an ethical responsibility,” he added. “They’re becoming like the new utilities of our time. When the power goes out… they have a responsibility to get the power back on.”
Microsoft has already been through a process of rethinking its involvement in humanitarian action. Although it has long had a humanitarian action department, “it’s been inconsistent in terms of what we do and where we do it,” said Jane Meseck, senior director of global programmes at Microsoft Philanthropies.
Kristy Siegfried for IRIN with a good overview over facebook's disaster mapping efforts guided by Patrick Meier. As always, questions about data, facebook and humanitarianism are complicated. I think it is too early to assess whether this is 'just' CSR or more. And as long as facebook does not allow access to its 'engine room' relying on a propitiatory algorithms will always be less than perfect. But then again, even if there was a way of being completely open access-how would NGOs or other organization handle data in the messay situation of a humanitarian emergency? Lots of questions...
How to Fix the Broken Humanitarian System: A Q&A with Paul SpiegelEmergencies are becoming more and more protracted. We’ve seen this in terms of both the conflict itself lasting for many years as well as the forced displacement: A refugee is a refugee for over 10 years now. The [weaknesses of] the Band-Aid approach and the division between development and humanitarian response … are now becoming more apparent. The system is clearly not able to function.
(...)
The coordination system is less of command control, and more of a consensus system. And I think that needs to change. And number two , we have developed systems—the most well-known is the cluster system, which has become far too process-heavy—and what we’re often measuring are not impact or outcome indicators but really simple process indicators. We often don’t know the effects of what we’re providing, but rather only the number and type of medicines have been provided, and that’s insufficient.
Brian W. Simpson interviews Paul Spiegel for Global Health Now. Some of the challenges that Spiegel highlights have been around for a while, but still a lot of food for thought in this long piece.
Why Are Geniuses Destroying Jobs in Uganda?Why are these geniuses working on destroying jobs? Well, in part just because it is cool and an interesting technical challenge, but also, at least in part because policy based restrictions on labor mobility make low-skill labor—which is globally abundant and cheap—artificially scarce in the US.
(...)
And, the technologies pioneered and developed in the US and Europe and Japan then blow back into poor countries. Automated pay-for-parking at airports, developed in rich countries to save labor costs at massively distorted prices, creeps into Uganda. As I recently flew home from giving a lecture about promoting economic growth in Tanzania I was confronted with automated check-in at the airport in Dar-Es-Salaam.
Lant Pritchett for the Center for Global Development with a powerful reminder about one of the biggest challenges for 'development' in the coming years: Making sure enough young men/people have jobs!
Organic Learning and Hustling: A Possible solution to Africa's Youth Unemployment?On digging about their background, the guys had just gone upto to high school, no one had gone to college, but they had learnt from another guy who had taken an electronic repair course at a TVET college. These guys had learnt organically by observation and tinkering, until they got it right. While I was there, another guy joined, and was given the least expensive gadget to start repairing, I was later to learn he is the apprentice.
Given that they had done something that the swanky Samsung customer care service center up the hill would not do, I asked them, if they would consider employment say by Samsung, there was an emphatic NO! They liked the flexible hours ( that day i had to wait until 2.00pm for the shop to open, generally they show-up after midday and work until 7.00pm). Second reason, is they made more money than they would make at Samsung. Based on the foot traffic in my time there, they would easily be making KES 5000 ( USD50) a day err halfday, even when split three way, it is enough to make a living. Finally, the work culture in the shop, was anything goes, no HR, no dress code and definitely no office drama.
Shikoh Gitau needed her phone fixed in Nairobi and wonders whether 'hustling' could be a employment strategy. I have doubts about sustainability-but also about the real income potential. And working with propitiatory systems can always be tricky-what if Samsung or any other company makes it more difficult to hack their hard- and software?
Ending the Gender Digital Divide in Myanmar: A Problem-Driven Political Economy AssessmentIn Myanmar, the gender digital divide is systemic, skills are not keeping pace with access, and local actors are key.
The gender digital divide in Myanmar is systemic. It is detrimental to women’s and girls’ ability to participate in and benefit from development processes, and a brake on Myanmar’s ability to prosper.
Gender is not the biggest challenge related to accessing ICTs. Two issues are more problematic for women and girls:
a. Men and boys often have more control over ICT devices and more opportunities to acquire ICT skills.
b. Women and girls often feel that ICTs and digital content are not relevant enough to justify the time and expense.
There are not enough local actors - whether government agencies or nonstate institutions - championing digital inclusion. Stakeholders often are not aware of how the gender digital divide impedes development.
More stakeholders have incentives to integrate ICTs into their work than to make gender equality a priority.
New work by IREX with an important reminder of how quickly Myanmar is 'developing'-and how important it is to ensure that inequalities are addressed right from the beginning.
Myanmar: Top UN official in Myanmar to be changedThe United Nations has confirmed that its top official in Myanmar is being moved from her position.
Diplomatic and aid community sources in Yangon told the BBC the decision was linked to Renata Lok-Dessallien's failure to prioritise human rights.
In particular, this referred to the oppressed Rohingya Muslim minority.
Internal UN documents - shown to the BBC - said the organisation had become "glaringly dysfunctional", and wracked by internal tensions.
Jonah Fisher for BBC News with more news from Myanmar...
Climate change risks can be turned into an asset for communities left to cope on their ownThe findings showed substantial successes in, for example, the empowerment of women, better access to education, and increased economic opportunities. But it also showed that community cohesion increased while local governance structures were strengthened.
The results indicate that climate policies can play an important role in facilitating the growth of local institutions and addressing peoples’ vulnerability and fragility – even if, as in this case, it was somewhat unintentional.
(...)
Kashwan’s research, and my own, shows that reducing emissions through small hydropower development or reforestation can do more than just mitigate the effects of climate change. It can have wider effects that deliver positive returns in all sorts of ways. This includes reducing the opportunity for terrorist groups to recruit vulnerable and marginalised people.
Florian Krampe for The Conversation with a reminder that some climate change/mitigation efforts can 'simply' become good development projects while having a positive environmental effect at the same time.
Why do people engage with international development?So what are the positive drivers of engagement with global poverty? Three big ones stand out.
Social norms – as respondents increasingly agree that other people are engaging and that other people admire those who engage with global poverty, they become more likely to engage themselves.
Moral case – as respondents become more persuaded by the normative case for aid, i.e. that it is the right thing to do, they become more engaged with the issue. This might not sound all that surprising but, for instance, we do not see a parallel effect when people increasingly agree that UK aid brings benefits.
Personal efficacy – as people increasingly believe that they can make a difference, they are more likely to become engaged.
Jennifer van Heerde-Hudson and David Hudson for DevCommsLab with an introduction to their research on political attitudes towards international development in the UK.
Global opinion leaders show increased use of social media for information on development Social media is increasingly becoming a driver of conversation on several topics including global development. The World Bank’s Public Opinion Research Group conducts Country Opinion Surveys in about 40 developing countries every year and found that the number of global opinion leaders using social media to get information on global development is steadily increasing.
Zubedah Robinson for the World Bank's Voices blog. The findings are not really surprising, but I'd like to find out more how they affect the World Bank and its publication and communication: Does 'getting information' trickle down to 'reading a (pdf) report'? An interesting debate as the Bank is struggling a little bit to find its place in the global development landscape.
Here's why donating £2 a month cannot possibly end povertyAlongside these stories we urgently need to ramp up our campaigns on the causes of poverty and situate them within this wider narrative. While many aid agencies do campaign on issues such as unfair trade deals, climate change or tax havens, we have failed as a sector to locate this within a bigger story about poverty creation and systemic change when talking to the public. Instead, we have focused on aid and charity – which, though it helps, is no long-term solution – and told people that their donation will end poverty. When it doesn’t, are we surprised that they begin to lose faith?
Matthew Bramall for The Guardian with a reminder that aid organizations need to address inequalities and create global solidarity and empathy rather than simply promising to 'save children'...
Memory, Wisdom and Mentoring: what do practitioners need from academics, beyond research papers? In return for mentoring/accompanying practitioners, academics could be given access to new sources of data from monitoring and evaluation of aid programmes or other sources – gold dust for any academic career.
And what of the practitioners? Everyone in the aid business says they want time to read and reflect, so the standard answer is often ‘why not pack them off to a university for a week every year so they can do just that?’ But it’s not that simple. The change of rhythm between activism and reflection can be jarring. When we sent our senior advocacy team to IDS for a reading week a few years ago, IDS was horrified by their attention deficit issues – they just couldn’t stay off their blackberries. A mentoring scheme would respond to the needs and rhythms of the practitioner, rather than the need to fit around university timetables (eg by boosting their coffers through summer schools).
Duncan Green for From Poverty to Power; bringing academic and practitioners together is complicated. One issue that immediately came to my mind is that academics usually need to plan much longer in advance-my calendar for the autumn semester is already filling up quickly-so being responsive to shifting work loads can be quite challenging...
How Everyday Africa Sparked a Movement That’s Changing Western Stereotypes of AfricaIt’s in that casual inclusiveness that Everyday Africa finds its voice. The Instagram feed, at 3,762 posts and counting, is catalyzing a new form of journalism that thrives not on the decisive moment but rather on a reality told in small pieces, from multiple perspectives. In doing so, it’s engaging a new generation of African photographers with newfound access to amplify their voices via social media, the internet, and mobile phones. And it’s giving them a platform—an audience nearly 330,000 followers strong, of Westerners and Africans and people of African descent alike—through which to define their own narrative.
Molly Gottschalk for Artsy with a reminder of the visual power of Everyday Africa.
Who has more power, privilege and expensive visa? Great discussion after the initial tweet...
Our digital lives
Design Education’s Big Gap: Understanding the Role of PowerBut as more and more designers pour into complex social situations (whether new graduates or seasoned professionals), this unintentional blind spot can be disastrous. Perhaps this would explain why it’s taken the design discipline so long to get a credible foothold within the social sector. Why would an executive director of a non-profit expose their staff to a hubristic designer, let alone to the population they’re serving?
(...)
Should designers get out of social impact design altogether? Absolutely not. Designers are uniquely trained to be comfortable working with ambiguity without losing hope. And that right there is a powerful asset.
But if you shy away from working in the social sector, you’ll miss out on opportunities to change the world and yourself in the process. All it takes is a more reflective approach—one that acknowledges the hidden forces at play in the world around us.
George Aye for the Greater Good Studio with a powerful reminder why designers need to talk to development researchers who have been thinking about power and participation since the good old days of 'Putting the last first'!
Strange men constantly explain to me how to do my jobThis is about power.
Put another way, these instructional approaches by men are not an invitation to have respectful dialogue; they are an attempt to put me back in my box.
Over time I’ve come to understand that men explaining things to me has nothing to do with what I’m writing about. It’s the fact I’m writing at all. I’m taking up space and having a public voice.
(...)
According to Dr Flood, probably not: “Mansplaining is about power and entitlement, [so] it’s probably less likely to be practiced by men who have other social positions, such as ethnic minority men or gay men or trans men or indigenous men. That means that they’re on the other side of those patterns of power.
“Gender isn’t the only story here. Gender intersects with other forms of social difference and social inequality and that shapes whose voices get heard and who is spoken to in patronising ways and who isn’t,” he says.
Ginger Gorman for The Big Smoke with an excellent piece that addresses 'mansplaining' in a deep and meaningful way!
3 Reasons Why Printing is Still a Killer App for Behavior ChangeIn the age of digital development, don’t forget the psychological benefit from slowing down and making something special to drive faster and deeper behavior change.
Wayan Vota for ICTworks with why printing still matters-especially 'in the field'!
Hot off the digital press
e-Book Launch: Can Dependency Theory Explain Our World Today?At a time when the core arguments of the Dependency framework are most pertinent, they disappeared from mainstream debates on ‘globalization’ and the academic curricula…[F]or a new generation of scholars and students, this volume should be a key that opens the door to an archive and a new way of reasoning about the current global order…[W]hat is at stake is more than the economic. What is required is thinking and acting on the multi-dimensional faces of dependence…—as much economic as it is political, social, and epistemic… confronting the different dimensions of domination and dependence.
The Young Scholars Initiative of the Institute of New Economic Thinking just released an interesting E-Book!
From Grand Bargain to beneficiary: an analysis of funding flows through the humanitarian systemFocusing on the classification and analysis of expenditure, the paper has not sought to make any judgements about the value or benefit of these expenditures to the aid recipients. While this approach does not capture the quality of assistance provided to crisis-affected populations, the study aims to lay the foundation for further discussions about cost-efficiency, the quality of humanitarian assistance and the added value of each actor in the chain.
Barnaby Willitts-King, Tasneem Mowjee and Lydia Poole with a new paper for ODI.
Reflections on media environment trends – IMS Annual Report 2016-2017 In this context, the year also saw journalism facing a crisis of a fundamental nature spurred on by technological advancement, political power play and global inequality — a crisis that challenges basic notions of truth, relevance and trust.
International Media Support, a Danish NGO, presents their latest annual report.
Social Media in South IndiaVenkatraman explores the impact of social media at home, work and school, and analyses the influence of class, caste, age and gender on how, and which, social media platforms are used in different contexts. These factors, he argues, have a significant effect on social media use, suggesting that social media in South India, while seeming to induce societal change, actually remains bound by local traditions and practices.
Shriram Venkatraman with a new open access book from UCL Press and their project on social media anthropology.
Academia
Facebook, an Online Learning Platform?David S. Janzen, professor of computer science at California Polytechnic State University at San Luis Obispo, is one of them. He has for years taught a Java coding course on Udemy, which his profile shows more than 6,500 learners have taken.
In an email, Janzen said he has no interest in teaching a course on Facebook.
“I am skeptical about Facebook entering online learning,” Janzen said. “I expect they will have some success just based on their size, but I don't expect them to become the dominant player in online learning. There is a lot of healthy competition. Also, I'm nervous about a deep integration of social media and learning. The mix of constant interruption (social media) with a need to focus (learning) seems counterproductive.”
Carl Straumsheim for Inside Higher Ed introduces facebook's efforts to become a learning platform.
Poem About Your University’s Brand New Community InitiativeOur current day porters
Have the opportunity
To reapply for their jobs
With this new company
Slash community.
This reapplication process
Will no doubt remind them
How much they belong
To a community,
Just not quite the same community
That they belonged to before.
Susan Harlan's poem for McSweeney's actually also addresses a lot of 'development projects'...
↧